fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2014 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2014So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO

  
 
macrobild
Offline
Details
p.3 #1So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
I compared 6D at 100 iso with d810 at 400iso and what can be seen in the lower levels. Latest Camera raw and selected profile Adobe standard and then equally lifted in shadows with Camera Raw.
http://www.dpreview.com/forums/post/54221363

I will later see how the D810 fares against 1DX and 25600iso , at base iso their is no discussion which camera who has has the best DR, d810

What I can see is that D810 is cleaner than my D800 at higher iso, low levels at higher iso are not twisting against red noise as it does in D800.
Aug 17, 2014 at 02:57 PM
johnctharp
Offline
Details
p.3 #2So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
macrobild wrote:
I compared 6D at 100 iso with d810 at 400iso and what can be seen in the lower levels. Latest Camera raw and selected profile Adobe standard and then equally lifted in shadows with Camera Raw.
http://www.dpreview.com/forums/post/54221363


Trying to make sense of what you are actually comparing using what you've written above along with what you've written in your DPR post has gotten me confused. Would you mind listing out the settings used and processing steps taken for each?

Also, didn't you have an FM account under the same name that you're posting under at DPR? Why make this new one?

And last, are you trying to show us something new, or just reiterating the point that Sony's full-frame Exmors have better shadow recovery at lower ISOs than Canon's current FF sensors?
Aug 17, 2014 at 03:09 PM
macrobild
Offline
Details
p.3 #3So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
new and new, the new is that d810 is even cleaner than d800 in the shadows, and much better than the Canon 6D sensor (who has less Canon banding of them all ) and even with 2 stop of less light falling in to the sensor the d810 are still better than the 6D regarding shadow noise and resolution in low levels , that may be news to some
Aug 17, 2014 at 04:22 PM
shutterbug guy
Offline
Details
p.3 #4So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
macrobild wrote:
new and new, the new is that d810 is even cleaner than d800 in the shadows, and much better than the Canon 6D sensor (who has less Canon banding of them all ) and even with 2 stop of less light falling in to the sensor the d810 are still better than the 6D regarding shadow noise and resolution in low levels , that may be news to some


Yeah, I bet that d810 must be awesome for extracting black cats in the bushes at night. Pretty handy I imagine.
Aug 17, 2014 at 05:16 PM
johnctharp
Offline
Details
p.3 #5So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
macrobild wrote:
new and new, the new is that d810 is even cleaner than d800 in the shadows, and much better than the Canon 6D sensor (who has less Canon banding of them all ) and even with 2 stop of less light falling in to the sensor the d810 are still better than the 6D regarding shadow noise and resolution in low levels , that may be news to some


The 'news' is three years old, except in the case of the D810, where it is slightly better than the cameras it replaces. Would you mind responding to my other two points please?
Aug 17, 2014 at 05:38 PM
jcolwell
Offline
Details
p.3 #6So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
macrobild wrote:
new and new, the new is that d810 is even cleaner than d800 in the shadows, and much better than the Canon 6D sensor (who has less Canon banding of them all ) and even with 2 stop of less light falling in to the sensor the d810 are still better than the 6D regarding shadow noise and resolution in low levels , that may be news to some


My 6D is so bad that I bought a second one to make it feel better.

P.S. I don't need to buy a second 1DX, because my 1DIV sucks so bad that it makes the 1DX look good.

Aug 17, 2014 at 05:47 PM
scalesusa
Offline
Details
p.3 #7So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
I bought a D800 when they first came out after all the hype. I used it side by side with my 1D MK IV at a theatrical event. I used both at ISO's up to 12,800. The D800 needed a huge amount of NR and even then, faces were blotchy from noise. The 1D MK IV looked better. Then, when I received my 5D MK III, again at 12800, and even 25600, it was making the D800 look poor.

At those high ISO levels, DR is critical. A light or spotlight can blow out a photo so easily. The 1/2 stop DR advantage of the Canon sensors made a big difference.

At Low ISO settings below 800, the D800 was wonderful, and captured some images with a huge dynamic range. However, my main use was at high ISO, and applying a huge amount of NR to a huge D800 file could take a minute or more to complete. PP'ing 1500 images at 2-5 minutes each for simple corrections was just too much, so the D800 went away. Then, I came down with carpal tunnel in both hands, and had surgery on both, so the 1D MK IV went away in favor of the lighter 5D MK III.

I'm looking forward to seeing if Canon actually comes up with layered sensor technology and back side illumination. This has the potential to improve colors, and reduce noise. Its unlikely to boost high ISO performance by much if any, but improved colors and more accurate autofocus would be a huge advance.
Aug 17, 2014 at 10:47 PM
macrobild
Offline
Details
p.3 #8So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
And you where looking at the same file size as Canons and higher iso?. Sorry no way the 1dmk4 looks better at high iso than d800, because it is a physical impossibility and you are looking at that case at noise reduction and not resolution and details. You are spreading myths like many others about d800-810 high iso reproduction and that is a reason why Im doing this little comparison which clearly shows the results from 25600ISO and between two of my cameras Canon 6D and Nikon d810

Aug 18, 2014 at 01:45 AM
macrobild
Offline
Details
p.3 #9So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
jcolwell wrote:
macrobild wrotenew and new, the new is that d810 is even cleaner than d800 in the shadows, and much better than the Canon 6D sensor (who has less Canon banding of them all ) and even with 2 stop of less light falling in to the sensor the d810 are still better than the 6D regarding shadow noise and resolution in low levels , that may be news to some
My 6D is so bad that I bought a second one to make it feel better.

P.S. I don't need to buy a second 1DX, because my 1DIV sucks so bad that it makes the 1DX look good.



no Canon cameras from Canon are bad, but there are better cameras IQ wise today due to modern sensor tech/ read out.


Aug 18, 2014 at 02:52 AM
macrobild
Offline
Details
p.3 #10So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
shutterbug guy wrote:
macrobild wrotenew and new, the new is that d810 is even cleaner than d800 in the shadows, and much better than the Canon 6D sensor (who has less Canon banding of them all ) and even with 2 stop of less light falling in to the sensor the d810 are still better than the 6D regarding shadow noise and resolution in low levels , that may be news to some
Yeah, I bet that d810 must be awesome for extracting black cats in the bushes at night. Pretty handy I imagine.


mybe in the future also canon has the ability to to reproduce black cats in a black room. conditions like that or higher resolution are not making the camera worse- or does it?
Aug 18, 2014 at 02:58 AM
Tony B
Offline
Details
p.3 #11So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
Believe it or not my Nikon dealer told me that of clients trying out the D800 series
a significant percentage were returning them due to file size & the problems inherent therein. So all is not brightness & light for some.
Aug 18, 2014 at 03:28 AM
shutterbug guy
Offline
Details
p.3 #12So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
macrobild wrote:
shutterbug guy wrote
macrobild wrotenew and new, the new is that d810 is even cleaner than d800 in the shadows, and much better than the Canon 6D sensor (who has less Canon banding of them all ) and even with 2 stop of less light falling in to the sensor the d810 are still better than the 6D regarding shadow noise and resolution in low levels , that may be news to some
Yeah, I bet that d810 must be awesome for extracting black cats in the bushes at night. Pretty handy I imagine.
mybe in the future also canon has the ability to to reproduce black cats in a black room. conditions like that or higher resolution are not making the camera worse- or does it?


If you're needing to photograph the shadows and extract black cats from those shadows my hat's off to you. Personally I don't require that.

Resolution is good however my 5d's are plugging away just fine the way they are. I don't feel that a lack of resolution is holding me back at this point.


Aug 18, 2014 at 07:32 AM
ggreene
Offline
Details
p.3 #13So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
macrobild wrote:
And you where looking at the same file size as Canons and higher iso?. Sorry no way the 1dmk4 looks better at high iso than d800, because it is a physical impossibility and you are looking at that case at noise reduction and not resolution and details. You are spreading myths like many others about d800-810 high iso reproduction and that is a reason why Im doing this little comparison which clearly shows the results from 25600ISO and between two of my cameras Canon 6D and Nikon d810


Don't know about the D810 but the D800 was not as good as my 1DX even when downsized at high ISO (6400+). A fellow sports shooter and I shot some indoor basketball in a low light gym and I thought my RAW and JPEG's looked cleaner. We synced settings and shot from the same sideline position.

Is the D810 that much better then the D800? From reading the Nikon forum many people liked the high ISO of the D800 over the D810 in one thread.
Aug 18, 2014 at 07:58 AM
snapsy
Offline
Details
p.3 #14So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
ggreene wrote:
macrobild wroteAnd you where looking at the same file size as Canons and higher iso?. Sorry no way the 1dmk4 looks better at high iso than d800, because it is a physical impossibility and you are looking at that case at noise reduction and not resolution and details. You are spreading myths like many others about d800-810 high iso reproduction and that is a reason why Im doing this little comparison which clearly shows the results from 25600ISO and between two of my cameras Canon 6D and Nikon d810
Don't know about the D810 but the D800 was not as good as my 1DX even when downsized at high ISO (6400+). A fellow sports shooter and I shot some indoor basketball in a low light gym and I thought my RAW and JPEG's looked cleaner. We synced settings and shot from the same sideline position.

Is the D810 that much better then the D800? From reading the Nikon forum many people liked the high ISO of the D800 over the D810 in one thread.


Here's a comparison I did a while back - the D3s in the comparison can serve as a proxy for the 1DX: Link
Aug 18, 2014 at 08:31 AM
macrobild
Offline
Details
p.3 #15So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
ggreene wrote:
macrobild wroteAnd you where looking at the same file size as Canons and higher iso?. Sorry no way the 1dmk4 looks better at high iso than d800, because it is a physical impossibility and you are looking at that case at noise reduction and not resolution and details. You are spreading myths like many others about d800-810 high iso reproduction and that is a reason why Im doing this little comparison which clearly shows the results from 25600ISO and between two of my cameras Canon 6D and Nikon d810
Don't know about the D810 but the D800 was not as good as my 1DX even when downsized at high ISO (6400+). A fellow sports shooter and I shot some indoor basketball in a low light gym and I thought my RAW and JPEG's looked cleaner. We synced settings and shot from the same sideline position.

Is the D810 that much better then the D800? From reading the Nikon forum many people liked the high ISO of the D800 over the D810 in one thread.


the raw d810 is cleaner due they have got rid of the visual read noise in lower levels which can be seen in d800 and high iso, Im talking about 25600iso
None of Nikons cameras has a thin CFA as Canon which are better suited for 2800K light, Nikons CFA is steeper and optimized for day light,therefore the higher color depth scores in DXO tests, the D810 results against 6D in a 2800K light and 25600iso is therefore incredible good .
Aug 18, 2014 at 08:47 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.3 #16So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
Tony B wrote:
Believe it or not my Nikon dealer told me that of clients trying out the D800 series
a significant percentage were returning them due to file size & the problems inherent therein. So all is not brightness & light for some.


That seems very strange to me. It costs less to save a 36MP image file today than it cost to save a 8MP file back when those were the state of the art, and modern computers process the larger files (in more sophisticated and useful ways) at the same or faster speed today.

Dan
Aug 18, 2014 at 11:18 AM
macrobild
Offline
Details
p.3 #17So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
So right you are. See you in 5 years from now when we maybe are discussing resolution that exceeds the resolution of a common lens (that include off course not my Otus)
Aug 18, 2014 at 03:37 PM
johnctharp
Offline
Details
p.3 #18So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
macrobild wrote:
So right you are. See you in 5 years from now when we maybe are discussing resolution that exceeds the resolution of a common lens (that include off course not my Otus)


Will you make another account then to argue about old news?
Aug 18, 2014 at 04:19 PM
whumber
Offline
Details
p.3 #19So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
markshelby wrote:
dpreview has a tool that lets you compare directly yourself; unfortunately it only seems to have the 5D3 and 6D, but it might be helpful nonetheless.

What I see is that at ISO 6400 RAW there isn't that much difference in bright areas, but in the shadows the two Canons preserve more detail, and have less shadow noise, than the D800:

http://www.dpreview.com/reviews/canon-eos-5d-mark-iii/28

(BTW, in my opinion shadow detail is a more important measure of high ISO performance than amount of visible noise--one because you can apply noise reduction in post, but also because the amount of noise appears to be manipulated by the
...Show more →

I'm not sure what they were seeing but I made 8.5x11 prints of the 1DX, 5D3, and D800E jpgs at 25.6K and the D800E is clearly worse than either of the Canon cameras, especially noticeable in the shadows behind the paintbrush in the lower right portion of the image.
Aug 18, 2014 at 04:43 PM
whumber
Offline
Details
p.3 #20So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
Here's the area where it's super noticeable, I downsampled the D800E image to match the 1DX's resolution.

http://imgur.com/zzO3sLWh.jpg
Aug 18, 2014 at 04:59 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister