fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII

  
 
darbo
Offline
Details
p.44 #1Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
Yeh...the latest pro lenses sure aren't cheap in my books. The new 35L is ridiculously expensive.


The 35L II looks ridiculously amazing.

Just a little more than the also excellent FE 35mm f/1.4 ZA, and I imagine it will drop down after a while just as the Sony model has. Optically the 35L II looks right up there with my Otus 55mm. It's a must-have for me...now to find an unguarded bank.

Anyway, that's a nice counter example of a 2015 Sony lens being less than a comparable (if optically superior - which remains to be seen) 2015 Canon lens.
Sep 03, 2015 at 08:22 AM
Dave McGaughey
Offline
Details
p.44 #2Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
Dave McGaughey wrote
chez wrote
Dave McGaughey wroteOne comment as a lens system nativist (AF): you have FAR more choices for reasonably priced, high quality system lenses with Canon. This is especially true for primes.

Sony doesn't have direct comparable (quality/price/existence) prime lenses for 24/2.8, 35/2, 50/1.8, 85/1.8, and anything above 100mm. In fact they only have one reasonably* priced prime lens: the 28/2.

* I don't consider a $1200 85/1.8 to be reasonably priced. Yeah, it's probably awesome and definitely Zeiss-y but I'd rather have a a 24/2.8 IS, 35/2 USM IS, and a 85/1.8 that are merely "very" good. I'd also rather have a $125 50/1.8 and $800 in my pocket.
True...but the flip side to this is the vast number if great small manual focus lenses available for very reasonable prices that can easily be used with the A7R2. Manually focusing the A7R is a breeze and really takes away the game of placing the little red rectangle onto what you want in focus. Once you get good at manually focusing, it becomes liberating to not worry about focus points.
Sure, but I don't care about that. AF is awesome.

An important point is that AF/MF ease aren't mutually exclusive for a mirrorless. Sony could produce these lenses, but they either won't or can't. Fuji, in roughly the same amount of time, has released numerous nice (though slightly pricey) prime lenses.
Come on...DSLR's are not made with MF in mind and are a pain the manually focus lenses using the viewfinder. I've done it for years with my 5d2 and compared to manually focusing with the A7R...it's painful and not accurate.

Sony's lens roadmap is filling in nicely especially with Zeiss contributing. I cover all my shooting situations using a combination of Sony, Canon, Zeiss and Zuiko lenses.



Huh? I wasn't making any comment about MF with a DSLR. It's obvious that a mirrorless is way better for this use case. But it's not a use case I care about.

I tried a Nex7 with MF glass and it was a massive PITA for how I shoot (moving people, wide open, not very far away). I'm full in on AF. The only time I'd consider using MF is for a uber wide angle lens dedicated landscape purposes (like the Rokinon 14mm).

Sony's lens roadmap is NOT filling in nicely for someone who like reasonably priced reasonably fast prime lenses. As I pointed out earlier, they have ONE affordable f2 or faster prime lens. And it's in a focal length I don't care for.
Sep 03, 2015 at 08:23 AM
Cliff L.
Online
Details
p.44 #3Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
I don't have first hand experience with using them in AF mode, but from the many posts, it seems like they are very capable on the A7R2...


I've heard that the AF with adapters is worse on the A7rII than it is on the A7II, and the AF on that camera is terrible - even with native FE mount Sony lenses.
Sep 03, 2015 at 08:27 AM
chez
Offline
Details
p.44 #4Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Dave McGaughey wrote:
chez wrote
jctriguy wrote
Dave McGaughey wrote
chez wrote
Dave McGaughey wroteOne comment as a lens system nativist (AF): you have FAR more choices for reasonably priced, high quality system lenses with Canon. This is especially true for primes.

Sony doesn't have direct comparable (quality/price/existence) prime lenses for 24/2.8, 35/2, 50/1.8, 85/1.8, and anything above 100mm. In fact they only have one reasonably* priced prime lens: the 28/2.

* I don't consider a $1200 85/1.8 to be reasonably priced. Yeah, it's probably awesome and definitely Zeiss-y but I'd rather have a a 24/2.8 IS, 35/2 USM IS, and a 85/1.8 that are merely "very" good. I'd also rather have a $125 50/1.8 and $800 in my pocket.
True...but the flip side to this is the vast number if great small manual focus lenses available for very reasonable prices that can easily be used with the A7R2. Manually focusing the A7R is a breeze and really takes away the game of placing the little red rectangle onto what you want in focus. Once you get good at manually focusing, it becomes liberating to not worry about focus points.
Sure, but I don't care about that. AF is awesome.

An important point is that AF/MF ease aren't mutually exclusive for a mirrorless. Sony could produce these lenses, but they either won't or can't. Fuji, in roughly the same amount of time, has released numerous nice (though slightly pricey) prime lenses.
+1 the range of AF lenses for canon and Nikon is a huge plus for people entering a new system, or wanting to fill out an existing system. When you can buy a whole lot of lenses for the price of a single prime, that has a huge impact. Some don't want to rely on MF and adapted glass in a new $4000 camera.
Well, the beauty is many of those "cheap" AF glass can also be used on the A7R2 with AF. I don't have first hand experience with using them in AF mode, but from the many posts, it seems like they are very capable on the A7R2...and that with generation 1 of the adapters. I can image these adapters will improve in the future with AF getting better with new generations. There is also a mini business being formed here with competition between multiple adapters so I'm thinking we'll see quick improvement in the AF area.
Eh, I'll believe when I see it. I won't tolerate having to reboot my camera because my adapter has locked it up because I focused too close. Etc etc.

I got burned twice buying things (Nex7, Fuji X-Pro1) that "could" be awesome, but weren't actually ready now.

That's why I'm hanging with the stupid herd with my boring, reliable, and attractively priced Canon system.


That's the beauty of having choices...we all can choose what works for each of us.
Sep 03, 2015 at 08:30 AM
chez
Offline
Details
p.44 #5Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
molson wrote:
chez wroteI don't have first hand experience with using them in AF mode, but from the many posts, it seems like they are very capable on the A7R2...
I've heard that the AF with adapters is worse on the A7rII than it is on the A7II, and the AF on that camera is terrible - even with native FE mount Sony lenses.


I've seen contradicting posts so like everything else, if I'm to evaluate the AF accuracy, I'll rent out a system for myself and test it out with the lenses and type of shooting I do. The Internet tests and results are full of discrepancies, too much to rely on any of it.

What I'm impressed with is the fact you can AF Canon lenses on Sony cameras. No one would have thought this was possible a couple years ago...yet it is here today, in it's early stages. I just wonder where it will be 5 years from now.

I remember the experts on these boards claim there is no way of IBIS for full frame sensors....just way too big to move...yet again here we are today with IBIS that actually works in tandem with lens based IS.

Pushing technology further will I'm sure amaze us in the coming years.
Sep 03, 2015 at 08:36 AM
Dave McGaughey
Offline
Details
p.44 #6Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
Dave McGaughey wrote
chez wrote
jctriguy wrote
Dave McGaughey wrote
chez wroteTrue...but the flip side to this is the vast number if great small manual focus lenses available for very reasonable prices that can easily be used with the A7R2. Manually focusing the A7R is a breeze and really takes away the game of placing the little red rectangle onto what you want in focus. Once you get good at manually focusing, it becomes liberating to not worry about focus points.
Sure, but I don't care about that. AF is awesome.

An important point is that AF/MF ease aren't mutually exclusive for a mirrorless. Sony could produce these lenses, but they either won't or can't. Fuji, in roughly the same amount of time, has released numerous nice (though slightly pricey) prime lenses.
+1 the range of AF lenses for canon and Nikon is a huge plus for people entering a new system, or wanting to fill out an existing system. When you can buy a whole lot of lenses for the price of a single prime, that has a huge impact. Some don't want to rely on MF and adapted glass in a new $4000 camera.
Well, the beauty is many of those "cheap" AF glass can also be used on the A7R2 with AF. I don't have first hand experience with using them in AF mode, but from the many posts, it seems like they are very capable on the A7R2...and that with generation 1 of the adapters. I can image these adapters will improve in the future with AF getting better with new generations. There is also a mini business being formed here with competition between multiple adapters so I'm thinking we'll see quick improvement in the AF area.
Eh, I'll believe when I see it. I won't tolerate having to reboot my camera because my adapter has locked it up because I focused too close. Etc etc.

I got burned twice buying things (Nex7, Fuji X-Pro1) that "could" be awesome, but weren't actually ready now.

That's why I'm hanging with the stupid herd with my boring, reliable, and attractively priced Canon system.
That's the beauty of having choices...we all can choose what works for each of us.



Yes. It'd also be nice if everyone here would remember that when posting. Odd how some people keep harping on how awesome the A7RII is at XYZ while pretending that there aren't some very real downsides to the Sony system.
Sep 03, 2015 at 08:42 AM
Cliff L.
Online
Details
p.44 #7Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
molson wrote
chez wroteI don't have first hand experience with using them in AF mode, but from the many posts, it seems like they are very capable on the A7R2...
I've heard that the AF with adapters is worse on the A7rII than it is on the A7II, and the AF on that camera is terrible - even with native FE mount Sony lenses.
I've seen contradicting posts so like everything else, if I'm to evaluate the AF accuracy, I'll rent out a system for myself and test it out with the lenses and type of shooting I do. The Internet tests and results are full of discrepancies, too much to rely on any of it.


I don't rely on internet information for much any more... I buy the gear that interests me, and try to use it the way I need to, to make the images I want. I sold my A7 II because no lens other than the FE 16-35 would focus reliably, and I found the benefits of the IBIS to be marginal at best.

I've owned the A7, A7R (on my third one now), and A7 II. The only one that didn't disappointed was the A7, and that's probably only because I had pretty low expectations for it. Now that my long-term Sony experiment has concluded, I wish Sony Canada could figure out how to replace the rear LCD on my A7R and get it back to me so I can list it on eBay before it's completely worthless...
Sep 03, 2015 at 08:49 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.44 #8Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
I can image these adapters will improve in the future with AF getting better with new generations. There is also a mini business being formed here with competition between multiple adapters so I'm thinking we'll see quick improvement in the AF area.


chez wrote:
Sony's lens roadmap is filling in nicely especially with Zeiss contributing.



There you have it. It will be much better in some time. Maybe. I already have 2 Metabones smart adapters. How many more adapters will I have to get before AF will work with all the AF lenses I use? How long will we have to wait for Sony to provide uncompressed RAW? Some hope for firmware to fix hot pixels. Some wait for the next camera with Exmor RS since Exmor R wasn't that much more than Exmor anyway. Sony may have the system for the future, but Canon has the system for today. The 5DS R gets me the shot, in focus, no questions asked, and the files are predictable and awesome.
Sep 03, 2015 at 09:01 AM
darbo
Offline
Details
p.44 #9Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
molson wrote:
Now that my long-term Sony experiment has concluded, I wish Sony Canada could figure out how to replace the rear LCD on my A7R and get it back to me so I can list it on eBay before it's completely worthless...


That has to be frustrating - I know that people can have service issues with any manufacturer, but I sure see a lot of this that catches my attention. As I referenced earlier, these anecdotes, which seem rather abundant for Sony users, pushed me back to the 5DS / 5DS R. A real bummer to me because in most ways the a7R II seems ideally suited for much of my photography. I was looking forward to putting my Apo Sonnar 2/135mm ZE on the a7R II's stabilized sensor.

For now, I'll just stick to my a7R rather than upgrade to a7R II. I can't decide if I would rather just pick up another a7R on the FM buy/sell for under $1000 to have redundant a7R's rather than the a7r II.
Sep 03, 2015 at 09:01 AM
chez
Offline
Details
p.44 #10Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII


Dave McGaughey wrote:
chez wrote
Dave McGaughey wrote
chez wrote
jctriguy wrote
Dave McGaughey wroteSure, but I don't care about that. AF is awesome.

An important point is that AF/MF ease aren't mutually exclusive for a mirrorless. Sony could produce these lenses, but they either won't or can't. Fuji, in roughly the same amount of time, has released numerous nice (though slightly pricey) prime lenses.
+1 the range of AF lenses for canon and Nikon is a huge plus for people entering a new system, or wanting to fill out an existing system. When you can buy a whole lot of lenses for the price of a single prime, that has a huge impact. Some don't want to rely on MF and adapted glass in a new $4000 camera.
Well, the beauty is many of those "cheap" AF glass can also be used on the A7R2 with AF. I don't have first hand experience with using them in AF mode, but from the many posts, it seems like they are very capable on the A7R2...and that with generation 1 of the adapters. I can image these adapters will improve in the future with AF getting better with new generations. There is also a mini business being formed here with competition between multiple adapters so I'm thinking we'll see quick improvement in the AF area.
Eh, I'll believe when I see it. I won't tolerate having to reboot my camera because my adapter has locked it up because I focused too close. Etc etc.

I got burned twice buying things (Nex7, Fuji X-Pro1) that "could" be awesome, but weren't actually ready now.

That's why I'm hanging with the stupid herd with my boring, reliable, and attractively priced Canon system.
That's the beauty of having choices...we all can choose what works for each of us.
Yes. It'd also be nice if everyone here would remember that when posting. Odd how some people keep harping on how awesome the A7RII is at XYZ while pretending that there aren't some very real downsides to the Sony system.


Ummm...likewise with other cameras. AF is great until you read about front focus, back focus, nothing in ficus, micro adjust for the near focus, micro adjust for the far focus...yadda, yadda, yadda.

Yes, no system is perfect...
Sep 03, 2015 at 09:01 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.44 #11Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
Ummm...likewise with other cameras. AF is great until you read about front focus, back focus, nothing in ficus, micro adjust for the near focus, micro adjust for the far focus...yadda, yadda, yadda.

Yes, no system is perfect...


Where have you read that about the 5DS? You have heard about 4 people in total having problems with the 7DII after service and recommend the not so great 7D instead? Remember the AF in the 5DS camera is tuned for maximal precision and not maximal speed. I have not micro adjusted and can do things like this: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1370747/24#13177624
Sep 03, 2015 at 09:06 AM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.44 #12Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
Dave McGaughey wrote
chez wrote
Dave McGaughey wrote
chez wrote
jctriguy wrote+1 the range of AF lenses for canon and Nikon is a huge plus for people entering a new system, or wanting to fill out an existing system. When you can buy a whole lot of lenses for the price of a single prime, that has a huge impact. Some don't want to rely on MF and adapted glass in a new $4000 camera.
Well, the beauty is many of those "cheap" AF glass can also be used on the A7R2 with AF. I don't have first hand experience with using them in AF mode, but from the many posts, it seems like they are very capable on the A7R2...and that with generation 1 of the adapters. I can image these adapters will improve in the future with AF getting better with new generations. There is also a mini business being formed here with competition between multiple adapters so I'm thinking we'll see quick improvement in the AF area.
Eh, I'll believe when I see it. I won't tolerate having to reboot my camera because my adapter has locked it up because I focused too close. Etc etc.

I got burned twice buying things (Nex7, Fuji X-Pro1) that "could" be awesome, but weren't actually ready now.

That's why I'm hanging with the stupid herd with my boring, reliable, and attractively priced Canon system.
That's the beauty of having choices...we all can choose what works for each of us.
Yes. It'd also be nice if everyone here would remember that when posting. Odd how some people keep harping on how awesome the A7RII is at XYZ while pretending that there aren't some very real downsides to the Sony system.
Ummm...likewise with other cameras. AF is great until you read about front focus, back focus, nothing in ficus, micro adjust for the near focus, micro adjust for the far focus...yadda, yadda, yadda.

Yes, no system is perfect...


This seems a little like what it would be like to walk into a car dealership. You go in looking for a mini van and the salesperson takes you over to a new prototype electric sports car and tells you how amazing it is. You remind him that you were looking at a mini van. He continues to tell you how amazing the new sports car is and how electric cars are the future. You ask about issues and he tells you that their roadmap shows an amazing range of electric vehicles coming in 5-10 years, maybe. You leave scratching your head and buy a mini van from someone that wants to listen to you.

Sep 03, 2015 at 09:07 AM
Sagar
Offline
Details
p.44 #13Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
I don't understand if Sony fans love their system so much why do they even bother to invade on Canikon forums to brag about how great their gear is. Love your system fine just enjoy with your herd why bother what other herd is doing?

It's one thing to compare system logically/subjectively and have sensible discussion but invade just for the sake of bragging I think it's just too much
Sep 03, 2015 at 09:15 AM
chez
Offline
Details
p.44 #14Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII


Sagar wrote:
I don't understand if Sony fans love their system so much why do they even bother to invade on Canikon forums to brag about how great their gear is. Love your system fine just enjoy with your herd why bother what other herd is doing?

It's one thing to compare system logically/subjectively and have sensible discussion but invade just for the sake of bragging I think it's just too much


I think many Photogs that bought a Sony camera also use Canon cameras and lenses so it's natural to hang out in both forums.

This thread is also comparing two cameras which is why the two cameras are being compared.
Sep 03, 2015 at 09:18 AM
chez
Offline
Details
p.44 #15Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII


alundeb wrote:
chez wroteUmmm...likewise with other cameras. AF is great until you read about front focus, back focus, nothing in ficus, micro adjust for the near focus, micro adjust for the far focus...yadda, yadda, yadda.

Yes, no system is perfect...
Where have you read that about the 5DS? You have heard about 4 people in total having problems with the 7DII after service and recommend the not so great 7D instead? Remember the AF in the 5DS camera is tuned for maximal precision and not maximal speed. I have not micro adjusted and can do things like this: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1370747/24#13177624


I've heard tons of photographers have issues with multiple 7d2 cameras, some still after being sent for service.

I guess that is why Canon service is so good...they get a lot of practice. 😃
Sep 03, 2015 at 09:21 AM
Cliff L.
Online
Details
p.44 #16Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
Ummm...likewise with other cameras. AF is great until you read about front focus, back focus, nothing in ficus, micro adjust for the near focus, micro adjust for the far focus...yadda, yadda, yadda.

Yes, no system is perfect...


I've owned a lot of Canon gear over the years, and have never, ever had to micro adjust any camera or lens. I did have a 28-135mm IS zoom back in the film days that was a bit suspect, but I bought it used so it may have taken a bump along the way...

From my own personal experience, the Canon AF system is an order of magnitude more accurate and reliable than Sony's crude CEIGE ("close enough is good enough") AF system... but YMMV.
Sep 03, 2015 at 09:23 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.44 #17Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
alundeb wrote
chez wroteUmmm...likewise with other cameras. AF is great until you read about front focus, back focus, nothing in ficus, micro adjust for the near focus, micro adjust for the far focus...yadda, yadda, yadda.

Yes, no system is perfect...
Where have you read that about the 5DS? You have heard about 4 people in total having problems with the 7DII after service and recommend the not so great 7D instead? Remember the AF in the 5DS camera is tuned for maximal precision and not maximal speed. I have not micro adjusted and can do things like this: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1370747/24#13177624
I've heard tons of photographers have issues with multiple 7d2 cameras, some still after being sent for service.

I guess that is why Canon service is so good...they get a lot of practice. 😃


What about that dozen of tons of photographers that think the 7DII is a much better camera than the 7D? But anyway, I guess you haven't heard of AF problems with the 5DS, no?
Sep 03, 2015 at 09:24 AM
Cliff L.
Online
Details
p.44 #18Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
I've heard tons of photographers have issues with multiple 7d2 cameras, some still after being sent for service.



I love buying used cameras from people who tell stories like this... I can usually get a great deal, and all it takes to fix the "problem" is to go into the camera's menu and turn off the micro adjustments they've made...
Sep 03, 2015 at 09:30 AM
boingyman
Offline
Details
p.44 #19Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Sure enough FM Canon forums have 44 pages of trivial discussion. It's 2 different cameras both with it's own pros/cons. Pick one, or don't and move forward. If you want to complain about Canon products why not go to the official Canon forums where your voice has a higher chance of being heard. If enough ducks quack they may listen...or not...
Sep 03, 2015 at 09:36 AM
Dave McGaughey
Offline
Details
p.44 #20Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
Dave McGaughey wrote
chez wrote
Dave McGaughey wrote
chez wrote
jctriguy wrote+1 the range of AF lenses for canon and Nikon is a huge plus for people entering a new system, or wanting to fill out an existing system. When you can buy a whole lot of lenses for the price of a single prime, that has a huge impact. Some don't want to rely on MF and adapted glass in a new $4000 camera.
Well, the beauty is many of those "cheap" AF glass can also be used on the A7R2 with AF. I don't have first hand experience with using them in AF mode, but from the many posts, it seems like they are very capable on the A7R2...and that with generation 1 of the adapters. I can image these adapters will improve in the future with AF getting better with new generations. There is also a mini business being formed here with competition between multiple adapters so I'm thinking we'll see quick improvement in the AF area.
Eh, I'll believe when I see it. I won't tolerate having to reboot my camera because my adapter has locked it up because I focused too close. Etc etc.

I got burned twice buying things (Nex7, Fuji X-Pro1) that "could" be awesome, but weren't actually ready now.

That's why I'm hanging with the stupid herd with my boring, reliable, and attractively priced Canon system.
That's the beauty of having choices...we all can choose what works for each of us.
Yes. It'd also be nice if everyone here would remember that when posting. Odd how some people keep harping on how awesome the A7RII is at XYZ while pretending that there aren't some very real downsides to the Sony system.
Ummm...likewise with other cameras. AF is great until you read about front focus, back focus, nothing in ficus, micro adjust for the near focus, micro adjust for the far focus...yadda, yadda, yadda.

Yes, no system is perfect...


In case you were wondering, it's posts like these that really get people riled up. There are some very clear and objective differences between a Canon/Nikon DSLR and a Sony mirrorless. Sounds like you agree and understand them. Then from nowhere you toss a grenade.*

* a subjective-internet-anecdote-based statement
Sep 03, 2015 at 09:41 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister