fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII

  
 
mogul
Offline
Details
p.33 #1Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RustyBug wrote:
mogul wrote
jcolwell wrote
molson wroteOne question I have about the A7rII is - if Sony's lossy compression reduces 14-bit capture to only 11 bits, what happens when the camera switches to 12-bit capture? Does that drop the compressed "RAW" file to 9 bits, which is essentially a JPEG file?
mogul wroteNo, that is essentially a Canon raw file.
(?) Canon RAW files are 14-bit. Even on my little old SL1.
14 bit does you no good if your DR is in the 9 bit range
Isn't that kinda like saying that greater precision does you no good if you've only got a machinist's rule instead of a yardstick.

Range, accuracy and precision are not interchangeable. I don't think bit & DR are either.

I thought the 14 bit was the ability to have finer incrementation in your steps (which would assist with banding prevention), whereas dynamic range is how dark and how light the range between the two end points (0-1) can be. Won't a 9 bit file be ever more prone to banding / posterization once you start processing the numbers in PP ... regardless
...Show more →
From everything I read, 14 bit (which can not be seen) helps with tonality over 12 bit. Nikon seems to be the best at getting the most out of tonality with their file. Of course without DR expansion, all this for naught.


Edited on Aug 31, 2015 at 12:19 PM · View previous versions
Aug 31, 2015 at 12:14 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.33 #2Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
molson wrote:
alundeb wrote
molson wrote
mogul wrote
jcolwell wrote
molson wroteOne question I have about the A7rII is - if Sony's lossy compression reduces 14-bit capture to only 11 bits, what happens when the camera switches to 12-bit capture? Does that drop the compressed "RAW" file to 9 bits, which is essentially a JPEG file?
mogul wroteNo, that is essentially a Canon raw file.
(?) Canon RAW files are 14-bit. Even on my little old SL1.
14 bit does you no good if your DR is in the 9 bit range
Which brings up another point - how can Sony possibly claim to have (for example) 14 bits worth of dynamic range, when their files can't possibly contain that much data?
The A7r has 12.98 Ev dynamic range per pixel, Canon 5DS 11.08

It is possible to represent a little above 13 Ev DR at the pixel level in a 12 bits file with linear encoding.

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1359028/4#12963553
I think the question now is, what can be achieved with a 9-bit file? (or 9+7 delta, or whatever it is that results from the lossy compression...)


11 bits non-linear + 7 bits delta is more than enough to represent very high DR.
Aug 31, 2015 at 12:17 PM
rattlebonez
Offline
Details
p.33 #3Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Sony was not thinking when they developed that lossy RAW format

lacking behind the competition

Maybe the Sony A7R IV will get it right
Aug 31, 2015 at 12:23 PM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.33 #4Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
molson wrote
alundeb wrote
molson wrote
mogul wrote
jcolwell wrote(?) Canon RAW files are 14-bit. Even on my little old SL1.
14 bit does you no good if your DR is in the 9 bit range
Which brings up another point - how can Sony possibly claim to have (for example) 14 bits worth of dynamic range, when their files can't possibly contain that much data?
The A7r has 12.98 Ev dynamic range per pixel, Canon 5DS 11.08

It is possible to represent a little above 13 Ev DR at the pixel level in a 12 bits file with linear encoding.

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1359028/4#12963553
I think the question now is, what can be achieved with a 9-bit file? (or 9+7 delta, or whatever it is that results from the lossy compression...)
11 bits non-linear + 7 bits delta is more than enough to represent very high DR.


But in many operational modes, the Sony A7rII switches from 14-bit capture to 12-bit capture. If 14 bit capture gets you only 11 bits in the image file, then presumably 12-bit capture knocks your image file down to something like 9 bits...?


Aug 31, 2015 at 12:24 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.33 #5Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
molson wrote:
alundeb wrote
molson wrote
alundeb wrote
molson wrote
mogul wrote14 bit does you no good if your DR is in the 9 bit range
Which brings up another point - how can Sony possibly claim to have (for example) 14 bits worth of dynamic range, when their files can't possibly contain that much data?
The A7r has 12.98 Ev dynamic range per pixel, Canon 5DS 11.08

It is possible to represent a little above 13 Ev DR at the pixel level in a 12 bits file with linear encoding.

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1359028/4#12963553
I think the question now is, what can be achieved with a 9-bit file? (or 9+7 delta, or whatever it is that results from the lossy compression...)
11 bits non-linear + 7 bits delta is more than enough to represent very high DR.
But in many operational modes, the Sony A7rII switches from 14-bit capture to 12-bit capture. If 14 bit capture gets you only 11 bits in the image file, then presumably 12-bit capture knocks your image file down to something like 9 bits...?



I don't think that's how it works. Sony 12 bits is a different hardware mode not using the special encoding, so it would be more like Nikon's 12 bits files.
Aug 31, 2015 at 12:27 PM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.33 #6Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
molson wrote
alundeb wrote
molson wrote
alundeb wrote
molson wroteWhich brings up another point - how can Sony possibly claim to have (for example) 14 bits worth of dynamic range, when their files can't possibly contain that much data?
The A7r has 12.98 Ev dynamic range per pixel, Canon 5DS 11.08

It is possible to represent a little above 13 Ev DR at the pixel level in a 12 bits file with linear encoding.

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1359028/4#12963553
I think the question now is, what can be achieved with a 9-bit file? (or 9+7 delta, or whatever it is that results from the lossy compression...)
11 bits non-linear + 7 bits delta is more than enough to represent very high DR.
But in many operational modes, the Sony A7rII switches from 14-bit capture to 12-bit capture. If 14 bit capture gets you only 11 bits in the image file, then presumably 12-bit capture knocks your image file down to something like 9 bits...?
I don't think that's how it works. Sony 12 bits is a different hardware mode not using the special encoding, so it would be more like Nikon's 12 bits files.


So Sony's 12-bit mode records more data than their 14-bit mode, which is really only 11 bits? This is beginning to sound like an Abbott and Costello routine.

I guess that's why Sony were so slow to move to 14-bit capture when all the other manufacturers did.
Aug 31, 2015 at 12:34 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.33 #7Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
molson wrote:
alundeb wrote
molson wrote
alundeb wrote
molson wrote
alundeb wroteThe A7r has 12.98 Ev dynamic range per pixel, Canon 5DS 11.08

It is possible to represent a little above 13 Ev DR at the pixel level in a 12 bits file with linear encoding.

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1359028/4#12963553
I think the question now is, what can be achieved with a 9-bit file? (or 9+7 delta, or whatever it is that results from the lossy compression...)
11 bits non-linear + 7 bits delta is more than enough to represent very high DR.
But in many operational modes, the Sony A7rII switches from 14-bit capture to 12-bit capture. If 14 bit capture gets you only 11 bits in the image file, then presumably 12-bit capture knocks your image file down to something like 9 bits...?
I don't think that's how it works. Sony 12 bits is a different hardware mode not using the special encoding, so it would be more like Nikon's 12 bits files.
So Sony's 12-bit mode records more data than their 14-bit mode, which is really only 11 bits? This is beginning to sound like an Abbott and Costello routine.

I guess that's why Sony were so slow to move to 14-bit capture when all the other manufacturers did.


Nope, thats not it either

11 + 7 bits records more data than 12 bits
Aug 31, 2015 at 12:42 PM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.33 #8Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
molson wrote
alundeb wrote
molson wrote
alundeb wrote
molson wroteI think the question now is, what can be achieved with a 9-bit file? (or 9+7 delta, or whatever it is that results from the lossy compression...)
11 bits non-linear + 7 bits delta is more than enough to represent very high DR.
But in many operational modes, the Sony A7rII switches from 14-bit capture to 12-bit capture. If 14 bit capture gets you only 11 bits in the image file, then presumably 12-bit capture knocks your image file down to something like 9 bits...?
I don't think that's how it works. Sony 12 bits is a different hardware mode not using the special encoding, so it would be more like Nikon's 12 bits files.
So Sony's 12-bit mode records more data than their 14-bit mode, which is really only 11 bits? This is beginning to sound like an Abbott and Costello routine.

I guess that's why Sony were so slow to move to 14-bit capture when all the other manufacturers did.
Nope, thats not it either

11 + 7 bits records more data than 12 bits


So it's 11+7 = 18 bits? Or is it just a poorly derived description.
Aug 31, 2015 at 12:56 PM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.33 #9Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
retrofocus wrote. Everybody knows that the 5Ds(R) is a 7D MkII sensor technology (where Canon did some minor tweaks compared to ealier sensor technology).
Now we are back to the original point, the 7D Mk II sensor technology is newer than the 5D mk III, so Canon positively could not have released a 5DS quality sensor along with the 5D III, as you stated they should have.

And I don't care if you don't care about my annoyance, but I am not going to watch silently that you say the 5DS sensor is basically the same technology as the 5D II regarding dynamic range, because Canon has actually closed 1/3 of the gap to Sony (normalized, measured) and much more subjectively because of the noise
...Show more →

I think we remain in disagreement here. From a hardware perspective, I really don't see a big improvement in Canon's FF sensors since 2008. I give them that they improved the algorithms and the internal image processing parameters to tweak to a better performance especially at high ISO. I really question that the slightly improved DR in the 5Ds(R) comes from the sensor itself at all. Of course you will argue now that the end result counts no matter how it is done. And if you are willing to vest $4K for this technology with just "usable" DR as you said then so be it. Just I rather invest in newer sensor technology itself out there. Canon fanboys don't like to hear this, but sensor technology was and is not a focus area for Canon after they were very successful to develop the 5D MkII and the equivalent sensor in the former 1Ds series camera.
Aug 31, 2015 at 12:59 PM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.33 #10Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Okay... somebody help me out here.

8 bits = 256 distinct color tones (JPEG)

11 bits = 2,048 distinct color tones

12 bits = 4,096 distinct color tones

14 bits = 16,384 distinct color tones (Canon RAW)

11 + 7 bits = ?
Aug 31, 2015 at 01:03 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.33 #11Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
retrofocus wrote:
alundeb wrote
retrofocus wrote. Everybody knows that the 5Ds(R) is a 7D MkII sensor technology (where Canon did some minor tweaks compared to ealier sensor technology).
Now we are back to the original point, the 7D Mk II sensor technology is newer than the 5D mk III, so Canon positively could not have released a 5DS quality sensor along with the 5D III, as you stated they should have.

And I don't care if you don't care about my annoyance, but I am not going to watch silently that you say the 5DS sensor is basically the same technology as the 5D II regarding dynamic range, because Canon has actually closed 1/3 of the gap to Sony (normalized, measured) and much more subjectively because of the noise character. That difference makes a heck of an importance to many people, because it breaks the barrier from bad to usable in many's view.
I think we remain in disagreement here. From a hardware perspective, I really don't see a big improvement in Canon's FF sensors since 2008. I give them that they improved the algorithms and the internal image processing parameters to tweak to a better performance especially at high ISO. I really question that the slightly improved DR in the 5Ds(R) comes from the sensor itself at all. Of course you will argue now that the end result counts no matter how it is done. And if you are willing to vest $4K for this technology with just "usable" DR as you
...Show more →

Yes we remain in disagreement. As much as I value high DR, I prefer my 5DS R files over my A7r files.
Aug 31, 2015 at 01:06 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.33 #12Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
molson wrote:
alundeb wrote
molson wrote
alundeb wrote
molson wrote
alundeb wrote11 bits non-linear + 7 bits delta is more than enough to represent very high DR.
But in many operational modes, the Sony A7rII switches from 14-bit capture to 12-bit capture. If 14 bit capture gets you only 11 bits in the image file, then presumably 12-bit capture knocks your image file down to something like 9 bits...?
I don't think that's how it works. Sony 12 bits is a different hardware mode not using the special encoding, so it would be more like Nikon's 12 bits files.
So Sony's 12-bit mode records more data than their 14-bit mode, which is really only 11 bits? This is beginning to sound like an Abbott and Costello routine.

I guess that's why Sony were so slow to move to 14-bit capture when all the other manufacturers did.
Nope, thats not it either

11 + 7 bits records more data than 12 bits
So it's 11+7 = 18 bits? Or is it just a poorly derived description.


Simplified it works like this:
In a patch, a reference pixel is assigned one value in 11 bits non-linear encoding. Then the position of the brightest and darkest pixel within the patch are stored. The delta between them is encoded with 7 bits. If there is little difference between brightest and darkest, one can approach 18 bits in the encoding scheme. If the difference is higher, the tonal resolution decreases. But the 11 bits remain, and they are not linearly encoded.
Aug 31, 2015 at 01:10 PM
rattlebonez
Offline
Details
p.33 #13Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
A7R II is lacking the competition for RAW unless Sony can patch with a firmware update
but the hardware may be the limitation

Too many issues with A7R II for me -- over-hyped for what it delivers
Aug 31, 2015 at 01:12 PM
Shield
Offline
Details
p.33 #14Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
retrofocus wrote:
alundeb wrote
retrofocus wrote. Everybody knows that the 5Ds(R) is a 7D MkII sensor technology (where Canon did some minor tweaks compared to ealier sensor technology).
Now we are back to the original point, the 7D Mk II sensor technology is newer than the 5D mk III, so Canon positively could not have released a 5DS quality sensor along with the 5D III, as you stated they should have.

And I don't care if you don't care about my annoyance, but I am not going to watch silently that you say the 5DS sensor is basically the same technology as the 5D II regarding dynamic range, because Canon has actually closed 1/3 of the gap to Sony (normalized, measured) and much more subjectively because of the noise character. That difference makes a heck of an importance to many people, because it breaks the barrier from bad to usable in many's view.
I think we remain in disagreement here. From a hardware perspective, I really don't see a big improvement in Canon's FF sensors since 2008. I give them that they improved the algorithms and the internal image processing parameters to tweak to a better performance especially at high ISO. I really question that the slightly improved DR in the 5Ds(R) comes from the sensor itself at all. Of course you will argue now that the end result counts no matter how it is done. And if you are willing to vest $4K for this technology with just "usable" DR as you
...Show more →

I must ask you - which Canon bodies have you spent a great deal of time with since 2008? I see a noticable difference in my 1dc raw vs. the 5d3 I shot for 2 years. Could just be confirmation bias, but I swear there's just an extra ounce or two of goodness in those 1dc raw files. Especially in lower light.

Aug 31, 2015 at 01:12 PM
ggreene
Offline
Details
p.33 #15Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
I have no problem with companies having different priorities or areas of focus. Since 2008 Canon has made some pretty nice strides in getting better high ISO. Back then I was using a pair of 1D2's and 1600/3200 was pretty rough. 1D4 made large improvements in high ISO allowing me to go to 2.8 zooms with far more versatility then primes. 1DX took it to another level yet again. I think Canon simply believed that more people were interested in high ISO then low ISO DR and the 5D3 sales seem to prove them right. The thing is still on the Amazon top selling DSLR list and it's over 3.5 years old. Clearly people don't view low ISO DR as the be all end all for photography.

Whether they can reproduce that kind of success with the 5D4 I have no idea but Canon sure hopes they can.
Aug 31, 2015 at 01:28 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.33 #16Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
retrofocus wrote:
alundeb wrote
retrofocus wrote. Everybody knows that the 5Ds(R) is a 7D MkII sensor technology (where Canon did some minor tweaks compared to ealier sensor technology).
Now we are back to the original point, the 7D Mk II sensor technology is newer than the 5D mk III, so Canon positively could not have released a 5DS quality sensor along with the 5D III, as you stated they should have.

And I don't care if you don't care about my annoyance, but I am not going to watch silently that you say the 5DS sensor is basically the same technology as the 5D II regarding dynamic range, because Canon has actually closed 1/3 of the gap to Sony (normalized, measured) and much more subjectively because of the noise character. That difference makes a heck of an importance to many people, because it breaks the barrier from bad to usable in many's view.
I think we remain in disagreement here. From a hardware perspective, I really don't see a big improvement in Canon's FF sensors since 2008. I give them that they improved the algorithms and the internal image processing parameters to tweak to a better performance especially at high ISO. I really question that the slightly improved DR in the 5Ds(R) comes from the sensor itself at all. Of course you will argue now that the end result counts no matter how it is done. And if you are willing to vest $4K for this technology with just "usable" DR as you
...Show more →

What I find curious is that neither you nor mttran nor chez who speak so highly of the latest Sony sensor developments, seem to upgrade to the new Sony A7rII. Aren't the improvements from this groundbreaking new technology so much better after all?
Aug 31, 2015 at 01:59 PM
chez
Online
Details
p.33 #17Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
retrofocus wrote
alundeb wrote
retrofocus wrote. Everybody knows that the 5Ds(R) is a 7D MkII sensor technology (where Canon did some minor tweaks compared to ealier sensor technology).
Now we are back to the original point, the 7D Mk II sensor technology is newer than the 5D mk III, so Canon positively could not have released a 5DS quality sensor along with the 5D III, as you stated they should have.

And I don't care if you don't care about my annoyance, but I am not going to watch silently that you say the 5DS sensor is basically the same technology as the 5D II regarding dynamic range, because Canon has actually closed 1/3 of the gap to Sony (normalized, measured) and much more subjectively because of the noise character. That difference makes a heck of an importance to many people, because it breaks the barrier from bad to usable in many's view.
I think we remain in disagreement here. From a hardware perspective, I really don't see a big improvement in Canon's FF sensors since 2008. I give them that they improved the algorithms and the internal image processing parameters to tweak to a better performance especially at high ISO. I really question that the slightly improved DR in the 5Ds(R) comes from the sensor itself at all. Of course you will argue now that the end result counts no matter how it is done. And if you are willing to vest $4K for this technology with just "usable" DR as you said then so be it. Just I rather invest in newer sensor technology itself out there. Canon fanboys don't like to hear this, but sensor technology was and is not a focus area for Canon after they were very successful to develop the 5D MkII and the equivalent sensor in the former 1Ds series camera.
What I find curious is that neither you nor mttran nor chez who speak so highly of the latest Sony sensor developments, seem to upgrade to the new Sony A7rII. Aren't the improvements from this groundbreaking new technology so much better after all?


Speaking for myself...I'm still evaluating the camera. Have rented it and really enjoyed all the improvements...but am weighing those improvements and the extra costs. It's always a tradeoff between cost and improvements. My current A7R produces amazing images...that to me is number 1. I don't shoot my Canon lenses in AF mode...mainly use them for landscapes tripod mounted. I use quite a few manual focus lenses which shine on the A7R. I bought a Sony 16-35 for my street shooting in AF if I so desire.

Would I love to upgrade to the A7R2...you bet. If you buy it for me, I surely won't refuse it...but would I pay over $4,000 Canadian for it...not at this moment.

It was the exact same feature versus tradeoff I did when I was evaluating upgrading from the 5D2 to the 5D3 and I just did not see enough benefits in the 5D3 to warrant the costs. I then looked into the A7R and it truly did provide the benefits I was looking for over what the 5D2(3) could deliver...so I purchased the A7R.

Edited on Aug 31, 2015 at 02:26 PM · View previous versions
Aug 31, 2015 at 02:22 PM
mogul
Offline
Details
p.33 #18Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
retrofocus wrote
alundeb wrote
retrofocus wrote. Everybody knows that the 5Ds(R) is a 7D MkII sensor technology (where Canon did some minor tweaks compared to ealier sensor technology).
Now we are back to the original point, the 7D Mk II sensor technology is newer than the 5D mk III, so Canon positively could not have released a 5DS quality sensor along with the 5D III, as you stated they should have.

And I don't care if you don't care about my annoyance, but I am not going to watch silently that you say the 5DS sensor is basically the same technology as the 5D II regarding dynamic range, because Canon has actually closed 1/3 of the gap to Sony (normalized, measured) and much more subjectively because of the noise character. That difference makes a heck of an importance to many people, because it breaks the barrier from bad to usable in many's view.
I think we remain in disagreement here. From a hardware perspective, I really don't see a big improvement in Canon's FF sensors since 2008. I give them that they improved the algorithms and the internal image processing parameters to tweak to a better performance especially at high ISO. I really question that the slightly improved DR in the 5Ds(R) comes from the sensor itself at all. Of course you will argue now that the end result counts no matter how it is done. And if you are willing to vest $4K for this technology with just "usable" DR as you said then so be it. Just I rather invest in newer sensor technology itself out there. Canon fanboys don't like to hear this, but sensor technology was and is not a focus area for Canon after they were very successful to develop the 5D MkII and the equivalent sensor in the former 1Ds series camera.
What I find curious is that neither you nor mttran nor chez who speak so highly of the latest Sony sensor developments, seem to upgrade to the new Sony A7rII. Aren't the improvements from this groundbreaking new technology so much better after all?


We all want the best but the almighty $ gets in the way.
Aug 31, 2015 at 02:24 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.33 #19Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
001 IF readerA likes cameraA
002 AND readerB likes cameraB
003 THEN readerA yell at readerB
004 THEN readerB yell at readerA
005 GOTO 003

Not a lot left to say that hasn't been said to death on this subject at this point, is there? ;-)

Edited on Aug 31, 2015 at 03:05 PM · View previous versions
Aug 31, 2015 at 02:26 PM
chez
Online
Details
p.33 #20Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
gdanmitchell wrote:
001 IF readerA likes cameraA
002 AND readerB likes cameraB
003 THEN readerA yell at readerB
004 THEN readerB yell at readerA
005 GOTO 003



And what happens when bystander interrupts with his stupid remarks...like usual?

Dan for just once, practice what you keep preaching.
Aug 31, 2015 at 02:29 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister