fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)

  
 
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.9 #1Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
artd wrote:
gdanmitchell wrote
artd wrote
zlatko wroteThe fact is that Canon cameras — including Canon sensors with their current DR — are very competitive in both professional and amateur photography.
I agree. That's why I still own Canon gear. At the same time, while Canon is extremely competitive as a system, I would love to see a Canon camera that is more competitive in regards to dynamic range.

I also agree that there have been some hypercritical voices in these discussions that exaggerate the issue and its impact. The problem is, trying to counter someone's exaggeration with more exaggeration isn't a very effective strategy and doesn't lead to reasonable discussion.

It is possible to still think Canon's cameras are good and also think that their sensors could be better.

It is possible to be critical of Canon's limitations, yet still use them to make good photos.

It is possible to be analytical and engineering minded and still be a good photographer.
Who said otherwise?
Someone who, after the OP provided a technical analysis of 5DS DR, made a witty turn on the OP's mispelling of analyzed and to imply he was being anal, along with making comments about those who would like DR improvements as moaning and thinking the sky is falling. And then then applied the label of "Forumtography" as a disparaging term for people choosing to discuss the topic. And wrote that "actual photographers" don't care about "gear wars" implying that if you actually are interested in gear comparisons and analysis you must not be a real photographer.

(Plus someone else who wrote
...Show more →

Those comments (taken out of context) are not the things that you said people were saying. I do not hold the positions you described in the post about which I was asking. Go ahead, take a look at what you wrote in that post.

My comments are not about the skills of photographers with different gear preferences. If anything, I acknowledged pretty clearly that there are a wide range of preferences among photographers. I have written repeatedly that the Sony sensors (as found in Sony, Nikon, and a few other cameras) represent the current state of the art in DSLRs and mirrorless camera sensors. I have never remotely suggested (at least not that I recall) that people can't be technically oriented and good photographers — in fact, every good photographer I know is quite aware of the technical issues of photography.

My issue — and let me state this with as much clarity as I can muster — is not about which camera you or anyone else chooses. Intelligent and talented photographers choose to work with a wide range of equipment and produce wonderful work with all of it. My reference to other photographers was not to suggest that real photographers don't care about DR. It was to point out that most photographers place that in the context of a wide range of factors that go into choosing and using equipment, and that they make decisions based on that larger context — decisions that they find to be the most productive for their photography.

My argument is not that "DR doesn't matter." I've never, to the best of my knowledge, written such a thing. I have pointed out that the effect of the differences that exist among current sensors — a real and measurable difference — doesn't seem to be as big of a deal as others think in my experience and in my opinion.

My argument is not that Sony or Canon or any other company is better or worse than Canon or Sony or whomever. There are differences, which I have acknowledged over and over. I've written quite a few times (to paraphrase) that Sony makes very compelling products, that Nikon produces excellent gear, and that friends and associates use both brands. I use brands other than Canon myself. I don't think anyone is stupid for choosing either of those brands or any others. I don't think that their equipment choices say anything at all about their skill as photographers or the quality of the work they do.

My argument is not that people shouldn't buy Sony cameras or Nikon cameras. They are fine photographic tools, and I know lots of people who put them to good use.

I don't object one bit to people holding the opinion that their gear choices are the best choices for them. I don't object one bit to people sharing, in reasonable and intelligent ways, their preferences and the reasons for those preferences. I have these discussions with photographer friends from time to time. We explain. We compare. We try to understand. We accept.

My issue — and, again, let me try to be very clear — is the obsessive nature of some posters about one (or another) particular technical issue, and the incessant apparent compulsion to turn every discussion of any new piece of Canon equipment into (yet another!) opportunity to "prove" that Canon cameras are substandard or insufficient or poorly designed. (Take a look at the record — the forum is full of such threads.) Again, it isn't holding that point of view that is the problem (anyone is welcome to feel that way about Canon or any other brand). It is the constant, repetitive, seemingly-obsessive redirection of virtually any discussion about Canon cameras in the Canon forum to yet another opportunity to tell us, explicitly or implicitly, that our choice is a bad one... until we finally just give up and go away. The thread sort of gives up and dies. Until the next one...

We get it. We understand that Sony makes really nice sensors. Asked and answered. Can we please move on?

Dan

Edited on Mar 24, 2015 at 01:11 PM · View previous versions
Mar 24, 2015 at 09:20 AM
renowood
Offline
Details
p.9 #2Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)

I went to a fight and a camera forum broke out.
Mar 24, 2015 at 09:30 AM
mttran
Offline
Details
p.9 #3Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
This forum is not belong to number of canon hardcore posters like some of you. What about last decade 11stops DR owners now want to upgrade to better DR cams that are available from most MFG out there. Have you guys ever thought about this or just concentrate on your own shell and don't care the others

Talking about multiplication does not apply on the zero...the same arguments since low iso banding years.
Mar 24, 2015 at 09:31 AM
artd
Offline
Details
p.9 #4Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
gdanmitchell wrote:
My issue — and, again, let me try to be very clear — is the obsessive nature of some posters about one (or another) particular technical issue, and the incessant apparent compulsion to turn every discussion of any new piece of Canon equipment into (yet another!) opportunity to "prove" that Canon cameras a substandard or insufficient or poorly designed. (Take a look at the record — the forum is full of such threads.) Again, it isn't holding that point of view that is the problem (anyone is welcome to feel that way about Canon or any other brand). It is the constant,
...Show more →

I would put it to you that it was not the intent of the OP to "prove that Canon cameras a substandard or insufficient or poorly designed." I read nothing of the sort. His use of the phrase "boring 11-stop DR" while perhaps not the most diplomatic choice of words, simply conveys that the dynamic range is the same as its been for the last seven years (and regardless of what one's opinion is on the overall excellence of Canon cameras there is no context in which I find 11 stops of dynamic range to be an exciting development in modern sensor technology.) But it does not from my view imply an opinion that Canon cameras are "substandard or insufficient or poorly designed."

So, my point, is that making the technical analysis and demonstrating that, does not constitute "substandard or insufficient or poorly designed."

Mar 24, 2015 at 09:54 AM
zlatko
Offline
Details
p.9 #5Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
artd wrote:
His use of the phrase "boring 11-stop DR" while perhaps not the most diplomatic choice of words, simply conveys that the dynamic range is the same as its been for the last seven years (and regardless of what one's opinion is on the overall excellence of Canon cameras there is no context in which I find 11 stops of dynamic range to be an exciting development in modern sensor technology.)


11 stops of DR may not be an "exciting development" and it isn't the cutting edge, but it is excellent enough for a vast quantity of artistic, journalistic and commercial work that has been done with it. It has met and continues to meet the needs and standards of some of the world's most renowned photographers for diverse and demanding work, even when they could easily have chosen to work with Sony / Nikon.
Mar 24, 2015 at 10:04 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.9 #6Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
gdanmitchell wrote:
We get it. We understand that Sony makes really nice sensors. Asked and answered. Can we please move on?

Dan


What would it mean, practically, to move on in this case? We have a new camera, and this thread is about new data for that camera. I am all in for progress in the discussion, but I think we should accept that people who have been hoping for increased DR can now express their opinion about the 5Ds in that respect.
Mar 24, 2015 at 10:08 AM
ggreene
Offline
Details
p.9 #7Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
mttran wrote:
This forum is not belong to number of canon hardcore posters like some of you. What about last decade 11stops DR owners now want to upgrade to better DR cams that are available from most MFG out there. Have you guys ever thought about this or just concentrate on your own shell and don't care the others


It has very little to do with caring and everything to do with business.

The problem is those other manufacturers with higher DR sensors aren't out selling Canon. From their viewpoint that one metric is not making a difference. Canon will invest in infrastructure when they are ready. Right now there just doesn't seem to be enough pressure on them to do it.
Mar 24, 2015 at 10:08 AM
panicatnabisco
Offline
Details
p.9 #8Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Access wrote:
dhphoto wroteSome users should just accept we are happy with what we have.
And some people also need to accept that Canon just isn't right for everyone.


Reminds me of a vegan joke;
How do you know someone shoots Sony? Don't worry, they'll tell you
Mar 24, 2015 at 10:37 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.9 #9Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
gdanmitchell wrote:
..... and the incessant apparent compulsion to turn every discussion of any new piece of Canon equipment into (yet another!) opportunity to "prove" that Canon cameras a substandard or insufficient or poorly designed. (Take a look at the record — the forum is full of such threads.)


If this forum is full of those threads as you say, maybe there is a fact-based reason for it.....

We get it. We understand that Sony makes really nice sensors. Asked and answered. Can we please move on?

Dan


Your renewed attempt to shut down any kind of discussion which reveals potential (since we don't know it fully yet!) drawbacks of Canon's new sensor does not work. Sorry.
Mar 24, 2015 at 11:08 AM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.9 #10Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
retrofocus wrote:
Your renewed attempt to shut down any kind of discussion which reveals potential (since we don't know it fully yet!) drawbacks of Canon's new sensor does not work. Sorry.


You mean discussions that say the sensor has very similar DR performance to other canon FF sensors? Is anyone learning anything new here? Canon certainly never said the DR was higher in this sensor. This topic is really not a discussion, it is a simple fact.

Now, if this was a topic on the overall image quality and comparisons to other camera systems, that would be an actual discussion.

As it is, these DR 'discussions' just turn to the same tired argument with both sides digging in. You either buy a camera with higher DR or you don't.
Mar 24, 2015 at 11:19 AM
Access
Offline
Details
p.9 #11Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
retrofocus wrote:
If this forum is full of those threads as you say, maybe there is a fact-based reason for it.....

Or could it be that this forum is so far removed from reality that the only appropriate place for the discussion would be here.

Maybe my world is kinda limited, but I have never been to a camera club (more than a hundred active members of all skill levels) or met a photographer irl who wanted to talk at such extended length about DR or Canon's "deficiencies" in general. And I've met plenty of chatty photographers, especially after a few drinks when inhibitions are lowered everything anyone wants to chat about comes out. Where else can you hear words or phrases like "Canon's Achilles Heel" or "Yet another... boring... Canon sensor..." thrown around so casually? In a way, like it or hate it, this forum has a charm all of its own.

The fact-based reason you refer to may be rather mundane -- after having been given too many blank stares or being ignored too many times in a group social environment, they all piled in here since this is the only place the could have a voice and be welcomed among like company.
Mar 24, 2015 at 11:36 AM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.9 #12Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
mttran wrote:
This forum is not belong to number of canon hardcore posters like some of you. What about last decade 11stops DR owners now want to upgrade to better DR cams that are available from most MFG out there. Have you guys ever thought about this or just concentrate on your own shell and don't care the others

Talking about multiplication does not apply on the zero...the same arguments since low iso banding years.


If you want more DR in your sensors, I suggest you check out sony or Nikon. They have some great options that might suit your needs.
Mar 24, 2015 at 11:39 AM
StillFingerz
Offline
Details
p.9 #13Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Tony Rogers wrote:
StillFingerz wrote
Monito wrote
Beni wroteIn the studio I often use the Nikon MC-30A release in my teeth for when I have my hands full, it's such a big button that it's far easier in general to use than any other release from my canon or sony cameras. In the mouth I press the button with my tounge. Bit yeuch perhaps to some but when you're shooting product or repro and have both hands full, it's very very useful.
A switch is a switch. Adapt it to a foot switch.
Monito, Beni wrote that reply to me, a disabled photographer that just happens to have a paralyzed body with paralysis starting at the neck, so a foot switch would not be doable in my case. Cheers
I thought that the foot switch comment was sensible in context - if you have both hands full, then a foot switch might be more convenient than using the MC-30A in your mouth. That's assuming you have the use of two hands and one foot.

I don't know if the MC-30A would be suited to your needs. If it were mounted to something, I expect it would be easier to use - I think it would be awkward if it weren't.



Tony, without working fingers to tap the shutter button and wanting to still hold/focus a camera/lens, what I do is place some thick tape; for gripping purposes, on the sides of Canon's RS-80N3 so that my teeth can hold the remote; from left to right. This puts the shutter button directly in front of my tongue, allowing a half or full click of the shutter.and both of my hands free to hold body and focus/zoom.

Fastening a remote somewhere on my wheelchair would require either my hand being moved from the camera or using perhaps an elbow, and that would not allow for hand-holding. Attaching anything to my chair really restricts most freedom of movement and would require using Liveview only and I'm partial to viewfinders, prefer them; optical or electronic.

I started shooting back in the late 60's before my disability and even though it isn't easy hand-holding, the freedom to do so helps me get better compositions. I'm restricted due to my wheelchair, but can move/twist my upper body just enough to vary composition and use light/shadows when possible.

As for the remote Beni recommended, it might be easier to manage given it's smaller and the button is larger/higher. The major difference is the remote would be positioned differently, so I've ordered a 3rd party knock-off to test, giving me the option of Nikon gear. An able-bodied friend on mine; we've shot together over four decades, is a Nikon user; D7000. His remote switch is larger and wasn't usable, I did not followup/look for a different style, but now we'll see

That said, other than the current D610/810 peeking my interest, it's the Sony a7's that are my focus and primarily for usage of my EF/EF-S and much older FD/FL lenses. But I'm in no hurry to move from or augment my Canon gears, they suit me well, don't restrict much if any, ergonomically or image wise

Cheers,
Jerry
Mar 24, 2015 at 11:51 AM
artd
Offline
Details
p.9 #14Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
zlatko wrote:
artd wroteHis use of the phrase "boring 11-stop DR" while perhaps not the most diplomatic choice of words, simply conveys that the dynamic range is the same as its been for the last seven years (and regardless of what one's opinion is on the overall excellence of Canon cameras there is no context in which I find 11 stops of dynamic range to be an exciting development in modern sensor technology.)
11 stops of DR may not be an "exciting development" and it isn't the cutting edge, but it is excellent enough for a vast quantity of artistic, journalistic and commercial work that has been done with it. It has met and continues to meet the needs and standards of some of the world's most renowned photographers for diverse and demanding work, even when they could easily have chosen to work with Sony / Nikon.


It's really just semantics, but I would define "excellent" as "exceeding" or "excelling" past the average. By that criteria, I would not put Canon's DR in the range of "excellent," but instead "average."

As you correctly have observed, though, that "average" DR capability (again, simply my semantical definition) is sufficient for a vast quantity of work. No one is disputing that.

And DR is not by any means the most important choice when selecting a camera system to use. This is why I have continued to use Canon for much of my work.
Mar 24, 2015 at 01:37 PM
Gary Irwin
Offline
Details
p.9 #15Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Too bad really...Canon would have done their customers a bigger favour by licensing Sony's 36MP sensor rather than develop their own 50MP sensor using their old fab. Oh well.
Mar 24, 2015 at 04:04 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.9 #16Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Late to the party ...

Honest

While folks rage on about how much greater DR benefits them ... is there an application where the lesser DR is beneficial, or at least a trade-off is incurred in some regard, and how might that be?

It reminds me (not necessarily a good example) of how much I was a total fan-boy of FujiChrome and found Ektachrome to be ... BORING. Yet, some folks had a very strong preference toward Ekatchrome and wouldn't touch Fujichrome.

My point is this ... is Canon's decision to remain @ current and longstanding DR based on some rationale that some folks aren't aware of. It strikes me as very hard to believe that Canon hasn't changed their DR because they can't, but rather they consistently choose not to for some rationale of other preference that isn't being given credence to ... i.e. maybe something in regard to the publishing industry, etc.

Personally, I find the argument rather tiring ... going back to when Fuji was the stand alone leader in DR, you didn't have all the noise about Fuji's superior DR over everyone. So, why is that now SoNikon's DR is the holy grail, but it wasn't when Fuji was the king of DR?
Mar 24, 2015 at 04:09 PM
whumber
Offline
Details
p.9 #17Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
RustyBug wrote:
My point is this ... is Canon's decision to remain @ current and longstanding DR based on some rationale that some folks aren't aware of. It strikes me as very hard to believe that Canon hasn't changed their DR because they can't, but rather they consistently choose not to for some rationale of other preference that isn't being given credence to ... i.e. maybe something in regard to the publishing industry, etc


New semi-conductor fabrication facilities are astronomically expensive and Canon's production volume is dropping off a cliff with the death of P&S cameras and their lack of any cell phone cameras.

Mar 24, 2015 at 04:17 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.9 #18Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
whumber wrote:
New semi-conductor fabrication facilities are astronomically expensive and Canon's production volume is dropping off a cliff with the death of P&S cameras and their lack of any cell phone cameras.


Inferring they are standing pat, until they develop their next gen "organic" or "Foveon-like" non-Bayer array sensor @ paradigm shift / quantum leap, rather than incur the expense for a half-step (not to be confused with half-stop) incremental improvement.
Mar 24, 2015 at 04:22 PM
AJSJones
Offline
Details
p.9 #19Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
RustyBug wrote:
.. is Canon's decision to remain @ current and longstanding DR based on some rationale that some folks aren't aware of. It strikes me as very hard to believe that Canon hasn't changed their DR because they can't, but rather they consistently choose not to for some rationale..


Something about patents.

It seems that the improved DR of the Exmor sensor was achieved by implementing technology that was patented so Canon can't use that method: it appears to be a patent on the simple concept of putting the ADC on the chip in some specified configuration - Canon's image information therefore has to travel in analog mode off the chip to the ADC and picks up the noise along the way. (Probably way more complex ways of describing it, but that's as far as I've got)
Mar 24, 2015 at 04:27 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.9 #20Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Patents hmmm ... that would be more of a "not allowed" vs. a "can't" ... although it still yields a "not happening" where the rubber meets the street.

That makes way more sense (to me) than all the cyber-bashing of how Canon isn't capable. Just was kinda hard for me to fathom "not capable" ... which imo, is a different thing from "not allowed". Having working around pharmaceutical delivery patents, I get how safeguarding / binding they can be.

Now Canon just has to figure out something diff that isn't bound by patents ... which might be even trickier depending on how the patent is structured.

Takeaway ... if they are "patent bound", then it is silly to hope for much change in DR until their R&D delivers a game changer. No reason to hope for the 6D II or other to deliver significant (incremental, maybe) DR until they have a breakthrough (which will go on flagship models @ flagship prices first) ... thus the consistency we've been seeing as the OP notes.

Thanks.

Edited on Mar 24, 2015 at 04:58 PM · View previous versions
Mar 24, 2015 at 04:42 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister