fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII

  
 
darbo
Offline
Details
p.43 #1Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
dakel wrote:
Here's my perception of the advantages of each system, for what it's worth:

A7RII
Better video
EVF
Smaller body
More accurate AF (single shot)
Wider dynamic range (sensor)

Canon 5DS/R
More reliable camera brand and better service
More robust
Better colour (subjective)
Faster AF (maybe)
Uncompressed raw
Better native lens selection
Better AF tracking
Better menu and button layout

Personally I still can't decide which one to get.


It's a really tough decision! I went 5DS/5DS R, but you left out a couple of my favorite a7R II assets: 1. I would love to have that IBIS for an improved handheld shooting experience with my non-IS lenses, 2. The BSI sensor appears to pay nice dividends for low-light high ISO performance.

Both are awesome and I agree with your points. I played it safe - I trust Canon reliability and their service. Happy choosing.

Sep 02, 2015 at 10:23 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.43 #2Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
dakel wrote:
Here's my perception of the advantages of each system, for what it's worth:

A7RII
Better video
EVF
Smaller body
More accurate AF (single shot)
Wider dynamic range (sensor)

Canon 5DS/R
More reliable camera brand and better service
More robust
Better colour (subjective)
Faster AF (maybe)
Uncompressed raw
Better native lens selection
Better AF tracking
Better menu and button layout

Personally I still can't decide which one to get.


The one that I'd point out as having a significant caveat to it is the "Faster AF (maybe)" ...

If you are talking about using longer lenses or lenses that are pre-2006, like the venerable 135/2, 100/2, 200/2.8, 400/5.6 etc. ...my understanding is that there isn't much "maybe" about it ... they will AF better on the Canon. If you are talking about using shorter focal length, in the normal, wide, short tele (newer than 2006), my understanding is that these could be "maybe" faster on the Canon, maybe close enough to not quibble over.

Disclaimer ... only based on what I've read / seen about using Canon on the A7R II.

Sep 02, 2015 at 10:41 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.43 #3Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Another plus for the A7R(2) is its ability to manual focus lenses. The AF centric DSLR has left behind the manual focus world. I use manual focus more than AF so this feature ways greatly on my decisions.
Sep 02, 2015 at 10:50 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.43 #4Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
I will add one more plus for each:

5DS(R): Long exposures. Very good thermal noise characteristics and built-in bulb timer. The A7rII is unfortunately a step backwards regarding long exposure noise.

A7rII: Fast lenses: Less pixel vignetting ( f-stop blues ) because of the BSI structure. This effect also gives less vignetting with small wide angle lenses, but that vignetting is something you will mostly see on the Sony FE platform anyway.
Sep 03, 2015 at 12:29 AM
jcolwell
Offline
Details
p.43 #5Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
molson wrote:
...I asked Sony Canada last year if they planned to offer pro service,and they stated that they would not be offering anything like CPS or NPS, because, and I quote: "Sony does not make any professional camera equipment". I'm glad at least one person in that company is in touch with reality...


From a recent DPReview article on Sony RAW compression,

"as the company shows its ambitions in the high end market, with the launch of the a7 series and a dedicated support system for professionals, the impact on image quality deserves a little scrutiny."

http://www.dpreview.com/articles/2834066212/the-raw-and-the-cooked-pulling-apart-sony-raw-compression

Also from the same article, here's the conclusion regarding the effects of Sony RAW compression on IQ and related issues,

"Conclusion

These approaches probably made sense in consumer-grade cameras, back in the days where processing power and storage space came at a significant premium. However, on a camera as expensive as the a7R II, which is likely to be used for quality-critical shooting, it's hard to justify clumsy compression that can, depending on the image, throw away data you were expecting to have access to.

Overall, the effects of this compression aren't often visually significant. Their impact should mostly be understood as a reduction in processing latitude, since it tends only to be when you push and pull the Raw files that the missing data becomes visible. The compression curve throws away more shadow data than would be ideal: reducing dynamic range. There's a further reduction if you shoot in a mode that drops the camera into 12-bit readout mode. Meanwhile, the localized compression of tonal differences only has an impact near high-contrast edges.

It's quite possible to shoot for years and never notice the impact of these design choices Sony has made, but they do add up to mean that you can't access the full capability of the camera. Most people shoot Raw precisely because they want to preserve the maximum possible processing latitude and keep their creative options open. Raw compression isn't the end of the world by any means, but it throws away a little bit of a camera's capability, which might be a little hard to swallow if you've paid multiple thousands of dollars for a cutting-edge camera."

Sep 03, 2015 at 04:39 AM
Dave McGaughey
Offline
Details
p.43 #6Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
One comment as a lens system nativist (AF): you have FAR more choices for reasonably priced, high quality system lenses with Canon. This is especially true for primes.

Sony doesn't have direct comparable (quality/price/existence) prime lenses for 24/2.8, 35/2, 50/1.8, 85/1.8, and anything above 100mm. In fact they only have one reasonably* priced prime lens: the 28/2.

* I don't consider a $1200 85/1.8 to be reasonably priced. Yeah, it's probably awesome and definitely Zeiss-y but I'd rather have a a 24/2.8 IS, 35/2 USM IS, and a 85/1.8 that are merely "very" good. I'd also rather have a $125 50/1.8 and $800 in my pocket.
Sep 03, 2015 at 07:06 AM
darbo
Offline
Details
p.43 #7Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
^I agree that Sony has a tendency to price their lenses quite a bit higher. I've tried the Sony FE 35mm f/2.8 - nice lens, but I have recently got in the $150 EF 40mm f/2.8 STM, and it seems comparable. The price for their A-mount 70-200mm f/2.8 is shockingly high in comparison to the Canon and Nikon options.
Sep 03, 2015 at 07:30 AM
chez
Offline
Details
p.43 #8Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Dave McGaughey wrote:
One comment as a lens system nativist (AF): you have FAR more choices for reasonably priced, high quality system lenses with Canon. This is especially true for primes.

Sony doesn't have direct comparable (quality/price/existence) prime lenses for 24/2.8, 35/2, 50/1.8, 85/1.8, and anything above 100mm. In fact they only have one reasonably* priced prime lens: the 28/2.

* I don't consider a $1200 85/1.8 to be reasonably priced. Yeah, it's probably awesome and definitely Zeiss-y but I'd rather have a a 24/2.8 IS, 35/2 USM IS, and a 85/1.8 that are merely "very" good. I'd also rather have a $125
...Show more →

True...but the flip side to this is the vast number if great small manual focus lenses available for very reasonable prices that can easily be used with the A7R2. Manually focusing the A7R is a breeze and really takes away the game of placing the little red rectangle onto what you want in focus. Once you get good at manually focusing, it becomes liberating to not worry about focus points.
Sep 03, 2015 at 07:32 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.43 #9Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
Dave McGaughey wroteOne comment as a lens system nativist (AF): you have FAR more choices for reasonably priced, high quality system lenses with Canon. This is especially true for primes.

Sony doesn't have direct comparable (quality/price/existence) prime lenses for 24/2.8, 35/2, 50/1.8, 85/1.8, and anything above 100mm. In fact they only have one reasonably* priced prime lens: the 28/2.

* I don't consider a $1200 85/1.8 to be reasonably priced. Yeah, it's probably awesome and definitely Zeiss-y but I'd rather have a a 24/2.8 IS, 35/2 USM IS, and a 85/1.8 that are merely "very" good. I'd also rather have a $125 50/1.8 and $800 in my pocket.
True...but the flip side to this is the vast number if great small manual focus lenses available for very reasonable prices that can easily be used with the A7R2. Manually focusing the A7R is a breeze and really takes away the game of placing the little red rectangle onto what you want in focus. Once you get good at manually focusing, it becomes liberating to not worry about focus points.


The accuracy of manual focus is very often dependent on mangification in the viewfinder. So you have to move something there too, and it is slower. If you can get manual focus with accuracy even close to AF without micro adjustment, without magnification, that is exceptional and very few will get to that level.
Sep 03, 2015 at 07:38 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.43 #10Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
darbo wrote:
The price for their A-mount 70-200mm f/2.8 is shockingly high in comparison to the Canon and Nikon options.


In part ... laws of supply & demand vs. economies of scale vs. cost to produce. The Sony market for A-mount is vastly smaller than the Canon or Nikon markets for EF or F mount.

Kinda comes with the territory of the smaller market. Have you looked at the price for their 300/2.8 or 500/4?


Edited on Sep 03, 2015 at 07:44 AM · View previous versions
Sep 03, 2015 at 07:39 AM
Dave McGaughey
Offline
Details
p.43 #11Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
Dave McGaughey wroteOne comment as a lens system nativist (AF): you have FAR more choices for reasonably priced, high quality system lenses with Canon. This is especially true for primes.

Sony doesn't have direct comparable (quality/price/existence) prime lenses for 24/2.8, 35/2, 50/1.8, 85/1.8, and anything above 100mm. In fact they only have one reasonably* priced prime lens: the 28/2.

* I don't consider a $1200 85/1.8 to be reasonably priced. Yeah, it's probably awesome and definitely Zeiss-y but I'd rather have a a 24/2.8 IS, 35/2 USM IS, and a 85/1.8 that are merely "very" good. I'd also rather have a $125 50/1.8 and $800 in my pocket.
True...but the flip side to this is the vast number if great small manual focus lenses available for very reasonable prices that can easily be used with the A7R2. Manually focusing the A7R is a breeze and really takes away the game of placing the little red rectangle onto what you want in focus. Once you get good at manually focusing, it becomes liberating to not worry about focus points.


Sure, but I don't care about that. AF is awesome.

An important point is that AF/MF ease aren't mutually exclusive for a mirrorless. Sony could produce these lenses, but they either won't or can't. Fuji, in roughly the same amount of time, has released numerous nice (though slightly pricey) prime lenses.
Sep 03, 2015 at 07:42 AM
chez
Offline
Details
p.43 #12Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
chez wrote
Dave McGaughey wroteOne comment as a lens system nativist (AF): you have FAR more choices for reasonably priced, high quality system lenses with Canon. This is especially true for primes.

Sony doesn't have direct comparable (quality/price/existence) prime lenses for 24/2.8, 35/2, 50/1.8, 85/1.8, and anything above 100mm. In fact they only have one reasonably* priced prime lens: the 28/2.

* I don't consider a $1200 85/1.8 to be reasonably priced. Yeah, it's probably awesome and definitely Zeiss-y but I'd rather have a a 24/2.8 IS, 35/2 USM IS, and a 85/1.8 that are merely "very" good. I'd also rather have a $125 50/1.8 and $800 in my pocket.
True...but the flip side to this is the vast number if great small manual focus lenses available for very reasonable prices that can easily be used with the A7R2. Manually focusing the A7R is a breeze and really takes away the game of placing the little red rectangle onto what you want in focus. Once you get good at manually focusing, it becomes liberating to not worry about focus points.
The accuracy of manual focus is very often dependent on mangification in the viewfinder. So you have to move something there too, and it is slower. If you can get manual focus with accuracy even close to AF without micro adjustment, without magnification, that is exceptional and very few will get to that level.


I shoot 90% of my A7R photos using manual focus. Depending on the aperture being used, focus peaking works very well for manual focusing. True, if you are shooting at 2.0 and larger, then focus magnification is required, but for my street shooting, focus peaking is wonderful.
Sep 03, 2015 at 07:47 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.43 #13Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
alundeb wrote
chez wrote
Dave McGaughey wroteOne comment as a lens system nativist (AF): you have FAR more choices for reasonably priced, high quality system lenses with Canon. This is especially true for primes.

Sony doesn't have direct comparable (quality/price/existence) prime lenses for 24/2.8, 35/2, 50/1.8, 85/1.8, and anything above 100mm. In fact they only have one reasonably* priced prime lens: the 28/2.

* I don't consider a $1200 85/1.8 to be reasonably priced. Yeah, it's probably awesome and definitely Zeiss-y but I'd rather have a a 24/2.8 IS, 35/2 USM IS, and a 85/1.8 that are merely "very" good. I'd also rather have a $125 50/1.8 and $800 in my pocket.
True...but the flip side to this is the vast number if great small manual focus lenses available for very reasonable prices that can easily be used with the A7R2. Manually focusing the A7R is a breeze and really takes away the game of placing the little red rectangle onto what you want in focus. Once you get good at manually focusing, it becomes liberating to not worry about focus points.
The accuracy of manual focus is very often dependent on mangification in the viewfinder. So you have to move something there too, and it is slower. If you can get manual focus with accuracy even close to AF without micro adjustment, without magnification, that is exceptional and very few will get to that level.
I shoot 90% of my A7R photos using manual focus. Depending on the aperture being used, focus peaking works very well for manual focusing. True, if you are shooting at 2.0 and larger, then focus magnification is required, but for my street shooting, focus peaking is wonderful.


I have experienced that focus peaking reacts too much on low frequency contrast and too little on high frequency detail. So the peaking has fooled me regarding where the actual focus was. Sometimes I just turn it off and the high resolution EVF is good enough. Sure manual focus with an EVF is much better than with a DSLR.
Sep 03, 2015 at 07:52 AM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.43 #14Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Dave McGaughey wrote:
chez wrote
Dave McGaughey wroteOne comment as a lens system nativist (AF): you have FAR more choices for reasonably priced, high quality system lenses with Canon. This is especially true for primes.

Sony doesn't have direct comparable (quality/price/existence) prime lenses for 24/2.8, 35/2, 50/1.8, 85/1.8, and anything above 100mm. In fact they only have one reasonably* priced prime lens: the 28/2.

* I don't consider a $1200 85/1.8 to be reasonably priced. Yeah, it's probably awesome and definitely Zeiss-y but I'd rather have a a 24/2.8 IS, 35/2 USM IS, and a 85/1.8 that are merely "very" good. I'd also rather have a $125 50/1.8 and $800 in my pocket.
True...but the flip side to this is the vast number if great small manual focus lenses available for very reasonable prices that can easily be used with the A7R2. Manually focusing the A7R is a breeze and really takes away the game of placing the little red rectangle onto what you want in focus. Once you get good at manually focusing, it becomes liberating to not worry about focus points.
Sure, but I don't care about that. AF is awesome.

An important point is that AF/MF ease aren't mutually exclusive for a mirrorless. Sony could produce these lenses, but they either won't or can't. Fuji, in roughly the same amount of time, has released numerous nice (though slightly pricey) prime lenses.


+1 the range of AF lenses for canon and Nikon is a huge plus for people entering a new system, or wanting to fill out an existing system. When you can buy a whole lot of lenses for the price of a single prime, that has a huge impact. Some don't want to rely on MF and adapted glass in a new $4000 camera.

Sep 03, 2015 at 07:55 AM
mogul
Online
Details
p.43 #15Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
jctriguy wrote:
Dave McGaughey wrote
chez wrote
Dave McGaughey wroteOne comment as a lens system nativist (AF): you have FAR more choices for reasonably priced, high quality system lenses with Canon. This is especially true for primes.

Sony doesn't have direct comparable (quality/price/existence) prime lenses for 24/2.8, 35/2, 50/1.8, 85/1.8, and anything above 100mm. In fact they only have one reasonably* priced prime lens: the 28/2.

* I don't consider a $1200 85/1.8 to be reasonably priced. Yeah, it's probably awesome and definitely Zeiss-y but I'd rather have a a 24/2.8 IS, 35/2 USM IS, and a 85/1.8 that are merely "very" good. I'd also rather have a $125 50/1.8 and $800 in my pocket.
True...but the flip side to this is the vast number if great small manual focus lenses available for very reasonable prices that can easily be used with the A7R2. Manually focusing the A7R is a breeze and really takes away the game of placing the little red rectangle onto what you want in focus. Once you get good at manually focusing, it becomes liberating to not worry about focus points.
Sure, but I don't care about that. AF is awesome.

An important point is that AF/MF ease aren't mutually exclusive for a mirrorless. Sony could produce these lenses, but they either won't or can't. Fuji, in roughly the same amount of time, has released numerous nice (though slightly pricey) prime lenses.
+1 the range of AF lenses for canon and Nikon is a huge plus for people entering a new system, or wanting to fill out an existing system. When you can buy a whole lot of lenses for the price of a single prime, that has a huge impact. Some don't want to rely on MF and adapted glass in a new $4000 camera.


If your idea of a huge + in lenses is a lot of cheap film era lenses and 18/xxx consumer zooms, I guess Canon and Nikon have Sony beat.
Sep 03, 2015 at 08:00 AM
chez
Offline
Details
p.43 #16Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
jctriguy wrote:
Dave McGaughey wrote
chez wrote
Dave McGaughey wroteOne comment as a lens system nativist (AF): you have FAR more choices for reasonably priced, high quality system lenses with Canon. This is especially true for primes.

Sony doesn't have direct comparable (quality/price/existence) prime lenses for 24/2.8, 35/2, 50/1.8, 85/1.8, and anything above 100mm. In fact they only have one reasonably* priced prime lens: the 28/2.

* I don't consider a $1200 85/1.8 to be reasonably priced. Yeah, it's probably awesome and definitely Zeiss-y but I'd rather have a a 24/2.8 IS, 35/2 USM IS, and a 85/1.8 that are merely "very" good. I'd also rather have a $125 50/1.8 and $800 in my pocket.
True...but the flip side to this is the vast number if great small manual focus lenses available for very reasonable prices that can easily be used with the A7R2. Manually focusing the A7R is a breeze and really takes away the game of placing the little red rectangle onto what you want in focus. Once you get good at manually focusing, it becomes liberating to not worry about focus points.
Sure, but I don't care about that. AF is awesome.

An important point is that AF/MF ease aren't mutually exclusive for a mirrorless. Sony could produce these lenses, but they either won't or can't. Fuji, in roughly the same amount of time, has released numerous nice (though slightly pricey) prime lenses.
+1 the range of AF lenses for canon and Nikon is a huge plus for people entering a new system, or wanting to fill out an existing system. When you can buy a whole lot of lenses for the price of a single prime, that has a huge impact. Some don't want to rely on MF and adapted glass in a new $4000 camera.



Well, the beauty is many of those "cheap" AF glass can also be used on the A7R2 with AF. I don't have first hand experience with using them in AF mode, but from the many posts, it seems like they are very capable on the A7R2...and that with generation 1 of the adapters. I can image these adapters will improve in the future with AF getting better with new generations. There is also a mini business being formed here with competition between multiple adapters so I'm thinking we'll see quick improvement in the AF area.
Sep 03, 2015 at 08:07 AM
chez
Offline
Details
p.43 #17Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
mogul wrote:
jctriguy wrote
Dave McGaughey wrote
chez wrote
Dave McGaughey wroteOne comment as a lens system nativist (AF): you have FAR more choices for reasonably priced, high quality system lenses with Canon. This is especially true for primes.

Sony doesn't have direct comparable (quality/price/existence) prime lenses for 24/2.8, 35/2, 50/1.8, 85/1.8, and anything above 100mm. In fact they only have one reasonably* priced prime lens: the 28/2.

* I don't consider a $1200 85/1.8 to be reasonably priced. Yeah, it's probably awesome and definitely Zeiss-y but I'd rather have a a 24/2.8 IS, 35/2 USM IS, and a 85/1.8 that are merely "very" good. I'd also rather have a $125 50/1.8 and $800 in my pocket.
True...but the flip side to this is the vast number if great small manual focus lenses available for very reasonable prices that can easily be used with the A7R2. Manually focusing the A7R is a breeze and really takes away the game of placing the little red rectangle onto what you want in focus. Once you get good at manually focusing, it becomes liberating to not worry about focus points.
Sure, but I don't care about that. AF is awesome.

An important point is that AF/MF ease aren't mutually exclusive for a mirrorless. Sony could produce these lenses, but they either won't or can't. Fuji, in roughly the same amount of time, has released numerous nice (though slightly pricey) prime lenses.
+1 the range of AF lenses for canon and Nikon is a huge plus for people entering a new system, or wanting to fill out an existing system. When you can buy a whole lot of lenses for the price of a single prime, that has a huge impact. Some don't want to rely on MF and adapted glass in a new $4000 camera.
If your idea of a huge + in lenses is a lot of cheap film era lenses and 18/xxx consumer zooms, I guess Canon and Nikon have Sony beat.


Yeh...the latest pro lenses sure aren't cheap in my books. The new 35L is ridiculously expensive.
Sep 03, 2015 at 08:08 AM
chez
Offline
Details
p.43 #18Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Dave McGaughey wrote:
chez wrote
Dave McGaughey wroteOne comment as a lens system nativist (AF): you have FAR more choices for reasonably priced, high quality system lenses with Canon. This is especially true for primes.

Sony doesn't have direct comparable (quality/price/existence) prime lenses for 24/2.8, 35/2, 50/1.8, 85/1.8, and anything above 100mm. In fact they only have one reasonably* priced prime lens: the 28/2.

* I don't consider a $1200 85/1.8 to be reasonably priced. Yeah, it's probably awesome and definitely Zeiss-y but I'd rather have a a 24/2.8 IS, 35/2 USM IS, and a 85/1.8 that are merely "very" good. I'd also rather have a $125 50/1.8 and $800 in my pocket.
True...but the flip side to this is the vast number if great small manual focus lenses available for very reasonable prices that can easily be used with the A7R2. Manually focusing the A7R is a breeze and really takes away the game of placing the little red rectangle onto what you want in focus. Once you get good at manually focusing, it becomes liberating to not worry about focus points.
Sure, but I don't care about that. AF is awesome.

An important point is that AF/MF ease aren't mutually exclusive for a mirrorless. Sony could produce these lenses, but they either won't or can't. Fuji, in roughly the same amount of time, has released numerous nice (though slightly pricey) prime lenses.


Come on...DSLR's are not made with MF in mind and are a pain the manually focus lenses using the viewfinder. I've done it for years with my 5d2 and compared to manually focusing with the A7R...it's painful and not accurate.

Sony's lens roadmap is filling in nicely especially with Zeiss contributing. I cover all my shooting situations using a combination of Sony, Canon, Zeiss and Zuiko lenses.

Sep 03, 2015 at 08:14 AM
Dave McGaughey
Offline
Details
p.43 #19Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
jctriguy wrote
Dave McGaughey wrote
chez wrote
Dave McGaughey wroteOne comment as a lens system nativist (AF): you have FAR more choices for reasonably priced, high quality system lenses with Canon. This is especially true for primes.

Sony doesn't have direct comparable (quality/price/existence) prime lenses for 24/2.8, 35/2, 50/1.8, 85/1.8, and anything above 100mm. In fact they only have one reasonably* priced prime lens: the 28/2.

* I don't consider a $1200 85/1.8 to be reasonably priced. Yeah, it's probably awesome and definitely Zeiss-y but I'd rather have a a 24/2.8 IS, 35/2 USM IS, and a 85/1.8 that are merely "very" good. I'd also rather have a $125 50/1.8 and $800 in my pocket.
True...but the flip side to this is the vast number if great small manual focus lenses available for very reasonable prices that can easily be used with the A7R2. Manually focusing the A7R is a breeze and really takes away the game of placing the little red rectangle onto what you want in focus. Once you get good at manually focusing, it becomes liberating to not worry about focus points.
Sure, but I don't care about that. AF is awesome.

An important point is that AF/MF ease aren't mutually exclusive for a mirrorless. Sony could produce these lenses, but they either won't or can't. Fuji, in roughly the same amount of time, has released numerous nice (though slightly pricey) prime lenses.
+1 the range of AF lenses for canon and Nikon is a huge plus for people entering a new system, or wanting to fill out an existing system. When you can buy a whole lot of lenses for the price of a single prime, that has a huge impact. Some don't want to rely on MF and adapted glass in a new $4000 camera.
Well, the beauty is many of those "cheap" AF glass can also be used on the A7R2 with AF. I don't have first hand experience with using them in AF mode, but from the many posts, it seems like they are very capable on the A7R2...and that with generation 1 of the adapters. I can image these adapters will improve in the future with AF getting better with new generations. There is also a mini business being formed here with competition between multiple adapters so I'm thinking we'll see quick improvement in the AF area.


Eh, I'll believe when I see it. I won't tolerate having to reboot my camera because my adapter has locked it up because I focused too close. Etc etc.

I got burned twice buying things (Nex7, Fuji X-Pro1) that "could" be awesome, but weren't actually ready now.

That's why I'm hanging with the stupid herd with my boring, reliable, and attractively priced Canon system.
Sep 03, 2015 at 08:16 AM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.43 #20Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
jctriguy wrote
Dave McGaughey wrote
chez wrote
Dave McGaughey wroteOne comment as a lens system nativist (AF): you have FAR more choices for reasonably priced, high quality system lenses with Canon. This is especially true for primes.

Sony doesn't have direct comparable (quality/price/existence) prime lenses for 24/2.8, 35/2, 50/1.8, 85/1.8, and anything above 100mm. In fact they only have one reasonably* priced prime lens: the 28/2.

* I don't consider a $1200 85/1.8 to be reasonably priced. Yeah, it's probably awesome and definitely Zeiss-y but I'd rather have a a 24/2.8 IS, 35/2 USM IS, and a 85/1.8 that are merely "very" good. I'd also rather have a $125 50/1.8 and $800 in my pocket.
True...but the flip side to this is the vast number if great small manual focus lenses available for very reasonable prices that can easily be used with the A7R2. Manually focusing the A7R is a breeze and really takes away the game of placing the little red rectangle onto what you want in focus. Once you get good at manually focusing, it becomes liberating to not worry about focus points.
Sure, but I don't care about that. AF is awesome.

An important point is that AF/MF ease aren't mutually exclusive for a mirrorless. Sony could produce these lenses, but they either won't or can't. Fuji, in roughly the same amount of time, has released numerous nice (though slightly pricey) prime lenses.
+1 the range of AF lenses for canon and Nikon is a huge plus for people entering a new system, or wanting to fill out an existing system. When you can buy a whole lot of lenses for the price of a single prime, that has a huge impact. Some don't want to rely on MF and adapted glass in a new $4000 camera.
Well, the beauty is many of those "cheap" AF glass can also be used on the A7R2 with AF. I don't have first hand experience with using them in AF mode, but from the many posts, it seems like they are very capable on the A7R2...and that with generation 1 of the adapters. I can image these adapters will improve in the future with AF getting better with new generations. There is also a mini business being formed here with competition between multiple adapters so I'm thinking we'll see quick improvement in the AF area.


I wouldn't use the word cheap, I'd say lower priced lens options. Yes, some can be used with the a7r and the **4th** generation metabones, for an additional $400. Some can't be used at all with Sony, like the 135f2, a very good and relatively low priced option for many people. So, back to the original point, canon has a system where you can buy a huge range of different lenses and use the natively with excellent AF on all canon EF bodies, and a larger range of you use EF-S bodies. No adapters, no lists of compatible lenses, no requirememt to MF.

If you love adapted lenses and MF shooting, that system isn't relevant, but for others it is quite important. I enjoy my mamiya lenses on occasion, but certainly not all the time.
Sep 03, 2015 at 08:19 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister