fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr

  
 
snapsy
Offline
Details
p.4 #1Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
I examined the A7rII, A7r, and 5DSR raws in RawDigger. First the EXIF including shooting times:

A7r 1/2500 f/8 ISO 100: 12:05:44 PM
A7rII 1/1000 f/8 ISO 100: 12:58:01 PM
5DSR 1/2500 f/8 ISO 100: 01:02:35 PM

Based on the raw data it appears the relative raw levels of the sky are in fact close even though the absolute exposure is different by more than 1EV. Shooting times between the A7r and A7rII are nearly an hour apart (if camera clocks are correctly set) but the 5DSR and A7rII were shot within a few minutes of each other and their raw levels still roughly match, so it's not clear it's an ambient light difference.

It is curious that the A7rII required so much more exposure to achieve the same relative raw levels as the A7r/5DSR. Here's a screen cap of my RawDigger comp of the A7rII vs A7r:

A7rII vs A7r RawDigger comp
Aug 05, 2015 at 06:59 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.4 #2Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
alundeb wrote:
Native ISO 40 would be huge especially for long exposures. It would allow double exposure times without ND filters. But if the A7rII has such exposure latitude, why is ISO 50 advertised as extended ISO? Wouldn't it be natural to extend the ISO to 25?


I would love to have ISO 25......
Aug 05, 2015 at 07:07 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.4 #3Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
jctriguy wrote:
Is anyone surprised that the Sony camera has more DR than the Canon? Has either manufacturer made any attempt to claim otherwise?


Nops. Canon stated upfront that the 5Ds(R) dynamic range was not improved. The question is still out how much the DR difference is between both of the 5Ds(R) and the A7R II in practical terms at ISO < 800.

To me the more interesting news is that the A7R II seems to have improved DR versus its predecessor, the A7R.
Aug 05, 2015 at 07:12 AM
Phillip Reeve
Offline
Details
p.4 #4Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr


Stoffer wrote:
OK checked out the raw files again. First you open them in ACR/LR and set Exposure to +5 and Shadows to +100. Then you move the Whites slider up until it starts to clip the highlights in the sky.

They all do that around +25 give or take. But it is a bit tricky to rely on since it clips the highlights in different areas so the skies have moved between shots. This also means that the light could be a different between shots even on an overcast day.

I think you donn't fully understand the test setup. They never measured against the sky "We exposed such that the brightest area of non-sky was exposed to the right (using rawdigger to check) and then stopped down 6 stops and took our ‘under’ exposure. . They first determined how much exposure they could give without losing details in the brightest part of the quarry. They didn't use the sky as a reference point for exposure because the brightness in the sky varies a lot more than in the quarry.Then they reduced the shutter speed by 6 stops and took another picture which we are discussing here.

If anyone really thinks Tim Parkin motivation for including the 5dsr in the test was to put it in a bad light I would recommend to that person to read his very extensive test of that camera here is a part of his conclusion: The 5DS and 5DSr are stunning cameras. Yes they are an incremental upgrade in everything but the resolution stakes but I think these incremental improvements are in the right places.


Aug 05, 2015 at 07:16 AM
Bones74
Offline
Details
p.4 #5Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Phillip Reeve wrote:
What I didn't know was that the a7rII has significantly more DR than the a7r, thats why the test is useful to me.


Fair enough I'd quite fancy that A7R ii sensor in a 5Diii style body!

Aug 05, 2015 at 07:17 AM
Bones74
Offline
Details
p.4 #6Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
chez wrote:
Superfluous to you...fine, others have an interest.


You are quite Chez, that's the whole point. The test is useful to some and they say so. Its not to others and they say so. Both are equally legitimate.

Aug 05, 2015 at 07:19 AM
darbo
Offline
Details
p.4 #7Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr

retrofocus wrote:
alundeb wroteNative ISO 40 would be huge especially for long exposures. It would allow double exposure times without ND filters. But if the A7rII has such exposure latitude, why is ISO 50 advertised as extended ISO? Wouldn't it be natural to extend the ISO to 25?
I would love to have ISO 25......


Gimme ISO 12! Kidding, of course.

When the D810 was released last year I was hoping it would prove to be a trendsetter with regards to native lower-than-ISO 100 settings. Just look at the extra DR the D810 gains at ISO 64 vs 100! So, I am disappointed in both 5DS and a7R II in sticking to a base ISO 100.
Aug 05, 2015 at 07:19 AM
chez
Offline
Details
p.4 #8Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
jctriguy wrote:
chez wrote
Bones74 wrote
Phillip Reeve wroteIf you want to see nice pictures check out the author's flickr stream
Or have a look at http://www.onlandscape.co.uk, as a subscriber I have learned a lot from Tim and the other authors. The magazine is the least gear oriented and most manufacturer independent (well maybe a little focused on Fujis's Velvia 50 with it's 6-8 stops of DR;-)) I know of and full of nice or thought provoking images.

The test clearly demonstrates that the a7rII has better DR than the a7r and thats important information for me. Which is quite relevant in the field.
I will go check out the beautiful images, thank you I'm sure you already knew the Sony sensors have more DR before this "superfluous" test
Superfluous to you...fine, others have an interest.
Is anyone surprised that the Sony camera has more DR than the Canon? Has either manufacturer made any attempt to claim otherwise? Were any changes made that would indicate canon catching up at base ISO DR? What new info is shared by this 'review'?

PS what review have you done? Not sure why you are commenting until you've done the work yourself. What is your experience with the 5Dsr?



The real interest is the results of the A7R2 compared to the A7R. With the A7r2 dr improving...it's just one more feature which makes me lean further to upgrading my A7R.

JC...exactly what is your interest in this thread? You just continually jump into threads, dump on people and contribute exactly nothing. Maybe it's time to grow up a bit and give it a rest. Just a suggestion so you might be taken seriously one day.
Aug 05, 2015 at 07:22 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.4 #9Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
darbo wrote:
retrofocus wrote
alundeb wroteNative ISO 40 would be huge especially for long exposures. It would allow double exposure times without ND filters. But if the A7rII has such exposure latitude, why is ISO 50 advertised as extended ISO? Wouldn't it be natural to extend the ISO to 25?
I would love to have ISO 25......
Gimme ISO 12! Kidding, of course.

When the D810 was released last year I was hoping it would prove to be a trendsetter with regards to native lower-than-ISO 100 settings. Just look at the extra DR the D810 gains at ISO 64 vs 100! So, I am disappointed in both 5DS and a7R II in sticking to a base ISO 100.


I agree - I wish especially Sony would have lowered the base ISO to 50 in the new camera. But I guess the felt demand for high ISO has more supporters.
Aug 05, 2015 at 07:33 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.4 #10Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Sneakyracer wrote:
No surprise that the Sony A7RII is THE Best choice for Landscape/Architecture photography at base iso.


It will be no surprise to find that the A7rII has the largest dynamic range of any currently available full frame digital camera. That makes is, in many ways, a fine camera for landscape and architecture and certain other subjects. However, no single parameter (e.g. — DR) makes it "THE Best choice" for these or any other subjects, since there is more than that single parameter to consider.

I might as well argue that "No surprise that the Canon 5DsR is THE Best choice for Landscape/Architecture because is has 'industry leading' sensor resolution." But I won't ...

Is a small camera body your highest priority? You may be a candidate for the A7rII. Is moving quickly among varying subjects — landscape, wildlife, etc — significant for you? You many be a candidate for the 5DsR. Are you doing street photography with MF primes? You sound like someone who would love the A7rII. Do you do long exposure night photography? You may have good reasons for preferring the 5DsR.

Yes, Sony has better dynamic range. Canon has higher sensor resolution. Sony is smaller. Canon AFs better. Sony uses a lot of lenses by means of adapters. Canon provides a full range of its own lenses. Sony works great from the tripod with its EVF. Canon does, too, but is also works great through the OVF for shooting handheld.j

Dan

Edited on Aug 05, 2015 at 01:31 PM · View previous versions
Aug 05, 2015 at 07:41 AM
darbo
Offline
Details
p.4 #11Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
chez wrote:
The real interest is the results of the A7R2 compared to the A7R. With the A7r2 dr improving...it's just one more feature which makes me lean further to upgrading my A7R.


Couldn't agree more with that. And I am interested in learning that you are also considering upgrading. If I recall correctly you weren't initially thinking about upgrading - though I may have confused you with someone else.

To me the a7R II is pretty doggone amazing in terms of all it offers to me and my work. With assets like IBIS, BSI sensor, etc. I just wonder what Sony could possibly do with the a7R III that can match the revolutions of the a7R and now the a7R II. My feeling (and my hope, as one that wants to settle down with my cameras for years to come) is that going forward the next versions will be less ground-breaking and more iterative. Just like the 5D and 5D II were revolutionary, but the latest versions are iterative improvements. But, hey, that's the wishful thinking of a guy that can buy this year's model, but can't afford to buy future models for a while. hehe.
Aug 05, 2015 at 07:43 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.4 #12Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
darbo wrote:
Just like the 5D and 5D II were revolutionary, but the latest versions are iterative improvements.


Aug 05, 2015 at 07:45 AM
chez
Offline
Details
p.4 #13Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
darbo wrote:
chez wroteThe real interest is the results of the A7R2 compared to the A7R. With the A7r2 dr improving...it's just one more feature which makes me lean further to upgrading my A7R.
Couldn't agree more with that. And I am interested in learning that you are also considering upgrading. If I recall correctly you weren't initially thinking about upgrading - though I may have confused you with someone else.

To me the a7R II is pretty doggone amazing in terms of all it offers to me and my work. With assets like IBIS, BSI sensor, etc. I just wonder what Sony could possibly do with the a7R III that can match the revolutions of the a7R and now the a7R II. My feeling (and my hope, as one that wants to settle down
...Show more →

You and I are in the same boat...early retirement for me at the end of this year.

I'd pick up the A7R2 today as it's feature set is amazing. The only obstacle for me is it's price tag. I'm waiting to the end of the year with hopes of some Xmas sales.

I'd love to see a head to head image test between the A7R and A7R2 at various ISO ranges.
Aug 05, 2015 at 07:52 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.4 #14Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
retrofocus wrote:
alundeb wroteNative ISO 40 would be huge especially for long exposures. It would allow double exposure times without ND filters. But if the A7rII has such exposure latitude, why is ISO 50 advertised as extended ISO? Wouldn't it be natural to extend the ISO to 25?
I would love to have ISO 25......


I've had it for years in the SLR/C ... actually, it can go down to ISO 6. Technically it is a bit software wizardry that achieves it, but it's been there since 2004.
Aug 05, 2015 at 08:13 AM
chez
Offline
Details
p.4 #15Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
retrofocus wrote:
darbo wrote
retrofocus wrote
alundeb wroteNative ISO 40 would be huge especially for long exposures. It would allow double exposure times without ND filters. But if the A7rII has such exposure latitude, why is ISO 50 advertised as extended ISO? Wouldn't it be natural to extend the ISO to 25?
I would love to have ISO 25......
Gimme ISO 12! Kidding, of course.

When the D810 was released last year I was hoping it would prove to be a trendsetter with regards to native lower-than-ISO 100 settings. Just look at the extra DR the D810 gains at ISO 64 vs 100! So, I am disappointed in both 5DS and a7R II in sticking to a base ISO 100.
I agree - I wish especially Sony would have lowered the base ISO to 50 in the new camera. But I guess the felt demand for high ISO has more supporters.


Iso 50 or why stop there, 25 would be amazingly handy. I quite often use ND filters to extend shutter times...would be great not to need a filter to do the same.
Aug 05, 2015 at 08:19 AM
darbo
Offline
Details
p.4 #16Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Unfortunately, the conventional wisdom remains: "ISO 100 why not just stop there...."

I don't know the technical reasons why there is such a reluctance to go lower - does it mess with high-ISO performance somehow? Doesn't seem to be the case with the D810.
Aug 05, 2015 at 08:33 AM
Sneakyracer
Offline
Details
p.4 #17Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
gdanmitchell wrote:
jctriguy wrotePS what review have you done? Not sure why you are commenting until you've done the work yourself. What is your experience with the 5Dsr?
I wrote something, earlier in this thread I think, for the irony-impaired. I had read a brief rant by someone who pointed out that some commenting on the a7r did not own one and therefore their perspectives were invalid.

That notion, offered from time to time by several who have made an appearance n this thread, alternated infuriates and entertains me. First, virtually no one should then have anything to say about the A7rII, since almost no one has one, and even fewer have used it extensively, right? Second, (from the Right Back Atcha' Department, Irony Division), I'll bet a
...Show more →
Sneakyracer wroteNo surprise that the Sony A7RII is THE Best choice for Landscape/Architecture photography at base iso.


The A7RII is the best choice, does not mean it is going to be everyone's preferred choice obviously since camera choice is quite personal.

Resolution is close enough between the two that it is not really a determining factor.

Capturing all of a scene's tones in one capture thanks to gobs of dynamic range really makes life a LOT simpler and easier for landscape and architecture photographers. When time/access at certain locations is limited and conditions difficult or let's say more "interesting" being able to just get everything with one capture and still maintaining great color and low noise is a huge edge.

Makes "sculpting" the final image in post-production much much easier. It saves time. Gives one more options in post.

And let's not forget that with the A7RII one can use a HUGE range of lenses. One can even mount it on an ARCA body and use tech camera lenses with movements or use adapters and mount Canon/Nikon/Hasselblad/Zeiss/Leica lenses among others.

So combine the large lens selection with a sensor that is the best ever made and it is an easy choice to make unless you want/need stuff that it does not have like an optical viewfinder and the handling associated with that and a larger body.

Again, does not mean the 5DS/R is useless, far from it since it is an excellent camera in it's own right.
Aug 05, 2015 at 08:35 AM
Sneakyracer
Offline
Details
p.4 #18Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
chez wrote:
darbo wrote
chez wroteThe real interest is the results of the A7R2 compared to the A7R. With the A7r2 dr improving...it's just one more feature which makes me lean further to upgrading my A7R.
Couldn't agree more with that. And I am interested in learning that you are also considering upgrading. If I recall correctly you weren't initially thinking about upgrading - though I may have confused you with someone else.

To me the a7R II is pretty doggone amazing in terms of all it offers to me and my work. With assets like IBIS, BSI sensor, etc. I just wonder what Sony could possibly do with the a7R III that can match the revolutions of the a7R and now the a7R II. My feeling (and my hope, as one that wants to settle down with my cameras for years to come) is that going forward the next versions will be less ground-breaking and more iterative. Just like the 5D and 5D II were revolutionary, but the latest versions are iterative improvements. But, hey, that's the wishful thinking of a guy that can buy this year's model, but can't afford to buy future models for a while. hehe.
You and I are in the same boat...early retirement for me at the end of this year.

I'd pick up the A7R2 today as it's feature set is amazing. The only obstacle for me is it's price tag. I'm waiting to the end of the year with hopes of some Xmas sales.

I'd love to see a head to head image test between the A7R and A7R2 at various ISO ranges.


Let's be thankful that Sony is not charging $4500 for it. The camera is so good that even at that price it will probably not affect much its sales.
Aug 05, 2015 at 08:38 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.4 #19Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
chez wrote:
I'd love to see a head to head image test between the A7R and A7R2 at various ISO ranges.


That would be good to see. Hopefully in a more "straightforward" manner ... changing only one variable (ISO), leaving the other aspects of exposure & lighting constant. Once we start making multiple variable "tests", then it really muddies the water, raising the results into more question than answer.

If one needs to do multiple tests regarding multiple aspects, so be it do them independently. THEN, after showing the individual aspects, you can "play" with multiple variables and folks can then see the synthesis possibilities ... but when you start off with multiple variables in your approach, it makes it kinda tough for folks to follow sometimes.

In this test, I'm also intrigued by the variance in the sky ... in the posted images (I can't open the raw), the sky in the 5DsR is only around 245-ish, while the A7R II is fully blown @ 255 (which could be anything from 255 to 255 + a gazillion). Here again, we are showing a degree of unequitable variance. If you think these are equitable @ ETTR, then simply desaturate them both and you see the difference more clearly. A sampled area of the triangular rock face on the right reveals 168 (A7R II) vs. 134 (5DsR) ... again, a significant variance on the order of magnitude @ yet again +/- another full stop.

For the OP ... I do appreciate the effort. It reminds me of some testing that I did quite some time ago ... and it got "picked apart". But, to be fair, the things that folks were pointing out about my method were indeed valid. Did that invalidate all aspects of my presentation ... "No." Did it require an adjustment in understanding to what we were looking at "Yes."

The test here is being presented as though it is equitable ... but on three different issues (exposure, tint, adjustment to ETTR) I see variation in the testing. I think it would be prudent (if you have the time / inclination) for a repeat of the test. Again, I appreciate the effort, but I think that we do need to (honestly) take the presentation and results with a (rather large) grain of salt ... which, since the A7R II was given more light than the A7R (although I only looked into the two @ A7R II vs. 5DsR @ lazy on my part), the perception that the A7R II is a quantum leap above the A7R ... well, that also falls into question, given the variances involved.

Thanks again, but I have to take this one as "swing and a miss" or a "foul ball" ... step in the box and take another swing at it. Looking forward to seeing you put this one in the field of fair play for everyone to chime in on @ redux.

Do I expect to see similar results showing the DR of the A7R II different from the others ... sure, but I think that in it's current form ... it may be exaggerated by virtue of all the synergistic effects from the variances. I mean, once we start talking about making 2^6 exponential changes to things, and then adding / subtracting, clipping, etc. well, that can really provide for some diff results through the wonderful aspect of numerical manipulation to those variances.

I realize that pride of authorship may continue to invoke a defense of your test (hey, we're all human here), but I do hope you'll take an honest revisit to your approach and look for the possible errors. The final aspect of all my tests in physics were ... here's all my data and findings ... now, here's all the ways it could be flubbed up or skewed en route (i.e. no such thing as a perfect test), including human error. That's just a part of good testing, to review where the folly's might exist ... grand or minute.

Thanks again for the effort.



Edited on Aug 05, 2015 at 11:14 AM · View previous versions
Aug 05, 2015 at 08:42 AM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.4 #20Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Phillip Reeve wrote:
The test clearly demonstrates that the a7rII has better DR than the a7r and thats important information for me. Which is quite relevant in the field.


Is it getting close to the Nikon D810 yet, or is it still handicapped by low bit rate and file compression?
Aug 05, 2015 at 08:51 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister