retrofocus wrote:
jctriguy wrote
retrofocus wrote
jctriguy wrote
retrofocus wrote
jctriguy wrote
I'm still waiting for your explanation of how a 0.5 vs 0.18 process is relevant (not Wikipedia, but you basic and easy to understand explanation)
Fact is that Sony had the exmor R sensor years ago. They had a BSI sensor over 6 years ago. The rest of us understand why it takes time to release these in different variations, but you seem to judge canon while ignoring all others. You just make up crap about what canon could've done, yet you don't have the faintest concept of product development or sensor technology(quoting a sensor spec repeatedly is not an understanding of sensor technology). To say it in simple words is that smaller process generation allows smaller pixel size needed to allow better resolution on a hardware basis. For example using 0.18 µm generation process technology produces 4.75 µm pitch pixels whereas Canon sticks with 0.5 µm generation leading to 6-8 µm pitch pixels up to nearly twice this size.
You forget that the Exmor R generation years ago is not the same as the current Exmor RS generation which addresses some of the R's llimitations by further increasing pixel sensitivity. You are incorrect in many ways here.
- Canon has a higher density sensor, how is that possible since they use a larger process spec?
- Why are smaller photo site sizes better?
- The a7rII uses the exmor R, not the RS. It was in fact release in 2008, so Sony is using tech from 2008 in the 'revolutionary' a7rII.
Again, what benefit is there for a smaller manufacturing process size, since the two sensors in question are roughly the same density and therefore it isn't for a higher density sensor as you incorrectly stated.
Also, why are you ok with Sony technology from 2008, but not Canon technology from the same timeframe? What does the age of the technology have to do with its characteristics? For the record, I don't care how old something is as long as it works. I know the Sony has better sensor specs in many areas, but are you buying it because it's newer or because it's better? Smaller pixels allow better spatial seperation between each of them which reduces unwanted electron tunneling and noise plus increases sharpness. This also allows a better setup of the microlens array. In addition, the pixel wells were improved to further avoid electron tunneling. There are several generations of Exmor R sensors with the first one announced in 2008 - and used in cell phones. The sensor used in the A7R is a far more developed generation from the first original cell phone sensor. You are comparing apples and oranges when stating that Sony used the same sensor technology in the A7 series. It is a different beast to go from a tiny cell phone sensor to a 35 mm full frame sensor.
Canon on the other hand released in 2008 the FF sensor in the 5D MkII and 1Ds camera series. At the time, it was top of the line for FF. Unfortunately - against other members belief here - I don't see a huge progression from this sensor (or the 7D MkII cropped sensor) towards the latest one in the 5Ds(R) series other that Canon finally improved the FF resolution. Software algorithms definitely helped to improve in noise and high ISO, in the 5Ds(R) maybe with a bit of DR improvement, but hardware-wise it is no big change IMO.
I decided to go with this Sony technology last year because I wanted a higher resolution FF camera which Canon did not offer. Additional benefit was much better DR at low ISO. So clearly yes, I benefit a lot from this sensor technology. That it came in a mirrorless body, was an additional benefit for me.
I agree nevertheless with your point to use older technology as long as it works. My IR-converted 5D MkII is still great because I am using it at low ISO and don't need a wide DR for this kind of photos. Thanks, I sorta expected you to not really understand the concept. It sounds like you are regurgitating tech specs without a full understanding.
Do you see the bias and irony in your assessment of what is old vs new technology? You say it's apples to oranges for a Sony sensor from 2008 to 2015, yet a canon sensor is identical in your mind. The test data shows that this isn't the case. The user reports (end results in prints) shows that this isn't the case. You are making a wild claim that canon could've released a product years earlier, yet you have absolutely no way of knowing anything about their capability to release such a sensor. You say that Sony couldn't possibly release a sensor, yet you constantly say they are capable of putting out a product at the drop of a hat, often waiting until canon releases to develop their technology.
Talk about apples and oranges. I guess it is fruitless to respond to anything you ask or write with your behavior. SNIP...random useless insults removed.
You try to pass off baseless opinions as statements of fact. People question your faulty logic and you get all in a huff about it. What do you expect when you say things like a multinational technology company could've released a product 3 years earlier. Combined with you lack of understanding of sensor designs, why should anyone pay attention to what you say? You can't even keep the exmor R and RS version separate. Why would I trust your opinion on the technical improvements of the last 10 years of image sensors?