fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII

  
 
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.37 #1Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
darbo wrote:
^ Is there a reason the e-shutter was used for the comparison? Does it make a difference? Just curious.


http://www.dpreview.com/articles/2436252004/bsi-boss-sony-alpha-7r-ii-added-to-studio-scene
Sep 01, 2015 at 10:09 AM
darbo
Offline
Details
p.37 #2Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
darbo wrote^ Is there a reason the e-shutter was used for the comparison? Does it make a difference? Just curious.
http://www.dpreview.com/articles/2436252004/bsi-boss-sony-alpha-7r-ii-added-to-studio-scene


Perfect...thanks for the link. ....and I can see no diff between e-shutter and standard shutter. Question answered.
Sep 01, 2015 at 10:21 AM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.37 #3Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
retrofocus wrote:
jctriguy wrote
retrofocus wrote
jctriguy wrote
retrofocus wrote
jctriguy wroteIn my view, your bias comes through in the way you write. You say the canon sensor is simply doubled, whereas the Sony sensor is clearly brand new and not merely a larger version from an existing sensor. The BSI exmor R was first available over 2 years ago in a 20MP rx100. Both the Canon and Sony are FF versions of an existing sensor, yet you paint it as one making huge steps and the other just doing something that they should've done 3 years ago. The 7Dii sensor wasn't available 3 years ago, so still not sure how you know that Canon could've easily released a FF version at that time. What is your reasoning for Sony releasing such a flawed initial a7r?
Because the 7D MkII is not groundbreaking new technology either. It improved (again) in high ISO, same old game. Main improvement in this camera was - again - AF. There is no technical reason why Canon could not have used this technology to release a high MP FF body much earlier as competitive reply to the D800(E).
You have no idea what your talking about. You can't possibly know what Canon was able to release 3,5,8 years ago. Again, what was groundbreaking about the a7rII sensor, it was just a bigger version of the sensor they release in 2013 and using the same technology as one release in 2009...6 years ago. Why are you using 6yr old technology (well, not you, since you don't want all the software/peripheral junk in the A7rII).
Certainly we know that Canon wasn't able to develop a new FF sensor technology with less than the 2008 developed 0.5 micrometer process generation sensors - and they still aren't. If you look at the specs, you will see that the sensor used in the A7R and in the A7R II are very differnet types of sensors even they might both rely on the same 0.18 micrometer process generation. Certainly Sony currently keeps a much faster pace in cranking sensors out than Canon does, this is without doubt.
I'm still waiting for your explanation of how a 0.5 vs 0.18 process is relevant (not Wikipedia, but you basic and easy to understand explanation)

Fact is that Sony had the exmor R sensor years ago. They had a BSI sensor over 6 years ago. The rest of us understand why it takes time to release these in different variations, but you seem to judge canon while ignoring all others. You just make up crap about what canon could've done, yet you don't have the faintest concept of product development or sensor technology(quoting a sensor spec repeatedly is not an understanding of sensor technology).
To say it in simple words is that smaller process generation allows smaller pixel size needed to allow better resolution on a hardware basis. For example using 0.18 µm generation process technology produces 4.75 µm pitch pixels whereas Canon sticks with 0.5 µm generation leading to 6-8 µm pitch pixels up to nearly twice this size.

You forget that the Exmor R generation years ago is not the same as the current Exmor RS generation which addresses some of the R's llimitations by further increasing pixel sensitivity.


You are incorrect in many ways here.
- Canon has a higher density sensor, how is that possible since they use a larger process spec?
- Why are smaller photo site sizes better?
- The a7rII uses the exmor R, not the RS. It was in fact release in 2008, so Sony is using tech from 2008 in the 'revolutionary' a7rII.

Again, what benefit is there for a smaller manufacturing process size, since the two sensors in question are roughly the same density and therefore it isn't for a higher density sensor as you incorrectly stated.

Also, why are you ok with Sony technology from 2008, but not Canon technology from the same timeframe? What does the age of the technology have to do with its characteristics? For the record, I don't care how old something is as long as it works. I know the Sony has better sensor specs in many areas, but are you buying it because it's newer or because it's better?
Sep 01, 2015 at 10:53 AM
StillFingerz
Offline
Details
p.37 #4Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Thirty-Seven pages and growing, and little if any new content, at least try to be original

Sep 01, 2015 at 11:12 AM
jcolwell
Online
Details
p.37 #5Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
No you didn't!
Sep 01, 2015 at 11:14 AM
John_T
Offline
Details
p.37 #6Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Well I didn't and won't, but you did 'cause you're stoooopid.
Sep 01, 2015 at 11:33 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.37 #7Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
jctriguy wrote:
retrofocus wrote
jctriguy wrote
retrofocus wrote
jctriguy wrote
retrofocus wroteBecause the 7D MkII is not groundbreaking new technology either. It improved (again) in high ISO, same old game. Main improvement in this camera was - again - AF. There is no technical reason why Canon could not have used this technology to release a high MP FF body much earlier as competitive reply to the D800(E).
You have no idea what your talking about. You can't possibly know what Canon was able to release 3,5,8 years ago. Again, what was groundbreaking about the a7rII sensor, it was just a bigger version of the sensor they release in 2013 and using the same technology as one release in 2009...6 years ago. Why are you using 6yr old technology (well, not you, since you don't want all the software/peripheral junk in the A7rII).
Certainly we know that Canon wasn't able to develop a new FF sensor technology with less than the 2008 developed 0.5 micrometer process generation sensors - and they still aren't. If you look at the specs, you will see that the sensor used in the A7R and in the A7R II are very differnet types of sensors even they might both rely on the same 0.18 micrometer process generation. Certainly Sony currently keeps a much faster pace in cranking sensors out than Canon does, this is without doubt.
I'm still waiting for your explanation of how a 0.5 vs 0.18 process is relevant (not Wikipedia, but you basic and easy to understand explanation)

Fact is that Sony had the exmor R sensor years ago. They had a BSI sensor over 6 years ago. The rest of us understand why it takes time to release these in different variations, but you seem to judge canon while ignoring all others. You just make up crap about what canon could've done, yet you don't have the faintest concept of product development or sensor technology(quoting a sensor spec repeatedly is not an understanding of sensor technology).
To say it in simple words is that smaller process generation allows smaller pixel size needed to allow better resolution on a hardware basis. For example using 0.18 µm generation process technology produces 4.75 µm pitch pixels whereas Canon sticks with 0.5 µm generation leading to 6-8 µm pitch pixels up to nearly twice this size.

You forget that the Exmor R generation years ago is not the same as the current Exmor RS generation which addresses some of the R's llimitations by further increasing pixel sensitivity.
You are incorrect in many ways here.
- Canon has a higher density sensor, how is that possible since they use a larger process spec?
- Why are smaller photo site sizes better?
- The a7rII uses the exmor R, not the RS. It was in fact release in 2008, so Sony is using tech from 2008 in the 'revolutionary' a7rII.

Again, what benefit is there for a smaller manufacturing process size, since the two sensors in question are roughly the same density and therefore it isn't for a higher density sensor as you incorrectly stated.

Also, why are you ok with
...Show more →

Smaller pixels allow better spatial seperation between each of them which reduces unwanted electron tunneling and noise plus increases sharpness. This also allows a better setup of the microlens array. In addition, the pixel wells were improved to further avoid electron tunneling. There are several generations of Exmor R sensors with the first one announced in 2008 - and used in cell phones. The sensor used in the A7R is a far more developed generation from the first original cell phone sensor. You are comparing apples and oranges when stating that Sony used the same sensor technology in the A7 series. It is a different beast to go from a tiny cell phone sensor to a 35 mm full frame sensor.

Canon on the other hand released in 2008 the FF sensor in the 5D MkII and 1Ds camera series. At the time, it was top of the line for FF. Unfortunately - against other members belief here - I don't see a huge progression from this sensor (or the 7D MkII cropped sensor) towards the latest one in the 5Ds(R) series other that Canon finally improved the FF resolution. Software algorithms definitely helped to improve in noise and high ISO, in the 5Ds(R) maybe with a bit of DR improvement, but hardware-wise it is no big change IMO.

I decided to go with this Sony technology last year because I wanted a higher resolution FF camera which Canon did not offer. Additional benefit was much better DR at low ISO. So clearly yes, I benefit a lot from this sensor technology. That it came in a mirrorless body, was an additional benefit for me.

I agree nevertheless with your point to use older technology as long as it works. My IR-converted 5D MkII is still great because I am using it at low ISO and don't need a wide DR for this kind of photos.
Sep 01, 2015 at 11:55 AM
Gunzorro
Offline
Details
p.37 #8Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Oh, Jerry! Those 37 pages were worth getting to the Monty Python sketch! Best wishes for the next 37!
Sep 01, 2015 at 11:59 AM
lukeiam
Offline
Details
p.37 #9Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Loved the Monty Python!
Sep 01, 2015 at 12:01 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.37 #10Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
retrofocus wrote:
To say it in simple words is that smaller process generation allows smaller pixel size needed to allow better resolution on a hardware basis. For example using 0.18 µm generation process technology produces 4.75 µm pitch pixels whereas Canon sticks with 0.5 µm generation leading to 6-8 µm pitch pixels up to nearly twice this size.

...

Smaller pixels allow better spatial seperation between each of them which reduces unwanted electron tunneling and noise plus increases sharpness. This also allows a better setup of the microlens array. In addition, the pixel wells were improved to further avoid electron tunneling.


The first paragraph describes pixel pitch, which is directly related to resolution. The pixel pitch of the 5DS is 4.14 µm and not 6 -8 µm. This has nothing to do with the process line width.

The small line width of 0.18 µm of the Sony sensors allows for bigger photodiode array relative to the pixel pitch, because the surrounding circuitry can be made narrower. BSI takes this a step further. The relation between line width and effect is the opposite of what you say. Above you describe why the 0.5 µm process of the Canon 5DS R has less tunnelling and appears sharper than the Sony A7r II.
Sep 01, 2015 at 12:10 PM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.37 #11Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
retrofocus wroteAnd believe it or not, it makes a difference how a sensor is built. To give an easy comparison for you to better grasp it, it is like film in the old days (and I don't mean this negative at all!) - depending on the applied emulsion recipe you got different results in contrast/noise/color etc. Also you see differences in the digital technology how sensors are made and built. And BTW, those differences might look small in number but can lead to a big impact in the final image.
Let's have a look at the 2008 vintage Canon 5DSR 0.5 um sensor compared to the latest and greatest Sony Exmor R 0.18 um sensor then. Outstanding, right?

http://i306.photobucket.com/albums/nn242/Overflate/dprcomp1_zpsi25nw2og.png
http://i306.photobucket.com/albums/nn242/Overflate/dprcomp2_zpsd7mbcxbw.png



Why are the Sony pictures so blurry?

Sep 01, 2015 at 12:12 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.37 #12Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
molson wrote:
Why are the Sony pictures so blurry?



They can't be.

Joking.

Se explanation above. Different lenses and possible focus error as well.
Sep 01, 2015 at 12:17 PM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.37 #13Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
retrofocus wroteTo say it in simple words is that smaller process generation allows smaller pixel size needed to allow better resolution on a hardware basis. For example using 0.18 µm generation process technology produces 4.75 µm pitch pixels whereas Canon sticks with 0.5 µm generation leading to 6-8 µm pitch pixels up to nearly twice this size.

...

Smaller pixels allow better spatial seperation between each of them which reduces unwanted electron tunneling and noise plus increases sharpness. This also allows a better setup of the microlens array. In addition, the pixel wells were improved to further avoid electron tunneling.
The first paragraph describes pixel pitch, which is directly related to resolution. The pixel pitch of the 5DS is 4.14 µm and not 6 -8 µm. This has nothing to do with the process line width.

The small line width of 0.18 µm of the Sony sensors allows for bigger photodiode array relative to the pixel pitch, because the surrounding circuitry can be made narrower. BSI takes this a step further. The relation between line width and effect is the opposite of what you say. Above you describe why the 0.5 µm process of the Canon 5DS R has less tunnelling
...Show more →

I state corrected - I mistranslated pixel (pitch) and photodiode from the German language.
Sep 01, 2015 at 12:23 PM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.37 #14Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
molson wroteWhy are the Sony pictures so blurry?
They can't be.

Joking.

Se explanation above. Different lenses and possible focus error as well.


It's not possible to have focus error with a Sony A7rII - just ask Lloyd Chambers!
Sep 01, 2015 at 12:32 PM
ggreene
Offline
Details
p.37 #15Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
darbo wrote:
For better or for worse Sony a-mount system appears to be dead on the vine.


I would agree unless they have reached a technical block with ML and low light AF tracking. Still the main reason why I don't take them serious. I watched two student photographers struggle like hell to get anything out of an A6000 body for indoor sports. They eventually went back to DSLR's. My settings for that gymnasium were 8000 ISO, f2.8, 1/800 ss. That is by no means the worst it can get. High Schools have notoriously bad lighting.

Will be interesting to see how the A6000 successor does in low light tracking. If they can resolve the issues they could have the beginnings of a real alternative to Canon/Nikon if they put that improved AF module in a real ML body. The A6000 type body is really for remote type stuff. It's far too fragile for a main body and has awful ergonomics for hand holding larger/heavier lenses.

Sep 01, 2015 at 12:55 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.37 #16Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
ggreene wrote:
darbo wroteFor better or for worse Sony a-mount system appears to be dead on the vine.
I would agree unless they have reached a technical block with ML and low light AF tracking. Still the main reason why I don't take them serious. I watched two student photographers struggle like hell to get anything out of an A6000 body for indoor sports. They eventually went back to DSLR's. My settings for that gymnasium were 8000 ISO, f2.8, 1/800 ss. That is by no means the worst it can get. High Schools have notoriously bad lighting.

Will be interesting to see how the A6000 successor does in low light tracking. If they can resolve the issues they could
...Show more →

Don't forget you are talking about a $500 camera here. For what it is, the A6000 delivers pretty amazing images. Love to see you do anything at all with Canon's flagship ( which costs roughly $1,000 with viewfinder) M3 in that same gym.
Sep 01, 2015 at 01:12 PM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.37 #17Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
ggreene wrote:
darbo wroteFor better or for worse Sony a-mount system appears to be dead on the vine.
I would agree unless they have reached a technical block with ML and low light AF tracking. Still the main reason why I don't take them serious. I watched two student photographers struggle like hell to get anything out of an A6000 body for indoor sports. They eventually went back to DSLR's. My settings for that gymnasium were 8000 ISO, f2.8, 1/800 ss. That is by no means the worst it can get. High Schools have notoriously bad lighting.

Will be interesting to see how the A6000 successor does in low light tracking. If they can resolve the issues they could
...Show more →


The A-6000 is not an A-mount camera (but I suspect that even most Sony employees don't know that...)
Sep 01, 2015 at 01:16 PM
ggreene
Offline
Details
p.37 #18Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
Don't forget you are talking about a $500 camera here. For what it is, the A6000 delivers pretty amazing images. Love to see you do anything at all with Canon's flagship ( which costs roughly $1,000 with viewfinder) M3 in that same gym.


Probably true but doesn't change the fact that ML seems to have issues with low light AF tracking. There are plenty of hands on forum posts about the A7RII still not having good low light AF tracking and that's a just released $3200 camera. Given that the A6000 is viewed as Sony's best action body its successor is of interest to me if Sony has a better AF module for it. If it's the same as the A7RII then we are still not there yet.
Sep 01, 2015 at 01:31 PM
rattlebonez
Offline
Details
p.37 #19Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Lloyd Chambers, Ken Rockwell, Tony Northrup

solid internet sources of camera info
bias has nothing to do with it
like presenting DXO Mark as the gospel

people like to brag up the latest new widget even if it is not any better then the old widgets

Sep 01, 2015 at 01:37 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.37 #20Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
ggreene wrote:
chez wroteDon't forget you are talking about a $500 camera here. For what it is, the A6000 delivers pretty amazing images. Love to see you do anything at all with Canon's flagship ( which costs roughly $1,000 with viewfinder) M3 in that same gym.
Probably true but doesn't change the fact that ML seems to have issues with low light AF tracking. There are plenty of hands on forum posts about the A7RII still not having good low light AF tracking and that's a just released $3200 camera. Given that the A6000 is viewed as Sony's best action body its successor is of interest to me if Sony has a better AF module for it. If it's the same as the A7RII then we are still not there yet.


I don't see the A7r2 being a sports camera. It's a very good landscape, event, travel and street camera, but I would not use it for sports. It is definitely there for the photography niches I mentioned, but not action.

Not so sure Sony even wants to enter the action arena with both Canon and Nikon solidly in place there. If I was managing Sony camera products, action photography would be way down in my list...not a huge market that needs huge investments in both cameras and lenses.
Sep 01, 2015 at 01:44 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister