p.18 #1Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Pixel Perfect wrote
Everything is a compromise and you have to choose which ones are most important.
+1
Sometimes it is good to understand the difference between most important to have vs. most important to avoid. Having more of a good thing can be a far different matter from having less of a bad thing. That of course will also vary from person to person, so ... choose your poison(s).
p.18 #2Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
timparkin wrote:
Agreed - and I think that it makes sense for the dedicated photographer who can afford to to have both cameras.
I think that makes it a case where for some folks ... it is a matter of what they can afford, such that they have to make choices. And by "afford", it can mean much more than just $$$ (which is always part of the equation). Sometimes, it is affording the extra bag space, the extra adapters, the extra workflow (multi-diff platform = multi-diff processing), the extra diff thought process, affording the different menu's and controls, affording a niche utility, etc.
Those may seem like insignificant things to afford for person "A", while they are things that person "B" doesn't care to afford. Are there gains to be incurred in alternative lens use or DR or , sure, but it always comes at a cost of some sort (i.e. there is no such thing as a free lunch), although some folks would project otherwise. Always a personal choice @ horses for courses.
Which, for some, they don't care to afford shooting 4x5 film, even though it does present diff opportunities than DSLR ... right back to horses for courses.
Thanks for the Velvia shot, btw. My film days approach was not unlike your 400 / 160, so I'm with ya. My bag was always filled with FujiChrome 50 as my mainstay, with a roll or two of Gold 200 for my "just in case". Yup, no such thing as a perfect film, nor a perfect camera for all situations or temperaments.
p.18 #3Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
RustyBug wrote: timparkin wroteAgreed - and I think that it makes sense for the dedicated photographer who can afford to to have both cameras.I think that makes it a case where for some folks ... it is a matter of what they can afford, such that they have to make choices. And by "afford", it can mean much more than just $$$ (which is always part of the equation). Sometimes, it is affording the extra bag space, the extra adapters, the extra workflow (multi-diff platform = multi-diff processing), the extra diff thought process, affording the different menu's and controls, etc. Those may seem like insiginificant things to afford for person "A", while they are things that person "B" doesn't care to afford. Always a personal choice @ horses for courses.
Thanks for the Velvia shot, btw. My film days approach was not unlike your 400 / 160, so I'm with ya. My bag was always filled with FujiChrome 50 as my mainstay, with a roll or two of Gold 200 for my "just in case". Yup, no such thing as a perfect film, nor a perfect camera for all situations or temperaments.
I have multiple cameras each used for specific conditions ranging from a small X100 to a large format 4x5 camera. When I go out, I typically know what type of photography I'm going to be doing and only bring along the gear that fits the photography which includes camera(s), lens, filters etc. I never bring along all my gear as I would need multiple Sherpas.
The different workflow from the various systems is what keeps photography exciting. I typically shoot my X100 in jpeg mode...they are that good. I love shooting 4x5 B&W film developing and scanning negatives...and then love to shoot my various digital cameras in raw and process / printing them.
I would find one do-it-all system boring after a bit...love the variety of techniques required with different systems. Each of my systems produce better results in their various niches...not one single system is best in all situations.
p.18 #4Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Chez,
+1
You are exactly presenting my point @ horses for courses.
I (otoh) am at a place where I want to minimize the multitude of variances that you find so "exciting". There was a day when I could be a mental pack mule with all the novelty and variety among platforms. Today, not so much. I want my gear to support me, rather than me trying to support all my gear.
There is a balance that everyone has with respect to where (i.e. too much of a good thing) a joy becomes a burden. If you like dabbling with all manner of things, super-duper cooper ... that doesn't mean that it is the cat's meow for everyone else. Some folks find minimizing their gear to be liberating. I've been on both sides of the equation ... I think most folks have swung with that pendulum to one degree or another. When / where an individual "settles in" at ... well, that's highly subjective and rather dependent upon a person's individual temperament.
Presently, the thought of more adapters (some work with some glass, some with other glass, but not with my glass) and the need to drop an additional $4K to get to a "partial solution", or $1,500 for a "niche" option ... well between "afford" and "burden" ... it's just not tipping the scales for me in that direction. Can I retool things to support using a Sony ... sure, but I reiterate that I want my gear to support me, rather than me trying to support my gear ... not to mention the additional burden that endeavor becomes.
p.18 #6Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
RustyBug wrote:
Chez,
+1
You are exactly presenting my point @ horses for courses.
I (otoh) am at a place where I want to minimize the multitude of variances that you find so "exciting". There was a day when I could be a mental pack mule with all the novelty and variety among platforms. Today, not so much. I want my gear to support me, rather than me trying to support all my gear.
There is a balance that everyone has with respect to where (i.e. too much of a good thing) a joy becomes a burden. If you like dabbling with all manner of things, super-duper cooper ... that doesn't mean that it is the cat's meow for everyone else. Some folks find minimizing their gear to be liberating. I've been on both sides of the equation ... I think most folks have swung with that pendulum to one degree or another. When / where an individual "settles in" at ... well, that's highly subjective and rather dependent upon a person's individual temperament.
Presently, the thought of more adapters (some work with some glass, some with other glass, but not with my glass) and the need to drop an additional $4K to get to a "partial solution", or $1,500 for a "niche" option ... well between "afford" and "burden" ... it's just not tipping the scales for me in that direction. Can I retool things to support using a Sony ... sure, but I reiterate that I want my gear to support me, rather than me trying to support my gear ... not to mention the additional burden that endeavor becomes.
Please elaborate how your gear supports you. You say you have to shoot multiple exposures and merge in post...is that your gear supporting you? You do a lot of manual focus and need to attach a gizmo to the back of the LCD screen in order to see the screen...is that your gear supporting you? The fact that you need to use the rear LCD to manual focus rather than a viewfinder...is that your gear supporting you?
You make it sound like using something like the A7R to be a real pain ( have you even used one )...yet you go through hoops to use your existing gear and that is OK?
p.18 #8Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
timparkin wrote: gdanmitchell wroteartd wrotegdanmitchell wroteI'm also fascinated by photographs (surprise!) and by the observation that if differences between a thing and the next step in the evolution of the thing were as stupendous as some imagine them to be and thus had such a central impact on the nature of photographs (technically or aesthetically) that such a rate of change projected backwards across a series of such evolutionary step could easily confirm the fact that any photograph made more than perhaps a decade or so ago would be seriously deficient, or to use one the many terms seen here "inadequate" or even "pretty bad." ;-)No one has even come close to making that absurd argument Dan, and you should know better than to conflate words to make that implication.I didn't say they were making that argument. Actually I made the argumentative proposition that you quoted, and I did so to make a point.
I'm pointing out that "if differences between a thing and the next stop in the evolution of the thing were as stupendous as some imagine them to be" that the rate of change over a period of time would be much larger than what the evidence suggests.
There are only two possibilities that I can see. Either the magnitude of the change between the products under discussion in this thread is far more consequential than virtually all other changes in photography and, as such, is truly a singular sort of thing, or...
... a change that seems to be huge right at this moment will reveal itself to be far less huge in reality. (The earlier post suggesting the very high quality obtainable by the old technology of film is among factors that tend to argue for the latter rather than the former.)
Please note that neither of those possibilities negate the reality that change has occurred. They only speak to the question of how significant the changes are. Here we get to what I regard as the core issue.
I like RustyBug's clear description of a fundamental problem with how these terms are being used. If a car is excellent by virtue of some measurable thing, it does not become non-excellent when another car can do that one thing better by some increment. If car A has the most comfortable seats and then car B comes out with a bit better seats, that doesn't make the seats in car A no longer comfortable. If fast car A can go 230 MPH, when fast car B is released with a top speed of 240 MPH, car A is still very fast. And lots of people might think that the car that does 235 and has the second-most-comfortable seats is the most excellent car overall.
Also note that I referred also to the technical quality of photographs made in the past, not just the aesthetic quality that you mention in your post.
DanHmm... you use many words but not a lot of semantic content comes through. I think we can summarise by saying
"language is relative"
p.s. When I was on the judging panel for the Wildlife Photographer of the Year last year we were looking through all of the books from the competition for the last 50 years and we asked ourselves the question about whether we could see the change from film to digital and what it looked like. Well it looked like a drop in quality at about the year 2002/2003 and then the quality picked back up again in about 2006/2007.
More interestingly, the quality of images overall didn't really change over the period - we should find this surprising considering the vast number of photographers that digital has enabled. ...Show more →
Regarding your analysis of my writing skills, I'll simply plead that whatever one does when writing in photography forums — short and punchy, long and philosophical, blunt declaration of opinion, in-depth technical summary, you name it — someone won't like it. OK, I will add that, indeed, "language is relative." Perhaps that seems as obvious a concept to you as it does to me, but it clearly eludes quite a few folks on photography forums.
Your second point regarding your experience looking at many photographs from many photographers over a long period of time spanning the "film only" era through the "film still predominates but here comes digital" era and on to the current "where did film go?" era is in line with what I have seen, too.
I think that there is more "high quality" photography today, just as there is more low quality photography — because, quite simply, there are more photographs being made and they are seen much more widely. That said, the quality level of the best work is not better than that of the best work in earlier periods. The best photographers today, regardless of photographic medium or gear used, produce work that is every bit as good as the best photographers of some decades ago. (And, as you certainly know, but not everyone in this forum knows, this goes all the way back to the best work from the 1800s.)
All of which sort of supports my basic point about the nature and significance of technological differences. I welcome them for what they are, but they aren't the point.
RustyBug wrote:
BTW, can you perform MFA of your Canon glass on a Sony body?
If I'm not mistaken, when using sensor based AF systems, the MFA concept becomes kind of irrelevant.
In general, while current mirrorless AF systems are typically not as fast as DSLR systems, they are generally very accurate once (and in a few cases if) they do acquire focus.
p.18 #10Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Okay, so the thing that makes them accurate is the same thing that makes them slow ... particularly as you are using longer focal lengths, so it would seem.
Chez, my gear selection supports my goals and agenda by having a versatility to them. In the case of me using an angle finder / magnification ... I can achieve additional critical focus for manual work ... and RETAIN FULL performance and functionality of my AF system. Sure, an angle finder isn't convenient in some scenarios ... yet, it is more convenient in others (ummm, the Sony display won't articulate to support low-angle portrait orientation). I shoot both with & without it as the situation warrants.
In that regard, the Sony is a compromise (which is different from an inconvenience) on two counts for me. One it is a significant compromise on the AF performance of my glass (neither A7R, nor A7R II can AF the long glass well, nor the -2006 glass). It is a compromise on my portrait orientation shooting viewing capabilities, when I'm low to the ground.
When I go out exploring into certain areas, I may not know if I'm going to find wildlife or not. Carrying a single body that can support both AF and MF is prudent for me. The fact is that the Sony CANNOT support AF performance with long glass. I don't know of any other way to say it. That is a serious compromise in capability, not a mere inconvenience.
Your point would be that I should spend $$$$$ on a Sony body and adapters, so I can support my MF uses. Instead, I choose to spend $ on an angle finder ... which is far lighter, far smaller and far simpler than carrying a second body and multiple adapters and different batteries, and have yet another charging system to pack in my bag or truck, and a different menu interface and a different tactile interface ... and that still retards (or mitigates) my AF functionality. The cost of more $$$$, more gear, more weight, more hassle and less versatile AF functionality is a high price to pay for some. For others, it matters not to them.
And, since I have the ability to use Live View for manual focusing ... OR ... an angle finder, do I really need the Sony for MF? Thus the Sony is seen (by me) as an (expensive) niche augmentation or special use tool ... not an overall improvement tool. That niche or specialization comes at a cost ... which is more than just $$$$. Not everyone finds that cost to be meritable for their needs @ diff strokes for diff folks.
Obviously, there is always going to be a difference of opinion regarding approach @ horses for courses.
p.18 #11Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
timparkin wrote:
Let's take your 'everything improves' reference and analyse the amount of dynamic range increase over time.
According to DxO, the Canon 1DS had 11 stops of dynamic range the D810 has 14.8 stops of dynamic range. (and before that the D30 had about 10 stops - I have one and I'm about to check this)
This is an increase of 3.8 stops in 12 years.. That's 3 and a bit years per stop.
In that context, a 2 stop advantage is nearly 6.5 years of development advantage. Is that a minor difference?
Or I could put it another way, colour negative film with 16+ stops of dynamic range has been around since the 1950s and 18+ stops for the last two decades.
So according the the history of photography we were going up and up in dynamic range to the point that we could capture any conceivable scene and when digital came along there was a massive drop back to slide levels of dynamic range.
At some point we might catch up with where we were half a century ago..
That comparison clearly shows how much more resolution can be had from large format film compared to even the best digital medium format. IMO there is still much more resolution to be had from 35 mm digital. I base that on my own tests done with lenses for 35 mm format on the Pentax Q small sensor interchangeable lens camera with pixel density corresponding to 360 MP on 35 mm.
When I hear somenoe saying that 50 or even 36 MP is ridiculously high resolution, I think that digital is slowly applroaching the capabilities of LF film, and there is room for doubling of resolution a couple more times within the 35 mm format.
p.18 #12Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
RustyBug wrote:
Okay, so the thing that makes them accurate is the same thing that makes them slow ... particularly as you are using longer focal lengths, so it would seem.
Chez, my gear selection supports my goals and agenda by having a versatility to them. In the case of me using an angle finder / magnification ... I can achieve additional critical focus for manual work ... and RETAIN FULL performance and functionality of my AF system. Sure, an angle finder isn't convenient in some scenarios ... yet, it is more convenient in others (ummm, the Sony display won't articulate to support low-angle portrait orientation). I shoot both with & without it as the situation warrants.
In that regard, the Sony is a compromise (which is different from an inconvenience) on two counts for me. One it is a significant compromise on the AF performance of my glass (neither A7R, nor A7R II can AF the long glass well, nor the -2006 glass). It is a compromise on my portrait orientation shooting viewing capabilities, when I'm low to the ground.
When I go out exploring into certain areas, I may not know if I'm going to find wildlife or not. Carrying a single body that can support both AF and MF is prudent for me. The fact is that the Sony CANNOT support AF performance with long glass. I don't know of any other way to say it. That is a serious compromise in capability, not a mere inconvenience.
Your point would be that I should spend $$$$$ on a Sony body and adapters, so I can support my MF uses. Instead, I choose to spend $ on an angle finder ... which is far lighter, far smaller and far simpler than carrying a second body and multiple adapters and different batteries, and have yet another charging system to pack in my bag or truck ... and that still retards (or mitigates) my AF functionality. The cost of more $$$$, more gear, more weight, more hassle and less versatile AF functionality is a high price to pay for some. For others, it matters not to them.
And, since I have the ability to use Live View for manual focusing ... OR ... an angle finder, do I really need the Sony for MF? Thus the Sony is seen (by me) as an (expensive) niche augmentation or special use tool ... not an overall improvement tool. That niche or specialization comes at a cost ... which is more than just $$$$. Not everyone finds that cost to be meritable for their needs @ diff strokes for diff folks.
Obviously, there is always going to be a difference of opinion regarding approach @ horses for courses....Show more →
Rusty...my point is not that you should spend $$$ on anything...truthfully I don't care. My point is that you are pretty vocal about compromises...yet your equipment is full of compromises. Shooting manual focus in general with an angle finder is a sever pain in the ass. If might work for you in a very niche case...but general manual focus with an angle finder does not work. Same goes with using the read LCD monitor to focus...just does not work for many situations. This...to many...is a compromise to manual focus using a DSLR. They have never been designed with manual focus in mind.
As far as extra weight to carry...how big and bulky is that angle finder you have to carry around with you. I bet a slim A7R is less bulk and possibly weight than your angle finder.
You seem to pull out all sorts of "compromises" on other cameras...yet you don't feel your setup is one. I'm glad it works for you...but please don't call carrying around an angle finder just to manually focus "not a compromise". I've used my 5D2 with the rear LCD finder for manual focus off tripods and if the sun is too bright...you are hooped as far as trying to get critical focus. Been there, done that...and use a Hoodman lupe in such conditions. Yes...to me its a major compromise, but there was no other solution for the 5D2.
p.18 #13Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
alundeb wrote:
When I hear somenoe saying that 50 or even 36 MP is ridiculously high resolution, I think that digital is slowly applroaching the capabilities of LF film, and there is room for doubling of resolution a couple more times within the 35 mm format.
I agree that (obviously) we have not yet seen the full capabilities of digital cameras. On the other hand, there are image aspects that come from the much larger recording areas of the bigger formats that seem like they would be close to impossible to duplicate. So they won't go away, at least not for a long time.
That said, smaller formats can increasingly perform tasks that used to require larger formats. A good friend and highly-regarded "landscape" photographer made the move from LF film (initially developed/printed in the optical/chemical darkroom, then scanned and printed digitally) to MF digital (using Phase One 80MP back) and most recently has done a great deal of serious (and quite beautiful) work using the D800e and then the D810.
We are likely to see the continuing and steadily decreasing "cost per MP" of sensors, even as sensor capabilities increase. Parallel to this we see (and will continue to see) that the functional costs of more MP also decrease — camera data processing speed increases, storage costs decrease, computers and software continue to become faster and less expensive. As long as this happens, there will less and less liability to having high MP systems. When the increasing resolution, decreasing cost, and continuing performance intersect, the reasons to not incorporate higher MP sensors diminish.
It is logical and true to say that most photographers don't and won't need more MP. But we've been saying that for some time. 4MP is more than enough for typical casual use, yet cameras designed for such purposes typically have more. Most users of DSLRs and good mirrorless cameras are not doing anything that cannot be done beautifully in 16MP or fewer, yet that now constitutes the low end of the market. (I can produce excellent 18" x 24" prints from a 16MP 1.5x sensor camera.) So, logic aside, I don't see these trends slowing or stopping any time soon.
p.18 #14Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
alundeb wrote: timparkin wroteLet's take your 'everything improves' reference and analyse the amount of dynamic range increase over time.
According to DxO, the Canon 1DS had 11 stops of dynamic range the D810 has 14.8 stops of dynamic range. (and before that the D30 had about 10 stops - I have one and I'm about to check this)
This is an increase of 3.8 stops in 12 years.. That's 3 and a bit years per stop.
In that context, a 2 stop advantage is nearly 6.5 years of development advantage. Is that a minor difference?
Or I could put it another way, colour negative film with 16+ stops of dynamic range has been around since the 1950s and 18+ stops for the last two decades.
So according the the history of photography we were going up and up in dynamic range to the point that we could capture any conceivable scene and when digital came along there was a massive drop back to slide levels of dynamic range.
At some point we might catch up with where we were half a century ago..
TimI was first aware of your site some years ago when I stumbled upon this large camera resolution comparison, and you immediately gained my respect:
That comparison clearly shows how much more resolution can be had from large format film compared to even the best digital medium format. IMO there is still much more resolution to be had from 35 mm digital. I base that on my own tests done with lenses for 35 mm format on the Pentax Q small sensor interchangeable lens camera with pixel density corresponding to 360 MP on 35 mm.
When I hear somenoe saying that 50 or even 36 MP is ridiculously high resolution, I think that digital is slowly applroaching the capabilities of LF film, and there is room for doubling of resolution a couple more times within the 35 mm format....Show more →
Heh... I've made the same test of centre resolution using a Pentax Q behind modern lenses.. it's surprising just how much resolution you can render.
p.18 #15Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
chez wrote:
As far as extra weight to carry...how big and bulky is that angle finder you have to carry around with you. I bet a slim A7R is less bulk and possibly weight than your angle finder.
A7R + adapter(s) + batteries vs. angle finder.
We apparently live in alternate universes if you think adding an extra body of an A7R (16 ounces) + adapter(s) + extra batteries to your bag is a more svelte approach than an angle finder (4 ounces). And that comes with a significant penalty to your AF capability, which you continue to ignore, as well as an inability to view low-angle portrait orientation.
Horses for courses ... although we might be better off referencing unicorns for universes at this point.
Agree to disagree, but if you're arguing that an A7R + adapters + batteries ...
p.18 #16Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
alundeb wrote: timparkin wroteLet's take your 'everything improves' reference and analyse the amount of dynamic range increase over time.
According to DxO, the Canon 1DS had 11 stops of dynamic range the D810 has 14.8 stops of dynamic range. (and before that the D30 had about 10 stops - I have one and I'm about to check this)
This is an increase of 3.8 stops in 12 years.. That's 3 and a bit years per stop.
In that context, a 2 stop advantage is nearly 6.5 years of development advantage. Is that a minor difference?
Or I could put it another way, colour negative film with 16+ stops of dynamic range has been around since the 1950s and 18+ stops for the last two decades.
So according the the history of photography we were going up and up in dynamic range to the point that we could capture any conceivable scene and when digital came along there was a massive drop back to slide levels of dynamic range.
At some point we might catch up with where we were half a century ago..
TimI was first aware of your site some years ago when I stumbled upon this large camera resolution comparison, and you immediately gained my respect:
That comparison clearly shows how much more resolution can be had from large format film compared to even the best digital medium format. IMO there is still much more resolution to be had from 35 mm digital. I base that on my own tests done with lenses for 35 mm format on the Pentax Q small sensor interchangeable lens camera with pixel density corresponding to 360 MP on 35 mm.
When I hear somenoe saying that 50 or even 36 MP is ridiculously high resolution, I think that digital is slowly applroaching the capabilities of LF film, and there is room for doubling of resolution a couple more times within the 35 mm format....Show more →
In the center I'd agree. However on FF the list of lenses that can resolve edges reasonably well relative to the center shrinks to a small subset, eliminating most zooms. The disparity between the center and edge resolution starts to look ridiculous even @ 50MP FF and it'll only get worse as MP goes up. This isn't a problem for all types of shooting but it's a headache for landscapes.
p.18 #17Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
snapsy wrote:
In the center I'd agree. However on FF the list of lenses that can resolve edges reasonably well relative to the center shrinks to a small subset, eliminating most zooms. The disparity between the center and edge resolution starts to look ridiculous even @ 50MP FF and it'll only get worse as MP goes up. This isn't a problem for all types of shooting but it's a headache for landscapes.
Thus the day for a variable curved sensor to match the projected image (might be a while off yet though). I figure Sony will be the first one to achieve that in the year 2025.
p.18 #18Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
snapsy wrote: alundeb wrotetimparkin wroteLet's take your 'everything improves' reference and analyse the amount of dynamic range increase over time.
According to DxO, the Canon 1DS had 11 stops of dynamic range the D810 has 14.8 stops of dynamic range. (and before that the D30 had about 10 stops - I have one and I'm about to check this)
This is an increase of 3.8 stops in 12 years.. That's 3 and a bit years per stop.
In that context, a 2 stop advantage is nearly 6.5 years of development advantage. Is that a minor difference?
Or I could put it another way, colour negative film with 16+ stops of dynamic range has been around since the 1950s and 18+ stops for the last two decades.
So according the the history of photography we were going up and up in dynamic range to the point that we could capture any conceivable scene and when digital came along there was a massive drop back to slide levels of dynamic range.
At some point we might catch up with where we were half a century ago..
TimI was first aware of your site some years ago when I stumbled upon this large camera resolution comparison, and you immediately gained my respect:
That comparison clearly shows how much more resolution can be had from large format film compared to even the best digital medium format. IMO there is still much more resolution to be had from 35 mm digital. I base that on my own tests done with lenses for 35 mm format on the Pentax Q small sensor interchangeable lens camera with pixel density corresponding to 360 MP on 35 mm.
When I hear somenoe saying that 50 or even 36 MP is ridiculously high resolution, I think that digital is slowly applroaching the capabilities of LF film, and there is room for doubling of resolution a couple more times within the 35 mm format.In the center I'd agree. However on FF the list of lenses that can resolve edges reasonably well relative to the center shrinks to a small subset, eliminating most zooms. The disparity between the center and edge resolution starts to look ridiculous even @ 50MP FF and it'll only get worse as MP goes up. This isn't a problem for all types of shooting but it's a headache for landscapes.
That is true, still if the subset of lenses is very small, we can do with those lenses. It will probably be a more versatile selection than for larger formats anyway, especially for longer focal lengths.
p.18 #19Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
gdanmitchell wrote:
I think that there is more "high quality" photography today, just as there is more low quality photography — because, quite simply, there are more photographs being made and they are seen much more widely. That said, the quality level of the best work is not better than that of the best work in earlier periods. The best photographers today, regardless of photographic medium or gear used, produce work that is every bit as good as the best photographers of some decades ago. (And, as you certainly know, but not everyone in this forum knows, this goes all the way back to the best work from the 1800s.)
All of which sort of supports my basic point about the nature and significance of technological differences. I welcome them for what they are, but they aren't the point. ...Show more →
I agree, the level of the "best work" has not changed, and advancements in technology have an overall marginal impact on the quality level of that work. But, arguing that point misunderstands the issue.
Technology doesn't necessarily improve the inherent quality of the work, but it does improve the photographer's ability to create work of a particular quality level. Better technology provides gains in efficiency and improvements in workflow. It can makes things faster, provide desired results with more consistency and reliability, and make circumstances which were previously difficult easier to handle.
p.18 #20Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
RustyBug wrote: chez wroteAs far as extra weight to carry...how big and bulky is that angle finder you have to carry around with you. I bet a slim A7R is less bulk and possibly weight than your angle finder.A7R + adapter(s) + batteries vs. angle finder.
We apparently live in alternate universes if you think adding an extra body of an A7R (16 ounces) + adapter(s) + extra batteries to your bag is a more svelte approach than an angle finder (4 ounces). And that comes with a significant penalty to your AF capability, which you continue to ignore, as well as an inability to view low-angle portrait orientation.
Horses for courses ... although we might be better off referencing unicorns for universes at this point.
Agree to disagree, but if you're arguing that an A7R + adapters + batteries ...
No...I'm saying if you want to carry an extra gizmo ( angle finder ) just so you can focus manual lenses in a very limited fashion...well I'd rather carry the A7R which can focus manual lenses in many more situations than what an angle finder provides. I can really see myself shooting street scenes peering down an angle finder as I try to manually focus my lens
I know you have a very niche use for your manual focus ( low level portrait oriented )...but the majority of people that want to manually focus their lenses are not on their knees peering through an angle finder. I shoot much of my street photography using manual lenses and I see no way of using an angle finder to help with my focus.
Like you say...horses of courses. I have no problem carrying the A7R in my bag to use along side my 5D2. The weight and size are not noticeable...but the flexibility it adds is very noticeable.