fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII

  
 
justruss
Offline
Details
p.57 #1Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RustyBug wrote:
+1 @ IBIS has value. I've never said it didn't ... particularly compared to a situation of no IBIS, no OS, no IS, no VR of any kind at all. I know the first time I used stabilization with a telephoto on a Nikon demo, I was pretty amazed at how much it transformed the ability to handhold things to lower speeds.

justruss wroteI very much doubt the IBIS is very effective at >100-200mm focal lengths, particularly compared to lens-based stabilization designed for a single lens.
But, I think this ^ illustrates the salient point that is worth recognizing when talking about the diff between the IBIS vs. IS approach of two different platforms. When Sony first came out with the concept of IBIS with
...Show more →

Right, but for the most part IBIS > not having IBIS. And IBIS doesn't have to come at the cost of IS, as seen by, for instance, the Sony FE 16-35mm f/4 OSS, 90mm f/2.8 OSS or the longer, stabilized 70-200 f/4. (I only use Sony, because I'm not familiar with other brands using IBIS and their lens lineups.) The system can choose to use the optimized balance between the two, say using IBIS for 2 axis, and lens for the 3 axis better done in-lens-- which is better than having to rely on either system alone.

It doesn't seem to me that the companies that provide IBIS forgo producing plenty of lenses with stabilization when dealing with zooms, or moderate tele lenses and longer. So there's not a ton to consider beyond: Don't expect to take a non-stabilized 70-200mm and expect it to outperform its stabilized brethren just because you mount in on a camera with IBIS (but do expect to get some advantage over the same lens on a camera without IBIS) & you'll have to measure the effectiveness of any IBIS or IS function on a lens-by-lens and camera-by-camera basis.

The short version is: There's virtually no disadvantage to offering IBIS beyond a slight weight penalty. There are lots of advantages. IBIS ≠ IS.
Oct 09, 2015 at 07:08 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.57 #2Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
justruss wrote:
Right, but for the most part IBIS > not having IBIS. And IBIS doesn't have to come at the cost of IS, as seen by, for instance, the Sony FE 16-35mm f/4 OSS, 90mm f/2.8 OSS or the longer, stabilized 70-200 f/4.

Which takes the whole concept of Canon glass on Sony body and tosses it out the window once we start talking about buying Sony glass to do what Canon glass already does on Canon body ... if we are talking about the Sony as an "alternative Canon body" ... rather than a full-on platform change. Imo, once I have to start buying Sony glass to achieve Canon performance, we are no longer discussing an augmentation to Canon, but rather a full-fledged platform change or a split platform or a niche usage. I mean, why do I want to spend $3600 to have a camera that functions worse with my $2000 lens ... so I can spend another $2000 dollars on a Sony lens?

My understanding has largely been that the rationale for much of the Sony love in the Canon forum is its utility with our Canon investments. So far, all I'm understanding with the 100-400L II is a degradation in AF performance and stabilization performance when coupled to the Sony rather than the Canon. Owners of other Canon glass can feel the hit as well. Am I somehow mistaken in this regard?


The short version is: There's virtually no disadvantage to offering IBIS beyond a slight weight penalty. There are lots of advantages.
It seems that this ^ is most appropriate when we include the Sony & Alt glass into the discussion.

IBIS ≠ IS
But, when we consider the full realm of Canon glass as a focal aspect (Canon Forum, owning Canon glass), this ^ seems to be more the prevailing takeaway from what I've been able to understand so far. +1 @ IBIS for non-IS, post-2006 Canon glass, i.e. 24L TS-E II, etc. (niche).
Oct 09, 2015 at 07:22 AM
justruss
Offline
Details
p.57 #3Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RustyBug wrote:
justruss wroteRight, but for the most part IBIS > not having IBIS. And IBIS doesn't have to come at the cost of IS, as seen by, for instance, the Sony FE 16-35mm f/4 OSS, 90mm f/2.8 OSS or the longer, stabilized 70-200 f/4.
Which takes the whole concept of Canon glass on Sony body and tosses it out the window once we start talking about buying Sony glass to do what Canon glass already does on Canon body ... if we are talking about the Sony as an "alternative Canon body" ... rather than a full-on platform change. Imo, once I have to start buying Sony glass to achieve Canon performance, we are no longer discussing an augmentation to Canon, but rather full-fledged platform or split platform. We can get that with Nikon or Pentax too.

My understanding has largely been that the
...Show more →
Earlier quoteThe short version is: There's virtually no disadvantage to offering IBIS beyond a slight weight penalty. There are lots of advantages.
Earlier quoteIBIS ≠ IS


Wait a minute, you're the one bringing all these things up-- not me. Perhaps it is you who is stuck on this idea of using a Sony merely as a stabilized back for Canon glass.

Look, I never advocated buying a Sony camera to use primarily with Canon glass, or that an A7rII would magically turn a Canon 70-200 non-IS into a Canon 70-200 IS. In fact, if you'll see my contribution to this thread (which you're currently quoting in order to argue against a point that I never made)... it was a personal experience with IBIS comparing its use to my Canon 5D2 and Fuji X-E1. That's all.

In fact, what you've done is create a straw-man in order to invent an argument against a point someone-- who doesn't care which system anyone in particular buys (and owns three different systems himself)-- never made. You do remember that in my post a little ways back... I'm the one who brought up that I didn't think IBIS was a replacement for in-lens stabilization... right?

You keep quoting me in order to argue with me-- and then go on to tell me EXACTLY what I said, in my overview of how IBIS fits into my own system, as if I hadn't said it. You're arguing against yourself. That's odd.

It's like if I say: "In the morning the sky was red. In the evening it was blue."

Then you quote me saying, "In the morning the sky was red." And then you make your point: Yeah, but in the evening the sky was blue!

Agreed.
Oct 09, 2015 at 07:51 AM
justruss
Offline
Details
p.57 #4Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Just as a reminder, this all started with a post of mine that went:

"My own personal experience (focal lengths from 17mm to 55mm, all primes, some full-alt) is that IBIS works quite well. Let me illustrate with a relative comparison from general use, not controlled testing..."

Your immediate response was to argue with me as if I was trying to prove any point whatsoever except that IBIS had worked well in my system for my needs. And you made that argument by repeating my own point as if I somehow didn't emphasize it enough, or that my post about "personal experience" was really a veiled attempt to convert all the rest of the Canon heathens to the true light of Sony (please read that last line as snark.)

Oct 09, 2015 at 07:56 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.57 #5Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Russ,

I'm sorry if you think I was arguing with you about your points. Rather I was agreeing with varying points of application ... in context to the aforementioned concept @ stabilized back for Canon glass. I tend to think you fairly present both sides of the coin in many regards. No malice intended, just an understanding of the limitations / benefits afforded rather than a panacea that gets advocated (not by you) by the IBIS / E mount at times.

+1 @ two different animals. Just aspiring for clarity at the distinction where panacea starts and ends for each.

justruss wrote:
Just as a reminder, this all started with a post of mine


Nah, it was something that started way before that.

Snark ... no worries. Likely me not presenting my thoughts as well as might have otherwise been.

Oct 09, 2015 at 08:28 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.57 #6Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
Rusty...show me where I am giving high praise to IBIS.

Geez, I don't even own a camera with IBIS...let alone praising it.


RustyBug wrote:
Chez, if in the proliferation of advocacy of Sony, you have never given such praise to IBIS, then I owe you an apology for my misunderstanding of your historical position.


chez wrote:
If you are going to be shooting Canon lenses, I have no doubt that a dedicated action camera like 7d which can be picked up for less than $500 is the way to go. For other type of photography, I believe the A7R2 is the best way to go as it will work with Canon lenses...even decent AF, has IBIS and can take just about any lens made and be able to manually focus with relative ease.


My misunderstanding of what you were previously stating ... apology extended as offered.

But, I still think it re-iterates the point @ IBIS limitations vs. IS limitations approach ... i.e. two different animals with two different sets of advantages / disadvantages of each.
Oct 09, 2015 at 09:02 AM
justruss
Offline
Details
p.57 #7Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
No worries, Rusty.

We agree, no doubt, about the risk (to the prospective buyer) of any camera being seen as a panacea or unicorn!

Oct 09, 2015 at 09:05 AM
chez
Online
Details
p.57 #8Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII


RustyBug wrote:
+1 @ IBIS has value. I've never said it didn't ... particularly compared to a situation of no IBIS, no OS, no IS, no VR of any kind at all. I know the first time I used stabilization with a telephoto on a Nikon demo, I was pretty amazed at how much it transformed the ability to handhold things to lower speeds.

justruss wroteI very much doubt the IBIS is very effective at >100-200mm focal lengths, particularly compared to lens-based stabilization designed for a single lens.
But, I think this ^ illustrates the salient point that is worth recognizing when talking about the diff between the IBIS vs. IS approach of two different platforms. When Sony first came out with the concept of IBIS with
...Show more →

One thing to note Rusty is that IBIS works with in lens IS...providing even greater stabalization than just in lens IS. The Sony 16-35 lens I use for "MY" street photography has IS in it and it works very well. I don't have the A7R2, yet, but from what I read using the 16-35 or any other Sony lens with in Len stabilization, you get further stabalization from the IBIS resulting in 5 axis of stabalization. More is always better than less.

Now when Sony comes out with their long lenses with stabalization, they will work in concert with the IBIS providing even better stabalization.
How much better...IE: how much slower can I shoot with IBIS and a stabslized lens is the question I'm asking. Renting the A7R2 will give my answers.
Oct 09, 2015 at 10:10 AM
chez
Online
Details
p.57 #9Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII


RustyBug wrote:
justruss wroteRight, but for the most part IBIS > not having IBIS. And IBIS doesn't have to come at the cost of IS, as seen by, for instance, the Sony FE 16-35mm f/4 OSS, 90mm f/2.8 OSS or the longer, stabilized 70-200 f/4.
Which takes the whole concept of Canon glass on Sony body and tosses it out the window once we start talking about buying Sony glass to do what Canon glass already does on Canon body ... if we are talking about the Sony as an "alternative Canon body" ... rather than a full-on platform change. Imo, once I have to start buying Sony glass to achieve Canon performance, we are no longer discussing an augmentation to Canon, but rather a full-fledged platform change or a split platform or a niche usage. I mean, why do I want to spend $3600
...Show more →
Earlier quoteThe short version is: There's virtually no disadvantage to offering IBIS beyond a slight weight penalty. There are lots of advantages.
Earlier quoteIBIS ≠ IS


Well Rusty I use both Canon mount glass and Sony glass on my Sony camera so it does not need to be an all or non to still take advantage of one system versus the other...they are just tools and I use the best tool for the application at hand.
In my case, I wanted a nice street lens and augmented my Canon mount lenses with the Sony 16-35 because of its size and IS. Now with the A7R2, I can use this lens with further stabalization from the IBIS.

Oct 09, 2015 at 10:18 AM
chez
Online
Details
p.57 #10Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII


RustyBug wrote:
chez wroteRusty...show me where I am giving high praise to IBIS.

Geez, I don't even own a camera with IBIS...let alone praising it.
RustyBug wroteChez, if in the proliferation of advocacy of Sony, you have never given such praise to IBIS, then I owe you an apology for my misunderstanding of your historical position.
chez wroteIf you are going to be shooting Canon lenses, I have no doubt that a dedicated action camera like 7d which can be picked up for less than $500 is the way to go. For other type of photography, I believe the A7R2 is the best way to go as it will work with Canon lenses...even decent AF, has IBIS and can take just about any lens made and be able to manually focus with relative ease.
My misunderstanding of what you were previously stating ... apology extended as offered.

But, I still think it re-iterates the point @ IBIS limitations vs. IS limitations approach ... i.e. two different animals with two different sets of advantages / disadvantages of each.


Yes they are different animals but with IBIS does not prohibit in lens IS...but in fact works together with in lens IS to provide even greater stabalization. Not to mention IBIS works with lenses that have no IS at all.
I view IBIS as a full plus with no minuses.
Oct 09, 2015 at 10:24 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.57 #11Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
justruss wrote:
No worries, Rusty.

We agree, no doubt, about the risk (to the prospective buyer) of any camera being seen as a panacea or unicorn!



The unicorn just got more beautiful with the new Voigtlaender ultra-wide lenses announced today in E-mount - at least for me shooting often wide and ultra-wide with the A7R! Small and compact sized UWA manual focus lenses, great to carry around and optimized for the A7 series. More third party companies are now jumping on the E-mount train....

http://www.sonyalpharumors.com/official-voigtlander-launches-three-new-wide-angle-native-full-frame-e-mount-lenses/

Oct 09, 2015 at 01:03 PM
justruss
Offline
Details
p.57 #12Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
I still need a 35mm f/2 that's sharp-sharp wide-open and focuses fast and is of a reasonable size (like up to Tamron 35mm f/1.8 VC... without having to add an inch for an adapter) to feel totally comfortable on this system.

Those Voightlanders are nice looking, though I can't imagine what trying to shoot at 10mm on FF is going to be like. I could see myself with the 12mm and one of either the Sony 16-35 or the 15mm. If I could buy a native Rokinon 18mm f/2... I'd do the all prime thing for sure.
Oct 09, 2015 at 03:28 PM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.57 #13Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
justruss wrote:
I still need a 35mm f/2 that's sharp-sharp wide-open and focuses fast and is of a reasonable size (like up to Tamron 35mm f/1.8 VC... without having to add an inch for an adapter) to feel totally comfortable on this system.

Those Voightlanders are nice looking, though I can't imagine what trying to shoot at 10mm on FF is going to be like. I could see myself with the 12mm and one of either the Sony 16-35 or the 15mm. If I could buy a native Rokinon 18mm f/2... I'd do the all prime thing for sure.


Best small and very good in image quality option is IMO the CV 35/1.2 II lens. A bit more bulky than other smaller 35/2 systems, but it feels right in the hand and balance with the camera. The Loxia 35/2 is another good but also more expensive option.

10 mm seems too wide for me, too. I will likely upgrade my current CV 12/5.6 for M-mount with the announced one in E-mount (depending on pricing and reviews of course).
Oct 09, 2015 at 03:44 PM
Charlie N
Offline
Details
p.57 #14Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
retrofocus wrote:
justruss wroteI still need a 35mm f/2 that's sharp-sharp wide-open and focuses fast and is of a reasonable size (like up to Tamron 35mm f/1.8 VC... without having to add an inch for an adapter) to feel totally comfortable on this system.

Those Voightlanders are nice looking, though I can't imagine what trying to shoot at 10mm on FF is going to be like. I could see myself with the 12mm and one of either the Sony 16-35 or the 15mm. If I could buy a native Rokinon 18mm f/2... I'd do the all prime thing for sure.
Best small and very good in image quality option is IMO the CV 35/1.2 II lens. A bit more bulky than other smaller 35/2 systems, but it feels right in the hand and balance with the camera. The Loxia 35/2 is another good but also more expensive option.

10 mm seems too wide for me, too. I will likely upgrade my current CV 12/5.6 for M-mount with the announced one in E-mount (depending on pricing and reviews of course).


not many CV 12 shooters, but the lens has a new lease on life with the A7rii. Works really well with it. No more magenta cast.... not sure how sony did it, but it's gone.
Oct 09, 2015 at 07:10 PM
justruss
Offline
Details
p.57 #15Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
retrofocus wrote:
justruss wroteI still need a 35mm f/2 that's sharp-sharp wide-open and focuses fast and is of a reasonable size (like up to Tamron 35mm f/1.8 VC... without having to add an inch for an adapter) to feel totally comfortable on this system.

Those Voightlanders are nice looking, though I can't imagine what trying to shoot at 10mm on FF is going to be like. I could see myself with the 12mm and one of either the Sony 16-35 or the 15mm. If I could buy a native Rokinon 18mm f/2... I'd do the all prime thing for sure.
Best small and very good in image quality option is IMO the CV 35/1.2 II lens. A bit more bulky than other smaller 35/2 systems, but it feels right in the hand and balance with the camera. The Loxia 35/2 is another good but also more expensive option.

10 mm seems too wide for me, too. I will likely upgrade my current CV 12/5.6 for M-mount with the announced one in E-mount (depending on pricing and reviews of course).


True, but as I mentioned... I want 35mm f/2.0 and fast AF.
Oct 10, 2015 at 12:23 AM
charlyw
Offline
Details
p.57 #16Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
justruss wrote:
The short version is: There's virtually no disadvantage to offering IBIS beyond a slight weight penalty. There are lots of advantages.


False. There are huge disadvantages to IBIS: you can't have a decent sized heat sink connected to the sensor. There are plenty of problems with the sensor heating up in long exposures and video use with the A7R2.
Oct 10, 2015 at 01:04 AM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.57 #17Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
charlyw wrote:
justruss wroteThe short version is: There's virtually no disadvantage to offering IBIS beyond a slight weight penalty. There are lots of advantages.
False. There are huge disadvantages to IBIS: you can't have a decent sized heat sink connected to the sensor. There are plenty of problems with the sensor heating up in long exposures and video use with the A7R2.


Exactly. There is very rarely a feature that is universally beneficial with no possible drawbacks. Everything is a compromise on some level.
Oct 10, 2015 at 05:57 AM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.57 #18Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
charlyw wrote:
justruss wroteThe short version is: There's virtually no disadvantage to offering IBIS beyond a slight weight penalty. There are lots of advantages.
False. There are huge disadvantages to IBIS: you can't have a decent sized heat sink connected to the sensor. There are plenty of problems with the sensor heating up in long exposures and video use with the A7R2.


Another big (potential) problem with IBIS is the risk of damaging it if you try to clean the sensor yourself. I haven't seen anything from Sony warning about this (but I have't read the manual, either..) but the Sony IBIS is based on the Olympus design, and Olympus explicitly warns that the camera has to be sent in to them for sensor cleaning.

As the Sony sensor dust removal system is not very effective, this could become a real problem as my camera starts to accumulate dust and pollen spots, since Sony Canada's turnaround time for their new third-party service department is over two months, and presumably sensor cleaning will not be covered under warranty (and will therefore cost an arm and a leg like their other services).
Oct 10, 2015 at 07:01 AM
mogul
Offline
Details
p.57 #19Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
molson wrote:
charlyw wrote
justruss wroteThe short version is: There's virtually no disadvantage to offering IBIS beyond a slight weight penalty. There are lots of advantages.
False. There are huge disadvantages to IBIS: you can't have a decent sized heat sink connected to the sensor. There are plenty of problems with the sensor heating up in long exposures and video use with the A7R2.
Another big (potential) problem with IBIS is the risk of damaging it if you try to clean the sensor yourself. I haven't seen anything from Sony warning about this (but I have't read the manual, either..) but the Sony IBIS is based on the Olympus design, and Olympus explicitly warns that the camera has to be sent in to them for sensor cleaning.

As the Sony sensor dust removal system is not very effective, this could become a real problem as my camera starts to accumulate dust and pollen spots, and Sony Canada's turnaround time for their new third-party service
...Show more →
Sony has stated that their IBIS is completely in house and not Oly's design...but it does use magnets and is not mechanical as in the A mount IBIS. Cleaning will depend if it locks down in the off position or floats. It is full frame, so is probably a lot more stout than the 110 format that Olympus uses.
Oct 10, 2015 at 07:06 AM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.57 #20Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
mogul wrote:
molson wrote
charlyw wrote
justruss wroteThe short version is: There's virtually no disadvantage to offering IBIS beyond a slight weight penalty. There are lots of advantages.
False. There are huge disadvantages to IBIS: you can't have a decent sized heat sink connected to the sensor. There are plenty of problems with the sensor heating up in long exposures and video use with the A7R2.
Another big (potential) problem with IBIS is the risk of damaging it if you try to clean the sensor yourself. I haven't seen anything from Sony warning about this (but I have't read the manual, either..) but the Sony IBIS is based on the Olympus design, and Olympus explicitly warns that the camera has to be sent in to them for sensor cleaning.

As the Sony sensor dust removal system is not very effective, this could become a real problem as my camera starts to accumulate dust and pollen spots, and Sony Canada's turnaround time for their new third-party service department is over two months for simple repairs...
Sony has stated that their IBIS is completely in house and not Oly's design...but it does use magnets and is not mechanical as in the A mount IBIS. Cleaning will depend if it locks down in the off position or floats. It is full frame, so is probably a lot more stout than the 110 format that Olympus uses.


Are your Sony cheerleader pom-poms effective for cleaning your sensor?

I guess that explains why it does such a poor job in shaking off dust, and why why it consumes so much battery power, and why the camera is so heavy... or maybe Sony just built it "more stout" because they new it would require constant wet cleaning?
Oct 10, 2015 at 07:36 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister