p.19 #1Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
RustyBug wrote: snapsy wroteIn the center I'd agree. However on FF the list of lenses that can resolve edges reasonably well relative to the center shrinks to a small subset, eliminating most zooms. The disparity between the center and edge resolution starts to look ridiculous even @ 50MP FF and it'll only get worse as MP goes up. This isn't a problem for all types of shooting but it's a headache for landscapes.Thus the day for a variable curved sensor to match the projected image (might be a while off yet though). I figure Sony will be the first one to achieve that in the year 2025.
Actually, Sony has already been playing around with curved sensors...would not be surprised to see it within 5 years or less.
p.19 #2Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
chez wrote: RustyBug wrotesnapsy wroteIn the center I'd agree. However on FF the list of lenses that can resolve edges reasonably well relative to the center shrinks to a small subset, eliminating most zooms. The disparity between the center and edge resolution starts to look ridiculous even @ 50MP FF and it'll only get worse as MP goes up. This isn't a problem for all types of shooting but it's a headache for landscapes.Thus the day for a variable curved sensor to match the projected image (might be a while off yet though). I figure Sony will be the first one to achieve that in the year 2025. Actually, Sony has already been playing around with curved sensors...would not be surprised to see it within 5 years or less.
I figure it will first show up in a fixed lens (or short range zoom) variety for UWA .. that I could see in a 5 year realm.
For ICL applications, I suspect they would either have to choose a "compromise" curve targeted for a range of FL's or devise some way to adjust it effectively. I'm thinking a four corner frame with micro adjusts on the corners would induce a nice curve to a flexible, yet stiff base.
Stay tuned ... I'm sure it will happen, I just don't look for it mainstream any time soon.
p.19 #3Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
As to street photography ... well, the general dialogue has been that the Sony is the holy grail of tripod based MF work. I don't shoot street, so when I'm shooting MF on the tripod the angle finder isn't an issue at all.
I'm not saying that it doesn't have its pros / cons ... just that there is more than one way to skin a cat, despite Sony fans portraying the Sony A7R to be the saving grace of photography for Canon shooters.
What is the cat's meow to one person, can be like herdin' cat's to another.
p.19 #4Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
RustyBug wrote:
As to street photography ... well, the general dialogue has been that the Sony is the holy grail of tripod based MF work. I don't shoot street, so when I'm shooting MF on the tripod the angle finder isn't an issue at all.
I'm not saying that it doesn't have its pros / cons ... just that there is more than one way to skin a cat, despite Sony fans portraying the Sony A7R to be the saving grace of photography for Canon shooters.
What is the cat's meow to one person, can be like herdin' cat's to another.
Shooting off the tripod...my 5D2 did great...except for its limited DR ( ). For street photography with manual focus lenses...the A7R wins hands down...no contest in fact. I was hit and miss using the 5D2 viewfinder with manual focus lenses...bang on with the A7R EVF and focus magnification.
I don't believe I see any Sony fans saying the A7R is the savings grace for Canon shooters. I do see many Sony shooters that see an advantage using the A7R(2) for many situations where the Canon cameras just aren't there yet.
I shoot landscapes / cityscapes / street photos with my A7R. For everything else, I use Canon cameras ( 5D2 / 7D ). Right now I'm in a dilemma whether to sell both the 5D2 and A7R to fund the A7R2 which would allow me to use the Sony camera for everything other than fast action or possibly wildlife where I like to use my 7D. I'm in a holding pattern as the price of new cameras these days are too high IMHO.
p.19 #5Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
snapsy wrote:
In the center I'd agree. However on FF the list of lenses that can resolve edges reasonably well relative to the center shrinks to a small subset, eliminating most zooms. The disparity between the center and edge resolution starts to look ridiculous even @ 50MP FF and it'll only get worse as MP goes up. This isn't a problem for all types of shooting but it's a headache for landscapes.
Two observations:
1. Lenses perform no worse on higher MP systems than they do on lower MP systems. A lens that produces quality suitable to produce, say, a 20" x 30" print on a 22MP camera will produce a print that is at least as good at that size when the photograph is made with a 50MP or 100MP camera. I think it is more accurate to say that if one uses higher MP sensor cameras to make larger prints than before that at some point the image resolution advantages at the larger sizes will not be as great.
2. Roger Cicala posted an interesting early article about using a variety of lenses on a 50MP camera. (Sorry, but I don't have the link handy — but is probably easy to find at the lensrentals site.) His conclusion was that the higher MP sensors had positive effects on image quality even when the lenses were not those that we might typically regard as the highest resolution lenses.
OK, one more. It absolutely is true that when one photographs with larger and larger prints in mind that a whole range of factors become more critical. These include the quality of the lens (and my experience tells me that at least the L lenses I use are up the challenge of 50MP, including in the corners), careful focus, camera stability, smart choices about aperture (for a variety of reasons), excellent post-processing skills and more.
artd wrote: gdanmitchell wroteI think that there is more "high quality" photography today, just as there is more low quality photography — because, quite simply, there are more photographs being made and they are seen much more widely. That said, the quality level of the best work is not better than that of the best work in earlier periods. The best photographers today, regardless of photographic medium or gear used, produce work that is every bit as good as the best photographers of some decades ago. (And, as you certainly know, but not everyone in this forum knows, this goes all the way back to the best work from the 1800s.)
All of which sort of supports my basic point about the nature and significance of technological differences. I welcome them for what they are, but they aren't the point.I agree, the level of the "best work" has not changed, and advancements in technology have an overall marginal impact on the quality level of that work. But, arguing that point misunderstands the issue.
Technology doesn't necessarily improve the inherent quality of the work, but it does improve the photographer's ability to create work of a particular quality level. Better technology provides gains in efficiency and improvements in workflow. It can makes things faster, provide desired results with more consistency and reliability, and make circumstances which were previously difficult easier to handle.
I don't disagree with the bulk of your second paragraph — better technology, which is a fine thing, does improve various functional aspects of photography.
However, I don't think that changes my observation that while these improvements have produced the improvements you describe, they have not resulted in better photography to any significant extent. In my opinion and the opinion of many others who know the work of a wide range of photographers, the most excellent work of the best photographers today does not eclipse the best work of the most excellent photographs from previous periods.
RustyBug wrote:
As to street photography ... well, the general dialogue has been that the Sony is the holy grail of tripod based MF work. I don't shoot street, so when I'm shooting MF on the tripod the angle finder isn't an issue at all.
From my own experience with street photography — shooting it myself with a small mirrorless camera and working with others using similar gear from several manufacturers — I think that for many kinds of street photography the mirrorless cameras are great tools. I'm using a Fujifilm system (I have my reasons) but for those who want to do this in full-frame, the Sony cameras look very appealing.
p.19 #6Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
gdanmitchell wrote:
The most excellent work of the best photographers today does not eclipse the best work of the most excellent photographs from previous periods.
Dan
In fact one could (tenuously) argue they've never had better tools therefore it is easier. Just look at the volumes of 'amateurs' producing sharp, vivid, albeit bland, scenes that would have tested pros thirty years earlier.
p.19 #7Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
gdanmitchell wrote:
However, I don't think that changes my observation that while these improvements have produced the improvements you describe, they have not resulted in better photography to any significant extent.
Neither do I think that. And I have never implied such a thing. Which makes me wonder why you keep trying to refute an argument that I haven't made? Or, to paraphrase a post you made earlier in this thread, arguing with something that I have never written or implied seems "strange and pointless."
Focusing on the question of whether technological improvements make "better photography" is a red herring. It's not about whether it makes the quality of photography better. It's whether it makes the process of photography better.
p.19 #8Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Paul Mo wrote: gdanmitchell wroteThe most excellent work of the best photographers today does not eclipse the best work of the most excellent photographs from previous periods.
DanIn fact one could (tenuously) argue they've never had better tools therefore it is easier. Just look at the volumes of 'amateurs' producing sharp, vivid, albeit bland, scenes that would have tested pros thirty years earlier.
I have a friend who got his start with AA in the 1980s, and he once said he sometimes feels that photography is just too easy these days. ;-) (He was referring to printing. Of course, he does it the modern way!)
artd wrote: gdanmitchell wroteHowever, I don't think that changes my observation,,,Neither do I think that...
OK. I'll let it lie. And I'll try to read your future posts more carefully before replying, since it seems that I must misinterpret every one of them.
p.19 #9Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
chez wrote: RustyBug wrotesnapsy wroteIn the center I'd agree. However on FF the list of lenses that can resolve edges reasonably well relative to the center shrinks to a small subset, eliminating most zooms. The disparity between the center and edge resolution starts to look ridiculous even @ 50MP FF and it'll only get worse as MP goes up. This isn't a problem for all types of shooting but it's a headache for landscapes.Thus the day for a variable curved sensor to match the projected image (might be a while off yet though). I figure Sony will be the first one to achieve that in the year 2025. Actually, Sony has already been playing around with curved sensors...would not be surprised to see it within 5 years or less.
I think I read the curved sensors might make an appearance in a smartphone sooner rather than later as the first case.
I know for a fact the Canon lens group has been asking for curved sensors going back at least 5 years.
The A7r II beats the 5DS R with 0.72 stops at ISO 800 and similarly above.
According to the same data set, the 5DS R beats the 5D III with 0.89 stops at ISO 50. You don't seem as eager to tell that
Which narrows the gap a bit to something around 1.5 stops diff instead of around 2.5 stops diff. Good news @1.5 stops is still notable (from both perspectives). Also notable to me, is that unlike where the A7R drops to on par with the Canon around ISO 800, the A7R II retains much of that additional DR throughout the entire range ... taking particular note of ISO 31,517 vs ... well, everything else.
Also interesting is that the 5DsR DR is no longer "oscillating" as previous models do.
p.19 #13Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
RustyBug wrote:
Also interesting is that the 5DsR DR is no longer "oscillating" as previous models do.
I saw that, too. Unlike some cameras with interesting spikes in their curve and some surprising glitches along the way, the 5DsR curve is smooth from start to finish. Not sure that is necessarily an advantage, but it makes me wonder about what is going on in other cameras from a range of manufacturers to produce the disjunct curves.
p.19 #15Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Yeah, I was already aware of the ISO oscillations ... picking the bang / buck spots accordingly. I forget the dialogue / technology behind the oscillation, but the smooth curve is welcome.
Curious to the "big dip" in the Sony just below base ISO @ what is driving that ... is it still 14 bit, or does it drop to 12 and then needs the extra light, or
p.19 #16Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Monito wrote:
The advantage of the smooth curve is that you can select as much or as little ISO as you desire.
With the 5D and the 5D2, I used to stick with the ISO 160, 320, 640, and 1250 set for the same or lower noise as their adjacent neighbors.
It's a slight advantage over the previous cameras, but one that I appreciate. Yet another of the many things tweaked and tuned in the 5DS.
Those ISOs (160, 320, 640) are not base ISOs, they result from processing in the camera. They have less noise because these ISO are actually pulled exposures of the next higher ISO setting.
So if you shoot at ISO 160, the camera is actually shooting at ISO 200 but over-exposing the shot by 1/3 stop, and then doing a 1/3 pull in its software. This technique when done manually at base ISOs is known as Expose to the Right (ETTR). In other words, you'd get the same result if you shot at ISO 200 with +1/3 exposure compensation and then pulled the exposure manually in post production.
p.19 #17Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Monito wrote:
With the 5D and the 5D2, I used to stick with the ISO 160, 320, 640, and 1250 set for the same or lower noise as their adjacent neighbors.
With the differences between "whole" ISOs (100, 200, 400) being so small at each step, the even smaller differences between the best and the worst of each sub-group seem so tiny as to be inconsequential. I always simply shoot at 100, 200, 400, 800, etc.
p.19 #18Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
mttran wrote:
Hi Anders, my requirement is little bit looser on sony side since their i/o is less DR dependent than canon; so far I can live on 10-11 stops but I have not do any serious shots these days, yet.
alundeb wrote:
Hello Michael,
Are you saying that you tolerate more noise in the shadows from Sony in your images because Sony sensors have less shadow noise? This does not make sense to me.
Hi Anders, I did some worst DR noise test awhile ago and sony sensor was doing fine when I tried to break the A7R meter. So 10-11 stops seems a good bet for my cases whenever I want smoother files, I have some reference recently posted here: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1380998/0#13150271
BTW, purpose of these tests is to see how sony DR benefits to all my canon fast prime (24L,35L,50L,85L,135L) in wide open aperture usage during the day which can't be fully supported by any canon sensor in a clean way.
p.19 #19Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
gdanmitchell wrote:
The most excellent work of the best photographers today does not eclipse the best work of the most excellent photographs from previous periods.
Dan
Wow, that must be true based on your say-so. Just for clarification, does excellent eclipse the best, or vice-versa
imo, it is a good test but test scene is not quite a wide DR challenge range for 5Ds, A7R and A7Rii. To find out their actual working range, I prefer more tricky lights than this case: http://www.onlandscape.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/latrigg-fullframe-656x438.jpg to a bit closer to Robin Hood's bay DR when Tim compared the noise between 5D3, 5Ds(r) and IQ280