p.4 #1What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
Personally, I love the A7r and definitely will get A7r ii when it is available but will still use d810 along side for different reason. I really feel that A7r with Leical 50/2 apo, 35/1.4 fle or Noct 50/0.95 still give me better result than D810 with available lenses in that range. Wate/Voigtlander 15/4.5 iii also works well with A7r for my wide angle need and they are small enough. Grantede they are all MF lenses so they may not always be suitable for all usage and sometimes I still bring 35/1.8 or 58/1.4 to use with D810 as well. Yesterday, I went out with A7r,WATE,50/2 apo, D810 with Sigma 24/1.4, 300/4PF and that really covers pretty much anything that I need for the day in a not so heavy or big camera bags.
I am tempted to leave D810 at home and go with A7r, A7r ii if I know that AF is not going to be a big deal for that specific day also.
There are things that Nikon can do much better than A7r cannot touch for me. For one thing, I still us D7100 for underwater photography. Tempted to get housing for D810 but I do about 80% macro work so D7100 is still better and Tokina 10-17mm fisheye is still the most versatile lens for underwater wide angle, much more versatile than both 14-24 /2.8 or 16-35/4 eventhough IQ may not be quite comparable.
If Nikon comes out with 50+mp FF camera with 20+MP DX cropped mode, I would be interested in replacing my D7100. However, if A7r ii AF is as good as what Sony advertizement claims, I might be tempted. This past week, 3 dolphins swam passed me so fast that D7100/Tokina had no hope of focusing in time and thought that If I have A7r/A7r ii with Nikonos 15mm FE lens (this combination can be used with Nauticam housing very well) I might have a chance of getting that shot last week
p.4 #2What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
you mean like the 11bit lossy compressed raw? (why do they do that?)
the highly limited battery life?(lets sell more batteries)
the minimally larger pixel count (mines bigger factor)?
really on a holistic level it still comes out to be less then the sum of its piled on technology. no single point that is anywhere powerful enough to cancel out the rest of reality.
p.4 #3What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
sjms wrote:
you mean like the 11bit lossy compressed raw?
the highly limited battery life?
the minimally larger pixel count?
really on a holistic level it still comes out to be less then the sum of its piled on technology. no single point that is anywhere powerful enough to cancel out the rest of reality.
You should preface your statement with "for me".
How about the inability to see f/2 DOF in the OVF, the lack of IBIS, not the greatest EFCS implementation for us tripod users, no tilt screen, no totally silent mode, no live histogram in the OVF, etc. etc. on the D810.
Neither camera is perfect nor the perfect tool for everyone.
I will continue to use my D800 (and likely a D810 sometime soon) along with the A7rII and use each one for the situation that they are better suited for.
p.4 #4What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
I covered that in the last line. Some are more enamored with the technology. i've been shooting for over 35 years somehow I work it out. Its relative knowledge and practice. Also my lens limits are currently 2.8.
An IBIS is a nice bird and a nice bike too.
And in the end if it doesn't have an ADIRU it just isn't happening
p.4 #5What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
I heard some beautiful notes played on some old guitars, by great musicians. I've seen people owing the best guitars, but they couldn't play at all.
Can we find some similarity in photography, by the chance. A great photographer will make beautiful photo even with the phone. I am afraid that "technology hunters" most likely won't fall into that group.
It's nice to talk about new stuff, but do I want to jump on every camera body, as soon as it's released. I could live with D700 for another 5-6 years, without missing too much at all. I wish I didn't sell it.
p.4 #6What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
jhinkey wrote: Lance B wrotejhinkey wroteLance B wroteLike I said, miniscule perceived advantage. You "don't see much disadvantages selling your dslr kit and moving to something smaller except for focusing which their working on. The quality of lenses coming out for the sony system is amazing."
Except for the huge loss of money and ability, no not much loss at all. .
The specs do not make the D810 look outdated at all. There is nothing in the Sony that is an update to the D810 in any way shape or form.Do you really mean that there is no feature of the A7RII that is better than the D810?None worth swapping out systems for.Well, that's a completely different statement than what you initially said.
There clearly are features on the upcoming A7RII that are superior to the D810, but those alone are worth it to some and not to others.
Actually it is what I initially said: 'The new Sony means nothing to me and I guess most Nikon users, unless they think wasting money selling one system to get another for a miniscule PERCEIVED advantage in one area (probably none in actual fact) but lose out in a larger way in another area of performance or features."
In other words, wasting money on a miniscule perceived advantage is not worth swapping out systems.
p.4 #8What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
sjms wrote:
it's referred to as "chasing the ghost". will there be a difference of quality in you final product, that being the image you create with these tools?
+1
I'm not sure who said it, but I'm reminded of the old saying "a good photographer can take great pictures with a Kodak Brownie."
p.4 #9What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
jancohen wrote: sjms wroteit's referred to as "chasing the ghost". will there be a difference of quality in you final product, that being the image you create with these tools?+1
I'm not sure who said it, but I'm reminded of the old saying "a good photographer can take great pictures with a Kodak Brownie."
That's like saying a great race car driver can win the Indianapolis 500 with a model T. Gear does matter. But the incremental changes, or features introduced, at this stage of the game between camera manufacturers, may or may not make a difference to a photographer. Without some truly innovative or overwhelmingly significant (milestone) type advancement, I'd see very few Nikon shooters giving up this gear just to jump ship to some latest, greatest announcement. It's only a guess, but other than those few vocal shooters who announce they are changing from Canon to Nikon that we see here, I'd believe most stay on their chosen manufacturer's upgrade path.
p.4 #10What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
I see what point some people are trying to make, but the "gear doesn't matter" argument that you hear so often is complete crap IMO, especially when taken to extremes. It also depends heavily on what the task at hand is. Some tools/equipment haven't changed much over the years, other things have changed exponentially.
Yes, cameras, lenses, etc. are just tools however some tools are objectively way better than other tools, some tools let us do our jobs much more easily, and some tools let us do things not possible with other tools. I could be the best builder in the world, but would that matter if my only tools were a shovel, a rock, and some rusty nails? That isn't going to mean much compared to the competition with cranes, excavators, and trucks full of things made by Hilti, DeWalt, Milwaukee, etc.
It's more about using the *right* tool for the job, and as clearly shown in the sales numbers every 2ish years when a new body comes out, (surprise!) a good number of people also enjoy using the best tool available for the job/hobby. Anything that makes their jobs easier, more pleasant, faster, or allows them to do things they could not previously do, has a lot of value. Can you take a great shot with a $100 point & shoot? Sure, of course you can, but there is a reason why a $100 point & shoot isn't the go-to camera for professional wedding photographers or just about any other demanding photography environment, and it certainly isn't due to lack of skill.
Now, if you have two similar state of the art pieces of equipment with differences mostly characterized by system design and personal preference like we are talking about in this thread, that is a completely different story. Better AF, better sensor performance, faster shooting rates, higher resolution, etc. are all things that will make real differences in the final product to many people, which is why Nikon, Sony and everyone else has no trouble selling improved cameras every couple of years. Every time I have upgraded my camera bodies, there have been exciting, easily achievable new things I could do compared to previous bodies that have made a noticeable difference to the final product. The more demanding of a user you are, the more often you're probably going to want to upgrade, since those incremental improvements are going to be more noticeable to you compared to the casual/novice shooter. Incremental refinements are likely to keep people within their current system, huge improvements in key areas are usually what gets people thinking about switching entire systems.
p.4 #11What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
ummm, yes and no. i was at a location where i wasn't supposed to shoot. all of a sudden the people i do business with asked if i could do a job. i did explain that i only had a P/S camera (at the time it was a Canon Powershot G10) with me but i'd take a shot at it anyway. got my standard rate in the end for the day and nice hot meal too. supplied them with over a dozen well liked images.
p.4 #12What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
Some of my friends are fully invested in Sony. Some Canon friends are going with a A7x + Metabones solution.
But nearly all my Nikon friends shrug off the Sony offering. The A7 series is definitely nice, but it offers only a slight improvement over a D8xx set up in terms of MPX count. IBIS is nice (Imagine having a 35 f/1.4 stabilized)... but meh. If I had to choose between the D8xx's better shutter response, and the A7x's IBIS, I'd take the shutter response.
I'm a fan of mirrorless systems. I have both a m4/3rds and a Sony A6000, but they don't quite have the versatility of my D800.
p.4 #13What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
I had an A7R (and will get the A7RII) mostly for my manual focus glass - it's a breeze to get them critically in focus with focus magnification assist and will be even more so with IBIS. Focus striping never seemed accurate enough for me. Unless I'm shooting tethered or am squinting at the rear LCD my D800 is hard to nail the focus (and Nikon's LiveView line skipping doesn't help).
p.4 #14What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
Back to the OP's original intent of the thread -
So to me this begs the question as to what will Nikon do to get my $$ that I'm going to spend on an A7RII? A D820? Hopefully it will be a DM810 - a mirrorless D810, but I'm not going to hold my breath waiting for them to come out with this.
In fact Nikon has done little to get the $$ that I spend on m43 gear or the A7r and that trend seems like it will continue.
p.4 #15What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
krickett wrote:
But nearly all my Nikon friends shrug off the Sony offering...
I'm a fan of mirrorless systems. I have both a m4/3rds and a Sony A6000, but they don't quite have the versatility of my D800.
I use my a6000 because it's tiny (and i don't care if it gets destroyed by my kid or the beach) and fun with that 10-18 on 'er. Don't know what I would do with a $3K A7Rii
But, yea, my Nikon is "prime time" and does indeed shrug off any Sony offering
p.4 #16What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
The A7R II begins to approach a replacement for my D800E's. I mostly use manual focus lenses on my D800E's for my work, so for me the EVF is a far better solution than an OVF. I don't really care about the size and weight advantage of the Sony. Nor do I care about most of the other gimmicky specs. But the high magnification EVF, improved (over the D800E) live view, tilt-LCD, and the ability to use adapted lenses from other mounts (17mm TS-E mostly) make it a great camera for what I do. If Sony added 14-bit lossless RAW files and a second card slot, I'd pre-order a pair and sell my D800E's. Until then, I'll keep shooting my D800E's and hoping Sony (or Nikon) sees the light.
p.4 #17What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
jhinkey wrote:
Back to the OP's original intent of the thread -
So to me this begs the question as to what will Nikon do to get my $$ that I'm going to spend on an A7RII? A D820? Hopefully it will be a DM810 - a mirrorless D810, but I'm not going to hold my breath waiting for them to come out with this.
In fact Nikon has done little to get the $$ that I spend on m43 gear or the A7r and that trend seems like it will continue.
What about this? D400 with the APS-C version of the 42Mp chip - still depend on price, I guess.
I'd like to see Nikon's version of the Sony RX1R with a state of the art EVF with 24mm, 40mm, and 80mm fixed lens variations; 36Mp. I'm not a pro or wedding photographer, but that would meet my needs.
p.4 #18What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
I'm not saying I'm perfectly happy with my D800E, but for the work I do (cityscape/landscape), I'm more than content with it. Honestly, the A7RII doesn't really interest me. I still prefer my DSLR to the mirrorless cameras, even though it seems they continue to rise in popularity.
I think if I still had my 5DIII, I probably would have the A7R or would be seriously considering the A7RII. But fortunately, I have the D800E and I'm happy with it.
p.4 #20What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
sjms wrote:
sales of mirrorless really hasn't risen
Yeah mirrorless shipments have been pretty flat since the start of 2013, and aren't even close to DSLR shipments yet. That's probably one reason Canon & Nikon haven't jumped in with both feet, along with there being a lot more competition in the mirrorless realm. It's probably safer for them to just keep on primarily with the DSLRs, which out-ship mirrorless 2:1 on a bad month (Q1 2015 has been more like 3:1).
Shipments don't perfectly equal sales of course, but it is still a helpful statistic.
Mirrorless won't interest me as a primary camera until they solve the common complaints surrounding EVF's, battery life, ergonomics, and lens/system depth. I still see them more as a compliment to DSLRs rather than a replacement, unless of course your shooting style or preferences do not need the advantages DSLRs still maintain.