darbo wrote: jeremy_clay wroteThese are wholly underwhelming.Meaning you are wholly underwhelmed by the image quality from the 5DS? What do you expect to see differently from an image quality standpoint?
I'm not sure, but this isn't it.
Crap response, I know. I don't intend to justify my lack of excitement, just offer it. Personally, for my work as someone who uses Canon gear day in and day out, I could not justify the upgrade. Which sucks, because my 5D3s are near the end of their life and it would be nice to be able to put a little money into replacements that I could be pumped about. No worry, and no challenge to those who are wanting this body, just my thoughts.
jeremy_clay wrote: darbo wrotejeremy_clay wroteThese are wholly underwhelming.Meaning you are wholly underwhelmed by the image quality from the 5DS? What do you expect to see differently from an image quality standpoint?I'm not sure, but this isn't it.
Crap response, I know. I don't intend to justify my lack of excitement, just offer it. Personally, for my work as someone who uses Canon gear day in and day out, I could not justify the upgrade. Which sucks, because my 5D3s are near the end of their life and it would be nice to be able to put a little money into replacements that I could be pumped about. No worry, and no challenge to those who are wanting this body, just my thoughts.
Oh, you're good Jeremy - it's perfectly fine to be underwhelmed. I was just curious to see what your perspective is. Hopefully, you'll get what you're looking for in a 5D IV - I'd like to see it announced in September or at least sometime 2015.
Maybe it's the huge pixel count, but at 100% (and probably as I can only think of MF files I've used at this size; I've not checked Nikon or Sony offerings) these look 'bleh'. Some seem a bit out of focus, or soft...definitely not making me get my wallet ready. I'd love to have the cropping power, but these 100%s do not inspire confidence for me..
My struggle (and I have the 5Dsr on order) has been the vast lack of quality shots being shared on the Internet. Meaning.... I've seen the promotional videos by Canon and the images they captured were great. However, the photos we have had a chance to "play" with have been random snapshots which were given little to no thought on how they were captured. A perfect example is the 1st link in this post... just some random street shots with little to no thought put into capturing them. This to me... doesn't do the camera/s justice.
I would love to see quality shots captured and shared. In the major areas of photography. Studio...Landscapes...even sports...etc. .... but by top professionals who do quality work and are willing to show off what the camera is capable of....
Just my $.02 These underwhelming images being shared didn't keep me from placing an order. I think the camera is going to be a hit... time will tell.
jeremy_clay wrote:
Maybe it's the huge pixel count, but at 100% (and probably as I can only think of MF files I've used at this size; I've not checked Nikon or Sony offerings) these look 'bleh'. Some seem a bit out of focus, or soft...definitely not making me get my wallet ready. I'd love to have the cropping power, but these 100%s do not inspire confidence for me..
May be it is a placebo effect, but the few good 5DS R raw photos that I have played with just seem to have a bit more bite and "clarity" than the 5DS vanilla when looking at them at 100%. Some of those implies that the detail can be amazing if the proper technique is used. The R definitely has the edge in regard to pixel level detail, IMHO, so you should go and check them out also.
I would like to thank the OP for posting them but I have to say I agree with jeremy_clay I am underwhelmed. All the shots are OK but I'm not seeing as much as an advantage to the pixel count as I had hoped for. Although I am interested in the 5Ds/r it is going to be a challenge to sort though the severe onslaught of marketing hype and overzealous early adopters with this one.
I don't know how much sharpness we can judge in handheld street shots. Where are some detailed, high contrast, tripod-mounted images? For street work I don't need a 5Ds R .
I am talking about images like this from my first generation 1Ds body:
I guess we should be happy they didn't post Selfies
Fortunately mine should arrive next week so the misery of looking at these awful shots will be over .
jeremy_clay wrote:
Maybe it's the huge pixel count, but at 100% (and probably as I can only think of MF files I've used at this size; I've not checked Nikon or Sony offerings) these look 'bleh'. Some seem a bit out of focus, or soft...definitely not making me get my wallet ready. I'd love to have the cropping power, but these 100%s do not inspire confidence for me..
JC....
You thinking about running one of these for weddings?
I only downloaded a couple of the RAWs but I was also very underwhelmed when viewed at 1:1 in LR. A lot of soft areas and just no WOW factor. That said, this is just one set of images. I really hope this isn't just going to be 7D2 IQ at FF size. And I actually am fairly impressed with my 7D2's IQ but I would want something better at this price point.
No useful shots with the 70-200/4 or 100 macro? This sounds disappointing :/
Well, either way, even though I cant afford the new 5d, these links came through my Google+ this morning and I wanted to share for you folks who can afford one. I know a lot of you have been looking forward to this.
Even though I can't afford one, I hope they're better than what we're all seeing this passed week. We need to quiet the Sony crowd a little.
jeremy_clay wrote:
Maybe it's the huge pixel count, but at 100% (and probably as I can only think of MF files I've used at this size; I've not checked Nikon or Sony offerings) these look 'bleh'. Some seem a bit out of focus, or soft...definitely not making me get my wallet ready. I'd love to have the cropping power, but these 100%s do not inspire confidence for me..
A 100% crop from a 50MP full frame sensor will never look sharper than a 100% crop from a sensor with fewer photo sites, and it will often look less sharp at 100% — as should be the case if the test images were carefully made using the same lens and aperture. This will be true with Canon, Nikon, Sony, and any others.
If that sounds like an odd or troubling thing to say, think more carefully about what it means to compare 100% magnification crops of samples from sensors with different numbers of photo sites.
For example, someone mentioned a 1Ds earlier in this thread. The 1Ds was a fine camera in its day. However, it had less than half the pixels in the horizontal dimension across the frame width. If you were looking at a 1000 pixel wide 100% magnification crop from the 1Ds you would be looking at about 25% of the image width. The 5Ds has slightly more than 8600 pixels across the frame width. If you look at a 1000 pixel 100% magnification crop from the 5Ds you will be looking at about 11.5% of the frame width and less than 1/4 of the image area seen in your 1Ds crop. Essentially, you are looking far more closely at the image in the latter case... and lens performance does not appear to improve as you look more closely at the samples...
Am I the only one that thinks most of these sample image photographers can't shoot? This is a commercial and studio camera with very few professional samples. Not sure why there are street style photos, OOF bicycle race photos at iso5000, and 1 second exposures of flowers. I don't know how Canon selects the photographers that do the testing, but it's not helping their cause.