p.17 #1Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
mttran wrote: timparkin wroteMonito wrotetimparkin wrote(emphasis added):
However, in case anyone thinks you can't take a photo with low dynamic range, here's a shot of Loch Tulla in Scotland taken with Fuji Velvia 50 which many people rate at having 5 stops of dynamic range. I think that qualifies as 'absolutely awful' dynamic range. So you see - dynamic range is useful, not essential.Right on.
And the difference between (say) 13 and 14.5 stops dynamic range is not the yawning chasm that some people relentlessly try to make it out to be.I would sort of agree and disagree.
I think the difference between the 5DS and A7R is about 2 stops in usable dynamic range and I'd say the usable range on the Canon is about 9 stops compared to just over 11 for the A7R
You can think about that as two stops less graduated filter you would need to get a clean shot (and from what I've seen a two stop grad is what is normally needed on the 5D3 to balance out shadows and sometimes a three stop).
So for many 'normal' shots it won't make a difference but for shots where you would have used a 2 stop grad in the past, you can now do without.
TimI would call 7 to 8 stops for most canon bodies to be safe in cleaner shadows & healthier tones curves if pushing is needed.
The tougher requirement you set for clean shadows, the closer Canon and Sony get in DR. At 7 stops DR, Canon has a SNR of 19 dB. For the Sony A7r, 19 dB corresponds to 8 stops DR. So only one stop advantage to Sony if you want to go that clean.
p.17 #2Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
artd wrote: alundeb wroteThe 5DS(r) is much better than the previous 5D models regarding dynamic range, much thanks to the elimination of fixed pattern noise. Throwing in the ability to do long exposures without LENR or black frame subtraction, which really boosts the number of exposures during the nice light in an evening. The 5DS R is the first Full Frame camera I have owned that is problem free in my use. Something I could not say about the A7r. Yes, the extra 1.5 stops of dynamic range is very welcome, but still my 5DS R is my main camera for manual focus tripod use now, and the A7r is my backup camera. The 5DS R files are that good.I'd be interested to hear what you're finding related to long exposures. I just read another photographer's blog where he said he was very disappointed in long exposures. http://www.photographyblackwhite.com/canon-5dsr-noise-issues/
A later posts mentions he returned the 5Dsr because of it.
I'd be interested to hear another perspective, sounds like you're pretty happy with the long exposure capability.
I will come back to you later today, with a couple long exposure examples.
p.17 #3Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
artd wrote: gdanmitchell wroteartd wroteConversely, if you think Canon deep shadow recovery qualifies as "excellent," then does that make Sony "more than excellent" That's pretty much in line with what I've consistently written all along.Since "more than excellent" is an odd superlative, I would propose that it would provide more clarity around the deep shadow recovery issue to label the Sony as simply "excellent" and the 5DSr "decent."
"Decent" to me would imply that deep shadow recovery can be adequate in many scenarios, but doesn't "excel" in the task.
All that said I'm still really curious about how the sensors compare in long exposure noise.
These words were suggested by someone else. As was pointed out in a post about film (!) in this Canon forum, one can set the dividing line anywhere between whatever subjective meaning one wants to apply to whatever descriptive words one likes to use.
I'm often fascinated by words, their meanings, and the ways they are used.
I'm also fascinated by photographs (surprise!) and by the observation that if differences between a thing and the next step in the evolution of the thing were as stupendous as some imagine them to be and thus had such a central impact on the nature of photographs (technically or aesthetically) that such a rate of change projected backwards across a series of such evolutionary step could easily confirm the fact that any photograph made more than perhaps a decade or so ago would be seriously deficient, or to use one the many terms seen here "inadequate" or even "pretty bad." ;-)
I'll be danged if photographs don't tell a contrary tale.
Dan,
who continues to check this thread from time to time and wonders just how far the spinning can go. ;-)
p.17 #4Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
gdanmitchell wrote:
I'm also fascinated by photographs (surprise!) and by the observation that if differences between a thing and the next step in the evolution of the thing were as stupendous as some imagine them to be and thus had such a central impact on the nature of photographs (technically or aesthetically) that such a rate of change projected backwards across a series of such evolutionary step could easily confirm the fact that any photograph made more than perhaps a decade or so ago would be seriously deficient, or to use one the many terms seen here "inadequate" or even "pretty bad." ;-) ...Show more →
No one has even come close to making that absurd argument Dan, and you should know better than to conflate words to make that implication.
We were strictly discussing your definition of Canon deep shadow recovery being "excellent." If someone refers to a camera having "pretty bad" or "barely adequate" or "decent" deep shadow recovery, that in no way results in an implication that photographs made a decade ago were "pretty bad" or deficient. The point is that if you are interested in deep shadow recovery as a technological tool, certain cameras perform better or worse in that area, and it's not unreasonable to say that the camera that does it best is excellent, the camera that doesn't do it as well but can still produce decent results is adequate, and the one that does worse than the adequate one could be considered "bad" at it.
Just because we say one camera is "excellent" in an area of particular technological advancement, that in no way creates an implication that older photos made without that advancement are somehow "bad."
Given that the root of excellent is the same Latin root as excel, the definition of excel relegates excellent to the concept of surpassing or going beyond.
In that regard, technically a 9.99 fps camera really can't claim to be excellent when a 10 fps camera exists, as it does not surpass the latter. If one wanting to qualify them as a group such that the top 10% of cameras are an excellent group compared to the other 90% of cameras, then one might structure it so.
However, in a head to head ... it does seem kinda awkward / redundant to say that one is "more than excellent" while the other is "excellent".
I get what Dan was trying to say ... I can hone one knife to 2,000 grit finish, and another to 4,000 grit finish. I'm pretty sure that for most steaks, you'll still be able to cut it with either of these knives better than if you tried using one honed to 1,000 grit.
Reminds me a bit about a chess match where one person came in "next to last" ... meanwhile, the other one came in "second place".
p.17 #6Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
artd wrote: gdanmitchell wroteI'm also fascinated by photographs (surprise!) and by the observation that if differences between a thing and the next step in the evolution of the thing were as stupendous as some imagine them to be and thus had such a central impact on the nature of photographs (technically or aesthetically) that such a rate of change projected backwards across a series of such evolutionary step could easily confirm the fact that any photograph made more than perhaps a decade or so ago would be seriously deficient, or to use one the many terms seen here "inadequate" or even "pretty bad." ;-)No one has even come close to making that absurd argument Dan, and you should know better than to conflate words to make that implication.
I didn't say they were making that argument. Actually I made the argumentative proposition that you quoted, and I did so to make a point.
I'm pointing out that "if differences between a thing and the next stop in the evolution of the thing were as stupendous as some imagine them to be" that the rate of change over a period of time would be much larger than what the evidence suggests.
There are only two possibilities that I can see. Either the magnitude of the change between the products under discussion in this thread is far more consequential than virtually all other changes in photography and, as such, is truly a singular sort of thing, or...
... a change that seems to be huge right at this moment will reveal itself to be far less huge in reality. (The earlier post suggesting the very high quality obtainable by the old technology of film is among factors that tend to argue for the latter rather than the former.)
Please note that neither of those possibilities negate the reality that change has occurred. They only speak to the question of how significant the changes are. Here we get to what I regard as the core issue.
I like RustyBug's clear description of a fundamental problem with how these terms are being used. If a car is excellent by virtue of some measurable thing, it does not become non-excellent when another car can do that one thing better by some increment. If car A has the most comfortable seats and then car B comes out with a bit better seats, that doesn't make the seats in car A no longer comfortable. If fast car A can go 230 MPH, when fast car B is released with a top speed of 240 MPH, car A is still very fast. And lots of people might think that the car that does 235 and has the second-most-comfortable seats is the most excellent car overall.
Also note that I referred also to the technical quality of photographs made in the past, not just the aesthetic quality that you mention in your post.
p.17 #7Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
RustyBug wrote:
Tim,
A bit OT ... but related ... why do you use Portra 400 instead of 160 (as it pertains to DR / noise / lifting shadows / etc.). Conventional thought would be that 160 would provide a superior result than 400.
Your thoughts
Portra 160 gives cleaner results throughout it's latitude but Portra 400 gives a bit more extension it seems (and when you're shooting 8x10 the extra speed is very useful)
p.17 #9Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
gdanmitchell wrote:
I'm pointing out that "if differences between a thing and the next stop in the evolution of the thing were as stupendous as some imagine them to be" that the rate of change over a period of time would be much larger than what the evidence suggests.
But we were talking about a specific capability and what qualifies as "excellent"...not the level of significance that capability has in relation to the broader evolution of photography.
Having dealt with lifting deep shadows not infrequently, my opinion is that Canon's cameras are not excellent in this one (very specific) area. That does not mean they are not good cameras overall, or that they cannot produce excellent photos (technically or aesthetically). It simply means they are not that great at doing this one particular thing.
Conversely, just because I find another camera excellent at this one specific thing, that doesn't mean the impact of that specific thing is enough to create a hugely consequential change in photography overall. It is, however, of significance to my photography in some very specific circumstances.
Also note that I referred also to the technical quality of photographs made in the past, not just the aesthetic quality that you mention in your post.
I did not specify anything about aesthetics in my post.
p.17 #12Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
timparkin wrote: RustyBug wroteTim,
A bit OT ... but related ... why do you use Portra 400 instead of 160 (as it pertains to DR / noise / lifting shadows / etc.). Conventional thought would be that 160 would provide a superior result than 400.
Your thoughts Portra 160 gives cleaner results throughout it's latitude but Portra 400 gives a bit more extension it seems (and when you're shooting 8x10 the extra speed is very useful)
Gotcha.
Although, you gotta admit that kinda sounds a bit like the Canon vs. Sony realm, where Canon folks talk about a need to shoot @ ISO 400 / 800 to keep a shutter speed up for various reasons. In certain regard, it would be like someone saying you SHOULD be shooting 160 because it is cleaner.
From what I can tell, you intelligently choose to shoot 400 because it works for you, even in full knowledge of the tradeoffs you might be making vs. 160. Many folks shoot Canon for a variety of reasons in full knowledge of the Sony difference ... but, they probably get tired of being "beat up" for making a decision to not shoot the Sony, much the same as you wouldn't appreciate me (or a barrage of people) incessantly telling you what you already know about the difference of 160 vs. 400.
That said, I do still appreciate the reveal of the diff and the test shots, etc (diff @ exposure still noted, etc.) and the effort you put to presenting (even in areas of disagreement). I find it interesting, in that it is a bit like the pot calling the kettle black for some ... but, I understand @ horses for courses.
It's your image, it's your call @ how to approach it.
p.17 #13Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Wow. Just spent some time reading Sony forum threads, which I do from time to time, as I want to understand various products in addition to those that I use myself.
There are, of course, lots of very positive reports — as there should be for a product as interesting and new as the A7rII. That said, since my last check about a week ago I'm seeing some new discussions among those who have been using and testing the new cameras, and (just like in Canon-land and Nikon-world) not everything is universally peachy in the Sony-universe.
Many will still have good reasons for looking at the excellent and compelling capabilities of the Sony product, but I encourage folks who are considering this to also spend some time over in that other forum in order to get a better sense of the evolving picture.
Meanwhile we can continue to dream of that imagined day when a camera is introduced that is sublimely perfect in all imaginable ways.
p.17 #14Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
alundeb wrote: mttran wrotetimparkin wroteMonito wrotetimparkin wrote(emphasis added):
However, in case anyone thinks you can't take a photo with low dynamic range, here's a shot of Loch Tulla in Scotland taken with Fuji Velvia 50 which many people rate at having 5 stops of dynamic range. I think that qualifies as 'absolutely awful' dynamic range. So you see - dynamic range is useful, not essential.Right on.
And the difference between (say) 13 and 14.5 stops dynamic range is not the yawning chasm that some people relentlessly try to make it out to be.I would sort of agree and disagree.
I think the difference between the 5DS and A7R is about 2 stops in usable dynamic range and I'd say the usable range on the Canon is about 9 stops compared to just over 11 for the A7R
You can think about that as two stops less graduated filter you would need to get a clean shot (and from what I've seen a two stop grad is what is normally needed on the 5D3 to balance out shadows and sometimes a three stop).
So for many 'normal' shots it won't make a difference but for shots where you would have used a 2 stop grad in the past, you can now do without.
TimI would call 7 to 8 stops for most canon bodies to be safe in cleaner shadows & healthier tones curves if pushing is needed.The tougher requirement you set for clean shadows, the closer Canon and Sony get in DR. At 7 stops DR, Canon has a SNR of 19 dB. For the Sony A7r, 19 dB corresponds to 8 stops DR. So only one stop advantage to Sony if you want to go that clean.
Anders, my requirement is little bit looser on sony side since their i/o is less DR dependent than canon; so far I can live on 10-11 stops but I have not do any serious shots these days, yet.
p.17 #16Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
gdanmitchell wrote:
Wow. Just spent some time reading Sony forum threads, which I do from time to time, as I want to understand various products in addition to those that I use myself.
There are, of course, lots of very positive reports — as there should be for a product as interesting and new as the A7rII. That said, since my last check about a week ago I'm seeing some new discussions among those who have been using and testing the new cameras, and (just like in Canon-land and Nikon-world) not everything is universally peachy in the Sony-universe.
Many will still have good reasons for looking at the excellent and compelling capabilities of the Sony product, but I encourage folks who are considering this to also spend some time over in that other forum in order to get a better sense of the evolving picture.
Meanwhile we can continue to dream of that imagined day when a camera is introduced that is sublimely perfect in all imaginable ways.
Always take this approach, which is one reason I didn't go with the original A7R. A camera is more than a sensor and Sony does not produce perfect products, nor does anyone else. Everything is a compromise and you have to choose which ones are most important.
p.17 #17Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Pixel Perfect wrote: gdanmitchell wroteWow. Just spent some time reading Sony forum threads, which I do from time to time, as I want to understand various products in addition to those that I use myself.
There are, of course, lots of very positive reports — as there should be for a product as interesting and new as the A7rII. That said, since my last check about a week ago I'm seeing some new discussions among those who have been using and testing the new cameras, and (just like in Canon-land and Nikon-world) not everything is universally peachy in the Sony-universe.
Many will still have good reasons for looking at the excellent and compelling capabilities of the Sony product, but I encourage folks who are considering this to also spend some time over in that other forum in order to get a better sense of the evolving picture.
Meanwhile we can continue to dream of that imagined day when a camera is introduced that is sublimely perfect in all imaginable ways.
YMMV,
DanAlways take this approach, which is one reason I didn't go with the original A7R. A camera is more than a sensor and Sony does not produce perfect products, nor does anyone else. Everything is a compromise and you have to choose which ones are most important.
I did not take this approach with the 5DS R, because it seemed that it was a long time development with focus on refinement of existing technology and high level of quality control before the product was released. Sony OTOH innovates fast, and releases products fast with many new technologies that are little tested. Both of these philospohies have advantages and disadvantages.
p.17 #18Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
mttran wrote:
Anders, my requirement is little bit looser on sony side since their i/o is less DR dependent than canon; so far I can live on 10-11 stops but I have not do any serious shots these days, yet.
Hello Michael,
Are you saying that you tolerate more noise in the shadows from Sony in your images because Sony sensors have less shadow noise? This does not make sense to me.
p.17 #19Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
gdanmitchell wrote: artd wrotegdanmitchell wroteI'm also fascinated by photographs (surprise!) and by the observation that if differences between a thing and the next step in the evolution of the thing were as stupendous as some imagine them to be and thus had such a central impact on the nature of photographs (technically or aesthetically) that such a rate of change projected backwards across a series of such evolutionary step could easily confirm the fact that any photograph made more than perhaps a decade or so ago would be seriously deficient, or to use one the many terms seen here "inadequate" or even "pretty bad." ;-)No one has even come close to making that absurd argument Dan, and you should know better than to conflate words to make that implication.I didn't say they were making that argument. Actually I made the argumentative proposition that you quoted, and I did so to make a point.
I'm pointing out that "if differences between a thing and the next stop in the evolution of the thing were as stupendous as some imagine them to be" that the rate of change over a period of time would be much larger than what the evidence suggests.
There are only two possibilities that I can see. Either the magnitude of the change between the products under discussion in this thread is far more consequential than virtually all other changes in photography and, as such, is truly a singular sort of thing, or...
... a change that seems to be huge right at this moment will reveal itself to be far less huge in reality. (The earlier post suggesting the very high quality obtainable by the old technology of film is among factors that tend to argue for the latter rather than the former.)
Please note that neither of those possibilities negate the reality that change has occurred. They only speak to the question of how significant the changes are. Here we get to what I regard as the core issue.
I like RustyBug's clear description of a fundamental problem with how these terms are being used. If a car is excellent by virtue of some measurable thing, it does not become non-excellent when another car can do that one thing better by some increment. If car A has the most comfortable seats and then car B comes out with a bit better seats, that doesn't make the seats in car A no longer comfortable. If fast car A can go 230 MPH, when fast car B is released with a top speed of 240 MPH, car A is still very fast. And lots of people might think that the car that does 235 and has the second-most-comfortable seats is the most excellent car overall.
Also note that I referred also to the technical quality of photographs made in the past, not just the aesthetic quality that you mention in your post.
Hmm... you use many words but not a lot of semantic content comes through. I think we can summarise by saying
"language is relative"
Let's take your 'everything improves' reference and analyse the amount of dynamic range increase over time.
According to DxO, the Canon 1DS had 11 stops of dynamic range the D810 has 14.8 stops of dynamic range. (and before that the D30 had about 10 stops - I have one and I'm about to check this)
This is an increase of 3.8 stops in 12 years.. That's 3 and a bit years per stop.
In that context, a 2 stop advantage is nearly 6.5 years of development advantage. Is that a minor difference?
Or I could put it another way, colour negative film with 16+ stops of dynamic range has been around since the 1950s and 18+ stops for the last two decades.
So according the the history of photography we were going up and up in dynamic range to the point that we could capture any conceivable scene and when digital came along there was a massive drop back to slide levels of dynamic range.
At some point we might catch up with where we were half a century ago..
Tim
p.s. When I was on the judging panel for the Wildlife Photographer of the Year last year we were looking through all of the books from the competition for the last 50 years and we asked ourselves the question about whether we could see the change from film to digital and what it looked like. Well it looked like a drop in quality at about the year 2002/2003 and then the quality picked back up again in about 2006/2007.
More interestingly, the quality of images overall didn't really change over the period - we should find this surprising considering the vast number of photographers that digital has enabled.
p.17 #20Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
RustyBug wrote: timparkin wroteRustyBug wroteTim,
A bit OT ... but related ... why do you use Portra 400 instead of 160 (as it pertains to DR / noise / lifting shadows / etc.). Conventional thought would be that 160 would provide a superior result than 400.
Your thoughts Portra 160 gives cleaner results throughout it's latitude but Portra 400 gives a bit more extension it seems (and when you're shooting 8x10 the extra speed is very useful)Gotcha.
Although, you gotta admit that kinda sounds a bit like the Canon vs. Sony realm, where Canon folks talk about a need to shoot @ ISO 400 / 800 to keep a shutter speed up for various reasons. In certain regard, it would be like someone saying you SHOULD be shooting 160 because it is cleaner.
And that is exactly what I do - if I can get away with 160 I will tend to do so and fall back to 400 when I need to.
RustyBug wrote:
From what I can tell, you intelligently choose to shoot 400 because it works for you, even in full knowledge of the tradeoffs you might be making vs. 160. Many folks shoot Canon for a variety of reasons in full knowledge of the Sony difference ... but, they probably get tired of being "beat up" for making a decision to not shoot the Sony, much the same as you wouldn't appreciate me (or a barrage of people) incessantly telling you what you already know about the difference of 160 vs. 400.
Agreed - and I think that it makes sense for the dedicated photographer who can afford to to have both cameras. I now have a 5DSr, A7Rii and A7R (my wife and I share the A7R and A7RII depending on what we need. She likes macro work and so hand holding with stabilisation is great - if I'm on the tripod the A7R is fine etc). 5DSr comes out for commission work where auto focus is useful, lens testing, etc, etc.
RustyBug wrote:
That said, I do still appreciate the reveal of the diff and the test shots, etc (diff @ exposure still noted, etc.) and the effort you put to presenting (even in areas of disagreement).