p.8 #1Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
I'll wait for this camera to drop to $3000 in half a year and then try to buy a used copy of it on Craigslist for $2500 like I did for the canon 5d mark iii. I love my Sony A7, but it still doesn't feel as good as holding Canon gear in your hands. I'll just have to wait a little long for my Canon camera with Sony sensor hahaha
p.8 #2Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
James Markus wrote:
Personally, I think the 5ds and 5dsR are exciting news. The DR may be c. However, 11 stops is still an excellent dynamic range.
I also think the 5Ds and 5DsR are exciting news, despite the conservative dynamic range.
History does not provide any support for any improvement beyond measurement uncertainty or common copy variation, in dynamic range measured from raw data between pre-production and production models, or between generic software or software with specific camera support. Understaning how dynamic range is limited in the cameras and how the file format of a raw file is constructed does not support that possibility either.
Saying that the DR may be different with the released retail products, and with the latest software support, is giving people false hope.
However, I can also live with 11 stops dynamic range, as long the fixed pattern noise is under control. It was always the banding in the shadows that disturbed me about the 5D II.
I have received information based on analysis of the masked sensor area that the banding control of the 5DsR is excellent. That is all the good news I need to stay interested in the 5Ds(R).
p.8 #3Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
StillFingerz wrote: Monito wroteBeni wroteIn the studio I often use the Nikon MC-30A release in my teeth for when I have my hands full, it's such a big button that it's far easier in general to use than any other release from my canon or sony cameras. In the mouth I press the button with my tounge. Bit yeuch perhaps to some but when you're shooting product or repro and have both hands full, it's very very useful.A switch is a switch. Adapt it to a foot switch.Monito, Beni wrote that reply to me, a disabled photographer that just happens to have a paralyzed body with paralysis starting at the neck, so a foot switch would not be doable in my case. Cheers
I thought that the foot switch comment was sensible in context - if you have both hands full, then a foot switch might be more convenient than using the MC-30A in your mouth. That's assuming you have the use of two hands and one foot.
I don't know if the MC-30A would be suited to your needs. If it were mounted to something, I expect it would be easier to use - I think it would be awkward if it weren't.
p.8 #4Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
This has (partly) turned into another pointless discussion with both sides simply trying to label each others beliefs and needs and priorities as "wrong" ... rather than accepting the truth that we don't all need or believe the same things.
p.8 #5Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
PhilDrinkwater wrote:
This has (partly) turned into another pointless discussion with both sides simply trying to label each others beliefs and needs and priorities as "wrong" ... rather than accepting the truth that we don't all need or believe the same things.
p.8 #6Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
artd wrote:
It is possible to be analytical and engineering minded and still be a good photographer.
I didn't say otherwise. Of course it is possible to be analytical and engineering minded and still be a good photographer. No doubt, many analytical and engineering minded people are good photographers. It is good to be analytical and engineering minded. However, people whose criticisms of Canon are laced with technical terms about sensor design, fabrication and measurement are not representative of either professional or amateur photographers generally, but are likely narrowly representative of engineers with specialized technical knowledge of sensor design, fabrication and measurement. Their concerns about outcompeting the competition in one benchmark number (low ISO DR) don't necessarily reflect the concerns of photographers generally. Moreover, the reliance on Canon by some of the world's most renowned photographers suggests that outcompeting the competition on this one benchmark number is not nearly as important as some people here make it out to be.
p.8 #7Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
PhilDrinkwater wrote:
This has (partly) turned into another pointless discussion with both sides simply trying to label each others beliefs and needs and priorities as "wrong" ... rather than accepting the truth that we don't all need or believe the same things.
Yeah it's like finding the wrong door and accidentally walking into a meeting of Narcissists Anonymous. "But what do you mean what's right for me isn't also right for everyone else? How can that be?"
p.8 #8Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Access wrote: PhilDrinkwater wroteThis has (partly) turned into another pointless discussion with both sides simply trying to label each others beliefs and needs and priorities as "wrong" ... rather than accepting the truth that we don't all need or believe the same things.Yeah it's like finding the wrong door and accidentally walking into a meeting of Narcissists Anonymous. "But what do you mean what's right for me isn't also right for everyone else? How can that be?"
The thing is I have never read of anyone on the Canon forum saying anything other than the Sony sensors are very good, they are indisputably and demonstrably very good, we get that.
The fact that I and many others are quite happy with the cameras we currently have and don't feel the need to upgrade still doesn't mean we don't think the Sony sensor isn't very good, nor does it make us inadequate in the camera department or somehow lagging behind
Some users should just accept we are happy with what we have.
p.8 #9Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
zlatko wrote: artd wroteIt is possible to be analytical and engineering minded and still be a good photographer.I didn't say otherwise. Of course it is possible to be analytical and engineering minded and still be a good photographer. No doubt, many analytical and engineering minded people are good photographers. It is good to be analytical and engineering minded. However, people whose criticisms of Canon are laced with technical terms about sensor design, fabrication and measurement are not representative of either professional or amateur photographers generally, but are likely narrowly representative of engineers with specialized technical knowledge of sensor design, fabrication and measurement. Their concerns about outcompeting the competition in one benchmark number (low ISO DR) don't necessarily reflect the concerns of photographers generally. Moreover, the reliance on Canon by some of the world's most renowned photographers suggests that outcompeting the competition on this one benchmark number is not nearly as important as some people here make it out to be....Show more →
If Canon had a sensor which would be better than all compettitive ones in DR, you would gladly use the technologically expressed difference as argument against other competitive sensors. Since DR seems to be the Achilles Heel even for Canon's newest sensor, you don't want to have talked about it and claim it sporadically as not important enough for "most" photographers.
I remember similar argumentations here in this forum a while back when Canon did not have a competitive D800 sensor out there.....several people here said that high MP is not needed by the majority of photographers anyway, Canon does the right thing not vesting in it etcetc. Now when it is obvious that also Canon recognized the need for more MP FF sensors, this reasoning all got quiet.
p.8 #11Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
dhphoto wrote:
Some users should just accept we are happy with what we have.
And some people also need to accept that Canon just isn't right for everyone.
Hopefully this doesn't come across as sexist, but I remember during my College years, there was a good looking but absolutely crazy girl on our floor. She and one of my friends started dating, and when asked about the relationship, he replied "She's not for everyone. But she's fine by me!" with a smile on his face. And we nodded our heads and said "that's cool" and then forgot about the whole thing. Last I checked they were still married, with two kids.
p.8 #12Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
gdanmitchell wrote: artd wrotezlatko wroteThe fact is that Canon cameras — including Canon sensors with their current DR — are very competitive in both professional and amateur photography.I agree. That's why I still own Canon gear. At the same time, while Canon is extremely competitive as a system, I would love to see a Canon camera that is more competitive in regards to dynamic range.
I also agree that there have been some hypercritical voices in these discussions that exaggerate the issue and its impact. The problem is, trying to counter someone's exaggeration with more exaggeration isn't a very effective strategy and doesn't lead to reasonable discussion.
It is possible to still think Canon's cameras are good and also think that their sensors could be better.
It is possible to be critical of Canon's limitations, yet still use them to make good photos.
It is possible to be analytical and engineering minded and still be a good photographer.Who said otherwise?
Someone who, after the OP provided a technical analysis of 5DS DR, made a witty turn on the OP's mispelling of analyzed and to imply he was being anal, along with making comments about those who would like DR improvements as moaning and thinking the sky is falling. And then then applied the label of "Forumtography" as a disparaging term for people choosing to discuss the topic. And wrote that "actual photographers" don't care about "gear wars" implying that if you actually are interested in gear comparisons and analysis you must not be a real photographer.
(Plus someone else who wrote they were "baffled at the fact that people convinced themselves that they need 2 more extra stops of DR to take a decent photo". And so on)
p.8 #13Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
retrofocus wrote: zlatko wroteartd wroteIt is possible to be analytical and engineering minded and still be a good photographer.I didn't say otherwise. Of course it is possible to be analytical and engineering minded and still be a good photographer. No doubt, many analytical and engineering minded people are good photographers. It is good to be analytical and engineering minded. However, people whose criticisms of Canon are laced with technical terms about sensor design, fabrication and measurement are not representative of either professional or amateur photographers generally, but are likely narrowly representative of engineers with specialized technical knowledge of sensor design, fabrication and measurement. Their concerns about outcompeting the competition in one benchmark number (low ISO DR) don't necessarily reflect the concerns of photographers generally. Moreover, the reliance on Canon by some of the world's most renowned photographers suggests that outcompeting the competition on this one benchmark number is not nearly as important as some people here make it out to be.If Canon had a sensor which would be better than all compettitive ones in DR, you would gladly use the technologically expressed difference as argument against other competitive sensors. Since DR seems to be the Achilles Heel even for Canon's newest sensor, you don't want to have talked about it and claim it sporadically as not important enough for "most" photographers.
I remember similar argumentations here in this forum a while back when Canon did not have a competitive D800 sensor out there.....several people here said that high MP is not needed by the majority of photographers anyway, Canon does the right thing not vesting in it etcetc. Now when it is obvious that also Canon recognized the need for more MP FF sensors, this reasoning all got quiet. ...Show more →
DR is hardly the "Achilles Heel" of Canon. Achilles Heel implies a strong weakness or vulnerability — it's what led to Achilles' demise. This exactly what I mean when I say, "outcompeting the competition on this one benchmark number is not nearly as important as some people here make it out to be." Canon is serving the vast majority of its market very well with its current sensors. Would it be beneficial if they managed to provide more DR — of course! No one would object to more DR. But the idea that Canon's DR is something like Achilles Heel — that's going to bring Canon down — is just not realistic.
High MP is still not needed by the majority of photographers anyway. But the fact that Canon wasn't making a high MP camera did not mean that Canon did not "recognize" that some photographers do need high MP. Of course they recognized that. No doubt they recognized it and were working on it long before the 5DS came to market. It just didn't have the priority that some photographers would like, amidst the thousands of other things they were actually bringing to the market — which were meeting the needs of millions of photographers. It's the same with low ISO DR. Why imagine that Canon doesn't recognize that some photographers would like more low ISO DR? Of course they recognize that. But amidst the thousands of other things they are actually bringing to the market, low ISO DR isn't getting the priority that some photographers would like. That doesn't mean Canon is headed for a demise.
p.8 #14Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
artd wrote:
Someone who, after the OP provided a technical analysis of 5DS DR, made a witty turn on the OP's mispelling of analyzed and to imply he was being anal, along with making comments about those who would like DR improvements as moaning and thinking the sky is falling. And then then applied the label of "Forumtography" as a disparaging term for people choosing to discuss the topic. And wrote that "actual photographers" don't care about "gear wars" implying that if you actually are interested in gear comparisons and analysis you must not be a real photographer.
(Plus someone else who wrote they were "baffled at the fact that people convinced themselves that they need 2 more extra stops of DR to take a decent photo". And so on)....Show more →
I would say the OP pretty much got exactly what they wanted out of the thread. They started it off by saying the Canon sensor was boring and 11 stops of DR is boring so he was low level trolling to begin with. Since most trolls want attention I would say the thread was a success from their standpoint.
p.8 #15Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
zlatko wrote: artd wroteIt is possible to be analytical and engineering minded and still be a good photographer.I didn't say otherwise. Of course it is possible to be analytical and engineering minded and still be a good photographer. No doubt, many analytical and engineering minded people are good photographers. It is good to be analytical and engineering minded. However, people whose criticisms of Canon are laced with technical terms about sensor design, fabrication and measurement are not representative of either professional or amateur photographers generally, but are likely narrowly representative of engineers with specialized technical knowledge of sensor design, fabrication and measurement. Their concerns about outcompeting the competition in one benchmark number (low ISO DR) don't necessarily reflect the concerns of photographers generally. Moreover, the reliance on Canon by some of the world's most renowned photographers suggests that outcompeting the competition on this one benchmark number is not nearly as important as some people here make it out to be....Show more →
I seriously question some of the poster here who throw out the sensor fabrication specs like they actually understand what impact that has. I know several people do actually work in that field, but others just say it to sound smart and try to justify their endless incorrect predictions and claims.
Also interesting that others don't understand that the world continues to move ahead and change. What made sense 2 years ago, doesn't necessarily make sense now. Saying that high MP wasn't needed several years ago was completely accurate. Canon is still the market leader in sales, they clearly didn't need a competitor to the d800 to remain as a viable camera company. This isn't about people changing their mind since canon now has a high MP camera, like some would love to believe.
p.8 #16Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
zlatko wrote: artd wroteIt is possible to be analytical and engineering minded and still be a good photographer.I didn't say otherwise. Of course it is possible to be analytical and engineering minded and still be a good photographer. No doubt, many analytical and engineering minded people are good photographers. It is good to be analytical and engineering minded. However, people whose criticisms of Canon are laced with technical terms about sensor design, fabrication and measurement are not representative of either professional or amateur photographers generally, but are likely narrowly representative of engineers with specialized technical knowledge of sensor design, fabrication and measurement. Their concerns about outcompeting the competition in one benchmark number (low ISO DR) don't necessarily reflect the concerns of photographers generally. Moreover, the reliance on Canon by some of the world's most renowned photographers suggests that outcompeting the competition on this one benchmark number is not nearly as important as some people here make it out to be....Show more →
I don't disagree with any of that, though I think the perspective on "outcompeting the competition in one benchmark" is a bit trivialized. It's more about being able to make technological improvement in an area the competition has excelled in. That technology allows for an improved workflow in circumstances where dynamic range is a limiting factor. It doesn't mean Canon cameras suddenly became bad because they have fallen behind in that area. It just simply means they've fallen behind in that area. And since we know there is room for improvement in that area, it'd be great if they could improve.
p.8 #17Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
ggreene wrote: artd wroteSomeone who, after the OP provided a technical analysis of 5DS DR, made a witty turn on the OP's mispelling of analyzed and to imply he was being anal, along with making comments about those who would like DR improvements as moaning and thinking the sky is falling. And then then applied the label of "Forumtography" as a disparaging term for people choosing to discuss the topic. And wrote that "actual photographers" don't care about "gear wars" implying that if you actually are interested in gear comparisons and analysis you must not be a real photographer.
(Plus someone else who wrote they were "baffled at the fact that people convinced themselves that they need 2 more extra stops of DR to take a decent photo". And so on).I would say the OP pretty much got exactly what they wanted out of the thread. They started it off by saying the Canon sensor was boring and 11 stops of DR is boring so he was low level trolling to begin with. Since most trolls want attention I would say the thread was a success from their standpoint.
I can see how using that word may have implied a dissatisfaction. But, I really think that's a bit harsh calling the OP a troll.
p.8 #19Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Access wrote: dhphoto wroteSome users should just accept we are happy with what we have.And some people also need to accept that Canon just isn't right for everyone.
p.8 #20Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
gdanmitchell wrote: Access wrotedhphoto wroteSome users should just accept we are happy with what we have.And some people also need to accept that Canon just isn't right for everyone.Who said that Canon is right for everyone?