fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr

  
 
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.5 #1Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Sneakyracer wrote:
The A7RII is the best choice, does not mean it is going to be everyone's preferred choice obviously since camera choice is quite personal.


Because it is your best choice, it does not follow that it is "the" best choice. It is a fine choice, but it is not the "best" choice for people whose needs don't mirror yours. Both cameras are potentially excellent choices, depending on what you want to do. Discounting the factors that are not important to you simply makes in "your" best choice.

I live in the San Francisco Bay Area, where folks often need to drive to Los Angeles. What is "the best route" from San Francisco to Los Angeles?

Answers person #1: Obviously, I-5 is The BEST Route. You can do the whole trip in about five hours, and get to your destination much faster. It is an interstate highway almost the entire distance. There are gas stations and fast food joints all along the route. The road is smooth and straight with only a few exceptions.

Answers person #2: Obviously Route 1 is The BEST Route. It follows closely along one of the continents most spectacular and rugged shorelines, twisting and turning as it drops to the edge of the ocean and then climbs to the tops of high bluffs with expansive views of the ocean. There are fine restaurants along the way, and you'll pass through a number of beautiful state parks and see wildlife ranging from whales to elephant seals to pelicans.

I've done both. Depending on your perspective, either can be the "best."

Dan

(Edited. Because I got carried away... Apologies. ;-)

Edited on Aug 05, 2015 at 01:28 PM · View previous versions
Aug 05, 2015 at 09:04 AM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.5 #2Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Sneakyracer wrote:
chez wrote
darbo wrote
chez wroteThe real interest is the results of the A7R2 compared to the A7R. With the A7r2 dr improving...it's just one more feature which makes me lean further to upgrading my A7R.
Couldn't agree more with that. And I am interested in learning that you are also considering upgrading. If I recall correctly you weren't initially thinking about upgrading - though I may have confused you with someone else.

To me the a7R II is pretty doggone amazing in terms of all it offers to me and my work. With assets like IBIS, BSI sensor, etc. I just wonder what Sony could possibly do with the a7R III that can match the revolutions of the a7R and now the a7R II. My feeling (and my hope, as one that wants to settle down with my cameras for years to come) is that going forward the next versions will be less ground-breaking and more iterative. Just like the 5D and 5D II were revolutionary, but the latest versions are iterative improvements. But, hey, that's the wishful thinking of a guy that can buy this year's model, but can't afford to buy future models for a while. hehe.
You and I are in the same boat...early retirement for me at the end of this year.

I'd pick up the A7R2 today as it's feature set is amazing. The only obstacle for me is it's price tag. I'm waiting to the end of the year with hopes of some Xmas sales.

I'd love to see a head to head image test between the A7R and A7R2 at various ISO ranges.
Let's be thankful that Sony is not charging $4500 for it. The camera is so good that even at that price it will probably not affect much its sales.

You really think that a 30% increase in price would have minimal impact on sales? 'Experts' on FM already say the 3200 price is over what it's true value should be. Is it worth 4x as much as an a7r on the used market? Add in the metabones and you're up to 5k for a body. You really think it's worth that much?

Edited on Aug 05, 2015 at 09:21 AM · View previous versions
Aug 05, 2015 at 09:12 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.5 #3Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
The real question for me ... is $3200 better spent on the A7R II for what it adds to my present capabilities, or is $3200 better spent on something else ... 5DsR, A7R + 7D2 + HR, 5DIII + HR or put those $$$ toward used MFD.

That's not to say that the A7R II (and A7R) doesn't seem to have a lot going for it ... it does. Just that everyone has to assess how that fits into their own needs and wants. Personally, I'm not into the "cradling" ergonomics of the A7R, so if the A7R II is improved into more of a "grip" ergonomic ... that raises it's level of interest as a hand-held shooting tool. If not, then the A7R as a niche, tripod, MF tool is likely worth more to me @ $1K than the A7R II is at $4K ... $3200 + Metabones + tax.

As such, if the results between the A7R vs. A7R II has been exaggerated by the variances @ capture ... that would be nice to vet out as well.



Edited on Aug 05, 2015 at 11:17 AM · View previous versions
Aug 05, 2015 at 09:19 AM
Rajan Parrikar
Offline
Details
p.5 #4Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
RustyBug wrote:
The real question for me ... is $3200 better spent on the A7R II for what it adds to my present capabilities, or is $3200 better spent on something else ... 5DsR, A7R + 7D2 + HR, 5DIII + HR or put those $$$ toward used MFD.

That's not to say that the A7R II doesn't seem to have a lot going for it ... it does. Just that everyone has to assess how that fits into their own needs and wants.



We will be able to make an informed judgement soon enough as more reviews begin to come online. Diglloyd will be getting his A7RII tomorrow so we can expect another review and comparison with the 5DS in the coming days.

Aug 05, 2015 at 09:25 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.5 #5Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Phillip Reeve wrote:
Fred Miranda wroteThis test is a complete joke. However I do expect the A7RII to do substantially better when recovering deep shadows.
Why do you think so?

I see no flaw in the testing. Sure they used different shutter speeds but the reason for that is that the a7rII does not only have much cleaner shadows but also seems to retain the highlights better. Here is what they did:
"We exposed such that the brightest area of non-sky was exposed to the right (using rawdigger to check) and then stopped down 6 stops and took our ‘under’ exposure."

I think this is a valid method to test a camera's dynamic range.

I think everybody should decide for themselves how important DR is to them. I
...Show more →

It's valid dynamic range test but we are examining the shadow crops and the more light hits the sensor the better the shadows will look when pushed.
When comparing shadow noise pushed by several stops, we should start from equivalent histograms.
Aug 05, 2015 at 11:27 AM
Phillip Reeve
Offline
Details
p.5 #6Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Fred Miranda wrote:
Phillip Reeve wrote
Fred Miranda wroteThis test is a complete joke. However I do expect the A7RII to do substantially better when recovering deep shadows.
Why do you think so?

I see no flaw in the testing. Sure they used different shutter speeds but the reason for that is that the a7rII does not only have much cleaner shadows but also seems to retain the highlights better. Here is what they did:
"We exposed such that the brightest area of non-sky was exposed to the right (using rawdigger to check) and then stopped down 6 stops and took our ‘under’ exposure."

I think this is a valid method to test a camera's dynamic range.

I think everybody should decide for themselves how important DR is to them. I own a couple of photo books with absolutely beautiful pictures in it, all of them were taken with Velvia 50 which has somewhere between 6 and 10 stops of DR. My own pictures don't come close to the quality of the images in that book but none the less, some times I really enjoy the flexibility of my Sony's files .
It's valid dynamic range test

I think you shouldn't have called it a joke then. I have great respect for you because of your images and reports so I am quite disillusioned to see you write in such a manner about another photographer I respect no less and who published a valid test and stressed that it "is an extreme test and I can't imagine too many real world situations where you'd pull back over six stops of exposure."

Phillip
Aug 05, 2015 at 11:54 AM
AJSJones
Offline
Details
p.5 #7Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
I'll be interested to see if the 1/1000 rather than 1/2500 exposure time results from a bigger well capacity or a different light level when the shot was taken. We can only wait
Aug 05, 2015 at 12:12 PM
Phillip Reeve
Offline
Details
p.5 #8Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr


AJSJones wrote:
I'll be interested to see if the 1/1000 rather than 1/2500 exposure time results from a bigger well capacity or a different light level when the shot was taken. We can only wait

There is an update about that on the site. Does it change things? Highlight recivery isn't as spectacular as it seemed. Shadow recovery is even more impressive.
Aug 05, 2015 at 12:48 PM
artd
Offline
Details
p.5 #9Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
gdanmitchell wrote:
Sneakyracer wroteAgain, does not mean the 5DS/R is useless...
I have no idea where you are going with that. Who other than you brought up the stalking horse issue of one of these cameras being useless? Not me.



Welll....no one said any of these cameras are useless. Except, on page 1....

gdanmitchell wrote:
"Well, dang. I guess that in all of my 5DsR photographs where I pushed blacks, shadows, and exposure and thought I got beautiful results (and prints) that I was just hallucinating. Actually the camera sucks. Just look at that horrible noise!"


So. Someone posted a comparison (albeit with debatable methodology). No one said the 5DsR sucks. And then you made a post implying that someone said the 5DsR sucks.

The same way you now qualify at the end of your posts with how you think the Sony is a fine camera etc., it seems that so too people must now qualify their statements with how they think the 5DsR is a fine camera or not useless or whatever.

Things are getting silly around here. It's too bad. The Exmor may not be a Canon-killer...but it may end up being a forum-killer.

-Art
(Who uses both Sony and Canon cameras, thinks both are great, and has also used Nikon and Pentax cameras, and thought those were great too, and thinks that all camera companies will continue to come up with great cameras, and thinks that it's also great to explore advantages of different cameras in comparison to each other, and who thinks that technological differences are great because it forces companies to innovate and make better products, and who thinks it's great we have so many great options and that we can each choose different tools to meet different purposes and preferences and there is no such thing as absolute right or wrong and that you can make a great image with any camera but if you want to make certain types of images certain cameras might be greater than other cameras, but that doesn't make the not selected cameras not great, it just makes them differently great, and if you're still reading this disclaimer this far down then your patience is great.)










Aug 05, 2015 at 12:50 PM
DtEW
Offline
Details
p.5 #10Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
artd wrote:
gdanmitchell wrote
Sneakyracer wroteAgain, does not mean the 5DS/R is useless...
I have no idea where you are going with that. Who other than you brought up the stalking horse issue of one of these cameras being useless? Not me.
Welll....no one said any of these cameras are useless. Except, on page 1....

gdanmitchell wrote"Well, dang. I guess that in all of my 5DsR photographs where I pushed blacks, shadows, and exposure and thought I got beautiful results (and prints) that I was just hallucinating. Actually the camera sucks. Just look at that horrible noise!"
So. Someone posted a comparison (albeit with debatable methodology). No one said the 5DsR sucks. And then you made a post implying that someone said the 5DsR sucks.



If I facetiously claim that I am a pretty unicorn, would I be necessarily be implying that somebody accused me of being a pretty unicorn, thereby facilitating a claim of misrepresentation/slander/victimhood?

You're reading way too much into what wasn't said.
Aug 05, 2015 at 12:56 PM
Monito
Offline
Details
p.5 #11Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Fred Miranda wrote:
This test is a complete joke. However I do expect the A7RII to do substantially better when recovering deep shadows.


Phillip Reeve wrote:
[...]

Fred Miranda wrote:

It's valid dynamic range test

Phillip Reeve wrote:
I think you shouldn't have called it a joke then. I have great respect for you because of your images and reports so I am quite disillusioned to see you write in such a manner about another photographer I respect no less and who published a valid test and stressed that it "is an extreme test and I can't imagine too many real world situations where you'd pull back over six stops of exposure."


It's sort of a valid test between the two Sony's which were given a level playing field, but it is a joke given the way they tested the 5DS.

Users of the 5DS have been getting results that show the camera is not so bad when it is not handicapped with 1 1/3 stops less light.
Aug 05, 2015 at 01:02 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.5 #12Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Phillip Reeve wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
Phillip Reeve wrote
Fred Miranda wroteThis test is a complete joke. However I do expect the A7RII to do substantially better when recovering deep shadows.
Why do you think so?

I see no flaw in the testing. Sure they used different shutter speeds but the reason for that is that the a7rII does not only have much cleaner shadows but also seems to retain the highlights better. Here is what they did:
"We exposed such that the brightest area of non-sky was exposed to the right (using rawdigger to check) and then stopped down 6 stops and took our ‘under’ exposure."

I think this is a valid method to test a camera's dynamic range.

I think everybody should decide for themselves how important DR is to them. I own a couple of photo books with absolutely beautiful pictures in it, all of them were taken with Velvia 50 which has somewhere between 6 and 10 stops of DR. My own pictures don't come close to the quality of the images in that book but none the less, some times I really enjoy the flexibility of my Sony's files .
It's valid dynamic range test
I think you shouldn't have called it a joke then. I have great respect for you because of your images and reports so I am quite disillusioned to see you write in such a manner about another photographer I respect no less and who published a valid test and stressed that it "is an extreme test and I can't imagine too many real world situations where you'd pull back over six stops of exposure."

Phillip


Philip,
Based on the shutter speed differences from the test, I initially thought that the A7RII had more headroom in the highlights when compared to the others cameras. Later on the author attributed that to ambient lighting changes.

Also, comparing pushed shadows noise from images taken from different exposure times is not a good idea and just fuels camera wars. Regardless, I apologize for using "joke" to describe it. It was my initial reaction when I read the big headline in a rumors site.
Aug 05, 2015 at 01:05 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.5 #13Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Monito wrote:
It's sort of a valid test between the two Sony's which were given a level playing field, but it is a joke given the way they tested the 5DS.



Even the A7R was shot at a diff exposure than the A7R II. But, it does seem to have a better WB equitability and possibly (I haven't checked the #'s) a closer adjustment toward ETTR. In that regard, it's almost like we have three different sets of parameters for some kind of hybrid comparison. Maybe the approach is just over my head, but it sure doesn't seem equitable, nor straightforward.
Aug 05, 2015 at 01:16 PM
snapsy
Offline
Details
p.5 #14Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Per update in the article, the author attributes 2/3EV to 1EV of the exposure difference to transitory ambient light changes and 1/3EV due to nominal ISO sensitivity differences.
Aug 05, 2015 at 01:21 PM
Stoffer
Offline
Details
p.5 #15Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
snapsy wrote:
Per update in the article, the author attributes 2/3EV to 1EV of the exposure difference to transitory ambient light changes and 1/3EV due to nominal ISO sensitivity differences.


Thanks. Now it makes more sense to me.
Aug 05, 2015 at 01:23 PM
Monito
Offline
Details
p.5 #16Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
snapsy wrote:
Per update in the article, the author attributes 2/3EV to 1EV of the exposure difference to transitory ambient light changes and 1/3EV due to nominal ISO sensitivity differences.


The guy was so eager to get something, anything, on to the web As Soon As Possible that he sloppily did an ill-conceived test and then a sloppy writeup that has required multiple amendments.

And we are supposed to respect that web guy?

Thanks snapsy for helping put this into perspective.


Edited on Aug 05, 2015 at 01:30 PM · View previous versions
Aug 05, 2015 at 01:26 PM
Schlotkins
Offline
Details
p.5 #17Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Interesting test. The A7RII image looks a lot better than even the A7R image. However, as noted, there are a lot of differences here so I'm not sure how much I believe it. The author states it's about a 2 stop advantage over the canon but the A7R already has a 2 stop advantage so that doesn't make sense.

Anyway, looking forward to a more scientific tests as well as Fred's impressions.

BTW, I also agree with that the DR advantage really only matters for landscapers. When I'm shooting wildlife, I'm rarely below 400ISO where that advantage disappears.

Chris
Aug 05, 2015 at 01:28 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.5 #18Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Monito wrote:
snapsy wrotePer update in the article, the author attributes 2/3EV to 1EV of the exposure difference to transitory ambient light changes and 1/3EV due to nominal ISO sensitivity differences.
The guy was so eager to get something, anything, on to the web ASAP that he did a sloppy test and then a sloppy writeup that has required multiple amendments.

And we are supposed to respect that web guy?

Thanks snapsy for helping put this into perspective.


The silver lining ... confirmation that it's hard to pull a fast one past the collective group of FM'ers.

FM ROCKS !!!

Thanks Fred.



Aug 05, 2015 at 01:30 PM
snapsy
Offline
Details
p.5 #19Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Monito wrote:
snapsy wrotePer update in the article, the author attributes 2/3EV to 1EV of the exposure difference to transitory ambient light changes and 1/3EV due to nominal ISO sensitivity differences.
The guy was so eager to get something, anything, on to the web ASAP that he did a sloppy test and then a sloppy writeup that has required multiple amendments.

And we are supposed to respect that web guy?

Thanks snapsy for helping put this into perspective.


In all fairness to him it's difficult to do outdoor comparisons when there is cloud cover and changing LV. Since he accommodated the ambient light changes with exposure adjustments his original results are within the ballpark and valid, except for any conclusions drawn about extra highlight headroom and its effect on total DR. As a reminder to all, CMOS sensors are linear so when measuring raw DR from clipping downward there is no such thing as highlight headroom - it's all one big fat DR continuum; six of one, half a dozen of the other
Aug 05, 2015 at 01:34 PM
Monito
Offline
Details
p.5 #20Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
snapsy wrote:
In all fairness to him it's difficult to do outdoor comparisons when there is cloud cover and changing LV.


Sure. But too many variables make a test unreliable and not so useful. Controlling variables is the hallmark of good experimental design.

He was in such a rush to get hits to his website that he ran the test anyway and rushed his writeup. I don't respect either action.
Aug 05, 2015 at 01:39 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister