fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII

  
 
chez
Offline
Details
p.34 #1Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
mogul wrote:
alundeb wrote
retrofocus wrote
alundeb wrote
retrofocus wrote. Everybody knows that the 5Ds(R) is a 7D MkII sensor technology (where Canon did some minor tweaks compared to ealier sensor technology).
Now we are back to the original point, the 7D Mk II sensor technology is newer than the 5D mk III, so Canon positively could not have released a 5DS quality sensor along with the 5D III, as you stated they should have.

And I don't care if you don't care about my annoyance, but I am not going to watch silently that you say the 5DS sensor is basically the same technology as the 5D II regarding dynamic range, because Canon has actually closed 1/3 of the gap to Sony (normalized, measured) and much more subjectively because of the noise character. That difference makes a heck of an importance to many people, because it breaks the barrier from bad to usable in many's view.
I think we remain in disagreement here. From a hardware perspective, I really don't see a big improvement in Canon's FF sensors since 2008. I give them that they improved the algorithms and the internal image processing parameters to tweak to a better performance especially at high ISO. I really question that the slightly improved DR in the 5Ds(R) comes from the sensor itself at all. Of course you will argue now that the end result counts no matter how it is done. And if you are willing to vest $4K for this technology with just "usable" DR as you said then so be it. Just I rather invest in newer sensor technology itself out there. Canon fanboys don't like to hear this, but sensor technology was and is not a focus area for Canon after they were very successful to develop the 5D MkII and the equivalent sensor in the former 1Ds series camera.
What I find curious is that neither you nor mttran nor chez who speak so highly of the latest Sony sensor developments, seem to upgrade to the new Sony A7rII. Aren't the improvements from this groundbreaking new technology so much better after all?
We all want the best but the almighty $ gets in the way.


Yep...if it wasn't for the little thing called money...we'd all have the best of the best. Unfortunately, we all need to make practical decisions that we can afford.
Aug 31, 2015 at 02:30 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.34 #2Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
But, if it makes such a marvelous improvement to ones photography that no one should be without it, it should be able to pay for itself with ease.

I mean, how many of those high dollar prints would you have to sell to make up the diff. Surely, from the immense amount of improvement gained by the BSI, IBIS, MP and DR ... that would make your sales go through the roof and recoup your ROI in very short order. After all, if you've already got the A7R and MB adapter, you're only upgrading around $2,000 after you sell your A7R.

If you revisit all that has been said about the technological breakthrough and incredible difference it makes, well ... it sounds more like you can't afford NOT to upgrade, rather than you can't afford TO upgrade.





Edited on Aug 31, 2015 at 02:52 PM · View previous versions
Aug 31, 2015 at 02:45 PM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.34 #3Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
retrofocus wrote:
Joke is that something was fixed which shouldn't have been there in the first place and now being used as a positive how Canon innovates. That it took Canon so long to fix it just supports my reasoning from mentioned above.



Are you suggesting that everything should be perfect from day one? Or maybe that every product should always be at the level of the best available product in every aspect?

I can't believe it took Sony so long to catch up at high ISO. I can't believe that we still have noise in any image. I can't believe people are praising Sony for getting AF to finally work (in some cases).

Do you see how illogical your arguments are here?
Aug 31, 2015 at 02:49 PM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.34 #4Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RustyBug wrote:
But, if it makes such a marvelous improvement to ones photography that no one should be without it, it should be able to pay for itself with ease.

I mean, how many of those high dollar prints would you have to sell to make up the diff. Surely, from the immense amount of improvement gained by the BSI, IBIS, MP and DR ... that would make your sales go through the roof and recoup your ROI in very short order.

If you revisit all that has been said about the technological breakthrough and incredible difference it makes, well ... it sounds
...Show more →

+1. Collecting more lights is simple engineering solution. Can't believe that everyone hasn't already switched over. Especially for people that sell so many prints to hotels and interior designers...should be one order and have the camera paid for.
Aug 31, 2015 at 02:51 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.34 #5Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
jctriguy wrote:
Especially for people that sell so many prints to hotels and interior designers...should be one order and have the camera paid for.


You do realize that now you're losing money faster than the government can print it by not using the A7R II. If you wait much longer to upgrade, you'll have lost more money than the national debt. (Snarcasm, in case you were wondering.)

Sorry, couldn't resist. Please forgive the departure for a light-hearted dabble in faulty logic.
Aug 31, 2015 at 02:57 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.34 #6Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Ah, funny, guys. Revised code:

001 IF readerA likes cameraA
002 AND readerB likes cameraB
003 THEN readerA yell at readerB
004 THEN readerB yell at readerA
005 GOTO humor... ;-)
Aug 31, 2015 at 03:10 PM
jcolwell
Offline
Details
p.34 #7Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
gdanmitchell wrote:
Ah, funny, guys. Revised code:

001 IF readerA likes cameraA
002 AND readerB likes cameraB
003 THEN readerA yell at readerB
004 THEN readerB yell at readerA
005 GOTO humor... ;-)


Hopefully, humor is one line before END.
Aug 31, 2015 at 03:18 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.34 #8Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RustyBug wrote:
But, if it makes such a marvelous improvement to ones photography that no one should be without it, it should be able to pay for itself with ease.

I mean, how many of those high dollar prints would you have to sell to make up the diff. Surely, from the immense amount of improvement gained by the BSI, IBIS, MP and DR ... that would make your sales go through the roof and recoup your ROI in very short order. After all, if you've already got the A7R and MB adapter, you're only upgrading around $2,000 after you sell your
...Show more →

Rusty...if you have been following my discussions on the A7R2...I've been very consistent saying it is too expensive for what it brings to the table for me. I am waiting for the price to drop...then I'll most likely sell my 5D2 and A7R and pick up the A7R2...but not until the price drops.

I've been very consistent in this matter...I don't appreciate you insulating otherwise as that is not true.



Aug 31, 2015 at 03:23 PM
Cliff L.
Online
Details
p.34 #9Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RustyBug wrote:
If you wait much longer to upgrade, you'll have lost more money than the national debt. (Snarcasm, in case you were wondering.)


"Snarcasm" aside, that does sort of describe precipitous trajectory of Sony equipment depreciation - compounded by the number of spares you need to own to offset the amount of time it takes Sony's apathetic service department to repair their shoddy products...
Aug 31, 2015 at 03:25 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.34 #10Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
jctriguy wrote:
RustyBug wroteBut, if it makes such a marvelous improvement to ones photography that no one should be without it, it should be able to pay for itself with ease.

I mean, how many of those high dollar prints would you have to sell to make up the diff. Surely, from the immense amount of improvement gained by the BSI, IBIS, MP and DR ... that would make your sales go through the roof and recoup your ROI in very short order.

If you revisit all that has been said about the technological breakthrough and incredible difference it makes, well ... it sounds more like you can't afford NOT to upgrade, rather than you can't afford TO upgrade.
+1. Collecting more lights is simple engineering solution. Can't believe that everyone hasn't already switched over. Especially for people that sell so many prints to hotels and interior designers...should be one order and have the camera paid for.


JC...you and your sideline cheerleaders ( you know who you are )...you are just starting to sound stupid. I'd continue to engage these idiotic discussion along with your side crew...but I feel it will deteriorate to much and we'll all join you ( and your sideshow ) in looking stupid.

It's painfully obvious the Canon forum is not where you can discuss anything else other than praises for Canon equipment. Really a shame as it was once a great forum with many knowledgeable people all willing to share their experiences. Many of these people have left...I can see why.
Aug 31, 2015 at 03:27 PM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.34 #11Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
jctriguy wrote
RustyBug wroteBut, if it makes such a marvelous improvement to ones photography that no one should be without it, it should be able to pay for itself with ease.

I mean, how many of those high dollar prints would you have to sell to make up the diff. Surely, from the immense amount of improvement gained by the BSI, IBIS, MP and DR ... that would make your sales go through the roof and recoup your ROI in very short order.

If you revisit all that has been said about the technological breakthrough and incredible difference it makes, well ... it sounds more like you can't afford NOT to upgrade, rather than you can't afford TO upgrade.
+1. Collecting more lights is simple engineering solution. Can't believe that everyone hasn't already switched over. Especially for people that sell so many prints to hotels and interior designers...should be one order and have the camera paid for.
JC...you and your sideline cheerleaders ( you know who you are )...you are just starting to sound stupid. I'd continue to engage these idiotic discussion along with your side crew...but I feel it will deteriorate to much and we'll all join you ( and your sideshow ) in looking stupid.

It's painfully obvious the Canon forum is not where you can discuss anything else other than praises for Canon equipment. Really a shame as it was once a great forum with many knowledgeable people all willing to share their experiences. Many of these people have left...I can see why.


I'll just quote this in case you sober up and choose to delete it. Quite pathetic attitude.

Aug 31, 2015 at 04:23 PM
Gunzorro
Offline
Details
p.34 #12Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
RustyBug wroteBut, if it makes such a marvelous improvement to ones photography that no one should be without it, it should be able to pay for itself with ease.

I mean, how many of those high dollar prints would you have to sell to make up the diff. Surely, from the immense amount of improvement gained by the BSI, IBIS, MP and DR ... that would make your sales go through the roof and recoup your ROI in very short order. After all, if you've already got the A7R and MB adapter, you're only upgrading around $2,000 after you sell your A7R.

If you revisit all that has been said about the technological breakthrough and incredible difference it makes, well ... it sounds more like you can't afford NOT to upgrade, rather than you can't afford TO upgrade.
Rusty...if you have been following my discussions on the A7R2...I've been very consistent saying it is too expensive for what it brings to the table for me. I am waiting for the price to drop...then I'll most likely sell my 5D2 and A7R and pick up the A7R2...but not until the price drops.

I've been very consistent in this matter...I don't appreciate you insulating otherwise as that is not true.





Anyone have a definition or origin for this? Insulating (from snarcasm)? Home remodeling?

"I don't appreciate you insulating otherwise as that is not true."

Really, this stuff just writes itself in front of me:

" . . . and we'll all join you ( and your sideshow ) in looking stupid."

I don't know about anyone else, but I have some rather bad news. That ship has sailed for you.
Aug 31, 2015 at 04:50 PM
jcolwell
Offline
Details
p.34 #13Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
...Really a shame as it was once a great forum with many knowledgeable people all willing to share their experiences. Many of these people have left...I can see why.


The Canon forum is still an interesting and informative place. By my reckoning, there are three or four threads on the first page of fifty active Canon threads that have a significant content of rude bickering. Apparently, some subjects are too touchy for some folks to handle in a civil manner. This is true for people on both sides of the fence. It diminishes us all.
Aug 31, 2015 at 04:59 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.34 #14Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
jcolwell wrote:
gdanmitchell wroteAh, funny, guys. Revised code:

001 IF readerA likes cameraA
002 AND readerB likes cameraB
003 THEN readerA yell at readerB
004 THEN readerB yell at readerA
005 GOTO humor... ;-)
Hopefully, humor is one line before END.


END would be good.

Or EXIT. Or even REBOOT. ;-)
Aug 31, 2015 at 05:23 PM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.34 #15Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
retrofocus wrote
alundeb wrote
retrofocus wrote. Everybody knows that the 5Ds(R) is a 7D MkII sensor technology (where Canon did some minor tweaks compared to ealier sensor technology).
Now we are back to the original point, the 7D Mk II sensor technology is newer than the 5D mk III, so Canon positively could not have released a 5DS quality sensor along with the 5D III, as you stated they should have.

And I don't care if you don't care about my annoyance, but I am not going to watch silently that you say the 5DS sensor is basically the same technology as the 5D II regarding dynamic range, because Canon has actually closed 1/3 of the gap to Sony (normalized, measured) and much more subjectively because of the noise character. That difference makes a heck of an importance to many people, because it breaks the barrier from bad to usable in many's view.
I think we remain in disagreement here. From a hardware perspective, I really don't see a big improvement in Canon's FF sensors since 2008. I give them that they improved the algorithms and the internal image processing parameters to tweak to a better performance especially at high ISO. I really question that the slightly improved DR in the 5Ds(R) comes from the sensor itself at all. Of course you will argue now that the end result counts no matter how it is done. And if you are willing to vest $4K for this technology with just "usable" DR as you said then so be it. Just I rather invest in newer sensor technology itself out there. Canon fanboys don't like to hear this, but sensor technology was and is not a focus area for Canon after they were very successful to develop the 5D MkII and the equivalent sensor in the former 1Ds series camera.
What I find curious is that neither you nor mttran nor chez who speak so highly of the latest Sony sensor developments, seem to upgrade to the new Sony A7rII. Aren't the improvements from this groundbreaking new technology so much better after all?


In my case it is simply a matter of price and if I benefit from improvements. I am not willing to spend $3200 upfront for a new mirrorless camera body. Also, the main improvements of the A7R II - better AF, better high ISO (deriving from the new sensor) - are not really of interest to me. As I said above, only if I see a valuable benefit of the backlit sensor especially with my rangefinder lenses compared to the A7R and at low ISO, I would consider an upgrade.
Aug 31, 2015 at 05:51 PM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.34 #16Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Shield wrote:
retrofocus wrote
alundeb wrote
retrofocus wrote. Everybody knows that the 5Ds(R) is a 7D MkII sensor technology (where Canon did some minor tweaks compared to ealier sensor technology).
Now we are back to the original point, the 7D Mk II sensor technology is newer than the 5D mk III, so Canon positively could not have released a 5DS quality sensor along with the 5D III, as you stated they should have.

And I don't care if you don't care about my annoyance, but I am not going to watch silently that you say the 5DS sensor is basically the same technology as the 5D II regarding dynamic range, because Canon has actually closed 1/3 of the gap to Sony (normalized, measured) and much more subjectively because of the noise character. That difference makes a heck of an importance to many people, because it breaks the barrier from bad to usable in many's view.
I think we remain in disagreement here. From a hardware perspective, I really don't see a big improvement in Canon's FF sensors since 2008. I give them that they improved the algorithms and the internal image processing parameters to tweak to a better performance especially at high ISO. I really question that the slightly improved DR in the 5Ds(R) comes from the sensor itself at all. Of course you will argue now that the end result counts no matter how it is done. And if you are willing to vest $4K for this technology with just "usable" DR as you said then so be it. Just I rather invest in newer sensor technology itself out there. Canon fanboys don't like to hear this, but sensor technology was and is not a focus area for Canon after they were very successful to develop the 5D MkII and the equivalent sensor in the former 1Ds series camera.
I must ask you - which Canon bodies have you spent a great deal of time with since 2008? I see a noticable difference in my 1dc raw vs. the 5d3 I shot for 2 years. Could just be confirmation bias, but I swear there's just an extra ounce or two of goodness in those 1dc raw files. Especially in lower light.



In 2009 and 2012 I bought 5D MkII camera bodies, one of them converted to IR. I have used the 5D MkIII for three weeks on a vacation and did not find anything better in image quality, just much better AF options (which I didn't need). I have never shot with a 1D series body and have no interest in doing so (too clunky, and I wouldn't benefit from the performance there in my style of photography).
Aug 31, 2015 at 05:56 PM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.34 #17Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
retrofocus wrote:
Shield wrote
retrofocus wrote
alundeb wrote
retrofocus wrote. Everybody knows that the 5Ds(R) is a 7D MkII sensor technology (where Canon did some minor tweaks compared to ealier sensor technology).
Now we are back to the original point, the 7D Mk II sensor technology is newer than the 5D mk III, so Canon positively could not have released a 5DS quality sensor along with the 5D III, as you stated they should have.

And I don't care if you don't care about my annoyance, but I am not going to watch silently that you say the 5DS sensor is basically the same technology as the 5D II regarding dynamic range, because Canon has actually closed 1/3 of the gap to Sony (normalized, measured) and much more subjectively because of the noise character. That difference makes a heck of an importance to many people, because it breaks the barrier from bad to usable in many's view.
I think we remain in disagreement here. From a hardware perspective, I really don't see a big improvement in Canon's FF sensors since 2008. I give them that they improved the algorithms and the internal image processing parameters to tweak to a better performance especially at high ISO. I really question that the slightly improved DR in the 5Ds(R) comes from the sensor itself at all. Of course you will argue now that the end result counts no matter how it is done. And if you are willing to vest $4K for this technology with just "usable" DR as you said then so be it. Just I rather invest in newer sensor technology itself out there. Canon fanboys don't like to hear this, but sensor technology was and is not a focus area for Canon after they were very successful to develop the 5D MkII and the equivalent sensor in the former 1Ds series camera.
I must ask you - which Canon bodies have you spent a great deal of time with since 2008? I see a noticable difference in my 1dc raw vs. the 5d3 I shot for 2 years. Could just be confirmation bias, but I swear there's just an extra ounce or two of goodness in those 1dc raw files. Especially in lower light.
In 2009 and 2012 I bought 5D MkII camera bodies, one of them converted to IR. I have used the 5D MkIII for three weeks on a vacation and did not find anything better in image quality, just much better AF options (which I didn't need). I have never shot with a 1D series body and have no interest in doing so (too clunky, and I wouldn't benefit from the performance there in my style of photography).


What is your experience with the 5dsr? And what position did you have with canon from 2008-2015...I'm assuming you must've been at a product development meeting as a canon employee since you know they had a 50mp FF ready and decided not to implement it. Otherwise, I guess you are just spouting your typical BS...
Aug 31, 2015 at 06:06 PM
Imagemaster
Offline
Details
p.34 #18Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
It's painfully obvious the Canon forum is not where you can discuss anything else other than praises for Canon equipment. Really a shame as it was once a great forum with many knowledgeable people all willing to share their experiences. Many of these people have left...I can see why.


Look who's talking. Talk about the pot calling the kettle black.
Aug 31, 2015 at 06:29 PM
Sneakyracer
Offline
Details
p.34 #19Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
mogul wrote
alundeb wrote
retrofocus wrote
alundeb wrote
retrofocus wrote. Everybody knows that the 5Ds(R) is a 7D MkII sensor technology (where Canon did some minor tweaks compared to ealier sensor technology).
Now we are back to the original point, the 7D Mk II sensor technology is newer than the 5D mk III, so Canon positively could not have released a 5DS quality sensor along with the 5D III, as you stated they should have.

And I don't care if you don't care about my annoyance, but I am not going to watch silently that you say the 5DS sensor is basically the same technology as the 5D II regarding dynamic range, because Canon has actually closed 1/3 of the gap to Sony (normalized, measured) and much more subjectively because of the noise character. That difference makes a heck of an importance to many people, because it breaks the barrier from bad to usable in many's view.
I think we remain in disagreement here. From a hardware perspective, I really don't see a big improvement in Canon's FF sensors since 2008. I give them that they improved the algorithms and the internal image processing parameters to tweak to a better performance especially at high ISO. I really question that the slightly improved DR in the 5Ds(R) comes from the sensor itself at all. Of course you will argue now that the end result counts no matter how it is done. And if you are willing to vest $4K for this technology with just "usable" DR as you said then so be it. Just I rather invest in newer sensor technology itself out there. Canon fanboys don't like to hear this, but sensor technology was and is not a focus area for Canon after they were very successful to develop the 5D MkII and the equivalent sensor in the former 1Ds series camera.
What I find curious is that neither you nor mttran nor chez who speak so highly of the latest Sony sensor developments, seem to upgrade to the new Sony A7rII. Aren't the improvements from this groundbreaking new technology so much better after all?
We all want the best but the almighty $ gets in the way.
Yep...if it wasn't for the little thing called money...we'd all have the best of the best. Unfortunately, we all need to make practical decisions that we can afford.


Even if money is not an object deciding on a camera is not that easy. What usually happens to those, that have a lot of money to spend, is that they buy several camera systems and most likely always keep more than one.
Aug 31, 2015 at 06:34 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.34 #20Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
I've been very consistent saying it is too expensive for what it brings to the table for me. I am waiting for the price to drop...then I'll most likely sell my 5D2 and A7R and pick up the A7R2...but not until the price drops.

I've been very consistent in this matter...I don't appreciate you insulating otherwise as that is not true.


Chez,

Yes, you have been very consistent in advocating the price is more than you feel it is worth. To that point, I will whole-heartedly stand behind you as being totally consistent and I respect that position of waiting for the price to come down for personal budgetary reasons.

My humor was just to highlight that if someone were to accept the plethora of impassioned voracity of alleged greatness that is perpetuated regarding the A7R II in the Canon Forum (noting that it receives mixed comments in the Sony forum) ... it would stand to reason that it would be such a magnificent investment, with an ROI that your strategy @ waiting will not really gain you anything.

Which, since as the cost of the A7R II comes down, so will the A7R and the 5D2. If that is your strategy, you might as well pull the trigger on it now, lest you continue to miss out on all the great shots that you are losing out on by not having the A7R II. How many missed opportunities will it take to offset any marginal difference in the arbitrage between now and whenever that might occur.

In that regard, this is not meant to be snarky, nor adversarial, but really if that is your objective ... you might as well get on with it, so you can get on with it @ shifting from A7R + 5D II to A7R II (retaining your 7D, I assume). Legitimate offer of perspective for consideration from one FM'er to another fellow FM'er.

Insinuating, insulating, insulting (fat fingers curse all of us at times) ... if I offended you with my snarcasm, I apologize. I just found it a bit humorous and figured as a "crusty ol' cuss" (term of endearment), your skin was plenty thick enough for (hopefully) a good-natured, light-hearted, poke in the ribs.

First round's on me.
Aug 31, 2015 at 06:39 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister