fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII

  
 
SoftImage
Offline
Details
p.51 #1Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
darbo wrote:
SoftImage wrote
bhollis wrote
darbo wroteProcessing photos from a recent shoot today - roughly 75% 5DS R and 25% a7R II. Here's my take:
The a7R II images just seem more lively and vibrant, while the 5DS R images appear more refined and subdued. I love both looks, but generally am attracted a bit more to the 5DS R look for my architectural work.
I have neither a 5DS nor a A7RII, but I do have a 5D3 and RX1R, and I generally agree with your characterization of the differences in appearance of the Canon vs Sony files. I'd also describe the Sony files as having a more digital look, while the Canon files are more film-like. The Sony files are more "brash" to my eye (although not overly so IMO), while the Canon files are more "muted"--for lack of better adjectives.

And I also agree that there's room to like both.
Not sure what's happening with Sony greens, some call it toxic green.

https://www.flickr.com/photos/albertdros/20892325553/

https://www.flickr.com/photos/clickpix_eu/20287583053/
If you use "camera landscape" in LR or in Sony's Image Data Converter you can get those radioactive greens. I admit I struggle more with greens on my a7 series cameras than I do with my Canon cameras. I regard Philip Reeve as the master of greens - the greens in his work looks amazing with the a7 series.

That said, I actually really like the greens in that first image and the second one is just a bit saturated for those in-shadow greens. The a7R II, however, made a nice improvement over previous a7 series cameras regarding color rendition
...Show more →

I didn't know about SoftImage software before reading your comment. What a coincidence! No wonder why someone once said, all good names are taken.
I am just a photo enthusiast, know nothing about software development.
Oct 01, 2015 at 12:13 AM
justruss
Offline
Details
p.51 #2Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
gdanmitchell wrote:
After shooting with more than one brand of camera and also comparing prints from the multiple brands and formats that friends and associates use... I firmly believe that while there are differences in out-of-camera files, once a skillful photographer takes the files through an optimized post-processing workflow the majority of the differences disappear. (Yes, things like dynamic range, grain size, noise levels and so forth will not be identical.)

It is even quite hard in most cases to tell whether, for example, the print came from a MF digital system or a FF digital system.

As to "film like" appearance, I've
...Show more →

I agree, to a point.

But different files in different software have an impact on the workflow when approaching one's own, defined look. This means that the steps taken (or even tools used) to capture, process, and output something from my Canon are different from my Fuji (and Sony). One might even say that one of my cameras makes getting to my desired output easier than the other (and no, I'm not making that judgement). So yes, one can normalize looks, but that doesn't mean there isn't an optimal tool for a given photographer and her desired output.

As an aside (leading to a rumination): I definitely find that my A7rII RAW files can take way, way more processing than my 5D2 or Fuji and hold together. And I've seen a similar thing, to a lesser extent, with the 5Ds(r) files and output from other members. Part of the learning curve, I think (analogous to when we first switched from film to digital) is that this latitude and freedom makes it so much easier to take our images across that threshold (subjectivity warning) into territory where the final output is no longer an honest representation of what we've seen (not just felt). I think there's a new sort of learning required: for so long it was tool + skills that held your average photographer back from creating convincing looking fakes (they were always possible, just harder to achieve)... but now it's ever more shifting towards restraint from the photographer/processor that keeps images looking realistic. I find it troubling that this restraint is being eroded; I look at so many images (from both amateurs and professionals) that look unrealistic, and I think it's having an impact on how society views (or rather imagines) the real world to look. It's like highly photoshopped men and women on magazine covers quietly (in recesses of our brain where we process reality's natural variations) changing our weighted view of what, say, the actual variation in ratios between leg length and diameter included (making room already that people who appear on covers are already outside the normal variation, which I'm OK with).

Short version: I think a lot of images I see from the 5Ds(r), A7(x), and other new, high resolution, high file latitude cameras look like convincing unrealism because these cameras, and modern software (haze removal) put the ball back into our court for keeping things real. And we just aren't good at that (no thanks, in part, to marketing and advertising's consumerist impact).

With great latitude comes great responsibility.

/rant.
Oct 01, 2015 at 02:23 AM
Monito
Offline
Details
p.51 #3Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
I would rather have convincing unrealism than unconvincing realism.

My aim when making photos, especially landscape photos, is to capture the feeling of the scene when I saw it. As suggested above, this requires care to not go overboard.

The human visual system integrates information from the eye as it roves a scene and builds up a visual impression (an enhanced image) in the visual cortex of the brain (outer surface at the upper back of the brain).

Our post-processing mimics this accretion of enhancements.

Shots straight out of the camera don't have the feeling (in Raw) unless I were to shoot in some picture style straight to JPEG, which would lose the Raws. The shots are unconvincing because they lack the punch and impact that the scene had on me. They are a bit flat, most often. This is because I have my picture style at Faithful and low control settings -- so I can make more accurate HistoBlinkyMeter assessments. The conversion software generally respects the picture style settings used in the camera, as a starting point.

I dial up stuff in Lightroom and push and pull things and brush this and that until I think it looks good (having impact) and then I often dial it all back just a bit. For example, take saturation down from 15 to 12 as well as similar steps back on other sliders.

With the 5DS, I have experienced the same kind of joy I had with the 5D classic, and more because everything is better. As somebody wrote on another thread -- a 5D classic on steroids.
Oct 01, 2015 at 04:12 AM
Sneakyracer
Offline
Details
p.51 #4Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
matejphoto wrote:
I have a Canon 5D mark II (since Jan 2009) and have been patiently waiting for a significant upgrade in sensor tech. 5D mark III looks great but for my work I don't need the speed.

The 5Ds looked like the answer but the lack of increase in dynamic range is disappointing to me. Are any of you who were gonna buy the 5Ds are now considering the Sony A7rII?

If the 5Ds had the dynamic range of the Sony sensors, I would not look any further. It just seems silly to buy old sensor tech at nearly $4000.


For Landscape and Architecture work on a tripod I would choose the A7RII over any Canon any day.

The Sony can use almost any lens including tech camera lenses from Schneider and Rodenstock (using A body like an Cambo Actus) and the awesome Canon TS-E lenses. The Sony has much more dynamic range and better high iso performance to boot. Never mind the in body IS and awesome EVF.

The Canon has a tiny bit more resolution and better battery performance. Also, the Canon has a better sensor clean system which greatly reduces (to almost zero) the need to do dust busting in post production. This is key for those who shoot and need to deliver a lot of images quickly.

All that said, for people work, specially in a studio using flash lights I would choose the 5DS/R. I just do not like EVFs in dimly lit studios and prefer the zero lag and faster shutter response of the Canon.



Oct 01, 2015 at 06:57 AM
Gunzorro
Offline
Details
p.51 #5Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Sneakyracer wrote:
matejphoto wroteI have a Canon 5D mark II (since Jan 2009) and have been patiently waiting for a significant upgrade in sensor tech. 5D mark III looks great but for my work I don't need the speed.

The 5Ds looked like the answer but the lack of increase in dynamic range is disappointing to me. Are any of you who were gonna buy the 5Ds are now considering the Sony A7rII?

If the 5Ds had the dynamic range of the Sony sensors, I would not look any further. It just seems silly to buy old sensor tech at nearly $4000.
For Landscape and Architecture work on a tripod I would choose the A7RII over any Canon any day.

The Sony can use almost any lens including tech camera lenses from Schneider and Rodenstock (using A body like an Cambo Actus) and the awesome Canon TS-E lenses. The Sony has much more dynamic range and better high iso performance to boot. Never mind the in body IS and awesome EVF.

The Canon has a tiny bit more resolution and better battery performance. Also, the Canon has a better sensor clean system which greatly reduces (to almost zero) the need to do
...Show more →

Reads as a pretty sensible approach. The Canon seems more versatile on a day to day basis, the Sony more versatile on a shot to shot basis. I can see a place for them both in a photographer's collection of gear.
Oct 01, 2015 at 08:26 AM
Schlotkins
Offline
Details
p.51 #6Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Gunzorro wrote:
Sneakyracer wrote
matejphoto wroteI have a Canon 5D mark II (since Jan 2009) and have been patiently waiting for a significant upgrade in sensor tech. 5D mark III looks great but for my work I don't need the speed.

The 5Ds looked like the answer but the lack of increase in dynamic range is disappointing to me. Are any of you who were gonna buy the 5Ds are now considering the Sony A7rII?

If the 5Ds had the dynamic range of the Sony sensors, I would not look any further. It just seems silly to buy old sensor tech at nearly $4000.
For Landscape and Architecture work on a tripod I would choose the A7RII over any Canon any day.

The Sony can use almost any lens including tech camera lenses from Schneider and Rodenstock (using A body like an Cambo Actus) and the awesome Canon TS-E lenses. The Sony has much more dynamic range and better high iso performance to boot. Never mind the in body IS and awesome EVF.

The Canon has a tiny bit more resolution and better battery performance. Also, the Canon has a better sensor clean system which greatly reduces (to almost zero) the need to do dust busting in post production. This is key for those who shoot and need to deliver a lot of images quickly.

All that said, for people work, specially in a studio using flash lights I would choose the 5DS/R. I just do not like EVFs in dimly lit studios and prefer the zero lag and faster shutter response of the Canon.
Reads as a pretty sensible approach. The Canon seems more versatile on a day to day basis, the Sony more versatile on a shot to shot basis. I can see a place for them both in a photographer's collection of gear.


I think this sums up things nicely.
Chris
Oct 01, 2015 at 08:32 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.51 #7Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
If you need to use lots of unusual and old-school lenses, you can do this more easily on a Sony A7r-series body. I know there are a few folks who are passionate about that potential — but the reality is that most photographers select a relatively small number of lenses that are optimized in functional and IQ ways for their photography, and that these are typically relatively recent lenses that have auto-focus and other modern capabilities. Even the folks I know who use the Sony system for (mostly) street photography or landscape photography are generally using fairly conventional lenses.

However, it is hard to argue with the idea that if you feel the need to use alt and similar lenses, the Sony platform has the adapters to support them.

As to image quality, in practical terms it is probably more or less a wash. The Sony sensor provides a bit more dynamic range (the exact magnitude of this difference and its effects are open to debate) and slightly less noise when things are pushed, but the Canon alternative is no slouch in these areas either. The Canon provides the highest sensor resolution, but the difference between 50.6MP and 42MP is hardly a big deal — in most cases it is more or less meaningless.

Frankly, you can make outstanding photographs with either system, and some of the hyperventilating about the image quality superiority of one or the other strikes me as being more a case of confirmation bias and/or wishful thinking on both sides.

The most significant differences probably come down to more functional and practical things. Does the camera body size make much difference to you? How important is the ability to shoot at very high ISO? How much long-exposure night photography do you do? What role does video play in your work? How important are long or short or alt or other special categories of lenses to you in your photography? How important is reliable and consistent AF with any lens you want/need to use? How do you feel about using adapters and so forth? If you currently use one brand or the other, how much do you think it is worth it for you to do a switch or an augmentation?

If you are hoping for a radical transformation of the quality of your work by deciding to choose a different camera/lens brand from among these... while the thrill of the new acquisition may make it seem like a transformation is likely, check back in a year or two and let's see how much your photography has actually changed.

Dan

Edited on Oct 01, 2015 at 09:54 AM · View previous versions
Oct 01, 2015 at 08:37 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.51 #8Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Sneakyracer wrote:
matejphoto wroteI have a Canon 5D mark II (since Jan 2009) and have been patiently waiting for a significant upgrade in sensor tech. 5D mark III looks great but for my work I don't need the speed.

The 5Ds looked like the answer but the lack of increase in dynamic range is disappointing to me. Are any of you who were gonna buy the 5Ds are now considering the Sony A7rII?

If the 5Ds had the dynamic range of the Sony sensors, I would not look any further. It just seems silly to buy old sensor tech at nearly $4000.
For Landscape and Architecture work on a tripod I would choose the A7RII over any Canon any day.

The Sony can use almost any lens including tech camera lenses from Schneider and Rodenstock (using A body like an Cambo Actus) and the awesome Canon TS-E lenses. The Sony has much more dynamic range and better high iso performance to boot. Never mind the in body IS and awesome EVF.

The Canon has a tiny bit more resolution and better battery performance. Also, the Canon has a better sensor clean system which greatly reduces (to almost zero) the need to do
...Show more →

Fully agree on the first two paragraphs above. Regarding dust on the sensor, I already see the difference on my A7R compared with the 5D MkII. The sensor glass is simply much closer to the camera cap in the mirrorless camera, so when I change lenses on my A7R often, I get more easily a lot more dust and pollen on the sensor. With a similar amount of lens changes on my 5D MKII, I don't get as much dust built up there because the sensor sits much further in the camera back (and I can clearly tell from my IR-converted 5D MkII which has even the ultrasonic cleaner removed). Possible that the ultrasonic cleaning was improved in the 5Ds(R) also, this might even increase this difference.

Can't comment on the difference in studio conditions since I am not doing studio photography at all.
Oct 01, 2015 at 08:42 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.51 #9Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
gdanmitchell wrote:
If you need to use lots of unusual and old-school lenses, you can do this more easily on a Sony A7r-series body. I know there are a few folks who are passionate about that potential — but the reality is that most photographers select a relatively small number of lenses that are optimized in functional and IQ ways for their photography, and that these are typically relatively recent lenses that have auto-focus and other modern capabilities. Even the folks I know who use the Sony system for (mostly) street photography or landscape photography are generally using fairly conventional lenses.

However, it
...Show more →

This is a post I can agree with. I often mix up more modern lenses with older Minolta and FD-based lenses, as well as (and meanwhile my main use on the Sony A7R) rangefinder lenses. I would also agree that most others I know which are using Sony A7-based cameras are using them meanwhile with Sony FE lenses.

Other than that I personally believe that Canon's timing for the 5Ds(R) was off and came too late to the market, I agree that choosing either 5Ds(R), D810, or Sony A7R series cameras is more for practical reasons and personal shooting preference. To me sensor performance is very important, and I benefit a lot from the DR of the Sony sensor. Camera size plays an important role and MF lens adaptability (I never made even once a bad experience by using different adapters). But I also compromise in AF performance (which I rarely need to rely on) and on fps performance (single shot is most often fine for me especially since I rarely need to bracket anymore with the A7R).

My style of photography wasn't changed after I acquired the A7R last year, but the way I am shooting did. I can easily pack now a set of 4-6 prime lenses in a fairly small camera bag with my A7R which was impossible with my DSLR gear. I saw the benefit when travelling or hiking with my gear a lot. To me the addition of FF mirrorless proved to be a huge benefit.
Oct 01, 2015 at 08:55 AM
mttran
Offline
Details
p.51 #10Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
No more new DSLR for me. A7Rii still has room in DR to boost for the whole iso range so I wait for the next BSI RS version. At the mean time my A7, A7R and 1Ds2 are doing well, they are comparable to 5Ds(r) and A7Rii for what I am doing
Oct 01, 2015 at 09:06 AM
dgdg
Offline
Details
p.51 #11Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
+1

I think if long exposure noise, which I have yet to test in real world situations, were reportedly good, I'd be tempted to get the A7RII. For now, 5D3 and A7R do not limit me. Only my opportunities to get out limit my photography.
Oct 01, 2015 at 09:20 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.51 #12Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
retrofocus wrote:
especially in the B&W camera processed JPGs which come out nice in contrast and detail which reminds me a lot on B&W film.


While I haven't seen that mono from the Sony files personally (I believe you) ... imo, that's (in part) because of the better contrast that you get from going true no-AA filter (vs. offset approach), as I see what you described similarly in my SLR/C (which in turn requires less "push" to get the desired contrast).

Oct 01, 2015 at 11:22 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.51 #13Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RustyBug wrote:
retrofocus wroteespecially in the B&W camera processed JPGs which come out nice in contrast and detail which reminds me a lot on B&W film.
While I haven't seen that mono from the Sony files personally (I believe you) ... imo, that's (in part) because of the better contrast that you get from going true no-AA filter (vs. offset approach), as I see what you described similarly in my SLR/C (which in turn requires less "push" to get the desired contrast).



Could be, not sure - I suspect it is also from the Bionz processer based created JPG files which seem in general more contrasty looking. I tested it by saving the photo both in RAW and as JPG on the SD card. I saved the JPG file as B&W file. Since the RAW file still was in color, I tried to post process it with Nik Silver Efex to get a similar look as the JPG file from the camera. Sometimes still the JPG file looked better than the B&W post-processed RAW file.

Your point regarding the AA filter is well taken because I see also a much richer contrast effect in my IR-converted 5D MkII camera which has the AA filter removed. I get great B&W photos with this camera, too.
Oct 01, 2015 at 11:36 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.51 #14Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Yeah, something about fuzz > re-fuzz > unfuzz ... just too much fuzziness in that process for me if I can otherwise avoid it.

I may not need 36, 42 or 50 MP, but I do still prefer a crisper starting point, when I can get it.
Oct 01, 2015 at 12:01 PM
mttran
Offline
Details
p.51 #15Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RustyBug wrote:
Yeah, something about fuzz > re-fuzz > unfuzz ... just too much fuzziness in that process for me if I can otherwise avoid it.

I may not need 36, 42 or 50 MP, but I do still prefer a crisper starting point, when I can get it.


Here ya go Rust:

A7 vs 5DSR: http://c2.staticflickr.com/6/5743/21709054318_3933af15d8_o.jpg
A7R vs 5Dsr: http://c2.staticflickr.com/6/5779/21896234265_7408ca348c_o.jpg
A7R2 vs 5Dsr: http://c1.staticflickr.com/1/670/21870047826_abee944e98_o.jpg

Sony mirror less is your best bet to get a better crisper look
Oct 02, 2015 at 03:51 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.51 #16Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Links won't open ... contains errors message.

I have little doubt at the crispness of the mirrorless without an AA filter. Even my Panny FZ1000 has some nice crispness to it. I just can't stand the ergonomics of the Sony for me. The A7R2 is a bit better, but I'll wait to see if they come around with something like an E99R ... then we could be talking about something of interest if they put that BSI into better (for me) body.

I mean, I did go as far as to purchase a grip for the A7 / A7R ... but even that doesn't help with my ergonomics enough.
Oct 02, 2015 at 08:08 PM
mttran
Offline
Details
p.51 #17Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RustyBug wrote:
Links won't open ... contains errors message.


hmm, I just try and they are opened fine. Those were compiled from the original so everyone of them is a huge file. It takes time to load them. BTW, all original are from IR. Left = A7series ; Right = 5Dsr
Oct 02, 2015 at 09:10 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.51 #18Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII


mttran wrote:
RustyBug wroteLinks won't open ... contains errors message.
hmm, I just try and they are opened fine. Those were compiled from the original so everyone of them is a huge file. It takes time to load them. BTW, all original are from IR. Left = A7series ; Right = 5Dsr


Links are fine from an iPhone.
Oct 02, 2015 at 09:47 PM
mttran
Offline
Details
p.51 #19Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
mttran wrote
RustyBug wroteLinks won't open ... contains errors message.
hmm, I just try and they are opened fine. Those were compiled from the original so everyone of them is a huge file. It takes time to load them. BTW, all original are from IR. Left = A7series ; Right = 5Dsr
Links are fine from an iPhone.


Thank you, Chez. I throw in the A6000 (L) vs 5Dsr (R) just for crisper fun: http://c1.staticflickr.com/1/610/21890409112_c2636f4841_o.jpg
Oct 02, 2015 at 10:04 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.51 #20Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
mttran wrote:
RustyBug wroteYeah, something about fuzz > re-fuzz > unfuzz ... just too much fuzziness in that process for me if I can otherwise avoid it.

I may not need 36, 42 or 50 MP, but I do still prefer a crisper starting point, when I can get it.
Here ya go Rust:

A7 vs 5DSR: http://c2.staticflickr.com/6/5779/21896234265_7408ca348c_o.jpg
A7R2 vs 5Dsr: _http://c1.staticflickr.com/1/670/21870047826_abee944e98_o.jpg

Sony]http://c2.staticflickr.com/6/5743/21709054318_3933af15d8_o.jpg
A7R vs 5Dsr: _http://c2.staticflickr.com/6/5779/21896234265_7408ca348c_o.jpg
A7R2 vs 5Dsr: _http://c1.staticflickr.com/1/670/21870047826_abee944e98_o.jpg

Sony[/url] mirror less is your best bet to get a better crisper look


The Canon images are shot with a Sigma 70 mm lens, and the Sony images are shot with a Sony Zeiss 55 mm lens. It might be just the difference between the lenses we see here. A direct comparison like this must use the same lens to be meaningful.
Oct 03, 2015 at 03:39 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister