p.2 #1So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
EB-1 wrote:
So the NR makes jpegs with little noise? Do they look mushy?
EBH
Well they don't show us the prints, but they explicitly state "And when we say a "solid print" we mean one with good sharpness, contrast, detail, color and very little visible high-ISO noise. In other words, a print that we'd be proud to show to a friend or colleague"
This might be more a test of jpg engines, but still if the Nikon can return a print made at 1 stop higher ISO then a lot of people will still see that as a great effort from Nikon and opposite to want any rational person would expect. I would have expected 1D X to still do better even in this test.
Ok their test is flawed and subjective, but viewing prints is always subjective. So what if we alter the test and shoot RAW and created the best possible image we can, irrespective of settings and plugins needed to achieve this, but still require prints are sharp, detailed, have good contrast and show low noise. Will 1D X now do much better? I know I can shoot ISO 3200 and often not need to do any NR outside of my standard fairly low amount in LR with the 1D X and that's looking at 100% view, let alone 8x10" print.
p.2 #2So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
shutterbug guy wrote: EB-1 wroteshutterbug guy wroteWhat is DxOmark?Imagemaster wroteGoogle it. shutterbug guy wroteNah, it'd just be a waste of time. Why, has your government taken Google and DXOMark off the web?
EBHI lost faith in DxO when they put out that certain full frame DSLR's surpassed the medium format cameras in image quality. They are scoring image quality a whole lot different than the way I see it.
Anything that I read put out by DxO is a waste of time imho.
Their raw sensor data is not a waste of time. Not perfect, but by far the best info out there of any site for sensors (not talking the overall scores, just the various print screen sensor data plots).
p.2 #6So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
Pixel Perfect wrote:
Ok, we all know the Sony 36MP sensor is the ducks guts for DR at low ISO and as ISO rises does a good job and is sort of even with the 5D III if you resample down to 5D III res, up to around ISO 6400.
This is simply wrong. The Sony Exmor sensor delivers a much better DR than the Canon 5D MkIII can do no matter what. Both sensors are far apart from "even".
p.2 #7So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
skibum5 wrote: shutterbug guy wroteEB-1 wroteshutterbug guy wroteWhat is DxOmark?Imagemaster wroteGoogle it. shutterbug guy wroteNah, it'd just be a waste of time. Why, has your government taken Google and DXOMark off the web?
EBHI lost faith in DxO when they put out that certain full frame DSLR's surpassed the medium format cameras in image quality. They are scoring image quality a whole lot different than the way I see it.
Anything that I read put out by DxO is a waste of time imho.Their raw sensor data is not a waste of time. Not perfect, but by far the best info out there of any site for sensors (not talking the overall scores, just the various print screen sensor data plots).
Good for you and the test results.
When they started lobbing air balls with their final scores and conclusions I quit drinking their Kool-Aid.
p.2 #8So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
dpreview has a tool that lets you compare directly yourself; unfortunately it only seems to have the 5D3 and 6D, but it might be helpful nonetheless.
What I see is that at ISO 6400 RAW there isn't that much difference in bright areas, but in the shadows the two Canons preserve more detail, and have less shadow noise, than the D800:
(BTW, in my opinion shadow detail is a more important measure of high ISO performance than amount of visible noise--one because you can apply noise reduction in post, but also because the amount of noise appears to be manipulated by the RAW converters.)
p.2 #9So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
I have both A7r and 1Dx shooting landscape on tripod / live view for several months, now I just give up using A7r when doing landscape, when I PP both files in LR I can see the truth, I can never squeeze out 1-2 more stops or more color depth from this 36mp sensor like the DXO data did. The 18mp sensor can even pull out more and better in actual photo and PP.
Regarding the high iso noise, the A7r I can accept up to iso3200 while the 1Dx iso12800 is still ok for me.
The only aspect that the 36mp sensor better than the 18mp sensor I found is the image size, really have ~30% bigger photo in actual.
I believe the DXO data can never lie but the way of the test is absolutely not perfect.
p.2 #10So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
kezeka wrote:
*facepalm*
Why do we even talk about this anymore
+1
This is soooo old. Why is it that no one seems to recognize that the sensor is only one part (albeit an important one) of an entire ecology of sensors, processors, lenses, peripherals, PP tools, etc., etc.? Purporting to measure just the sensor is like noting that the Chevy 451 CI has more horsepower than say the VW 1.8T. And your point is …
p.2 #11So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
OntheRez wrote: kezeka wrote*facepalm*
Why do we even talk about this anymore +1
This is soooo old. Why is it that no one seems to recognize that the sensor is only one part (albeit an important one) of an entire ecology of sensors, processors, lenses, peripherals, PP tools, etc., etc.? Purporting to measure just the sensor is like noting that the Chevy 451 CI has more horsepower than say the VW 1.8T. And your point is …
Robert
It is so old because Canon still lacks a high MP/high DR camera. The sensor is the heart of any digital camera. The rest is periphery - given that AF for some is more important than excellent sensor performance. Problem for Canon is that higher MP sensors with better DR have already been implemented as new standard. And that's why many switch or add other camera types.
p.2 #12So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
markshelby wrote:
dpreview has a tool that lets you compare directly yourself; unfortunately it only seems to have the 5D3 and 6D, but it might be helpful nonetheless.
Imaging Resources also has their own links for downloading higher ISO images:
I downloaded some files to compare, but have only looked at them on my 13" laptop so far. So no real conclusions.
Both of the higher ISO images lack large areas of black/dark detail, so I think they are a bit misleading. Looking in the lower right corner of the studio image with the red hair starts to show what low key, high ISO images will look like ...
p.2 #13So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
retrofocus wrote: Pixel Perfect wroteOk, we all know the Sony 36MP sensor is the ducks guts for DR at low ISO and as ISO rises does a good job and is sort of even with the 5D III if you resample down to 5D III res, up to around ISO 6400.This is simply wrong. The Sony Exmor sensor delivers a much better DR than the Canon 5D MkIII can do no matter what. Both sensors are far apart from "even".
You are simply arguing with a guy who says that the 36mp sensor has unmatchable DR (in 35mm) at low ISO which is, has not and until something better comes along, will never be in debate. The fact is however that advantage is simply gone by ISO 1600. Of course you could bring back shadow and highlight detail to compensate without the characteristic Canon banding
p.2 #14So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
Bones74 wrote: retrofocus wrotePixel Perfect wroteOk, we all know the Sony 36MP sensor is the ducks guts for DR at low ISO and as ISO rises does a good job and is sort of even with the 5D III if you resample down to 5D III res, up to around ISO 6400.This is simply wrong. The Sony Exmor sensor delivers a much better DR than the Canon 5D MkIII can do no matter what. Both sensors are far apart from "even".You are simply arguing with a guy who says that the 36mp sensor has unmatchable DR (in 35mm) at low ISO which is, has not and until something better comes along, will never be in debate. The fact is however that advantage is simply gone by ISO 1600. Of course you could bring back shadow and highlight detail to compensate without the characteristic Canon banding
Okay - I admit that I compared them at low ISO only because I rarely shoot above ISO 1600 (in fact I avoid ISO above 800 wherever I can). Sunrises and sunsets for example I also normally shoot ISO 200 and lower. There I clearly see a huge benefit of the Exmor sensor compared to the Canon sensor as you also said. Fortunately I didn't run too often in the Canon banding issue even it happened to me in the past a few times. Those few situations happened at very contrasty indoor shooting.
p.2 #15So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
retrofocus wrote: Bones74 wroteretrofocus wrotePixel Perfect wroteOk, we all know the Sony 36MP sensor is the ducks guts for DR at low ISO and as ISO rises does a good job and is sort of even with the 5D III if you resample down to 5D III res, up to around ISO 6400.This is simply wrong. The Sony Exmor sensor delivers a much better DR than the Canon 5D MkIII can do no matter what. Both sensors are far apart from "even".You are simply arguing with a guy who says that the 36mp sensor has unmatchable DR (in 35mm) at low ISO which is, has not and until something better comes along, will never be in debate. The fact is however that advantage is simply gone by ISO 1600. Of course you could bring back shadow and highlight detail to compensate without the characteristic Canon banding Okay - I admit that I compared them at low ISO only because I rarely shoot above ISO 1600 (in fact I avoid ISO above 800 wherever I can). Sunrises and sunsets for example I also normally shoot ISO 200 and lower. There I clearly see a huge benefit of the Exmor sensor compared to the Canon sensor as you also said. Fortunately I didn't run too often in the Canon banding issue even it happened to me in the past a few times. Those few situations happened at very contrasty indoor shooting.
I have run into it... hard As a 5D3 owner I am under no illusion the sensor is even close, especially to the D810 now. It's decent and can produce excellent results if the photog does his job right, but a new and up to date sensor is definitely something users should be expecting Canon to deliver sooner than later.
p.2 #16So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
I had one opportunity to see my 1DX go up against the D800 in a side by side for high ISO. When downsampled the D800 had good IQ but not at the level of the 1DX. DXO has the D800 as a better low light sports sensor then the 1DX but not only does it not bear out in my one experience looking at output it doesn't even match up with DXO's own graphs underneath the overall score. Weird rating.
DXO's low light sports rating for the D4s is only slightly more then the D800 so I'm thinking the 1DX sensor at high ISO is aging remarkably well.
p.2 #17So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
OntheRez wrote: kezeka wrote*facepalm*
Why do we even talk about this anymore +1
This is soooo old. Why is it that no one seems to recognize that the sensor is only one part (albeit an important one) of an entire ecology of sensors, processors, lenses, peripherals, PP tools, etc., etc.? Purporting to measure just the sensor is like noting that the Chevy 451 CI has more horsepower than say the VW 1.8T. And your point is …
Robert
And if you are racing cars, failing to measure the engine power would be a pretty important point no? Who cares if it has the best handling around the track, if it is so underpowered on the straights that it gets utterly blown away and loses, despite doing better on the curves, 2 seconds a lap?
p.2 #18So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
retrofocus wrote: Pixel Perfect wroteOk, we all know the Sony 36MP sensor is the ducks guts for DR at low ISO and as ISO rises does a good job and is sort of even with the 5D III if you resample down to 5D III res, up to around ISO 6400.This is simply wrong. The Sony Exmor sensor delivers a much better DR than the Canon 5D MkIII can do no matter what. Both sensors are far apart from "even".
No, as PP said, it is at low and mid ISO where it delivers much better and better DR, at high ISO it's DR is no better than the 5D3 (and the DR might even be a touch worse at very high ISO).
p.2 #19So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
ignore the DxO Mark scores and concentrate on comparing the charts of the measurement data. That will give a better indication across the entire ISO range, both at full resolution and at an equal dumbed down size. From there you will see that the 1D X is better at high ISO, just as the D3s is (and I have seen the benefits with the D3s).
The charts are offset diagonally from each other: There is a vertical separation (DR) at each ISO and there is a horizontal separation (ISO) at each DR. One may be less than a stop different while the other may be more than a stop different, which helps explain why some people see more than a stop of difference and some do not.
Personally, I like the idea of a 1DX even though I have a D800E because sometimes I am shooting hand-held in failing light and I need all the DR that I can get at high ISO. At low ISO it's largely a matter of how big I want to print (pixel count) and which lens I want to use (Canon or Nikon). I have great lenses in both brands.
While you compare the charts you might throw in the 1D4 for comparison - it's certainly not as good as the others.
DxO rates sensors for various applications using a single value that simply does not apply at all ISOs. When it comes to sports, for example, it uses the highest ISO that is capable of producing a specific number of unique colours in an image. The colour count may or may not relate directly to the dynamic range, depending on whether colour noise is chunkier than luminance noise. It is the colour count that let the 1D4 down in DxO Mark tests and yet it was Canon's pro sports camera. It isn't useless at sports but it doesn't meet that particular measurement definition as well as the D800 does. By studying the measurement charts we can gain a better idea of what is going on with different sensors.
I can understand that you effectively resample image files if you want to make small prints but if you want to print as big as the image file will allow then resampling is out. Also, in my opinion it is a pain in the butt to resample all images in a system that is based on Lightroom or DPP because that means creating extra files that have to be edited separately from the originals once they have been created. It defeats the advantage of non-destructive editing offered by those programs. Most of my images will never be printed and so I don't want to dumb them all down to reduce noise that should not be there.
p.2 #20So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
Pixel Perfect wrote:
Ok, we all know the Sony 36MP sensor is the ducks guts for DR at low ISO and as ISO rises does a good job and is sort of even with the 5D III if you resample down to 5D III res, up to around ISO 6400. But Beyond that ... well you tell me. Now I see this test at imaging resource where they make 8x10 prints at the highest possible ISO that looks clean and detailed and the results are interesting to say the least. I've downloaded high ISO RAWs from the D800 and IMO they can't touch the 1D X even downsampled. So what have other people found? I notice DxOmark rates D800 as better at high ISO than 1D X too, even if it's so close as to not be noticed in real world. Yet this new tes t=rates the D800 a full stop better than 1D X!
Next test will be 1dx against d810 but for now you can take a look at 25600iso from my 6D and D810
here
AWB in 2800K light 6D and d810 http://www.dpreview.com/forums/post/54215693