fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII

  
 
EB-1
Offline
Details
p.17 #1Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
What does the mirror have to do with the sensor Canon will replace the reflex system with an EVF when the technology is commensurate with the performance expectations. I expect it will save a whopping 150 g.

I don't know if the Sony has a wavy, grainy, delayed EVF due to the cheapness of the body or limitation of the technology, but I sure wouldn't want to spend $6-7K on a pro Nikon or Canon body and have to look at that annoying EVF all day.

EBH
Jun 16, 2015 at 12:57 AM
mttran
Offline
Details
p.17 #2Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
mttran wrote
Gunzorro wrote
alundeb wrote
retrofocus wrote
alundeb wroteThat looks like amp/conversion noise from the Canon sensor / electronics
I think we reach an agreement here....
Indeed. It would have been tremendously helpful for the interpretation of the grade of this if we knew the source of the image and how it was developed, especially regarding tone curve and exposure compensation.
This is my chief gripe with Michael's picking up other photographer's images, and dumping them here on the forum without attribution or proper explanation (he can't, because he didn't shoot the subject or handle image processing from the get-go). Very frustrating and impossible to draw conclusions, only speculation. Then there is the "told you so" happy dance and rally of Canon haters.
Really Jim? this is a basic stuffs how to debug a canon raw file. Read other 5Dsr threads, I am not going to repeat a same instruction in every thread. Beside, those are DPP display snapshots so all DPP parameters that you are looking for is there. Also test 5Dsr raw files were posted in this thread: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1370208 and this thread https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1369130
Hello Michael,

I find it difficult to interpret these kind of posts. I don't want to remember the processing habits of 100 posters who I read regularly. I don't know what you mean by a standard procedure of how to debug a Canon raw file. Is it 2 stops push? 4 stops push? And even if I did, I could not be sure that you were using it in that case. It is not true that we can find all the information from the DPP panels you include, and if something is wrong, like 200%, and you know it, it
...Show more →
Hi Anders,

Let me response to your post step by step so everyone can follow:

1) Set all DPP parameters to zeros:
http://farm4.staticflickr.com/3793/18852538715_de95ad5c05_h.jpg
2) Load any RAW into DPP. Screen dump is actual 1920x1056 but I use 1600x880 upload size to fit most monitor. Here is one of the original exposure:
http://farm4.staticflickr.com/3922/18851791015_f391b19e97_h.jpg
3) Shifting the middle gray to - 1.95 stops (double head arrow) to view the raw file in lower DR range. Use this key and DPP zoom to explore noise in any section from shadows to highlights range:
http://farm4.staticflickr.com/3699/18229211104_e44514b82a_h.jpg
4) Zoom 100%. These displays are less than 100% crop since I used 1600x880 uploads size.
http://farm6.staticflickr.com/5489/18825544126_074a0963ee_h.jpg
http://farm6.staticflickr.com/5579/18664059668_41afc05a1b_h.jpg
http://farm6.staticflickr.com/5583/18231169573_1710809094_h.jpg

Your noise characteristic is different based on how wide the DR. Here is -.97 stops sample in another DR from another raw file:
http://farm6.staticflickr.com/5444/18851805515_fcc510e649_h.jpg
Same above raw and no adjustment, only zoom to 100%
http://farm6.staticflickr.com/5485/18825552556_cfdb92b258_h.jpg

Here is one of -2.64 stops in another DR from another raw file:
http://farm1.staticflickr.com/416/18075131234_7c9efd5bd2_h.jpg

Another twos with -1.49 stops in another DR from another raw file:
http://farm4.staticflickr.com/3802/18229218864_ac48be0332_h.jpg
http://farm4.staticflickr.com/3867/18665637699_457189d083_h.jpg

All raw files were posted from this thread: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1370208.

Do not convert to JPG and use N/R when you are leaning noise and that is the message I want to say. Your IQ will be degrade in post with these noise regardless you like it or not specially for a large print.
Jun 16, 2015 at 01:07 AM
mttran
Offline
Details
p.17 #3Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
and trust me ...noise is just not in the shadows alone...they are everywhere when you play them in different level with your tone curves...you won't see much with 8-10 bits monitor but wait until you get a better display...of course you don't see them in print

BTW don't be confuse with 300% on the display. That is the new DPP feature to flip flop the display for you to examine the file in larger size. You have an option to set this flipflop key in 12%,25%,50%,100%,200%,300% and 400%.

Edited on Jun 16, 2015 at 02:18 AM · View previous versions
Jun 16, 2015 at 01:50 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.17 #4Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
mttran wrote:
and trust me ...noise is just not in the shadows alone...they are everywhere when you play them in different level with your tone curves...you won't see much with 8-10 bits monitor but wait until you get a better display


And trust me, there is noise everywhere also in Sony sensor files with similar pixel density, when you stretch contrast in well exposed areas. This is photon shot noise and unavoidable
Jun 16, 2015 at 01:56 AM
mttran
Offline
Details
p.17 #5Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
mttran wroteand trust me ...noise is just not in the shadows alone...they are everywhere when you play them in different level with your tone curves...you won't see much with 8-10 bits monitor but wait until you get a better display
And trust me, there is noise everywhere also in Sony sensor files with similar pixel density


I believe you but not at the canon levels
Jun 16, 2015 at 01:59 AM
mttran
Offline
Details
p.17 #6Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Good night, Anders. I better before JC and jimmy come out with a "BAM" and "BAM"
Jun 16, 2015 at 02:02 AM
zlatko
Offline
Details
p.17 #7Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
eyal.ma wrote:
zlatko wroteExcept that it doesn't have the same 7D2 sensor only enlarged.
Canon PR on the interviews when the 5Ds was announced, said several times pretty plainly that the 5Ds sensor buildup was based on the 7D2 sensor, and they share a similar ISO performance.


You wrote "It has the same 7D2 sensor only enlarged". The 7D2 and 70D have a dual pixel construction. The 5DS and 5DSR don't. The 7D2 and 70D have a 4.1µm pixel size. The 5DS and 5DSR have a 4.14µm pixel size. See this interview at 1:20:50 —
http://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/promotion/11107/canon-eos-5dsr-live-panel.html
Jun 16, 2015 at 07:16 AM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.17 #8Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
mttran wrote:
Gunzorro wrote
alundeb wrote
retrofocus wrote
alundeb wrote
retrofocus wroteReferring to the brownish area on the right in the first photo. Also visible in the black there but better seen in mttran's larger magnified view.
That looks like amp/conversion noise from the Canon sensor / electronics
I think we reach an agreement here....
Indeed. It would have been tremendously helpful for the interpretation of the grade of this if we knew the source of the image and how it was developed, especially regarding tone curve and exposure compensation.
This is my chief gripe with Michael's picking up other photographer's images, and dumping them here on the forum without attribution or proper explanation (he can't, because he didn't shoot the subject or handle image processing from the get-go). Very frustrating and impossible to draw conclusions, only speculation. Then there is the "told you so" happy dance and rally of Canon haters.
Really Jim? this is a basic stuffs how to debug a canon raw file. Read other 5Dsr threads, I am not going to repeat a same instruction in every thread. Beside, those are DPP display snapshots so all DPP parameters that you are looking for is there. Also test 5Dsr raw files were posted in this thread: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1370208 and this thread https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1369130


First, why don't you start a thread on this specific topic. It would allow people to discuss as they like. Would also be easier for you to link to a thread with all the info instead of what you've done here.

Second, if you can't be bothered to explain what you are posting, why should anyone be bothered to pay attention to it? You post images with absolutely no information, no attribution (ie stolen) and no context. Basically useless.
Jun 16, 2015 at 08:20 AM
Charlie N
Offline
Details
p.17 #9Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
zlatko wrote:
alundeb wrote
Paul Mo wroteBut Sony in the Alpha A7 range, has by far the better sensors, and the benefit of reduced size and weight.
Define far better sensor.

Color: The Canon 5DS sensor has been analyzed to have very good color separation, not in any way inferior to Sony.

Resolution: The Canon 5DS sensor has higher resolution than any Sony 35mm sensor, something I will benefit from in all my large prints.

Quantum efficiency: No significant difference here.

Lowest base ISO: Both Canon and Sony have native ISO 100 extendable to 50. Only the Nikon variety goes to 64 / 32.

High ISO DR: Both Canon and the latest Sony are top notch here.

Long exposure thermal noise: The latest generation Canon is far better here, allowing very long excposures without black frame subtraction.

Low ISO DR: Sony is far better than Canon here.

So in 7 criteria for image quality, 4 are a wash, and 2 goes to Canon and 1 goes to Sony.
Exactly. For many photographers, low ISO DR is no problem with Canon, so that leaves reduced size and weight as the key Sony benefit. But to get that, you have to accept Sony's inferior system, with its many missing components.


Clearly you dont get what other sony users are seeing. Optional low weight is just a perk at this point, shooting with sony changes how you shoot, this coming from a 10 year canon DSLR shooter, I can tell you weight is NOT the only factor.

firstly, you've got a stellar EVF, though it may have flaws, it has vastly more benefits than an OVF. Most DSLR users wouldnt even consider shooting MF lenses, but due to the implementation of the EVF and its tools, it's a very realistic scenario to shoot MF with sony. Couple that with the flange distance, and you've literally opened the floodgates to available inexpensive lenses.

IBIS and EF adaptability..... this will be a huge one, absolutely huge. IBIS is no small matter, and that combined with EF adaptability will change the way you see some lenses. There are some key lenses that are not very attractive due to key features of missing IS, which now have a 180 on life. Think about the 24-70ii. With IBIS, you can get ultra low shutter speeds should you use it for landscapes or want deliberate motion blur. Fast primes with IBIS, some may argue that its not "needed" with fast primes, and I'll say that their type of photography may not require it, however with some lenses, it will be hard to argue that it's not needed.

To name a few lenses that will be changed greatly: 85/1.2, 135/2, 200/1.8, 400/5.6. I'll tell you that I've never once considered the 400/5.6 as a canon shooter, because the lack of IS, however, it's inexpensive, and light..... it cant be ignored. I can sell off my 70-200ii for a lesser non IS version, and the money saved, pickup the 400, who knows. IBIS would upgrade more than half of my entire lens collection in one quick swoop..... that seriously cannot be ignored and minimized. Canon users pay good amounts of money for IS, compare the 70-200 F4/2.8 and their counterparts. Basically double the price for IS. From a hobbyist perspective, that's a pretty big deal.
Jun 16, 2015 at 08:35 AM
zlatko
Offline
Details
p.17 #10Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Charlie N wrote:
zlatko wrote
alundeb wrote
Paul Mo wroteBut Sony in the Alpha A7 range, has by far the better sensors, and the benefit of reduced size and weight.
Define far better sensor.

Color: The Canon 5DS sensor has been analyzed to have very good color separation, not in any way inferior to Sony.

Resolution: The Canon 5DS sensor has higher resolution than any Sony 35mm sensor, something I will benefit from in all my large prints.

Quantum efficiency: No significant difference here.

Lowest base ISO: Both Canon and Sony have native ISO 100 extendable to 50. Only the Nikon variety goes to 64 / 32.

High ISO DR: Both Canon and the latest Sony are top notch here.

Long exposure thermal noise: The latest generation Canon is far better here, allowing very long excposures without black frame subtraction.

Low ISO DR: Sony is far better than Canon here.

So in 7 criteria for image quality, 4 are a wash, and 2 goes to Canon and 1 goes to Sony.
Exactly. For many photographers, low ISO DR is no problem with Canon, so that leaves reduced size and weight as the key Sony benefit. But to get that, you have to accept Sony's inferior system, with its many missing components.
Clearly you dont get what other sony users are seeing. Optional low weight is just a perk at this point, shooting with sony changes how you shoot, this coming from a 10 year canon DSLR shooter, I can tell you weight is NOT the only factor.

firstly, you've got a stellar EVF, though it may have flaws, it has vastly more benefits than an OVF. Most DSLR users wouldnt even consider shooting MF lenses, but due to the implementation of the EVF and its tools, it's a very realistic scenario to shoot MF with sony. Couple that with the
...Show more →

Charlie N, those are some good points. I can see why the appeal of in-body stabilization for use with some lenses. I'm not personally fond of shooting DSLR lenses with an adapter. It looks awkward, kind of like having a teleconverter with every lens. Also, the EVF is a tradeoff, better in some ways, but worse in others.
Jun 16, 2015 at 08:51 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.17 #11Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Dear Sony, Nikon, Canon, Fujifilm, Pentax, Panasonic, Phase One, Wista, Instamatic, iPhone, Polaroid, Olympus, Hasselblad, Leica photographer:

It is absolutely fine for you to choose to use whatever brand you want for whatever photographic and other reasons you can cite. I'm positive that your camera will be capable of producing excellent photographs for you, and I hope you are very happy with your choice. I hope that you make excellent photographs with your equipment.

Another person's choice to use a different brand or model is not necessarily a reflection of their ignorance, stupidity, blind brand loyalty, lack of vision, inability to parse test charts, or poor photography skills. Their choice is as likely as yours to be the result of consideration of options and of their own needs.

It is unnecessary for you/me/us to prove to others that the camera we chose for our own use is the camera that every other intelligent person would choose for theirs. Insisting on this point, explicitly or implicitly, creates an impression that it is more about our self-gratification and a personal need to keep certain insecurities about our own choices at bay, and to publicly reinforce for ourselves the perfection of our personal choices.

All of these manufacturers produce excellent tools. None are perfect in all ways — all have pluses and minuses. All gear choices are a compromise. It is good and sometimes useful to know about technical stuff, but photography is about photographs, not about marginal technical differences between this thing and the other, nor is it a contest to see who owns the Most Perfect Thing.

YMMV,

Dan

Edited on Jun 17, 2015 at 09:58 AM · View previous versions
Jun 16, 2015 at 09:34 AM
Dpedraza
Offline
Details
p.17 #12Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
gdanmitchell wrote:
Dear Sony, Nikon, Canon, Fujifilm, Pentax, Panasonic, Phase One, Wista, Instamatic, iPhone, Polaroid, Olympus, users:

It is absolutely fine for you to choose to use whatever brand you want for whatever photographic reasons you can cite. I'm utterly positive that your camera will be capable of producing excellent photographs.


Yeah this is true people are only limited by their abilities to make excellent shots.
Jun 16, 2015 at 09:41 AM
mttran
Offline
Details
p.17 #13Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Charlie N wrote:
zlatko wrote
alundeb wrote
Paul Mo wroteBut Sony in the Alpha A7 range, has by far the better sensors, and the benefit of reduced size and weight.
Define far better sensor.

Color: The Canon 5DS sensor has been analyzed to have very good color separation, not in any way inferior to Sony.

Resolution: The Canon 5DS sensor has higher resolution than any Sony 35mm sensor, something I will benefit from in all my large prints.

Quantum efficiency: No significant difference here.

Lowest base ISO: Both Canon and Sony have native ISO 100 extendable to 50. Only the Nikon variety goes to 64 / 32.

High ISO DR: Both Canon and the latest Sony are top notch here.

Long exposure thermal noise: The latest generation Canon is far better here, allowing very long excposures without black frame subtraction.

Low ISO DR: Sony is far better than Canon here.

So in 7 criteria for image quality, 4 are a wash, and 2 goes to Canon and 1 goes to Sony.
Exactly. For many photographers, low ISO DR is no problem with Canon, so that leaves reduced size and weight as the key Sony benefit. But to get that, you have to accept Sony's inferior system, with its many missing components.
Clearly you dont get what other sony users are seeing. Optional low weight is just a perk at this point, shooting with sony changes how you shoot, this coming from a 10 year canon DSLR shooter, I can tell you weight is NOT the only factor.

firstly, you've got a stellar EVF, though it may have flaws, it has vastly more benefits than an OVF. Most DSLR users wouldnt even consider shooting MF lenses, but due to the implementation of the EVF and its tools, it's a very realistic scenario to shoot MF with sony. Couple that with the
...Show more →

+1, good post
Jun 16, 2015 at 02:50 PM
losloslos
Offline
Details
p.17 #14Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
...I've been dormant (in music photography) for more than 5 years, last new camera was a pair of 30D's, and before tha a nearly new 1D1. I still have my D2000

I am shocked to see that Canon is not up on 5D25 by now, and just kicking butt. The 100-400 seems AMAZING from the pics, too many to "fake" per se.

I am down to pretty much no pro gear right now, loving my old QL17 but its not practical to use film pretty much. I look around at what I want to do now (based on the good subjects in my area) and I'm willing to look at a non-Canon system. I was interested in the Nikon, where the crazy ISO avail. was a big factor (shunning flash and shooting in the dark with crazy lighting) but some of my available subjects (sky, Native American) beg some serious IQ and DR...and the Sony might deliver that for a lot less than a used D3, and smaller, and quieter.

Small and quiet is increasingly an issue.

I'm with the rest, "let it come on and get into people's hands and the pictures will tell the tale."

Glad to be back on FM!

G.
Jun 16, 2015 at 03:38 PM
Pixel Perfect
Offline
Details
p.17 #15Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Fred Miranda wrote:
Did you guys see this? The new A7R II is focusing very fast with Canon EF lenses

http://www.youtube.com/watch?t=353&v=rdhvDg2dkiM


That is the sort of news I want to hear.Tanks for the heads up Fred. Hard now to see how this could not be anything but a sales success. The sensor is supposedly a low light beast, but we will see.
Jun 16, 2015 at 08:17 PM
jcolwell
Offline
Details
p.17 #16Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
OMG. My decision for buying a 5DS/R vs. an A7R II is flipping on a flopping gate circuit.

Need more info...

(Dalek says, "Exterminate!").
Jun 16, 2015 at 08:22 PM
tdlavigne
Offline
Details
p.17 #17Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
I had high hopes for the 5Ds, but the initial raws I'm seeing aren't really impressive IQ wise....yeah, there's a lot of resolution, and yeah it's got the benefit of having access to the great Canon glass...but not enough to make me fork over almost $4k for one.

Initially the A7RII seems like a winner, especially now that they've finally got a decent lens lineup shaping up...but then again once I start thinking rationally: paying ~$1k for 4k video that I'll never use (the A7R was 2300 IIRC), and the spotty AF, and so-so battery life, and unless they fixed it; speedlights that don't use the AF assist lamp on Alpha series cameras, kinda kill anything more than a fleeting interest for me.

If I had to choose between the two, I'd probably go A7RII, but only because knowing Sony it'll be marked down to ~$2000 this time next year, whereas the 5Ds will still be $3700 3 years from now, and in that time hopefully a 5DIV will come out with some of the improvements I've been wanting, for a bit less. So yeah, I'll probably get another Sony FF mirrorless eventually, but only because they don't hold their value after the first year and can be had for ridiculously cheap....but I'd prefer to invest in a solid Canon platform for anything serious.
Jun 16, 2015 at 09:06 PM
johnvanr
Offline
Details
p.17 #18Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
gdanmitchell wrote:
Dear Sony, Nikon, Canon, Fujifilm, Pentax, Panasonic, Phase One, Wista, Instamatic, iPhone, Polaroid, Olympus, Hasselblad, Leica photographer:

It is absolutely fine for you to choose to use whatever brand you want for whatever photographic and other reasons you can cite. I'm positive that your camera will be capable of producing excellent photographs for you, and I hope you are very happy with your choice. I hope that you make excellent photographs with your equipment.

Another person's choice to use a different brand or model is not necessarily a reflection of their ignorance, stupidity, blind brand loyalty, lack of vision, inability to
...Show more →

What about Samsung photographers?

Jun 16, 2015 at 09:45 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.17 #19Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
jcolwell wrote:
OMG. My decision for buying a 5DS/R vs. an A7R II is flipping on a flopping gate circuit.

Need more info...

(Dalek says, "Exterminate!").


Jim, you are not in a hurry. Sit back and enoy the flip fliop and the endless discussions about A7r II AF that are going to emerge. Seeing that focus confirmation occurs within 1 second with a wide angle lens without seeing the resulting photos is less reassuring than saying that the 1D III never had focus issues.
Jun 17, 2015 at 12:26 AM
EB-1
Offline
Details
p.17 #20Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
gdanmitchell wrote:
Dear Sony, Nikon, Canon, Fujifilm, Pentax, Panasonic, Phase One, Wista, Instamatic, iPhone, Polaroid, Olympus, Hasselblad, Leica photographer:

It is absolutely fine for you to choose to use whatever brand you want for whatever photographic and other reasons you can cite. I'm positive that your camera will be capable of producing excellent photographs for you, and I hope you are very happy with your choice. I hope that you make excellent photographs with your equipment.

Another person's choice to use a different brand or model is not necessarily a reflection of their ignorance, stupidity, blind brand loyalty, lack of vision, inability to
...Show more →
johnvanr wrote:
What about Samsung photographers?


Are there all that many Samsungs that need to be photographed?

EBH
Jun 17, 2015 at 12:43 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister