fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII

  
 
Cliff L.
Online
Details
p.56 #1Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
molson wrote
alundeb wroteYou try to make it sound like Sony is superior to Canon with respect to shutter vibration, while the truth is that only Sony has a camera with an active user base (the A7r) with real problems both in handheld and tripod shooting. Canon cameras don't have such problems.
The A7R II seems to have solved most of these problems, but the IBIS is not very effective - I'm seeing only one or two stops of stabilization at most. the IBIS "feels" like it's working well, but on close examination there is still a lot of motion blur in most images, so I find a tripod is still mandatory for sharp results.
That's two stops more for my Zeiss lenses than is available anywhere else. 😀

My understanding is the IBIS works in tandem with the IS in the Sony lenses to provide even more stabalization than is possible with just the IS in the lens.
I'm looking at the A7R2 for next year and my primary travel lens is the Sony 16-35 which has IS. Would be great if the IBIS adds to the capabilities of this lens. Would be great for low light handheld street shooting.


Hopefully it works better with stabilized Sony lenses that it does with Canon IS lenses - those are the situations where I'm seeing no more than 1 to 2 stops in total, using both IBIS and IS.

The Canon EF 70-300mm f4-5.6L IS is a real disappointment on the A7R2 - IS seems non-existent, and focusing at 300mm is a major challenge. The same lens is brilliant on my 5DsR and 5D Mark III.
Oct 08, 2015 at 12:34 PM
mogul
Offline
Details
p.56 #2Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
molson wrote:
chez wrote
molson wrote
alundeb wroteYou try to make it sound like Sony is superior to Canon with respect to shutter vibration, while the truth is that only Sony has a camera with an active user base (the A7r) with real problems both in handheld and tripod shooting. Canon cameras don't have such problems.
The A7R II seems to have solved most of these problems, but the IBIS is not very effective - I'm seeing only one or two stops of stabilization at most. the IBIS "feels" like it's working well, but on close examination there is still a lot of motion blur in most images, so I find a tripod is still mandatory for sharp results.
That's two stops more for my Zeiss lenses than is available anywhere else. 😀

My understanding is the IBIS works in tandem with the IS in the Sony lenses to provide even more stabalization than is possible with just the IS in the lens.
I'm looking at the A7R2 for next year and my primary travel lens is the Sony 16-35 which has IS. Would be great if the IBIS adds to the capabilities of this lens. Would be great for low light handheld street shooting.
Hopefully it works better with stabilized Sony lenses that it does with Canon IS lenses - those are the situations where I'm seeing no more than 1 to 2 stops in total, using both IBIS and IS.

The Canon EF 70-300mm f4-5.6L IS is a real disappointment on the A7R2 - IS seems non-existent, and focusing at 300mm is a major challenge. The same lens is brilliant on my 5DsR and 5D Mark III.


Stick with Canon, you seem more at home with their technology.
Oct 08, 2015 at 12:39 PM
Cliff L.
Online
Details
p.56 #3Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
mogul wrote:
Stick with Canon, you seem more at home with their technology.


Stick with your day job - you aren't having much success as a professional Sony cheerleader.
Oct 08, 2015 at 12:42 PM
Schlotkins
Offline
Details
p.56 #4Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
This thread is still going? It's like watching a pro-choice and pro-life person argue - neither one is going to persuade the other.
Oct 08, 2015 at 12:47 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.56 #5Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
molson wrote:
chez wrote
molson wrote
alundeb wroteYou try to make it sound like Sony is superior to Canon with respect to shutter vibration, while the truth is that only Sony has a camera with an active user base (the A7r) with real problems both in handheld and tripod shooting. Canon cameras don't have such problems.
The A7R II seems to have solved most of these problems, but the IBIS is not very effective - I'm seeing only one or two stops of stabilization at most. the IBIS "feels" like it's working well, but on close examination there is still a lot of motion blur in most images, so I find a tripod is still mandatory for sharp results.
That's two stops more for my Zeiss lenses than is available anywhere else. 😀

My understanding is the IBIS works in tandem with the IS in the Sony lenses to provide even more stabalization than is possible with just the IS in the lens.
I'm looking at the A7R2 for next year and my primary travel lens is the Sony 16-35 which has IS. Would be great if the IBIS adds to the capabilities of this lens. Would be great for low light handheld street shooting.
Hopefully it works better with stabilized Sony lenses that it does with Canon IS lenses - those are the situations where I'm seeing no more than 1 to 2 stops in total, using both IBIS and IS.

The Canon EF 70-300mm f4-5.6L IS is a real disappointment on the A7R2 - IS seems non-existent, and focusing at 300mm is a major challenge. The same lens is brilliant on my 5DsR and 5D Mark III.


My understanding is IBIS does not work with non native glass. I might be wrong here, have not really dug into it that much. My plan is to wait until at least next spring to purchase the A7R2...have a big South East Asia trip planned and would love to take the A7R2 with me.
Oct 08, 2015 at 12:57 PM
Cliff L.
Online
Details
p.56 #6Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
molson wrote
chez wrote
molson wrote
alundeb wroteYou try to make it sound like Sony is superior to Canon with respect to shutter vibration, while the truth is that only Sony has a camera with an active user base (the A7r) with real problems both in handheld and tripod shooting. Canon cameras don't have such problems.
The A7R II seems to have solved most of these problems, but the IBIS is not very effective - I'm seeing only one or two stops of stabilization at most. the IBIS "feels" like it's working well, but on close examination there is still a lot of motion blur in most images, so I find a tripod is still mandatory for sharp results.
That's two stops more for my Zeiss lenses than is available anywhere else. 😀

My understanding is the IBIS works in tandem with the IS in the Sony lenses to provide even more stabalization than is possible with just the IS in the lens.
I'm looking at the A7R2 for next year and my primary travel lens is the Sony 16-35 which has IS. Would be great if the IBIS adds to the capabilities of this lens. Would be great for low light handheld street shooting.
Hopefully it works better with stabilized Sony lenses that it does with Canon IS lenses - those are the situations where I'm seeing no more than 1 to 2 stops in total, using both IBIS and IS.

The Canon EF 70-300mm f4-5.6L IS is a real disappointment on the A7R2 - IS seems non-existent, and focusing at 300mm is a major challenge. The same lens is brilliant on my 5DsR and 5D Mark III.
My understanding is IBIS does not work with non native glass. I might be wrong here, have not really dug into it that much. My plan is to wait until at least next spring to purchase the A7R2...have a big South East Asia trip planned and would love to take the A7R2 with me.


You're right, Harry; with the Metabones IV adapter and latest firmware, it disables IBIS when the lens IS is on, and IBIS is enabled when you switch off the lens IS, so you only get one or the other. For some reason, the Canon lens IS does not seem to be as effective when used on the Sony bodes - I get much more stable images using the same lenses on the 5D SR. The only Sony lens I currently have is the 55mm f1.8 but IBIS doesn't seem to be very effective with that lens either.
Oct 08, 2015 at 01:16 PM
Schlotkins
Offline
Details
p.56 #7Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
molson wrote:
chez wrote
molson wrote
chez wrote
molson wrote
alundeb wroteYou try to make it sound like Sony is superior to Canon with respect to shutter vibration, while the truth is that only Sony has a camera with an active user base (the A7r) with real problems both in handheld and tripod shooting. Canon cameras don't have such problems.
The A7R II seems to have solved most of these problems, but the IBIS is not very effective - I'm seeing only one or two stops of stabilization at most. the IBIS "feels" like it's working well, but on close examination there is still a lot of motion blur in most images, so I find a tripod is still mandatory for sharp results.
That's two stops more for my Zeiss lenses than is available anywhere else. 😀

My understanding is the IBIS works in tandem with the IS in the Sony lenses to provide even more stabalization than is possible with just the IS in the lens.
I'm looking at the A7R2 for next year and my primary travel lens is the Sony 16-35 which has IS. Would be great if the IBIS adds to the capabilities of this lens. Would be great for low light handheld street shooting.
Hopefully it works better with stabilized Sony lenses that it does with Canon IS lenses - those are the situations where I'm seeing no more than 1 to 2 stops in total, using both IBIS and IS.

The Canon EF 70-300mm f4-5.6L IS is a real disappointment on the A7R2 - IS seems non-existent, and focusing at 300mm is a major challenge. The same lens is brilliant on my 5DsR and 5D Mark III.
My understanding is IBIS does not work with non native glass. I might be wrong here, have not really dug into it that much. My plan is to wait until at least next spring to purchase the A7R2...have a big South East Asia trip planned and would love to take the A7R2 with me.
You're right, Harry; with the Metabones IV adapter and latest firmware, it disables IBIS when the lens IS is on, and IBIS is enabled when you switch off the lens IS, so you only get one or the other. For some reason, the Canon lens IS does not seem to be as effective when used on the Sony bodes - I get much more stable images using the same lenses on the 5D SR. The only Sony lens I currently have is the 55mm f1.8 but IBIS doesn't seem to be very effective with that lens either.


I believe this is just because the body is lighter. I have the same problem with IS lenses and the A7r. There isn't as much mass so the body moves more in my hands, especially when hitting the shutter button.
Oct 08, 2015 at 01:26 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.56 #8Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
This shutter vibration has been corrected in the latest Sony camera.

I've been shooting the last 3 weeks using the A7R and viewing on my iPad, I have not noticed any vibration caused issues. Now many of my shots are in the 1 sec and longer range or during daylight when the shutter is upwards of 1/500 second.

Also, most of my images are taken at the wide end, 35mm and wider.


The thing is, that the A7r still has a place even if most if not all the quirks about it have been fixed in the latest version. For long exposures, the shutter vibration is not an issue, and the A7r is even better than the A7rII. The mk II is also significantly heavier. As a second body and lightweight FF camera, I don't want to part with the A7r.

My 5DII however doesn't get that love anymore. There is nothing it does better than the 5DS R.


Edited on Oct 08, 2015 at 02:03 PM · View previous versions
Oct 08, 2015 at 01:26 PM
justruss
Offline
Details
p.56 #9Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
molson wrote
chez wrote
molson wrote
alundeb wroteYou try to make it sound like Sony is superior to Canon with respect to shutter vibration, while the truth is that only Sony has a camera with an active user base (the A7r) with real problems both in handheld and tripod shooting. Canon cameras don't have such problems.
The A7R II seems to have solved most of these problems, but the IBIS is not very effective - I'm seeing only one or two stops of stabilization at most. the IBIS "feels" like it's working well, but on close examination there is still a lot of motion blur in most images, so I find a tripod is still mandatory for sharp results.
That's two stops more for my Zeiss lenses than is available anywhere else. 😀

My understanding is the IBIS works in tandem with the IS in the Sony lenses to provide even more stabalization than is possible with just the IS in the lens.
I'm looking at the A7R2 for next year and my primary travel lens is the Sony 16-35 which has IS. Would be great if the IBIS adds to the capabilities of this lens. Would be great for low light handheld street shooting.
Hopefully it works better with stabilized Sony lenses that it does with Canon IS lenses - those are the situations where I'm seeing no more than 1 to 2 stops in total, using both IBIS and IS.

The Canon EF 70-300mm f4-5.6L IS is a real disappointment on the A7R2 - IS seems non-existent, and focusing at 300mm is a major challenge. The same lens is brilliant on my 5DsR and 5D Mark III.
My understanding is IBIS does not work with non native glass. I might be wrong here, have not really dug into it that much. My plan is to wait until at least next spring to purchase the A7R2...have a big South East Asia trip planned and would love to take the A7R2 with me.


IBIS seems to work well on my non-native glass with the Viltrox II adapter, including my Tamron SP 17mm, OM 24mm, 35L, and FL 55 f/1.2. And it works great on my FE 28mm f/2. The real alt lenses (mf design, no electrical contacts) need to have their focal length input into the camera manually so that IBIS works properly with them. The Canon seems to just set itself automatically. I don't have any stabilized lenses, so I can't say how that works out.

I think IBIS works much better with shorter lenses though, and once you go very far beyond mid-tele-- say 85mm?-- you're better sticking with a system (ideally native) that includes IS in the lens. But keep in mind that if you get down into the really slow shutter speeds (possible with short lenses), like 1/5 or 1/10, you have a MUCH higher chance of subject motion blur than if you're using IS in a long lens and shooting at 1/100 or 1/200.
Oct 08, 2015 at 01:44 PM
justruss
Offline
Details
p.56 #10Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
retrofocus wrote:
justruss wroteI'm surprised by how good the A7rII LCD is indoors, and how horrible it is outdoors in really bright light. Using both my 5D2 (ancient) and my A7rII to review images in the same setting (midday, not under shadow, bright, on smooth white rocks at the river... pupil constrictingly bright!)-- the 5d2 LCD image was easy to see and the A7rII LCD image was close to useless. I have good eyes too. It's just one of those details that one still expects (unfortunately) for Sony to have not handled quite right.
I am rarely using the A7R LCD screen to review/look at taken photos, this is much better to be done with the EVF. In most cases I use the LCD screen only for menu option selections, or if I shoot macros from the ground level where I can tilt the LCD display upwards to see the image.


Yes, well, I was shooting low to the ground with an UWA lens, and also trying to use the LCD to compose.

Not everyone works the same way. I don't review stuff all that often anyway (thanks to EVF and exposure simulation!)-- and while I quite like this camera I'm not going to make excuses for Sony when they drop the ball. In my opinion, having an LCD screen that is difficult to see in bright light-- notably in comparison to a 3+ year old camera like the 5D2 which was perfectly visible-- counts as dropping the ball a bit.
Oct 08, 2015 at 01:47 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.56 #11Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Schlotkins wrote:
This thread is still going? It's like watching a pro-choice and pro-life person argue - neither one is going to persuade the other.


Are we reading the same thread? I see mostly detailed technical discussions, with tips, hints and comparsions from level headed people, and many with dual Canon and Sony systems. There is some noise in between, but most people are not trying to persuade anybody, just build detailed knowledge for best purchase decision and usage.
Oct 08, 2015 at 01:49 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.56 #12Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
Schlotkins wroteThis thread is still going? It's like watching a pro-choice and pro-life person argue - neither one is going to persuade the other.
Are we reading the same thread? I see mostly detailed technical discussions, with tips, hints and comparsions from level headed people, and many with dual Canon and Sony systems. There is some noise in between, but most people are not trying to persuade anybody, just build detailed knowledge for best purchase decision and usage.


When forums work well, and when we can keep camera religion to a minimum, and when camera users acknowledge both the strengths and weaknesses of "their" brand and the other person's brand, the product of the discussion is often quite useful.

There has been a good amount of the useful and fairly objective stuff recently in this thread, interrupted only occasionally by the folks beating their usual branded drum. Don't worry though, that affliction can be found among a few folks using any brand, from Canon to Leica to Nikon to Sony to Pentax to...

;-)
Oct 08, 2015 at 02:03 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.56 #13Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
justruss wrote:
chez wrote
molson wrote
chez wrote
molson wrote
alundeb wroteYou try to make it sound like Sony is superior to Canon with respect to shutter vibration, while the truth is that only Sony has a camera with an active user base (the A7r) with real problems both in handheld and tripod shooting. Canon cameras don't have such problems.
The A7R II seems to have solved most of these problems, but the IBIS is not very effective - I'm seeing only one or two stops of stabilization at most. the IBIS "feels" like it's working well, but on close examination there is still a lot of motion blur in most images, so I find a tripod is still mandatory for sharp results.
That's two stops more for my Zeiss lenses than is available anywhere else. 😀

My understanding is the IBIS works in tandem with the IS in the Sony lenses to provide even more stabalization than is possible with just the IS in the lens.
I'm looking at the A7R2 for next year and my primary travel lens is the Sony 16-35 which has IS. Would be great if the IBIS adds to the capabilities of this lens. Would be great for low light handheld street shooting.
Hopefully it works better with stabilized Sony lenses that it does with Canon IS lenses - those are the situations where I'm seeing no more than 1 to 2 stops in total, using both IBIS and IS.

The Canon EF 70-300mm f4-5.6L IS is a real disappointment on the A7R2 - IS seems non-existent, and focusing at 300mm is a major challenge. The same lens is brilliant on my 5DsR and 5D Mark III.
My understanding is IBIS does not work with non native glass. I might be wrong here, have not really dug into it that much. My plan is to wait until at least next spring to purchase the A7R2...have a big South East Asia trip planned and would love to take the A7R2 with me.
IBIS seems to work well on my non-native glass with the Viltrox II adapter, including my Tamron SP 17mm, OM 24mm, 35L, and FL 55 f/1.2. And it works great on my FE 28mm f/2. The real alt lenses (mf design, no electrical contacts) need to have their focal length input into the camera manually so that IBIS works properly with them. The Canon seems to just set itself automatically. I don't have any stabilized lenses, so I can't say how that works out.

I think IBIS works much better with shorter lenses though, and once you go very far beyond
...Show more →

I'm actually going to rent out the A7R2 to see how well the stabalization works with the 16-35. If it improves on what speeds I'm able to shoot at with the A7r today...then that's just another feather in the A7R2 cap.

I understand that IS won't help much with people movement. Much of my street / urban interests is capturing the architectural aspects of different places where at times carrying a tripod for the day is painful.
Oct 08, 2015 at 07:12 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.56 #14Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
Much of my street / urban interests is capturing the architectural aspects of different places where at times carrying a tripod for the day is painful.


Isn't that a left-handed way of saying that you aren't shooting street? ... but, rather architecture (even if from a hand-held platform)?

chez wrote:
Also, most of my images are taken at the wide end, 35mm and wider.


Isn't that also the least challenging end of the focal range with regard to relative motion between camera / subject (particularly a subject distance of architecture / scene). As such, your reports of IBIS excellence compared with others of different IBIS effectiveness reports @ longer focal lengths should be noted accordingly by those collecting anecdotal input. I mean, using a 1:1 rule of thumb, a steady hand can shoot 16mm @ 1/15 (even lower if your technique is good) without IBIS or IS.

Meanwhile we are getting reports of Canon IS shooting 400mm at 1/40 (exceptional anecdote plausible) sec handheld, while the Sony can't even AF long glass well ... I doubt, it would then be able to IBIS such longer FL's very effectively. Just saying, that if the anecdotal information is highly restricted to a less challenging scenario, it's report of superiority might be with a grain of salt @ a somewhat (albeit without malice) stacked deck.

Kinda like saying a Camry is really quick at getting in and out of parking spaces, while others are talking about how quickly a Ferrari gets up to Autobahn speeds. Then saying the Camry is quicker, and since it never goes on the Autobahn, it is quick enough to get the groceries at the corner store ...

Edited on Oct 08, 2015 at 11:33 PM · View previous versions
Oct 08, 2015 at 11:07 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.56 #15Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RustyBug wrote:
chez wroteMuch of my street / urban interests is capturing the architectural aspects of different places where at times carrying a tripod for the day is painful.
Isn't that a left-handed way of saying that you aren't shooting street? ... but, rather architecture (even if from a hand-held platform)?

chez wroteAlso, most of my images are taken at the wide end, 35mm and wider.
Isn't that also the least challenging end of the focal range with regard to relative motion between camera / subject. As such, your reports of IBIS excellence compared with others of different IBIS effectiveness reports @ longer focal lengths should be noted accordingly by those collecting anecdotal input. I mean, using a 1:1 rule of thumb, a steady hand can shoot 16mm @ 1/15 or lower.

Meanwhile we are getting reports of Canon IS shooting 400mm at 1/40 (exceptional
...Show more →

Rusty, before getting your shorts too tight, maybe reread what I wrote. Never did I mention shutter vibration is not an issue with the A7R. I mentioned it was addressed in the latest A7R2...which it has right? Also the quotes you highlighted weren't even talking about IBIS...we were discussing shutter vibration at the time and I was indicating under the scenario I laid out which happens to be quite common with landscape shooter, wide lens and longer shutter speeds, that I have not noticed any issues with vibration.

As far as street photography goes, I shoot both people in the street as well as interesting buildings. Will I still be allowed in your definition of street photography...as if I really care ( said under my breath).


Oct 08, 2015 at 11:30 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.56 #16Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Understood ... but, the collective "connect the dots" of the information still raises the relative usage compared to your heralded reports is at least worth a "hmmm" given that others are reporting lesser results with longer FL's.

Just a moment of reflection to why your high praise of the IBIS might be valid in your usage, and yet the others with lower praise of IBIS remains valid under their usage. Otherwise, folks might be left to think that at least one person or the other is "stretching" a bit, when the point to be made COULD BE that there is a curve of effectiveness relative to the demands placed on application ... i.e works really good, to a point, then tapers until . After all, that is a roughly similar pattern to that which we see with EF adapted AF effectiveness.

Just illustrating the diff might not be something to overlook as one set of folks may herald greatness, while others refute such to more mundane mediocrity.
Oct 08, 2015 at 11:42 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.56 #17Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RustyBug wrote:
Understood ... but, the collective "connect the dots" of the information still raises the relative usage compared to your heralded reports is at least worth a "hmmm" given that others are reporting lesser results with longer FL's.

Just a moment of reflection to why your high praise of the IBIS might be valid in your usage, and yet the others with lower praise of IBIS remains valid under their usage. Otherwise, folks might be left to think that at least one person or the other is "stretching" a bit, when the point to be made COULD BE that there is
...Show more →


Rusty...show me where I am giving high praise to IBIS. I'm asking questions how well it works in conjunction with lens based IS. Geez, I don't even own a camera with IBIS...let alone praising it. I read in another thread that the IBIS works with lens based IS and was asking if others here had experience with it. Suggest you again reread my posts before coming on strong.
Oct 09, 2015 at 12:14 AM
justruss
Offline
Details
p.56 #18Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Just to reiterate on the IBIS front:

My own personal experience (focal lengths from 17mm to 55mm, all primes, some full-alt) is that IBIS works quite well. Let me illustrate with a relative comparison from general use, not controlled testing-- but this includes shooting on assignment, so it follows an internal belief of what I can actually, reliably pull off.

My benchmark is the 5D2. If I'm careful, I know I can shoot at 1/FL and get pretty sharp results most of the time. If the shot is absolutely critical, I try to get up to 1/(2 x FL). (Note: this doesn't mean critical-- aka tripod- sharpness, but good enough sharpness to deliver to, say, a big circulation glossy mag for a single-photo, 2-page spread.)

When I added my Fuji X-E1, I found that 1/FL wasn't quite as reliable. It was doable, but I had to work much more slowly. So my standard was to try to get to 1/(2 x FL) for attaining "pretty sharp results most of the time." For those critical things I tried for more. Keep in mind that's AFTER doing the APS-C to FF equiv. to get focal length. So with the 18mm native lens mounted, 1/60 was my mental baseline, and 1/30 was very much a push scenario where I'd want to have multiple shots to make sure I got one that really worked for me. I suspect this had a lot to do with: i) how light the system was, and ii) a tendency to either shoot using the LCD or not quite being able to lock the camera into my body as well when shooting through the EVF.

On the Sony (A7rII), I very comfortably can shoot at 1/(1/2 x FL) or 1/(1/3 x FL) for my baseline "pretty sharp results most of the time." Not only this, but I think I get better, sharper, pixel-level results at these shutter speeds than I do with 1/FL on my 5D2. When you consider what pixel-level sharpness translates to when you are comparing 22mp to 42mp-- the A7rII wipes the floor with my 5D2 from a stabilization standpoint. Being able to reliably shoot my 35L at 1/10 or 1/15 is something I would never, ever have been comfortable doing with my 5D2. (Note: as mentioned earlier, this introduces a greater risk of subject motion becoming an issue.)

So, if you're like me, going from no stabilization at all to IBIS-- even a couple stops is pretty remarkable for what it opens up. The other day I was shooting 0.5s exposures on a 17mm lens, while perched in an awkward position over a river on rocks (to blur the water motion)... and if there was softness I think it was from the diffraction of shooting at f/22! I might have been able to do that on my 5D2 after 1 of 10 shots compared to the pixel level sharpness I get on the 42mp of the A7rII in 1 of 2 shots in that situation.

I very much doubt the IBIS is very effective at >100-200mm focal lengths, particularly compared to lens-based stabilization designed for a single lens.

IBIS is just another nice thing to have, but it's definitely not magic. And if it can buy you a couple stops of exposure, aperture, or lower ISO... there are times that makes all the difference.
Oct 09, 2015 at 01:54 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.56 #19Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
+1 @ IBIS has value. I've never said it didn't ... particularly compared to a situation of no IBIS, no OS, no IS, no VR of any kind at all. I know the first time I used stabilization with a telephoto on a Nikon demo, I was pretty amazed at how much it transformed the ability to handhold things to lower speeds.

justruss wrote:
I very much doubt the IBIS is very effective at >100-200mm focal lengths, particularly compared to lens-based stabilization designed for a single lens.


But, I think this ^ illustrates the salient point that is worth recognizing when talking about the diff between the IBIS vs. IS approach of two different platforms. When Sony first came out with the concept of IBIS with the A900, the allure was there for me as I was heavy alt glass user then. For those who are heavy users of non-stabilized glass with shorter FL's, the IBIS and E mount combination provides blessing to a bevy of glass, but that doesn't seem to render it as a better performing option once you start moving up the FL chain.

The point here is the comparative aspect of the two platforms @ strength / weaknesses / features / preferences / etc.. The IBIS offers an alternative approach to the single lens stabilization. I'm just saying that it seems that the collection of anecdotal information indicates that those who are considering the diff approach, may want to give credence to the degree of effectiveness each offers throughout the entire FL range, or at least know how it matches up with their own applications / shooting style.

As to shooting wides, hand held @ slow shutter from awkward position ... I'm good with the 16-35/4 IS well below the 1:1 also, so I'm not knocking the real value of stabilization. But, IBIS doesn't have a corner on that market. I've not tried the new Tammy 15-30/2.8, but Tammy literature points out that they disable the stabilization in the Sony Mount offering, thus relying on the IBIS (assumed for incompatibility/conflict reasons).
Oct 09, 2015 at 06:11 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.56 #20Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
Rusty...show me where I am giving high praise to IBIS.

Geez, I don't even own a camera with IBIS...let alone praising it.


Chez, if in the proliferation of advocacy of Sony, you have never given such praise to IBIS, then I owe you an apology for my misunderstanding of your historical position. But, even if you have never given such historical praise of IBIS (which I believe you have, but am not searching for it atm), the salient point of its effectiveness differential @ FL application remains a viable point of consideration for those considering the compare / contrast of the two platforms on topic.

It just struck me that your indication of usage (albeit presented for the shutter vib) matched up with a different set of advocated results, thus explaining the delta between varying reports of effectiveness ... hence the suggestion that IBIS performance may trend similar to non-OEM AF performance @ shorter FL is better, longer FL not so much ... in both attributes of AF and stabilization for non-native mounts.

I mean, which body is a 100-400L II IS (recalling this is the Canon forum and the primary reason we even discuss Sony here is the ability to use our Canon glass on the Sony body) will provide for a better stabilization experience ... the 5Ds(R) or the A7R II Can the A7R II compare equitably to the AF / stabilization experience of the 5Ds(R) with longer glass? And, if the reply is the A7R II works well with Sony's 70-400 II to achieve such equitable performance ... then the whole "you can use your Canon glass on Sony" is really a false premise, based on an inequality of "can use" definition.

Which, then again relegates the A7R II to a niche position rather than an overall performer for Canon glass shooters. I just don't think that leaving the longer glass out of the equation / evaluation of the Sony A7R II is prudent to advocate its IBIS (or AF) effectiveness. I strikes me thus far, that the only way to get long glass performance with Sony ... is to dump Canon long glass in exchange for Sony or third party long glass in the Alpha Mount and use an adapter on the E mount. Just seems a bit anti-thetical to "you can use your Canon glass on Sony".
Oct 09, 2015 at 06:31 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister