fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr

  
 
artd
Offline
Details
p.16 #1Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
alundeb wrote:
The 5DS(r) is much better than the previous 5D models regarding dynamic range, much thanks to the elimination of fixed pattern noise. Throwing in the ability to do long exposures without LENR or black frame subtraction, which really boosts the number of exposures during the nice light in an evening. The 5DS R is the first Full Frame camera I have owned that is problem free in my use. Something I could not say about the A7r. Yes, the extra 1.5 stops of dynamic range is very welcome, but still my 5DS R is my main camera for manual focus
...Show more →

I'd be interested to hear what you're finding related to long exposures. I just read another photographer's blog where he said he was very disappointed in long exposures.
http://www.photographyblackwhite.com/canon-5dsr-noise-issues/

A later posts mentions he returned the 5Dsr because of it.

I'd be interested to hear another perspective, sounds like you're pretty happy with the long exposure capability.
Aug 10, 2015 at 03:15 PM
snapsy
Offline
Details
p.16 #2Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
artd wrote:
alundeb wroteThe 5DS(r) is much better than the previous 5D models regarding dynamic range, much thanks to the elimination of fixed pattern noise. Throwing in the ability to do long exposures without LENR or black frame subtraction, which really boosts the number of exposures during the nice light in an evening. The 5DS R is the first Full Frame camera I have owned that is problem free in my use. Something I could not say about the A7r. Yes, the extra 1.5 stops of dynamic range is very welcome, but still my 5DS R is my main camera for manual focus tripod use now, and the A7r is my backup camera. The 5DS R files are that good.
I'd be interested to hear what you're finding related to long exposures. I just read another photographer's blog where he said he was very disappointed in long exposures.
http://www.photographyblackwhite.com/canon-5dsr-noise-issues/

A later posts mentions he returned the 5Dsr because of it.

I'd be interested to hear another perspective, sounds like you're pretty happy with the long exposure capability.


There's a thread on the Sony forum comparing long-exposure noise of the A7rII to other cameras including the 5DSR (link). I supplied some 5DSR samples here and here.
Aug 10, 2015 at 03:31 PM
mttran
Offline
Details
p.16 #3Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
artd wrote:
alundeb wroteThe 5DS(r) is much better than the previous 5D models regarding dynamic range, much thanks to the elimination of fixed pattern noise. Throwing in the ability to do long exposures without LENR or black frame subtraction, which really boosts the number of exposures during the nice light in an evening. The 5DS R is the first Full Frame camera I have owned that is problem free in my use. Something I could not say about the A7r. Yes, the extra 1.5 stops of dynamic range is very welcome, but still my 5DS R is my main camera for manual focus tripod use now, and the A7r is my backup camera. The 5DS R files are that good.
I'd be interested to hear what you're finding related to long exposures. I just read another photographer's blog where he said he was very disappointed in long exposures.
http://www.photographyblackwhite.com/canon-5dsr-noise-issues/

A later posts mentions he returned the 5Dsr because of it.


I wouldn't be surprised from his finding by looking at his second image. Is noise & tones characteristic from most canon bodies depending on the DR of the scene. Yes, i see this (noise and shifted tones curves) dependent behavior in all generation sensor from canon. So canon usable DR is not the same as sony usable DR like some said.

Monito wrote:
Monito wroteNonsense. It is naive and biased to think that the 5DS offers only extra resolution.
chez wroteElaborate please...compared to the 5D3.
If you would like to believe that the 5DS only offers resolution above the 5D3, you are free to do so, but when you express that view, it makes you look much more naive than you are and much more biased than you need to be.


Are you sure whatever you are saying: http://tinyurl.com/o2cnqz8

And here is the real world sample for your pleasure: http://www.dpreview.com/previews/canon-eos-5ds-sr/samples/5DS-TulipSunrise-FullSize.jpg

is this "makes you more naive than you are and much more biased than you need to be"

Edited on Aug 10, 2015 at 08:55 PM · View previous versions
Aug 10, 2015 at 04:16 PM
artd
Offline
Details
p.16 #4Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
snapsy wrote:
artd wrote
alundeb wroteThe 5DS(r) is much better than the previous 5D models regarding dynamic range, much thanks to the elimination of fixed pattern noise. Throwing in the ability to do long exposures without LENR or black frame subtraction, which really boosts the number of exposures during the nice light in an evening. The 5DS R is the first Full Frame camera I have owned that is problem free in my use. Something I could not say about the A7r. Yes, the extra 1.5 stops of dynamic range is very welcome, but still my 5DS R is my main camera for manual focus tripod use now, and the A7r is my backup camera. The 5DS R files are that good.
I'd be interested to hear what you're finding related to long exposures. I just read another photographer's blog where he said he was very disappointed in long exposures.
http://www.photographyblackwhite.com/canon-5dsr-noise-issues/

A later posts mentions he returned the 5Dsr because of it.

I'd be interested to hear another perspective, sounds like you're pretty happy with the long exposure capability.
There's a thread on the Sony forum comparing long-exposure noise of the A7rII to other cameras including the 5DSR (link). I supplied some 5DSR samples here and here.


Thanks Snapsy. Though looks like a comparison to the A7s, not A7rII?

Your 8-minute exposures of the 5DSr don't look to bad to me. At least nothing like the photos the author posted at the other link. Wondering what variables are at play that could have made such an impact. (Higher ambient temperature? ISO settings? Noise more apparent in B&W conversion?)


Aug 10, 2015 at 05:12 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.16 #5Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Snapsy says this action works well removing stuck and hot pixels from the Canon 5DS/R as well.
Try it out guys:
https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1380165/2#13144278
Aug 10, 2015 at 05:20 PM
snapsy
Offline
Details
p.16 #6Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
artd wrote:
snapsy wrote
artd wrote
alundeb wroteThe 5DS(r) is much better than the previous 5D models regarding dynamic range, much thanks to the elimination of fixed pattern noise. Throwing in the ability to do long exposures without LENR or black frame subtraction, which really boosts the number of exposures during the nice light in an evening. The 5DS R is the first Full Frame camera I have owned that is problem free in my use. Something I could not say about the A7r. Yes, the extra 1.5 stops of dynamic range is very welcome, but still my 5DS R is my main camera for manual focus tripod use now, and the A7r is my backup camera. The 5DS R files are that good.
I'd be interested to hear what you're finding related to long exposures. I just read another photographer's blog where he said he was very disappointed in long exposures.
http://www.photographyblackwhite.com/canon-5dsr-noise-issues/

A later posts mentions he returned the 5Dsr because of it.

I'd be interested to hear another perspective, sounds like you're pretty happy with the long exposure capability.
There's a thread on the Sony forum comparing long-exposure noise of the A7rII to other cameras including the 5DSR (link). I supplied some 5DSR samples here and here.
Thanks Snapsy. Though looks like a comparison to the A7s, not A7rII?

Your 8-minute exposures of the 5DSr don't look to bad to me. At least nothing like the photos the author posted at the other link. Wondering what variables are at play that could have made such an impact. (Higher ambient temperature? ISO settings? Noise more apparent in B&W conversion?)


There are some 30-second A7Rii exposures in that thread, which btw are noticeably worse than the 5DSR's 8 minute exposures.
Aug 10, 2015 at 07:30 PM
Sneakyracer
Offline
Details
p.16 #7Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
snapsy wrote:
artd wrote
snapsy wrote
artd wrote
alundeb wroteThe 5DS(r) is much better than the previous 5D models regarding dynamic range, much thanks to the elimination of fixed pattern noise. Throwing in the ability to do long exposures without LENR or black frame subtraction, which really boosts the number of exposures during the nice light in an evening. The 5DS R is the first Full Frame camera I have owned that is problem free in my use. Something I could not say about the A7r. Yes, the extra 1.5 stops of dynamic range is very welcome, but still my 5DS R is my main camera for manual focus tripod use now, and the A7r is my backup camera. The 5DS R files are that good.
I'd be interested to hear what you're finding related to long exposures. I just read another photographer's blog where he said he was very disappointed in long exposures.
http://www.photographyblackwhite.com/canon-5dsr-noise-issues/

A later posts mentions he returned the 5Dsr because of it.

I'd be interested to hear another perspective, sounds like you're pretty happy with the long exposure capability.
There's a thread on the Sony forum comparing long-exposure noise of the A7rII to other cameras including the 5DSR (link). I supplied some 5DSR samples here and here.
Thanks Snapsy. Though looks like a comparison to the A7s, not A7rII?

Your 8-minute exposures of the 5DSr don't look to bad to me. At least nothing like the photos the author posted at the other link. Wondering what variables are at play that could have made such an impact. (Higher ambient temperature? ISO settings? Noise more apparent in B&W conversion?)
There are some 30-second A7Rii exposures in that thread, which btw are noticeably worse than the 5DSR's 8 minute exposures.


THIS thinks the 5DSR is useless for very long exposures.

What is the verdict on that? Is it a real issue with the 5DSR or is the 5DSR as good (or bad) as the D800E/D810/A7R in those situations. And how about the A7RII?

I mean, in THIS thread there is one 8 min dark frame (at 100 iso) exposure from the 5DSR and the 6D posted. They look quite similar at pixel level, of course the 5DSR has many more pixels! The 6D has been happily used for long exposures by many photographers for a long while now. So what is the real deal with this? VERY conflicting opinions on the matter.
Aug 10, 2015 at 08:01 PM
snapsy
Offline
Details
p.16 #8Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Sneakyracer wrote:
snapsy wrote
artd wrote
snapsy wrote
artd wrote
alundeb wroteThe 5DS(r) is much better than the previous 5D models regarding dynamic range, much thanks to the elimination of fixed pattern noise. Throwing in the ability to do long exposures without LENR or black frame subtraction, which really boosts the number of exposures during the nice light in an evening. The 5DS R is the first Full Frame camera I have owned that is problem free in my use. Something I could not say about the A7r. Yes, the extra 1.5 stops of dynamic range is very welcome, but still my 5DS R is my main camera for manual focus tripod use now, and the A7r is my backup camera. The 5DS R files are that good.
I'd be interested to hear what you're finding related to long exposures. I just read another photographer's blog where he said he was very disappointed in long exposures.
http://www.photographyblackwhite.com/canon-5dsr-noise-issues/

A later posts mentions he returned the 5Dsr because of it.

I'd be interested to hear another perspective, sounds like you're pretty happy with the long exposure capability.
There's a thread on the Sony forum comparing long-exposure noise of the A7rII to other cameras including the 5DSR (link). I supplied some 5DSR samples here and here.
Thanks Snapsy. Though looks like a comparison to the A7s, not A7rII?

Your 8-minute exposures of the 5DSr don't look to bad to me. At least nothing like the photos the author posted at the other link. Wondering what variables are at play that could have made such an impact. (Higher ambient temperature? ISO settings? Noise more apparent in B&W conversion?)
There are some 30-second A7Rii exposures in that thread, which btw are noticeably worse than the 5DSR's 8 minute exposures.
THIS thinks the 5DSR is useless for very long exposures.

What is the verdict on that? Is it a real issue with the 5DSR or is the 5DSR as good (or bad) as the D800E/D810/A7R in those situations. And how about the A7RII?

I mean, in THIS thread there is one 8 min dark frame (at 100 iso) exposure from the 5DSR and the 6D posted. They look quite similar at pixel level, of course the 5DSR has many more pixels! The 6D has been happily used for long exposures by many photographers for a long while now. So what is
...Show more →

I compared a 30-second exposure of the 5DSR to my 6D and they seemed similar. I can't speak to what author of that article found - for reference my exposures were taken at about 65F ambient. I'm the one who posted to that dpreview therad (I'm "horshack" there).
Aug 10, 2015 at 08:24 PM
artd
Offline
Details
p.16 #9Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
snapsy wrote:
artd wrote
snapsy wrote
artd wrote
alundeb wroteThe 5DS(r) is much better than the previous 5D models regarding dynamic range, much thanks to the elimination of fixed pattern noise. Throwing in the ability to do long exposures without LENR or black frame subtraction, which really boosts the number of exposures during the nice light in an evening. The 5DS R is the first Full Frame camera I have owned that is problem free in my use. Something I could not say about the A7r. Yes, the extra 1.5 stops of dynamic range is very welcome, but still my 5DS R is my main camera for manual focus tripod use now, and the A7r is my backup camera. The 5DS R files are that good.
I'd be interested to hear what you're finding related to long exposures. I just read another photographer's blog where he said he was very disappointed in long exposures.
http://www.photographyblackwhite.com/canon-5dsr-noise-issues/

A later posts mentions he returned the 5Dsr because of it.

I'd be interested to hear another perspective, sounds like you're pretty happy with the long exposure capability.
There's a thread on the Sony forum comparing long-exposure noise of the A7rII to other cameras including the 5DSR (link). I supplied some 5DSR samples here and here.
Thanks Snapsy. Though looks like a comparison to the A7s, not A7rII?

Your 8-minute exposures of the 5DSr don't look to bad to me. At least nothing like the photos the author posted at the other link. Wondering what variables are at play that could have made such an impact. (Higher ambient temperature? ISO settings? Noise more apparent in B&W conversion?)
There are some 30-second A7Rii exposures in that thread, which btw are noticeably worse than the 5DSR's 8 minute exposures.


Hmm. Perhaps, though hard for me to tell since they're not direct comparisons. Since I shoot at twilight a lot, this issue really has me interested. If 5Dsr really does have cleaner longer exposures, well hopefully someone can demonstrate with some side-by-side comparisons at some point....
Aug 10, 2015 at 10:05 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.16 #10Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
artd wrote:
Conversely, if you think Canon deep shadow recovery qualifies as "excellent," then does that make Sony "more than excellent"


That's pretty much in line with what I've consistently written all along.
Aug 10, 2015 at 11:52 PM
timparkin
Offline
Details
p.16 #11Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
gdanmitchell wrote:
artd wroteConversely, if you think Canon deep shadow recovery qualifies as "excellent," then does that make Sony "more than excellent"
That's pretty much in line with what I've consistently written all along.


I use 5x4 colour negative film and think the the Canon qualifies as pretty bad and the Sony qualifies as almost acceptable.

Here's a sample of portra 400 dynamic range

http://static.timparkin.co.uk/static/tmp/dynamic-range-2.jpg

Once digital cameras reach this level then we can call them 'excellent' otherwise we run out of superlatives for Portra :-)

However, in case anyone thinks you can't take a photo with low dynamic range, here's a shot of Loch Tulla in Scotland taken with Fuji Velvia 50 which many people rate at having 5 stops of dynamic range. I think that qualifies as 'absolutely awful' dynamic range. So you see - dynamic range is useful, not essential.

https://www.onlandscape.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2013/01/10x8-tulla-e6-flikr-small.jpg

Tim
Aug 11, 2015 at 03:02 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.16 #12Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
timparkin wrote:
I use 5x4 colour negative film and think the the Canon qualifies as pretty bad and the Sony qualifies as almost acceptable.

Tim


I agree that "excellent" is a bit too high superlative for the Canon dynamic range. Adjectives are both relative and subjective.

My personal view is that the low ISO dynamic range of the Canon 5DII is pretty bad, the 5DS is barely acceptable, and the A7r is very good.
Aug 11, 2015 at 03:21 AM
Monito
Offline
Details
p.16 #13Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
mttran, you didn't answer chez's question. You answered one of the only two questions that you always answer.
Aug 11, 2015 at 03:39 AM
Monito
Offline
Details
p.16 #14Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
timparkin wrote (emphasis added):
However, in case anyone thinks you can't take a photo with low dynamic range, here's a shot of Loch Tulla in Scotland taken with Fuji Velvia 50 which many people rate at having 5 stops of dynamic range. I think that qualifies as 'absolutely awful' dynamic range. So you see - dynamic range is useful, not essential.


Right on.

And the difference between (say) 13 and 14.5 stops dynamic range is not the yawning chasm that some people relentlessly try to make it out to be.
Aug 11, 2015 at 03:41 AM
timparkin
Offline
Details
p.16 #15Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Monito wrote:
timparkin wrote(emphasis added):
However, in case anyone thinks you can't take a photo with low dynamic range, here's a shot of Loch Tulla in Scotland taken with Fuji Velvia 50 which many people rate at having 5 stops of dynamic range. I think that qualifies as 'absolutely awful' dynamic range. So you see - dynamic range is useful, not essential.
Right on.

And the difference between (say) 13 and 14.5 stops dynamic range is not the yawning chasm that some people relentlessly try to make it out to be.


I would sort of agree and disagree.

I think the difference between the 5DS and A7R is about 2 stops in usable dynamic range and I'd say the usable range on the Canon is about 9 stops compared to just over 11 for the A7R

You can think about that as two stops less graduated filter you would need to get a clean shot (and from what I've seen a two stop grad is what is normally needed on the 5D3 to balance out shadows and sometimes a three stop).

So for many 'normal' shots it won't make a difference but for shots where you would have used a 2 stop grad in the past, you can now do without.

Tim




Aug 11, 2015 at 05:53 AM
chez
Offline
Details
p.16 #16Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
timparkin wrote:
Monito wrote
timparkin wrote(emphasis added):
However, in case anyone thinks you can't take a photo with low dynamic range, here's a shot of Loch Tulla in Scotland taken with Fuji Velvia 50 which many people rate at having 5 stops of dynamic range. I think that qualifies as 'absolutely awful' dynamic range. So you see - dynamic range is useful, not essential.
Right on.

And the difference between (say) 13 and 14.5 stops dynamic range is not the yawning chasm that some people relentlessly try to make it out to be.
I would sort of agree and disagree.

I think the difference between the 5DS and A7R is about 2 stops in usable dynamic range and I'd say the usable range on the Canon is about 9 stops compared to just over 11 for the A7R

You can think about that as two stops less graduated filter you would need to get a clean shot (and from what I've seen a two stop grad is what is normally needed on the 5D3 to balance out shadows and sometimes a three stop).

So for many 'normal' shots it won't make a difference but
...Show more →

Tim, that's exactly my experience in real world shooting. With my 5d2, I quite often needed to use my GND filter but with the A7R, I use it much less. I shoot a lot of sunrise and sunset photos which usually have a stretched DR.
Aug 11, 2015 at 06:07 AM
mttran
Offline
Details
p.16 #17Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Monito wrote:
mttran, you didn't answer chez's question. You answered one of the only two questions that you always answer.


Aug 11, 2015 at 08:17 AM
mttran
Offline
Details
p.16 #18Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
timparkin wrote:
Monito wrote
timparkin wrote(emphasis added):
However, in case anyone thinks you can't take a photo with low dynamic range, here's a shot of Loch Tulla in Scotland taken with Fuji Velvia 50 which many people rate at having 5 stops of dynamic range. I think that qualifies as 'absolutely awful' dynamic range. So you see - dynamic range is useful, not essential.
Right on.

And the difference between (say) 13 and 14.5 stops dynamic range is not the yawning chasm that some people relentlessly try to make it out to be.
I would sort of agree and disagree.

I think the difference between the 5DS and A7R is about 2 stops in usable dynamic range and I'd say the usable range on the Canon is about 9 stops compared to just over 11 for the A7R

You can think about that as two stops less graduated filter you would need to get a clean shot (and from what I've seen a two stop grad is what is normally needed on the 5D3 to balance out shadows and sometimes a three stop).

So for many 'normal' shots it won't make a difference but
...Show more →

I would call 7 to 8 stops for most canon bodies to be safe in cleaner shadows & healthier tones curves if pushing is needed.
Aug 11, 2015 at 09:23 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.16 #19Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Tim,

A bit OT ... but related ... why do you use Portra 400 instead of 160 (as it pertains to DR / noise / lifting shadows / etc.). Conventional thought would be that 160 would provide a superior result than 400.

Your thoughts
Aug 11, 2015 at 11:45 AM
artd
Offline
Details
p.16 #20Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
gdanmitchell wrote:
artd wroteConversely, if you think Canon deep shadow recovery qualifies as "excellent," then does that make Sony "more than excellent"
That's pretty much in line with what I've consistently written all along.


Since "more than excellent" is an odd superlative, I would propose that it would provide more clarity around the deep shadow recovery issue to label the Sony as simply "excellent" and the 5DSr "decent."

"Decent" to me would imply that deep shadow recovery can be adequate in many scenarios, but doesn't "excel" in the task.

All that said I'm still really curious about how the sensors compare in long exposure noise.
Aug 11, 2015 at 11:55 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister