p.7 #1Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
In before the DRones accuse anyone that have optimistic opinions to say about the 5Ds/r as the canon police or fan boys while posting in a canon thread within a canon subforum
retrofocus wrote:
That you feel personally offended about sensor drawbacks with your favorite brand, this is simply your problem.
Not offended, but baffled at the fact that people convinced themselves that they need 2 more extra stops of DR to take a decent photo, but that's not my problem
p.7 #2Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
panicatnabisco wrote:
In before the DRones accuse anyone that have optimistic opinions to say about the 5Ds/r as the canon police or fan boys while posting in a canon thread within a canon subforum
p.7 #3Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
panicatnabisco wrote:
In before the DRones accuse anyone that have optimistic opinions to say about the 5Ds/r as the canon police or fan boys while posting in a canon thread within a canon subforum
retrofocus wroteThat you feel personally offended about sensor drawbacks with your favorite brand, this is simply your problem.Not offended, but baffled at the fact that people convinced themselves that they need 2 more extra stops of DR to take a decent photo, but that's not my problem
There will be many threads soon and in the longer term comparing Sony with Canon sensors. Both forums will have posts about it - so what? Well, you and some others here (we all know who they are ) would love to have any criticism silenced - it is not gonna happen, buddy! If there are difference or no differences, both forums are the right place to discuss about it. I couldn't care less if you and others here in this forum dislike this.
2 more stops of DR don't make a better photo, but it facilitates (a) the process of taking it with less or no ND filters, and b) much less post processing needed. Maybe you should try - but I forgot, you are so addicted to one brand, this seems impossible .
p.7 #5Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
panicatnabisco wrote:
"I could care less" is what you're looking for, but what do I know after working at a gear rental company as a tech and shooting both Nikon and Canon systems side by side for years.
At least Nikon shooters don't froth in the mouth about DR as much, they're cool people
Agree in general about Nikon shooters....most of my personal photo friends use Nikon, mostly D800 and D810 cameras. Some switched in recent years from Canon cameras - all for the same reason: higher resolution and more DR . The remaining Canon shooters who own a 5D MkIII all focus more on event shootings.
p.7 #7Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
panicatnabisco wrote:
Not offended, but baffled at the fact that people convinced themselves that they need 2 more extra stops of DR to take a decent photo, but that's not my problem
What's really baffling is that people keep reiterating a version of this argument. Who has actually said this?
gdanmitchell wrote:
Yes. It is a wonder that anyone can make photographs at all given the horrendous and dire circumstances you describe. ;-)
Again: "No one wrote that". Who is actually implying anything of the sort?
Why is there the need to paint those who would like to see more dynamic range as unreasonable, as holding ridiculous standards, as being incompetent, as more interested in engineering than artistry, as incapable of making good photographs? Why should the desire for improvement be ridiculed?
p.7 #8Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
artd wrote: panicatnabisco wroteNot offended, but baffled at the fact that people convinced themselves that they need 2 more extra stops of DR to take a decent photo, but that's not my problem What's really baffling is that people keep reiterating a version of this argument. Who has actually said this?
gdanmitchell wroteYes. It is a wonder that anyone can make photographs at all given the horrendous and dire circumstances you describe. ;-)Again: "No one wrote that". Who is actually implying anything of the sort?
Why is there the need to paint those who would like to see more dynamic range as unreasonable, as holding ridiculous standards, as being incompetent, as more interested in engineering than artistry, as incapable of making good photographs? Why should the desire for improvement be ridiculed?
Basically they are close minded people who think just because they don't see a need for more dynamic range, then everyone else should not have a need. They have never used GND filters to tame down the dynamic range...never had to fight with merging multiple exposures to try obtain one image which contains details in both the highlights and shadows...never spent hours in post trying to recover blown highlights or trying to dig some detail from shadows without getting ugly banding.
These people know how to expose properly so they don't need a large dynamic range...at least that is their reasoning. These are people who I suggest are ignorant on the concept of dynamic range and how many of us need to jump through hoops like GND filters or merging multiple exposures just to get a good print.
p.7 #9Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
cgarcia wrote:
I didn't expected this crude debate on this topic... well, at least it seems that is a interesting topic, isn't it?. With the Canon words, we all expected not a huge improvement in DR, but still were expectant about a little tech improvement. The final improvement in DR is next to zero, and that won't change in the final product or with proper converters (the data was a bit difficult to be obtained, but do is correct, otherwise it there would have been math contradictions).
This fact doesn't invalidates the camera: the 5DS may have improved in other interesting parameters like color reproduction, or the shadows noise quality as in recent developments. Good engineering even better (shutter improvements). And it has 50 theoretical MP, in reality maybe half of that, which may seem too much for printing in pocketable sizes, but not for the 7680x4320 monitor or TV we'll have in our desk or wall more sooner than later. We'll definitely see a difference on such monitor between a 20 or a 50 MP sensor (prints are a thing of the past: a waste of paper, room and with limited DR! )
About my words I don't find "boring" as an insult... I think that it is simple what many feel. Yes, 11-stop DR is enough for many situations (for example with good lighting, just from were the best photos come out) but current technology allows better results. If we are conformist, manufacturers will have little incentive to improve, specially those with strengths, as Canon.
For example, how many years has needed Canon to get right the auto-ISO, only properly implemented for first time in the 1DX thanks to a firmware patch?. At first, only small industry players got it right. Nikon and Canon have needed more time and a lot of moaning. Another example: in the past, we checked the focus in the field using image reviews magnifying small thumbnails (while phones manufactured at the same date properly showed the pictures at 100%!). Still, nowadays (about 15 years after the first digital cameras) we don't have a good clue of how a photo is exposed after taking it. Histograms are related to poorly processed jpegs even when shooting RAW (fortunately, in Canon we have firmware hacks like Magic Lantern). Is it so difficult to show a RAW-data-related blinking alert overlayed on the human-readable reference jpeg when the user shoots raw only?. ML guys have managed it!. In fact, if ML doesn't runs in the 5DS (and maybe won't due to its lesser video features) I'll have little incentive to upgrade. I can't live without the ML highlights alert, specially in a gear desperately requiring a right exposure.
Still I think that manufacturers have improved a lot, including the ones with higher sales, and I think that is partly because we moan. Canon publicly acknowledged they patched the 1DX because some pros moaned about the lack of exposure compensation in manual mode with auto ISO (while some conformist forum members previously tried to ridiculize another forum members for asking that, referring them to the dictionary definition of exposure).
About DR we started moaning in the forums, then magazines reporting totally wrong DR measures have improved their analysis and joined us (see dpreview's 7D2 review with dedicated lab reports: about 10% of the rewiew is dedicated to show the 7D2 shortcomings in latitude and real world DR compared to Nikon D7000; even in their interviews with Canon managers they use the opportunity to ask about this subject).
In summary, despite somebody may not like it, we are entitled to analyze the gear (including beta products, which usually only change in firmware features or the jpeg IQ) and we are entitled to request our respective manufacturers of choice the missing features already provided by the competitors, which seems reasonably fair. ...Show more →
+1, We exchange our tools parameters to serve all GEAR members not just some poster here and there, thank for sharing your work.
p.7 #10Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
panicatnabisco wrote:
Its pretty obvious that Canon is not competing against Sony's sensor at this point with the DR performance of the 7DII and the upcoming 5Ds/r, so why do we keep bringing this subject up? I don't even think it was possible to beat this horse to the ground, but you DRones are finding ways to interject this tired and old argument into everything canon related so far. I guess it's a slow day in the Sony subforum
Why do you care? This thread is about dynamic range. Who is holding your head to the fire to even participate in this thread. Man, if it hurts you so much to yet again read about dynamic range...then just butt out.
Give it a rest and let people actually interested in this stuff continue with the conversations. Go start your own thread on whatever you really care about..
p.7 #11Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
jcolwell wrote:
Most of my personal photo friends use cameras...
;-)
gdanmitchell wrote:
Yes. It is a wonder that anyone can make photographs at all given the horrendous and dire circumstances you describe. ;-)
artd wrote:
Again: "No one wrote that". Who is actually implying anything of the sort?
No photographers that I know, which is precisely my point. ;-)
Why is there the need to paint those who would like to see more dynamic range as unreasonable, as holding ridiculous standards, as being incompetent, as more interested in engineering than artistry, as incapable of making good photographs? Why should the desire for improvement be ridiculed?
p.7 #12Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Personally, I think the 5ds and 5dsR are exciting news. The DR may be different with the released retail products, and with the latest software support. However, 11 stops is still an excellent dynamic range.
p.7 #13Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
artd wrote: panicatnabisco wroteNot offended, but baffled at the fact that people convinced themselves that they need 2 more extra stops of DR to take a decent photo, but that's not my problem What's really baffling is that people keep reiterating a version of this argument. Who has actually said this?
gdanmitchell wroteYes. It is a wonder that anyone can make photographs at all given the horrendous and dire circumstances you describe. ;-)Again: "No one wrote that". Who is actually implying anything of the sort?
Why is there the need to paint those who would like to see more dynamic range as unreasonable, as holding ridiculous standards, as being incompetent, as more interested in engineering than artistry, as incapable of making good photographs? Why should the desire for improvement be ridiculed?
There is a difference between saying "I would like to see more dynamic range" — which is reasonable — and saying "Canon sensors are not competitive ... Canon doesn't care ... Canon doesn't invest in new sensor fab ... Canon use old sensor tech ... Canon will ignore users until their sales crash ... etc." These sorts of things are written all of the time and sound very authoritative and techy, but have little to do with most photography for most photographers, including some of the most renowned professionals who choose Canon for their work. The fact is that Canon cameras — including Canon sensors with their current DR — are very competitive in both professional and amateur photography. Statements about Canon being "uncompetitive" are personal judgments/criticisms presented as general facts. If Canon sensors don't meet someone's personal needs — fine, they should move on to a brand that does, rather than making it their personal mission to proclaim Canon as the brand that puts "old 10D-era sensor tech" into new cameras ... which is what some people seem intent on doing.
p.7 #14Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
retrofocus wrote:
There will be many threads soon and in the longer term comparing Sony with Canon sensors. Both forums will have posts about it - so what? Well, you and some others here (we all know who they are ) would love to have any criticism silenced - it is not gonna happen, buddy! If there are difference or no differences, both forums are the right place to discuss about it. I couldn't care less if you and others here in this forum dislike this.
You can post comparisons all you want, it won't change the fact that Canon will invest in a new fabrication and design facility when they feel like it. Given the state of the market they really don't have much incentive to do so given that low ISO DR is not the panacea for sales. If it was, Nikon and Sony would be doing far better then Canon which they aren't. Both of their lineups are full of Exmor sensors and they still have declining sales.
You can bitch and moan all you want but I don't think we are getting greater low ISO DR until Canon sees some actual advantage in sales to justify the cost. So far it doesn't seem to be much of a factor.
p.7 #15Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
A magic lantern dual iso for this, even after some loss of resolution in highlights and shadows would be nice bonus. I have not read through the thread, but canon itself said there is no improvement in DR compared to 5d3, so although I understand the skeptisim of some, this is really not news.
I admit I was one of the vocally disappointed people with announcement of the camera, and predicted it would flop. I am not so sure now. Together with canons excellent zooms (11-24, 16-35 f4, 24-70 f2.8II or f4, 70-200 f4 IS, or f2.8II IS, and 100-400L II), this camera is a compelling option for those shooting medium format, at less cost, far more functional and portability.
p.7 #16Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Access wrote:
Zlatko, let's take this example, do you think a general "power user" should buy a computer based purely on a photoshop performance benchmark? Surely not, for a general user, it makes little sense, it makes more sense to buy a computer based on a larger set of benchmarks that are more representative of general use.
On the other hand, a working photographer who plans to use a computer for photoshop 90% of the time would be more than in the right to select his computer based purely on such a benchmark, provided the others that mattered were at least somewhat passable....Show more →
While some people are stressed about that low ISO DR benchmark, these working photographers are choosing Canon for at least some of their actual work: Sebastiao Salgado (for part of his multi-year Earth-spanning Genesis project), Patrick Demarchelier (shooting Beyonce for Vogue), Mario Sorrenti (2012 Pirelli Calendar), Pete Souza (for official White House photography), Peter Read Miller (for Sports Illustrated), and Annie Leibovitz (official Portraits of Queen Elizabeth II, Dream Portraits for Disney, Lady Gaga for Vanity Fair, Keith Richards for Luis Vuitton, Sean Connery for Luis Vuitton, Bono for Luis Vuitton, Meryl Streep for Vogue, Marion Cotillard for Dior, Rihanna for Vogue, etc.). Those are just a few examples that one can find online. So how bad are those Canon sensors?
p.7 #17Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
zlatko wrote:
The fact is that Canon cameras — including Canon sensors with their current DR — are very competitive in both professional and amateur photography.
I agree. That's why I still own Canon gear. At the same time, while Canon is extremely competitive as a system, I would love to see a Canon camera that is more competitive in regards to dynamic range.
I also agree that there have been some hypercritical voices in these discussions that exaggerate the issue and its impact. The problem is, trying to counter someone's exaggeration with more exaggeration isn't a very effective strategy and doesn't lead to reasonable discussion.
It is possible to still think Canon's cameras are good and also think that their sensors could be better.
It is possible to be critical of Canon's limitations, yet still use them to make good photos.
It is possible to be analytical and engineering minded and still be a good photographer.
p.7 #18Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
I'll wait till production models are in the hands of testers before getting all worked up. IF it does have similar DR like past bodies, I'll be rather disappointed and will consider other option. If it offers an improvement, I'll likely be a buyer. But if it doesn't it won't be the end of the world...
For the naysayers who don't think more DR is necessary; I agree that for many people it probably isn't that big a deal. But for some, it is definitely noticeable and borders on a hindrance. I first realized the difference a newer sensor technology with more DR could offer when switching from 5DII/7D to an A7 and borrowing a D600 for an extended period. The differences were almost night and day in some scenarios (and admittedly non-issues in others).
I'm one of the "better to have and not need, than need and not have" believers though. But who knows, maybe after handling one and seeing some proper raw images in situations that mirror extremes I might encounter...maybe I'll still want one. It doesn't look like Nikon is updating their 24-70 anytime soon, or their 135, so Canon is way ahead of the game as far as I'm concerned. Bodies come out almost yearly, and eventually Canon will give us the DR/low ISO improvement we all want.....lenses come out (at least in my experience with Nikon) far less often, so if I were to consider a D8XX or whatever they have next I'll probably still have to wait another decade for a proper 24-70.
Just kinda have to pick your poison really, and keep in mind you're investing into an entire system.
p.7 #19Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
zlatko wrote:
Those are just a few examples that one can find online. So how bad are those Canon sensors?
My point is just that even if the ones who truly need it are a minority among a minority; if you happen to be one of them, it's still the right decision to make.
p.7 #20Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
artd wrote: zlatko wroteThe fact is that Canon cameras — including Canon sensors with their current DR — are very competitive in both professional and amateur photography.I agree. That's why I still own Canon gear. At the same time, while Canon is extremely competitive as a system, I would love to see a Canon camera that is more competitive in regards to dynamic range.
I also agree that there have been some hypercritical voices in these discussions that exaggerate the issue and its impact. The problem is, trying to counter someone's exaggeration with more exaggeration isn't a very effective strategy and doesn't lead to reasonable discussion.
It is possible to still think Canon's cameras are good and also think that their sensors could be better.
It is possible to be critical of Canon's limitations, yet still use them to make good photos.
It is possible to be analytical and engineering minded and still be a good photographer....Show more →