bhollis wrote:
darbo wrote
Processing photos from a recent shoot today - roughly 75% 5DS R and 25% a7R II. Here's my take:
The a7R II images just seem more lively and vibrant, while the 5DS R images appear more refined and subdued. I love both looks, but generally am attracted a bit more to the 5DS R look for my architectural work. I have neither a 5DS nor a A7RII, but I do have a 5D3 and RX1R, and I generally agree with your characterization of the differences in appearance of the Canon vs Sony files. I'd also describe the Sony files as having a more digital look, while the Canon files are more film-like. The Sony files are more "brash" to my eye (although not overly so IMO), while the Canon files are more "muted"--for lack of better adjectives.
And I also agree that there's room to like both.
I can compare from own experience RAW files processed in LR taken with the 5D MkII and the A7R. In my opinion LR uses the better RAW processor algorithm with the Canon RAW files. The Sony RAW files need a few more adjustments afterwards. I read Capture One works much better with the Sony RAW files, but I have no experience with this program yet. I also see the Sony RAW files better processed with the Sony RAW converter freeware. One difference between Canon and Sony RAWs which I often see is in the green channel - the green color is much more saturated in the Sony RAW files. The Canon RAW files seem to be a bit more on the bluish side. For color photography, I often increase saturation of my Canon files more towards yellow/red, whereas I often reduce green and sometimes yellow in my Sony files.
Regarding film-like look, I see a bigger advantage here in the Sony files especially in the B&W camera processed JPGs which come out nice in contrast and detail which reminds me a lot on B&W film.