fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII

  
 
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.32 #1Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
mogul wrote:
jctriguy wrote
retrofocus wrote
alundeb wrote
retrofocus wrote
alundeb wroteThe D800 should have been released with or instead of the D700, which had too low resolution. The A7rII fixes many of the problems with the A7r, so it should have been released instead of the A7r. Now, since all cameras ever released are one generation too late, we can reset the counter and regard all current camera releases as what they are. Or wait for the next generation, that will be all the current gen should have been, except the little snag that at that time, we will expect more.
You forget here that the sensor in the A7R II is a totally different one than in the A7R even its resolution increase between 36 and 42 MP is not a lot. Canon's FF sensor technology remains pretty stagnant since the 5D MkII was released, no big changes here other than some improvement in high ISO (no hardware change but done with software algorithms). Even the 5Ds(R) finally has a great resolution, it relies on 7D MkII sensor technology simply doubling its resolution.

In fact the 5Ds(R) sensor easily could have been released 3 years ago. There is nothing groundbreaking new in its technology. Sony's technology is very different here, each generation so far showed a big advancement in sensor technology.
I don't think you know anything about when Canon could have released 50 MP without low ISO shadow banding ( a great acheivement from Canon since the 5DII ), and when Sony Could have released FF BSI. The order may be reverse of what you think.
Give me any proof for your assumption that the backlit sensor technology could be older and deriving from formerly implemented Sony or Nikon cameras. Pointing out that it was an improvement to remove sensor banding is a big joke IMO - it was an issue with the 5D MkII sensor which shouldn't have been there in the first place (BTW, the banding was still present in an lower extent in the 5D MkIII sensor since it was nearly the same anyway).
BSI sensor was sold by Sony in 2009. Why did it take 6 years to release in FF?
Unlike Canon, Sony has to do a lot of R&D to make a new sensor family.



Perhaps... but at least it's something (probably the only thing) that Sony does well.
Aug 31, 2015 at 10:58 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.32 #2Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
You are the one who makes assumptions without proof. I am just saying that we don't know.


That the basics of the current Canon FF sensor technology remain very similar to the first one announced in 2008 is no mystery. There were improvements of course, especially in the high ISO direction. All of Canon's sensors rely hardware-wise on the 0.5 micrometer process generation including the one in the 5Ds(R) series whereas Sony's sensors are at the much better 0.18 micrometer level (the latest one might be even smaller, not sure about this).

The RX100 II had a BSI Exmor sensor 4 months before the release of the A7r.

Okay, 4 months, yes - in a cropped sensor technology which is obviously not the same as with this A7R II high MP FF sensor. Or did you want to say that 4 months of some sort of delay is the same as 7 years in Canon terms?

Low ISO banding was present in all Canon sensors before the 5DII. the 5DII was worse than the best ones preceeding it, but the 5DS betters those old sensors by a fair margin. So that improvement is far from a joke.

Joke is that something was fixed which shouldn't have been there in the first place and now being used as a positive how Canon innovates. That it took Canon so long to fix it just supports my reasoning from mentioned above.

Aug 31, 2015 at 10:59 AM
darbo
Offline
Details
p.32 #3Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII


molson wrote:
mogul wrote
jctriguy wrote
retrofocus wrote
alundeb wrote
retrofocus wroteYou forget here that the sensor in the A7R II is a totally different one than in the A7R even its resolution increase between 36 and 42 MP is not a lot. Canon's FF sensor technology remains pretty stagnant since the 5D MkII was released, no big changes here other than some improvement in high ISO (no hardware change but done with software algorithms). Even the 5Ds(R) finally has a great resolution, it relies on 7D MkII sensor technology simply doubling its resolution.

In fact the 5Ds(R) sensor easily could have been released 3 years ago. There is nothing groundbreaking new in its technology. Sony's technology is very different here, each generation so far showed a big advancement in sensor technology.
I don't think you know anything about when Canon could have released 50 MP without low ISO shadow banding ( a great acheivement from Canon since the 5DII ), and when Sony Could have released FF BSI. The order may be reverse of what you think.
Give me any proof for your assumption that the backlit sensor technology could be older and deriving from formerly implemented Sony or Nikon cameras. Pointing out that it was an improvement to remove sensor banding is a big joke IMO - it was an issue with the 5D MkII sensor which shouldn't have been there in the first place (BTW, the banding was still present in an lower extent in the 5D MkIII sensor since it was nearly the same anyway).
BSI sensor was sold by Sony in 2009. Why did it take 6 years to release in FF?
Unlike Canon, Sony has to do a lot of R&D to make a new sensor family.
Perhaps... but at least it's something (probably the only thing) that Sony does well.


Hype. Don't forget hype! No one else manufactures hype nearly as well as Sony.
Aug 31, 2015 at 11:07 AM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.32 #4Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
darbo wrote:
molson wrote
mogul wrote
jctriguy wrote
retrofocus wrote
alundeb wroteI don't think you know anything about when Canon could have released 50 MP without low ISO shadow banding ( a great acheivement from Canon since the 5DII ), and when Sony Could have released FF BSI. The order may be reverse of what you think.
Give me any proof for your assumption that the backlit sensor technology could be older and deriving from formerly implemented Sony or Nikon cameras. Pointing out that it was an improvement to remove sensor banding is a big joke IMO - it was an issue with the 5D MkII sensor which shouldn't have been there in the first place (BTW, the banding was still present in an lower extent in the 5D MkIII sensor since it was nearly the same anyway).
BSI sensor was sold by Sony in 2009. Why did it take 6 years to release in FF?
Unlike Canon, Sony has to do a lot of R&D to make a new sensor family.
Perhaps... but at least it's something (probably the only thing) that Sony does well.
Hype. Don't forget hype! No one else manufactures hype nearly as well as Sony.


Don't they sub-contact that to rumorz sites?
Aug 31, 2015 at 11:08 AM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.32 #5Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
retrofocus wrote:
Joke is that something was fixed which shouldn't have been there in the first place and now being used as a positive how Canon innovates. That it took Canon so long to fix it just supports my reasoning from mentioned above.



It's hard to fault Canon for not anticipating that users would be sitting at their computers taking photos of the back side of their lens caps, instead of using their cameras for photography.

I have never screwed up an exposure so bad that I could see the banding in Canon images (although I did have an issue with banding in some dimly-lit interior shots I did with my A7R, so at least I know what the phenomenon looks like...)
Aug 31, 2015 at 11:13 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.32 #6Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
retrofocus wrote:
Okay, 4 months, yes - in a cropped sensor technology which is obviously not the same as with this A7R II high MP FF sensor. Or did you want to say that 4 months of some sort of delay is the same as 7 years in Canon terms?



No, I'm saying that Sony had BSI in a large cropped sensor available BEFORE the A7r, and Canon had banding free 50 MP density ready in a large cropped sensor (the7D II) AFTER the 5DIII.

What annoys me, is that you fail to recognize that elimination of banding, and expansion to the industry's highest resolution, while at the same time maintaing the per pixel low ISO characteristics, is indeed an improved sensor that took time to develop.
Aug 31, 2015 at 11:17 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.32 #7Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
molson wrote:
retrofocus wroteJoke is that something was fixed which shouldn't have been there in the first place and now being used as a positive how Canon innovates. That it took Canon so long to fix it just supports my reasoning from mentioned above.
It's hard to fault Canon for not anticipating that users would be sitting at their computers taking photos of the back side of their lens caps, instead of using their cameras for photography.

I have never screwed up an exposure so bad that I could see the banding in Canon images (although I did have an issue with banding in some dimly-lit interior shots I did with my A7R, so at least I know what the phenomenon looks like...)


I have never seen the low ISO banding ocurring either. I have seen it only at high ISO on my 5D MKII where then darker reddish/greenish areas just looked awful. Above ISO 3200 this is a well described phenomena with this camera.

For low ISO work, the 5D MkII is a good camera if we leave out of the discussion the DR performance which simply wasn't available in 2008 at the point of today's (competitive) cameras. That's the reason why I like my converted 5D MkII for infrared work since I never go above ISO 640 here.
Aug 31, 2015 at 11:23 AM
mogul
Offline
Details
p.32 #8Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
molson wrote:
One question I have about the A7rII is - if Sony's lossy compression reduces 14-bit capture to only 11 bits, what happens when the camera switches to 12-bit capture? Does that drop the compressed "RAW" file to 9 bits, which is essentially a JPEG file?


No, that is essentially a Canon raw file.
Aug 31, 2015 at 11:32 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.32 #9Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
retrofocus wroteOkay, 4 months, yes - in a cropped sensor technology which is obviously not the same as with this A7R II high MP FF sensor. Or did you want to say that 4 months of some sort of delay is the same as 7 years in Canon terms?
No, I'm saying that Sony had BSI in a large cropped sensor available BEFORE the A7r, and Canon had banding free 50 MP density ready in a large cropped sensor (the7D II) AFTER the 5DIII.

What annoys me, is that you fail to recognize that elimination of banding, and expansion to the industry's highest resolution, while at the same time maintaing the per pixel low ISO characteristics, is indeed an improved sensor that took time to develop.


I really don't care if you are annoyed or not. You are right so that I don't recognize the little low ISO banding issue (whereas the high ISO banding was the much bigger deal) and removal of banding in the same importance (other manufacturers never had any kind of banding issues) as of improving in other areas pointed out earlier. Everybody knows that the 5Ds(R) is a 7D MkII sensor technology (where Canon did some minor tweaks compared to ealier sensor technology).
Aug 31, 2015 at 11:32 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.32 #10Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
retrofocus wrote:
. Everybody knows that the 5Ds(R) is a 7D MkII sensor technology (where Canon did some minor tweaks compared to ealier sensor technology).


Now we are back to the original point, the 7D Mk II sensor technology is newer than the 5D mk III, so Canon positively could not have released a 5DS quality sensor along with the 5D III, as you stated they should have.

And I don't care if you don't care about my annoyance, but I am not going to watch silently that you say the 5DS sensor is basically the same technology as the 5D II regarding dynamic range, because Canon has actually closed 1/3 of the gap to Sony (normalized, measured) and much more subjectively because of the noise character. That difference makes a heck of an importance to many people, because it breaks the barrier from bad to usable in many's view.
Aug 31, 2015 at 11:43 AM
jcolwell
Offline
Details
p.32 #11Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
molson wrote:
One question I have about the A7rII is - if Sony's lossy compression reduces 14-bit capture to only 11 bits, what happens when the camera switches to 12-bit capture? Does that drop the compressed "RAW" file to 9 bits, which is essentially a JPEG file?

mogul wrote:
No, that is essentially a Canon raw file.


(?) Canon RAW files are 14-bit. Even on my little old SL1.
Aug 31, 2015 at 11:47 AM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.32 #12Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
retrofocus wrote:
alundeb wroteYou are the one who makes assumptions without proof. I am just saying that we don't know.
That the basics of the current Canon FF sensor technology remain very similar to the first one announced in 2008 is no mystery. There were improvements of course, especially in the high ISO direction. All of Canon's sensors rely hardware-wise on the 0.5 micrometer process generation including the one in the 5Ds(R) series whereas Sony's sensors are at the much better 0.18 micrometer level (the latest one might be even smaller, not sure about this).

Earlier quoteThe RX100 II had a BSI Exmor sensor 4 months before the release of the A7r.
Okay, 4 months, yes - in a cropped sensor technology which is obviously not the same as with this A7R II high MP FF sensor.
...Show more →
Earlier quoteLow ISO banding was present in all Canon sensors before the 5DII. the 5DII was worse than the best ones preceeding it, but the 5DS betters those old sensors by a fair margin. So that improvement is far from a joke.


Please stop quoting specs that you don't understand. You continually demonstrate a complete lack of understanding of imaging technology and manufacturing processes. Making outrageous claims like Canon should've release a 50MP sensor 5 years ago is really indicative of you level of understanding. These things take years to develop. Do you think Sony just whipped up a new sensor last month? They released a BSI sensor 6 years ago. They announced the exmor RS 3 years ago. Why haven't they been included as 100MP sensors in a new MF camera, I mean what are they waiting for?
Aug 31, 2015 at 11:54 AM
mogul
Offline
Details
p.32 #13Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
jcolwell wrote:
molson wroteOne question I have about the A7rII is - if Sony's lossy compression reduces 14-bit capture to only 11 bits, what happens when the camera switches to 12-bit capture? Does that drop the compressed "RAW" file to 9 bits, which is essentially a JPEG file?
mogul wroteNo, that is essentially a Canon raw file.
(?) Canon RAW files are 14-bit. Even on my little old SL1.


14 bit does you no good if your DR is in the 9 bit range
Aug 31, 2015 at 11:58 AM
jcolwell
Offline
Details
p.32 #14Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Well, I guess it makes no sense to talk with you about this.
Aug 31, 2015 at 12:00 PM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.32 #15Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
mogul wrote:
jcolwell wrote
molson wroteOne question I have about the A7rII is - if Sony's lossy compression reduces 14-bit capture to only 11 bits, what happens when the camera switches to 12-bit capture? Does that drop the compressed "RAW" file to 9 bits, which is essentially a JPEG file?
mogul wroteNo, that is essentially a Canon raw file.
(?) Canon RAW files are 14-bit. Even on my little old SL1.
14 bit does you no good if your DR is in the 9 bit range


Which brings up another point - how can Sony claim to have (for example) 14 bits worth of dynamic range, when their files can't possibly contain that much data?


Edited on Aug 31, 2015 at 12:06 PM · View previous versions
Aug 31, 2015 at 12:03 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.32 #16Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
mogul wrote:
jcolwell wrote
molson wroteOne question I have about the A7rII is - if Sony's lossy compression reduces 14-bit capture to only 11 bits, what happens when the camera switches to 12-bit capture? Does that drop the compressed "RAW" file to 9 bits, which is essentially a JPEG file?
mogul wroteNo, that is essentially a Canon raw file.
(?) Canon RAW files are 14-bit. Even on my little old SL1.
14 bit does you no good if your DR is in the 9 bit range


Don't confuse 9 EV photographic DR with 11 EV engineering DR. Linear encoding benefits from bit depth exceeding the engineering DR not the photographic DR.

Aug 31, 2015 at 12:04 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.32 #17Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
mogul wrote:
jcolwell wrote
molson wroteOne question I have about the A7rII is - if Sony's lossy compression reduces 14-bit capture to only 11 bits, what happens when the camera switches to 12-bit capture? Does that drop the compressed "RAW" file to 9 bits, which is essentially a JPEG file?
mogul wroteNo, that is essentially a Canon raw file.
(?) Canon RAW files are 14-bit. Even on my little old SL1.
14 bit does you no good if your DR is in the 9 bit range


Isn't that kinda like saying that greater precision does you no good if you've only got a machinist's rule instead of a yardstick.

Range, accuracy and precision are not interchangeable. I don't think bit & DR are either.

I thought the 14 bit was the ability to have finer incrementation in your steps (which would assist with banding prevention), whereas dynamic range is how dark and how light the range between the two end points (0-1) can be. Won't a 9 bit file be ever more prone to banding / posterization once you start processing the numbers in PP ... regardless of what your DR may or may not be.



Edited on Aug 31, 2015 at 12:11 PM · View previous versions
Aug 31, 2015 at 12:06 PM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.32 #18Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RustyBug wrote:
Won't a 9 bit file be ever more prone to banding / posterization once you start processing the numbers in PP ... regardless of what your DR may or may not be.


I think Facebook compresses the files even more, so most Sony users won't notice...
Aug 31, 2015 at 12:09 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.32 #19Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
molson wrote:
mogul wrote
jcolwell wrote
molson wroteOne question I have about the A7rII is - if Sony's lossy compression reduces 14-bit capture to only 11 bits, what happens when the camera switches to 12-bit capture? Does that drop the compressed "RAW" file to 9 bits, which is essentially a JPEG file?
mogul wroteNo, that is essentially a Canon raw file.
(?) Canon RAW files are 14-bit. Even on my little old SL1.
14 bit does you no good if your DR is in the 9 bit range
Which brings up another point - how can Sony possibly claim to have (for example) 14 bits worth of dynamic range, when their files can't possibly contain that much data?


The A7r has 12.98 Ev dynamic range per pixel, Canon 5DS 11.08

It is possible to represent a little above 13 Ev DR at the pixel level in a 12 bits file with linear encoding.

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1359028/4#12963553


Aug 31, 2015 at 12:09 PM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.32 #20Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
molson wrote
mogul wrote
jcolwell wrote
molson wroteOne question I have about the A7rII is - if Sony's lossy compression reduces 14-bit capture to only 11 bits, what happens when the camera switches to 12-bit capture? Does that drop the compressed "RAW" file to 9 bits, which is essentially a JPEG file?
mogul wroteNo, that is essentially a Canon raw file.
(?) Canon RAW files are 14-bit. Even on my little old SL1.
14 bit does you no good if your DR is in the 9 bit range
Which brings up another point - how can Sony possibly claim to have (for example) 14 bits worth of dynamic range, when their files can't possibly contain that much data?
The A7r has 12.98 Ev dynamic range per pixel, Canon 5DS 11.08

It is possible to represent a little above 13 Ev DR at the pixel level in a 12 bits file with linear encoding.

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1359028/4#12963553



I think the question now is, what can be achieved with a 9-bit file? (or 9+7 delta, or whatever it is that results from the lossy compression...)
Aug 31, 2015 at 12:12 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister