retrofocus wrote:
Shield wrote
retrofocus wrote
alundeb wrote
retrofocus wrote
. Everybody knows that the 5Ds(R) is a 7D MkII sensor technology (where Canon did some minor tweaks compared to ealier sensor technology). Now we are back to the original point, the 7D Mk II sensor technology is newer than the 5D mk III, so Canon positively could not have released a 5DS quality sensor along with the 5D III, as you stated they should have.
And I don't care if you don't care about my annoyance, but I am not going to watch silently that you say the 5DS sensor is basically the same technology as the 5D II regarding dynamic range, because Canon has actually closed 1/3 of the gap to Sony (normalized, measured) and much more subjectively because of the noise character. That difference makes a heck of an importance to many people, because it breaks the barrier from bad to usable in many's view. I think we remain in disagreement here. From a hardware perspective, I really don't see a big improvement in Canon's FF sensors since 2008. I give them that they improved the algorithms and the internal image processing parameters to tweak to a better performance especially at high ISO. I really question that the slightly improved DR in the 5Ds(R) comes from the sensor itself at all. Of course you will argue now that the end result counts no matter how it is done. And if you are willing to vest $4K for this technology with just "usable" DR as you said then so be it. Just I rather invest in newer sensor technology itself out there. Canon fanboys don't like to hear this, but sensor technology was and is not a focus area for Canon after they were very successful to develop the 5D MkII and the equivalent sensor in the former 1Ds series camera. I must ask you - which Canon bodies have you spent a great deal of time with since 2008? I see a noticable difference in my 1dc raw vs. the 5d3 I shot for 2 years. Could just be confirmation bias, but I swear there's just an extra ounce or two of goodness in those 1dc raw files. Especially in lower light. In 2009 and 2012 I bought 5D MkII camera bodies, one of them converted to IR. I have used the 5D MkIII for three weeks on a vacation and did not find anything better in image quality, just much better AF options (which I didn't need). I have never shot with a 1D series body and have no interest in doing so (too clunky, and I wouldn't benefit from the performance there in my style of photography).
What is your experience with the 5dsr? And what position did you have with canon from 2008-2015...I'm assuming you must've been at a product development meeting as a canon employee since you know they had a 50mp FF ready and decided not to implement it. Otherwise, I guess you are just spouting your typical BS...