fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015High DR for 5d4

  
 
Stoffer
Offline
Details
p.2 #1High DR for 5d4
chez wrote:
But wouldn't the 50mp camera that seems to fit nicely for landscapes benefit the expanded DR more than the 24mp camera which is more events or photo journalist focussed.


The idea that landscape photography is in more need of high DR that event photography is a bit flawed, IMHO. With events or photo journalist you might have to take photos of people outside in back light conditions where raising the shadows can be very beneficial.
Apr 10, 2015 at 01:08 PM
NCAndy
Offline
Details
p.2 #2High DR for 5d4
chez wrote:
NCAndy wrote
dhphoto wrotewouldn't this immediately render the 5Ds/r rather obsolete?

I can't see why Canon would do this to themselves.
Not if one camera is 24 mp and the other 50mp. Different uses I would think.
But wouldn't the 50mp camera that seems to fit nicely for landscapes benefit the expanded DR more than the 24mp camera which is more events or photo journalist focussed.


Yes, sure it would. But Canon is in the business to sell cameras. If they put everything into every body the bean counters would get upset. lol
Apr 10, 2015 at 01:43 PM
StillFingerz
Offline
Details
p.2 #3High DR for 5d4
WTF is wrong with targeting a specific group/genre of photographers with gear more tailored to their subject matter Not everyone is looking for a do-all body and given the 5D3 and newer 5D s/sr share many parts it's just smart financially to recycle technologies.

I doubt many don't/won't complain about the 2009 7Dish AF being implemented on xxD bodies and the soon to be released Rebel T6's. Let's hope Canon gives us an all-around body in the 5D4, betters the 5D3, on both the stills and video side

Edited on Apr 10, 2015 at 02:52 PM · View previous versions
Apr 10, 2015 at 02:04 PM
Tom Dix
Offline
Details
p.2 #4High DR for 5d4
Hoping there is truth in this rumor.
Apr 10, 2015 at 02:06 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.2 #5High DR for 5d4
Stoffer wrote:
chez wroteBut wouldn't the 50mp camera that seems to fit nicely for landscapes benefit the expanded DR more than the 24mp camera which is more events or photo journalist focussed.
The idea that landscape photography is in more need of high DR that event photography is a bit flawed, IMHO. With events or photo journalist you might have to take photos of people outside in back light conditions where raising the shadows can be very beneficial.


I'm a landscape photographer and could use more dynamic range out of my sensors. I've heard plenty on this board from event photographers that more dynamic range is way down on their wish list. I've heard plenty on this board from landscape photographers that dynamic range is high on their wish list.
Apr 10, 2015 at 02:08 PM
Mescalamba
Offline
Details
p.2 #6High DR for 5d4
Well, its only way to do it without switching to better fab.. also nice thing is, it will work perfectly even after switching to new fab (actually, if Canon did this and they moved to lets say 90nm fab or even 65nm, then it would floored every competition).
Apr 10, 2015 at 02:18 PM
PhilDrinkwater
Offline
Details
p.2 #7High DR for 5d4
chez wrote:
Stoffer wrote
chez wroteBut wouldn't the 50mp camera that seems to fit nicely for landscapes benefit the expanded DR more than the 24mp camera which is more events or photo journalist focussed.
The idea that landscape photography is in more need of high DR that event photography is a bit flawed, IMHO. With events or photo journalist you might have to take photos of people outside in back light conditions where raising the shadows can be very beneficial.
I'm a landscape photographer and could use more dynamic range out of my sensors. I've heard plenty on this board from event photographers that more dynamic range is way down on their wish list. I've heard plenty on this board from landscape photographers that dynamic range is high on their wish list.


Yeah. On the whole Id say landscape photographers would be the group which wil benefit most.

My answer is the same as its been for years. I don't need it, as a wedding photographer, in more than 1 in 10000 shots. It'll be a nice to have and I'm sure I'll find uses for it when it comes, but it really is way lower down on my list of priorities.

I am hopeful though for others more than myself. If it's 25mp and good Dr it'll solve a lot of people's problems. Not everyone's, but a lot.
Apr 10, 2015 at 02:46 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.2 #8High DR for 5d4
PhilDrinkwater wrote:
gdanmitchell wrote
PhilDrinkwater wroteThis is a rumour. Nothing more than a rumour. Just making sure you can see its a rumour and don't complain that it's not real yet

http://www.canonrumors.com/2015/04/eos-5d-mark-iv-to-use-eos-c300-mark-ii-technology-cr2/
But wait, isn't that just a rumor? ;-)
Oh it's not is it? I feel like I've misrepresented it


That's the rumor... ;-)
Apr 10, 2015 at 02:55 PM
EB-1
Offline
Details
p.2 #9High DR for 5d4
What does this mean, back to the August 2x announcements and availability in November

EBH
Apr 10, 2015 at 03:36 PM
curious80
Offline
Details
p.2 #10High DR for 5d4
snapsy wrote:
PhilDrinkwater wroteBut surely it wouldn't provide that many stops unless the sensor was capable of it? Or is that wrong?
Sony claimed 15.3EV of DR for the A7s but that turned out to be based on some type of slog2 interpretation. The sensor itself only measured 13EV per DxO.


A 14-bit RAW file can't store 15.3 EV of DR if it is stored as linear data. The reason you need slog2 is because it essentially tone maps 15.3-stop worth of data into 14-bits. But the sensor must be able to capture those 15.3 stops at the first place, to be able to store them as slog2.
Apr 10, 2015 at 03:45 PM
snapsy
Offline
Details
p.2 #11High DR for 5d4
curious80 wrote:
snapsy wrote
PhilDrinkwater wroteBut surely it wouldn't provide that many stops unless the sensor was capable of it? Or is that wrong?
Sony claimed 15.3EV of DR for the A7s but that turned out to be based on some type of slog2 interpretation. The sensor itself only measured 13EV per DxO.
A 14-bit RAW file can't store 15.3 EV of DR if it is stored as linear data. The reason you need slog2 is because it essentially tone maps 15.3-stop worth of data into 14-bits. But the sensor must be able to capture those 15.3 stops at the first place, to be able to store them as slog2.


Gamma conversion from raw to a color space can be non-linear and thus is not inhibited by bit depth. But independent of bit depth the A7s sensor is only capable of 13EV even though the implied linear limit would be 14EV for 14-bits (irrespective of Sony's tonal compression).
Apr 10, 2015 at 04:06 PM
Ziffl3
Offline
Details
p.2 #12High DR for 5d4
Access wrote:
IMO it makes some sense that the 5d4 would return the focus to video. The 5d2 was sold heavily on its video functionality, but the 5d3 offered little to no improvement in this respect.

Also in the embedded world the line between hardware and software is blurred. The sensor had to support the dual-ISO readout in hardware for the ML guys to use it at all.

There must have been at least some forethought by Canon to have designed a sensor with this capability. It's more likely that the full implementation of that capability (whether in the DIGIC or in
...Show more →

The 5DmkII started out marketed as a still shooter THEN took off as a budding video tool ... it then became a new market that was a surprise to Canon and everybody else.

The 5DmkIII did improve on several items otherwise many video shooters would have skipped the body and stayed with the 5DmkII.

While the lines between hardware /software can blur, you still need to have a solid hardware baseline married with a software architecture that is flexible.

While I see your point ... You forget that Canon is squarely a Japanese company. The engineering staff wants to deliver more but is handcuffed by marketing and a very conservative approach.

My video friends are hoping for the same as you mentioned: real coding output 4:2:2

-Mark



Apr 10, 2015 at 04:18 PM
Ziffl3
Offline
Details
p.2 #13High DR for 5d4
Lets hope the rumors have some meat to it....

me is hungrey!!!!




-mark
Apr 10, 2015 at 04:25 PM
curious80
Offline
Details
p.2 #14High DR for 5d4
snapsy wrote:
curious80 wrote
snapsy wrote
PhilDrinkwater wroteBut surely it wouldn't provide that many stops unless the sensor was capable of it? Or is that wrong?
Sony claimed 15.3EV of DR for the A7s but that turned out to be based on some type of slog2 interpretation. The sensor itself only measured 13EV per DxO.
A 14-bit RAW file can't store 15.3 EV of DR if it is stored as linear data. The reason you need slog2 is because it essentially tone maps 15.3-stop worth of data into 14-bits. But the sensor must be able to capture those 15.3 stops at the first place, to be able to store them as slog2.
Gamma conversion from raw to a color space can be non-linear and thus is not inhibited by bit depth. But independent of bit depth the A7s sensor is only capable of 13EV even though the implied linear limit would be 14EV for 14-bits (irrespective of Sony's tonal compression).


But raw image files don't store gamma converted data, they store the linear data, and with that you are limited to 14EV of maximum DR with 14-bits. And that too only if your A/D is up to the task. A 14-bit A/D doesn't produce actual 14-bit worth of data.

Note that cameras like D810 which have over 14 stops of DR on DxoMark have that DR when down-sampled to 8MP, which effectively gives you more bits per downsampled pixel. At pixel level D810 has 13.67EV of DR as per DxoMark (which admittedly is still very high for a 14-bit sample).

A7s is at a disadvantage here because it is natively only 12MP and each of its fat pixels gets only 14-bits to represent it. SLOG2 provides a non-linear mapping of the type that you are talking about allowing storing more stops of DR to be stores in lower number of bits.
Apr 10, 2015 at 04:27 PM
snapsy
Offline
Details
p.2 #15High DR for 5d4
curious80 wrote:
snapsy wrote
curious80 wrote
snapsy wrote
PhilDrinkwater wroteBut surely it wouldn't provide that many stops unless the sensor was capable of it? Or is that wrong?
Sony claimed 15.3EV of DR for the A7s but that turned out to be based on some type of slog2 interpretation. The sensor itself only measured 13EV per DxO.
A 14-bit RAW file can't store 15.3 EV of DR if it is stored as linear data. The reason you need slog2 is because it essentially tone maps 15.3-stop worth of data into 14-bits. But the sensor must be able to capture those 15.3 stops at the first place, to be able to store them as slog2.
Gamma conversion from raw to a color space can be non-linear and thus is not inhibited by bit depth. But independent of bit depth the A7s sensor is only capable of 13EV even though the implied linear limit would be 14EV for 14-bits (irrespective of Sony's tonal compression).
But raw image files don't store gamma converted data, they store the linear data, and with that you are limited to 14EV of maximum DR with 14-bits. And that too only if your A/D is up to the task. A 14-bit A/D doesn't produce actual 14-bit worth of data.

Note that cameras like D810 which have over 14 stops of DR on DxoMark have that DR when down-sampled to 8MP, which effectively gives you more bits per downsampled pixel. At pixel level D810 has 13.67EV of DR as per DxoMark (which admittedly is still very high for a 14-bit sample).

A7s is
...Show more →

But the gamma conversion is non-linear during demosaicing, the same technique performed for slog2 that you ascribed to its ability to exceed the native bit range for DR. If it applies to one it has to apply to the other. Also, if bit depth were the limiting factor to the A7s DR then its measured DR would be 14EV rather than 13EV.
Apr 10, 2015 at 04:32 PM
curious80
Offline
Details
p.2 #16High DR for 5d4
snapsy wrote:
curious80 wrote
snapsy wrote
curious80 wrote
snapsy wrote
PhilDrinkwater wroteBut surely it wouldn't provide that many stops unless the sensor was capable of it? Or is that wrong?
Sony claimed 15.3EV of DR for the A7s but that turned out to be based on some type of slog2 interpretation. The sensor itself only measured 13EV per DxO.
A 14-bit RAW file can't store 15.3 EV of DR if it is stored as linear data. The reason you need slog2 is because it essentially tone maps 15.3-stop worth of data into 14-bits. But the sensor must be able to capture those 15.3 stops at the first place, to be able to store them as slog2.
Gamma conversion from raw to a color space can be non-linear and thus is not inhibited by bit depth. But independent of bit depth the A7s sensor is only capable of 13EV even though the implied linear limit would be 14EV for 14-bits (irrespective of Sony's tonal compression).
But raw image files don't store gamma converted data, they store the linear data, and with that you are limited to 14EV of maximum DR with 14-bits. And that too only if your A/D is up to the task. A 14-bit A/D doesn't produce actual 14-bit worth of data.

Note that cameras like D810 which have over 14 stops of DR on DxoMark have that DR when down-sampled to 8MP, which effectively gives you more bits per downsampled pixel. At pixel level D810 has 13.67EV of DR as per DxoMark (which admittedly is still very high for a 14-bit sample).

A7s is at a disadvantage here because it is natively only 12MP and each of its fat pixels gets only 14-bits to represent it. SLOG2 provides a non-linear mapping of the type that you are talking about allowing storing more stops of DR to be stores in 14-bits.
But the gamma conversion is non-linear during demosaicing, the same technique performed for slog2 that you ascribed to its ability to exceed the native bit range for DR.


You are missing the point that once the linear data has been sampled by a 14-bit A/D and stored in the RAW file as 14-bits then any additional data that was captured by the sensor in the 15th or 16-bit has already been thrown away. There is nothing you can do to reclaim that. The only way you can save any extra information captured by the sensor is if the non-linear mapping is done in the sensor itself before it is sampled by the A/D. Which I believe is what modes like SLOG2 do.


Also, if bit depth were the limiting factor to the A7s DR then its measured DR would be 14EV rather than 13EV.


Well you can't really expect full 14-EV resolution out of a 14-bit A/D. As I said even D810 is 13.67EV per pixel. But it could be simply that Sony doesn't have as good an A/D and other components in the read path. This is somewhat supported by the fact that A7R which is basically the same sensor as D810, also has only about 13EV of DR at pixel level. For video it probably doesn't matter because they have likely already done the non-linear mapping to 10-bits before going to the A/D. So even a lousy 14-bit A/D would be good enough for that 10-bit data.
Apr 10, 2015 at 04:58 PM
mttran
Offline
Details
p.2 #17High DR for 5d4
Stoffer wrote:
chez wroteBut wouldn't the 50mp camera that seems to fit nicely for landscapes benefit the expanded DR more than the 24mp camera which is more events or photo journalist focussed.
The idea that landscape photography is in more need of high DR that event photography is a bit flawed, IMHO. With events or photo journalist you might have to take photos of people outside in back light conditions where raising the shadows can be very beneficial.


chez wrote:
I'm a landscape photographer and could use more dynamic range out of my sensors. I've heard plenty on this board from event photographers that more dynamic range is way down on their wish list. I've heard plenty on this board from landscape photographers that dynamic range is high on their wish list.


+1, wider DR is great for everyone not just landscape. In portraiture application, it opens a new full creation of most fast lenses (wider aperture setting) in tricky lightning condition. Yup, it is another dimension to play in full with those exotic lenses.

Edited on Apr 10, 2015 at 06:53 PM · View previous versions
Apr 10, 2015 at 05:32 PM
snapsy
Offline
Details
p.2 #18High DR for 5d4
curious80 wrote:
snapsy wrote
curious80 wrote
snapsy wrote
curious80 wrote
snapsy wroteSony claimed 15.3EV of DR for the A7s but that turned out to be based on some type of slog2 interpretation. The sensor itself only measured 13EV per DxO.
A 14-bit RAW file can't store 15.3 EV of DR if it is stored as linear data. The reason you need slog2 is because it essentially tone maps 15.3-stop worth of data into 14-bits. But the sensor must be able to capture those 15.3 stops at the first place, to be able to store them as slog2.
Gamma conversion from raw to a color space can be non-linear and thus is not inhibited by bit depth. But independent of bit depth the A7s sensor is only capable of 13EV even though the implied linear limit would be 14EV for 14-bits (irrespective of Sony's tonal compression).
But raw image files don't store gamma converted data, they store the linear data, and with that you are limited to 14EV of maximum DR with 14-bits. And that too only if your A/D is up to the task. A 14-bit A/D doesn't produce actual 14-bit worth of data.

Note that cameras like D810 which have over 14 stops of DR on DxoMark have that DR when down-sampled to 8MP, which effectively gives you more bits per downsampled pixel. At pixel level D810 has 13.67EV of DR as per DxoMark (which admittedly is still very high for a 14-bit sample).

A7s is at a disadvantage here because it is natively only 12MP and each of its fat pixels gets only 14-bits to represent it. SLOG2 provides a non-linear mapping of the type that you are talking about allowing storing more stops of DR to be stores in 14-bits.
But the gamma conversion is non-linear during demosaicing, the same technique performed for slog2 that you ascribed to its ability to exceed the native bit range for DR.
You are missing the point that once the linear data has been sampled by a 14-bit A/D and stored in the RAW file as 14-bits then any additional data that was captured by the sensor in the 15th or 16-bit has already been thrown away. There is nothing you can do to reclaim that. The only way you can save any extra information captured by the sensor is if the non-linear mapping is done in the sensor itself before it is sampled by the A/D. Which I believe is what modes like SLOG2 do.


That's true, Sony may be doing non-linear encoding of the sensor values at the ADC for slog2. However that doesn't really increase captured DR when the underlying pixels and their charge capture+transfer mechanism is still principally linear. It simply applies a tone curve earlier in the process (against the raw data) so that the encoded ADC values can later be gamma-interpreted to a > 2^14 of tonal space. I'm not seeing how that's fundamentally different than simply re-interpreting non-slog2 raw data in the same fashion after the fact. Perhaps I'm overlooking something though.

Btw I'm less inclined to believe the A7s's true sensor-level DR is 15.3EV that can only be unleased via slog2 when you consider that slog2 is only available on the A7s at ISO 3200, which has 1/5 the FWC (and thus DR) than ISO 100.
Apr 10, 2015 at 05:35 PM
Access
Offline
Details
p.2 #19High DR for 5d4
Ziffl3 wrote:
While the lines between hardware /software can blur, you still need to have a solid hardware baseline married with a software architecture that is flexible.

While I see your point ... You forget that Canon is squarely a Japanese company. The engineering staff wants to deliver more but is handcuffed by marketing and a very conservative approach.

I don't really agree with this, it sounds nice on paper but the real world isn't that perfect. A lot of hardware out there isn't as solid as people would like to think it is, it's poorly designed, halfway complete, or just downright broken altogether. Things are designed in pieces, so a 'nice to have' feature might make it into only some pieces of hardware but not others. And hence it becomes the software team's job to work with hardware in this state as best as they can -- to make something that at least minimally works or does the job it needs to do. Since they can't just kick a project back for another hardware redesign or revision without a lot of resistance -- especially as the product gets closer to its planned release.

I'm not saying this is black and white -- of course if some core feature or vital function of the product simply can't work with the hardware in the state it is, they might have no choice but to fix the hardware (and likely cause a delay in the release of the product). My point is just in the process of designing one piece of hardware to another and then the software, it would often seem haphazard, inefficient, and maybe even nonsensical and wasteful to an outside observer. A lot of nonvital functions and features can fall by the wayside and this "dual ISO" mode of operation was likely one of them.

It would be nice to see this feature implemented "the way it ought to be", by Canon, in the official firmware (whether the hardware is perfect or not). Especially if it could be scalable to the point where it could work in multiple modes of trading off resolution for DR.
Apr 10, 2015 at 05:35 PM
snapsy
Offline
Details
p.2 #20High DR for 5d4
snapsy wrote:
curious80 wrote
snapsy wrote
curious80 wrote
snapsy wrote
curious80 wroteA 14-bit RAW file can't store 15.3 EV of DR if it is stored as linear data. The reason you need slog2 is because it essentially tone maps 15.3-stop worth of data into 14-bits. But the sensor must be able to capture those 15.3 stops at the first place, to be able to store them as slog2.
Gamma conversion from raw to a color space can be non-linear and thus is not inhibited by bit depth. But independent of bit depth the A7s sensor is only capable of 13EV even though the implied linear limit would be 14EV for 14-bits (irrespective of Sony's tonal compression).
But raw image files don't store gamma converted data, they store the linear data, and with that you are limited to 14EV of maximum DR with 14-bits. And that too only if your A/D is up to the task. A 14-bit A/D doesn't produce actual 14-bit worth of data.

Note that cameras like D810 which have over 14 stops of DR on DxoMark have that DR when down-sampled to 8MP, which effectively gives you more bits per downsampled pixel. At pixel level D810 has 13.67EV of DR as per DxoMark (which admittedly is still very high for a 14-bit sample).

A7s is at a disadvantage here because it is natively only 12MP and each of its fat pixels gets only 14-bits to represent it. SLOG2 provides a non-linear mapping of the type that you are talking about allowing storing more stops of DR to be stores in 14-bits.
But the gamma conversion is non-linear during demosaicing, the same technique performed for slog2 that you ascribed to its ability to exceed the native bit range for DR.
You are missing the point that once the linear data has been sampled by a 14-bit A/D and stored in the RAW file as 14-bits then any additional data that was captured by the sensor in the 15th or 16-bit has already been thrown away. There is nothing you can do to reclaim that. The only way you can save any extra information captured by the sensor is if the non-linear mapping is done in the sensor itself before it is sampled by the A/D. Which I believe is what modes like SLOG2 do.
That's true, Sony may be doing non-linear encoding of the sensor values at the ADC for slog2. However that doesn't really increase captured DR when the underlying pixels and their charge capture+transfer mechanism is still principally linear. It simply applies a tone curve earlier in the process (against the raw data) so that the encoded ADC values can later be gamma-interpreted to a > 2^14 of tonal space. I'm not seeing how that's fundamentally different than simply re-interpreting non-slog2 raw data in the same fashion after the fact. Perhaps I'm overlooking something though.

Btw I'm less inclined to believe the A7s's
...Show more →

Thinking it through more, an ADC-based slog2 would be fundamentally different vs simply reinterpreting non-slog2 raw data if the native DR capability of the sensor is greater than the underlying ADC bit depth + ADC noise. But I don't see the A7s's FWC and charge-transfer noise supporting 15.3EV and its on-chip parallel ADC adding an entire 1EV of noise. Also, considering that the A7s has only 13EV of DR at ISO 100 (post-ADC) I don't see how it can how slog2 can achieve 15.3EV of sensor-level DR when it operates at ISO 3200 for slog2.
Apr 10, 2015 at 05:48 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister