fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?

  
 
uintaangler
Offline
Details
p.6 #1What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
trenchmonkey wrote:
Earlier quotePeople tend to be over-zealous with a piece of equipment because they own it and they want to see black or white.
OR they know how to use it and grow impatient with those that
don't know WTF to do with it. Gear needs to make me money
simple as that. If it can keep up, it stays. 50+ yrs under my belt
I have a pretty damn good handle on my equipment requirements.
FWIW, I just had an image hit $5000 in sales. One shot. Sony has
nothing to offer the 'monkey. Just sayin'


The Monkey abides
Jun 17, 2015 at 10:32 PM
technic
Offline
Details
p.6 #2What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
jimmy462 wrote:
"What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?"

I've been sorely tempted to invest in a D810 as a replacement for my aging 5D2, but here in 2015 I can't see purchasing anything that shoots HD video instead of 4K. The new Sony sensor in the a7R II, I would expect, should come as great news to the Nikon community, I should think it likely that this technology will find its way into their line-up. That Nikon is practically the de facto DSLR arm for Sony sensors I am looking forward to see how Nikon makes use of
...Show more →

I think the main impact for Nikonians is how it influences people from other platforms, primarily Canon DSLR, to switch gear.

I'm also looking for a replacement of my Canon DSLR and want FF sensor with much better DR, tilt screen and relatively small/light; high quality video would be a bonus. Canon for sure is not going to offer that within the next year or so. The D750 has everything I really need but the downside is I have to invest in new lenses (although a few Nikon lenses like the 4/300PF are an extra incentive to switch).

A7RII looks like an interesting alternative to me because I might be able to use it for all my photography; in that sense for me it competes with D750. If AF with Canon lenses is both fast AND accurate enough I could keep my Canon lenses and maybe buy a few Sony/Zeiss ones for most responsive AF. Although A7RII is more expensive than D750 it would save me money with lenses (plus it almost replaces a Nikon 1.4x converter). This camera packs a lot of technology and the downside is certain compromises compared to both Canon and Nikon DSLRs - but I think I can live with these compromises because all the possibilities that it offers. Waiting for user reports though to see if it works well in practice; with so much new technology there might be 'issues'.

If I already had a current Nikon DSLR with lenses I don't think the A7RII would be as interesting, mostly a promise of technology that may be coming to Nikon DSLRs in future (better sensor, better video).
Jun 18, 2015 at 03:19 AM
brunobarolo
Offline
Details
p.6 #3What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
A bit off topic, SonyAlphaRumors reports an adapter is coming that will provide full compatibility between Sony E mount cameras and Nikon lenses, including AF

http://www.sonyalpharumors.com/new-nikon-f-to-sony-e-mount-electronic-adapter-coming-soon/

This would surely make the A7rII an even more interesting proposition for those who own Nikon lenses.
Jun 18, 2015 at 06:31 AM
technic
Offline
Details
p.6 #4What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
brunobarolo wrote:
A bit off topic, SonyAlphaRumors reports an adapter is coming that will provide full compatibility between Sony E mount cameras and Nikon lenses, including AF

http://www.sonyalpharumors.com/new-nikon-f-to-sony-e-mount-electronic-adapter-coming-soon/

This would surely make the A7rII an even more interesting proposition for those who own Nikon lenses.


And on the other side, for a Canon user like me who is considering jumping to either Nikon D750 or Sony A7RII this is interesting as well. After investing in (lenses for) a closed system that I no longer like, I have doubts about moving to Nikon and investing in another closed system.

If I can buy a Nikon now with just a few nice Nikon lenses that I could use in future on e.g. a Sony camera, that makes the investment in Nikon glass much more attractive. I still like Canon lenses best, but Nikon also has a nice lens line with some really interesting ones while Sony has relatively little to offer for me, for now.

Just like for current owners of Canon lenses, the big question is how fast and accurate AF on the A7RII will be with these adapted lenses. AF with Canon lenses seems to be pretty fast but accuracy might suffer because it uses only (on-sensor) PDAF and not CDAF as with native Sony lenses. Probably the same applies for Nikon lenses on A7RII?
Jun 18, 2015 at 06:45 AM
trenchmonkey
Offline
Details
p.6 #5What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
Lauchlan Toal wrote: I love your posts, you're like the grizzled no-nonsense grandfather of Nikon photographers.

Was the shot micro stock or traditional licensing, if you don't mind my asking?


I like that, Lauchian...thanks! Traditional
Jun 18, 2015 at 06:56 AM
kaplah
Offline
Details
p.6 #6What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
brunobarolo wrote:
A bit off topic, SonyAlphaRumors reports an adapter is coming that will provide full compatibility between Sony E mount cameras and Nikon lenses, including AF

http://www.sonyalpharumors.com/new-nikon-f-to-sony-e-mount-electronic-adapter-coming-soon/

This would surely make the A7rII an even more interesting proposition for those who own Nikon lenses.


"...adapter made by an unnamed chinese company." That doesn't inspire confidence. Now, if Sony were making it, maybe it would work well, and for a long time (as new Nikon lenses come out).
Jun 18, 2015 at 07:38 AM
davewolfs
Offline
Details
p.6 #7What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
The Nikon adapter is kinda huge.
Jun 18, 2015 at 07:45 AM
JoshI
Offline
Details
p.6 #8What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
EB-1 wrote:
Does Thom Hogan really have any inside knowledge? Sometimes his articles are filled with self-indulgent nonsense so I'd take it with a block of salt.

EBH


Maybe at one time, but not anymore. A step above the Rockwell drivel, but nowhere near reliable or engaging.

Josh
Jun 18, 2015 at 12:19 PM
slrl0ver
Offline
Details
p.6 #9What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
To me, until Sony has a line of pancake and/or small f/2.8 primes, the A7 series doesn't seem to offer any real advantages of a small body.

Would you use a 70-200 f/2.8 on such a body? Did you gain much weight or size reduction? Same with an f/1.4 autofocus lens -- they tend to be big, so a D6xx or D750 body seems like a good pairing.

I think the micro 4/3rds guys have small, interchangeable bodies with a good lens selection down and Nikon / Canon have the larger body business locked up. I HOPE Sony makes smaller lenses, until then not sure what this new body really does.
Jun 18, 2015 at 05:01 PM
Elijah
Offline
Details
p.6 #10What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
slrl0ver wrote:
Would you use a 70-200 f/2.8 on such a body? Did you gain much weight or size reduction? Same with an f/1.4 autofocus lens -- they tend to be big, so a D6xx or D750 body seems like a good pairing.



Spot on dude, spot on. I Bought a DF last year and it was an awkward body to use with my 70-200VRII. At first I didn't have an issue (I even remember saying it on here that I actually liked it) but then after 3 weddings I got so sick of it... My D3s handles that 70-200VTRII like a charm.
Jun 18, 2015 at 05:18 PM
ckcarr
Offline
Details
p.6 #11What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
Actually to answer Jim's original question.

To me it means absolutely nothing. I don't need any Sony camera, or even the incremental technology which might eventually rub off.

If the Nikon world would freeze today, and cease all R&D, Nikon has so much glass out there I haven't tried, and some camera bodies, all of which would compliment them, or work fantastically on my D810 bodies... it's really a matter of affording it for me.

I'd love to someday own a 600mm f/4 and capture some scary critter up in the mountains, or own a fine f/2.8 400mm for dusk and dawn shooting... (I do think I've got landscape covered for now).

So, over the next twenty years or so, give or take, I'm not seeing a shortage of anything that wouldn't keep me happy. I think I'll go the Andre D400 route with my D810 bodies, and hold the ship straight and steady. Rather instead, work on self-improvement.

But, to each their own.
Jun 18, 2015 at 07:27 PM
m.sommers00
Offline
Details
p.6 #12What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
JoshI wrote:
EB-1 wroteDoes Thom Hogan really have any inside knowledge? Sometimes his articles are filled with self-indulgent nonsense so I'd take it with a block of salt.

EBH
Maybe at one time, but not anymore. A step above the Rockwell drivel, but nowhere near reliable or engaging.

Josh


Never understand why folks look to him as the all-knowing Nikon God.

He seems rather ranty these last couple years.
Jun 18, 2015 at 08:16 PM
technic
Offline
Details
p.6 #13What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
slrl0ver wrote:
To me, until Sony has a line of pancake and/or small f/2.8 primes, the A7 series doesn't seem to offer any real advantages of a small body.

Would you use a 70-200 f/2.8 on such a body? Did you gain much weight or size reduction? Same with an f/1.4 autofocus lens -- they tend to be big, so a D6xx or D750 body seems like a good pairing.

I think the micro 4/3rds guys have small, interchangeable bodies with a good lens selection down and Nikon / Canon have the larger body business locked up. I HOPE Sony makes smaller lenses, until
...Show more →

Yes, for size and weight there isn't much advantage in general. If you use A7 series as second body there still is an advantage compared to second DSLR body, and some combinations with hiqh quality WA or standard lens (e.g. f/1.8-f/2 versions) are significantly smaller/lighter for Sony as well. But for a complete kit that includes longer lenses there isn't much to gain (especially taking extra batteries into account). They could really use a few very compact primes for a high quality 'walkaround kit'.

There are very few good quality pancakes or otherwise really compact lenses for DSLRs. Maybe it just isn't possible to put the lens closer to the sensor while maintaining the high quality required for these hires sensors? With Sony NEX series there are similar issues ... very compact bodies but the few really compact lenses were optically disappointing.
Jun 19, 2015 at 05:20 AM
jhinkey
Offline
Details
p.6 #14What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
davewolfs wrote:
The Nikon adapter is kinda huge.


Relative to what? It's actually quite svelte and comparable in size to many other F mount to E mount adapters that have a built in tripod foot. Not sure how it could be made much smaller - it has to fill in the registration distance between the Sony and F mount AND it has to contain electronics.

Looks pretty good to me . . .
Jun 19, 2015 at 10:04 AM
jhinkey
Offline
Details
p.6 #15What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
technic wrote:
slrl0ver wroteTo me, until Sony has a line of pancake and/or small f/2.8 primes, the A7 series doesn't seem to offer any real advantages of a small body.

Would you use a 70-200 f/2.8 on such a body? Did you gain much weight or size reduction? Same with an f/1.4 autofocus lens -- they tend to be big, so a D6xx or D750 body seems like a good pairing.

I think the micro 4/3rds guys have small, interchangeable bodies with a good lens selection down and Nikon / Canon have the larger body business locked up. I HOPE Sony makes smaller lenses, until then not sure what this new body really does.
Yes, for size and weight there isn't much advantage in general. If you use A7 series as second body there still is an advantage compared to second DSLR body, and some combinations with hiqh quality WA or standard lens (e.g. f/1.8-f/2 versions) are significantly smaller/lighter for Sony as well. But for a complete kit that includes longer lenses there isn't much to gain (especially taking extra batteries into account). They could really use a few very compact primes for a high quality 'walkaround kit'.

There are very few good quality pancakes or otherwise really compact lenses for DSLRs. Maybe it
...Show more →

Yes you are right - it's hard to make a quality pancake even for the F mount - For the E mount if they do make a quality "pancake" like the 35/2.8 it ends up to be just as long as a F mount lens + the adapter.

Hopefully everyone realizes that the point of the A7 series is not necessarily size. Mirrorless technology offers many other benefits over a DSLR even if the bodies were identical in size/weight. I'm sure Sony will come out with a larger sized mirrorless body with much improved ergonomics that a larger body can afford - particularly a larger battery . . . . .
Jun 19, 2015 at 10:09 AM
davewolfs
Offline
Details
p.6 #16What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
jhinkey wrote:
davewolfs wroteThe Nikon adapter is kinda huge.
Relative to what? It's actually quite svelte and comparable in size to many other F mount to E mount adapters that have a built in tripod foot. Not sure how it could be made much smaller - it has to fill in the registration distance between the Sony and F mount AND it has to contain electronics.

Looks pretty good to me . . .


Not physically. More like "Wow bra, that is a huge addition to your lineup"
Jun 19, 2015 at 10:47 AM
jancohen
Offline
Details
p.6 #17What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
Though I've always been one of the first to claim size doesn't matter, I just wasn't born with the right genes and have also always compensated with what I've had my hands on. I truthfully feel well-endowed holding my Nikon

Of course, the proof is in the pudding so to speak, and only the results of what I've got baking will tell whether I'm right or wrong.
Jun 19, 2015 at 10:51 AM
JimFox
Offline
Details
p.6 #18What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
ckcarr wrote:
Actually to answer Jim's original question.

To me it means absolutely nothing. I don't need any Sony camera, or even the incremental technology which might eventually rub off.

If the Nikon world would freeze today, and cease all R&D, Nikon has so much glass out there I haven't tried, and some camera bodies, all of which would compliment them, or work fantastically on my D810 bodies... it's really a matter of affording it for me.

I'd love to someday own a 600mm f/4 and capture some scary critter up in the mountains, or own a fine f/2.8 400mm for dusk and dawn shooting...
...Show more →

Good points Craig!

I am very happy with the D800E and D810 combo I use, just amazing DR and IQ throughout. I believe these camera's stand up much like the D700 did where I can see getting 5 years or so shooting out them easily without feeling they got left in the dust.

But with that said, the one thing that got me thinking was they way they were working their sensor and if it really would translate into less noise at higher ISO. I don't need to shoot at ISO 500,000. But if through that technology they could get ISO 3200 to 6400 even more noise free, that would be a point of interest for me.

And your final point is well taken and maybe one of the most important in this thread. And that is for any of us, the biggest improvement we will see in our camera's is with our own personal growth as we learn and grow not only in shooting, but especially in processing our photos. That is one good thinking point.

Jim
Jun 19, 2015 at 12:07 PM
alexluuphoto
Offline
Details
p.6 #19What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
I still find it funny that people think the Sony a7 series doesn't have enough glass. I mean are you guys smoking something? They have 10+ native glass, but they can adapt every lens from every manufacture. The advantage of this camera is the fact that you can use canon lenses and nikon lenses too. Now that its been confirmed and there is enough proof on the internet that the a7r ii can focus these lenses at a good speed. When you decide on a Canon or a Nikon you only get those lenses made by that company. With Sony you can get both sides and feel pretty good about it. Like you can have a Nikon 58mm 1.4 which Canon doesn't have and you can adapt a 85mm 1.2 which nikon doesn't have. Your not limited to anything anymore which is just a great idea. Its the ultimate middle man. Nikon has like 300 lenses, Sony has like 1000+ lenses lol.

And honestly who the hell has 300 nikon or canon lenses. When people shove that number out it includes all the crop lenses, kit lenses and crappy lenses you rarely use. Realistically each company has like 20-30 lenses that are actually practical.
Jun 19, 2015 at 01:44 PM
jhinkey
Offline
Details
p.6 #20What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
JimFox wrote:
And your final point is well taken and maybe one of the most important in this thread. And that is for any of us, the biggest improvement we will see in our camera's is with our own personal growth as we learn and grow not only in shooting, but especially in processing our photos. That is one good thinking point.

Jim


Ah, the old "it's the photographer not the camera" . . . Surely I have technical and artistic growing to do, but many times the equipment gets in the way for what I want to do and either a shot doesn't get taken or it comes out poorly and is not salvageable: too much shutter shake, not easy to achieve critical focus, not enough DR, too much noise in the lifted shadows even though you've ETTR'd, flare/ghosting from the lens, it was too heavy or big so the lens/camera did not get taken along (and hence did not take any images), shutter sound unacceptable (and thus no picture taken), etc., etc.
Each of us needs to do a critical evaluation of what needs to improve in our images, whether a professional or amateur - sometimes it's technique & knowledge, sometimes it's the hardware, sometimes both.

For some of us, and I count myself in that group, the improvements in equipment will definitely make a difference in the images I take. For the A7RII it will be the ability to hand-hold some of my longer Nikon glass and still get sharp images because it has IBIS, better critical focus while being hand-held due to stabilization of the 100% image in the viewfinder, hopefully better wide angle sharpness due to the BSI sensor construction, using it in inclement weather with more confidence due to the improved weather resistance, now I can use a FX camera in quiet venues without the shutter sound waking the dead, and I can adapt glass that Nikon doesn't have in it's inventory. Sometimes it is about the equipment.
Jun 19, 2015 at 04:48 PM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister