p.1 #1So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
Ok, we all know the Sony 36MP sensor is the ducks guts for DR at low ISO and as ISO rises does a good job and is sort of even with the 5D III if you resample down to 5D III res, up to around ISO 6400. But Beyond that ... well you tell me. Now I see this test at imaging resource where they make 8x10 prints at the highest possible ISO that looks clean and detailed and the results are interesting to say the least. I've downloaded high ISO RAWs from the D800 and IMO they can't touch the 1D X even downsampled. So what have other people found? I notice DxOmark rates D800 as better at high ISO than 1D X too, even if it's so close as to not be noticed in real world. Yet this new tes t=rates the D800 a full stop better than 1D X!
p.1 #8So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
It really is a bit bogus! First this:
tests are conducted using straight-from-camera JPEGS at default noise reduction settings,
Because making the best files from RAW would be too subjective? Or even setting all of the NR parameters to "Medium"?
But then they don't even show a single print. They admit that part is completely subjective, the judging of prints. But they need to at least share a few samples so that we can tell what they are looking at!
Sometimes it comes down to a self fulfilling prophecy. I have seen many people say, for example, that they really like the noise from XXX camera, finding it very "film like." While I find it obnoxious & distracting & course.
Plus no handy link to samples, just the usual samples from their reviews that you have to go download & compare yourself.
When Michael Reichman compared high ISO files from the Sony 7R to the 7S, he claimed a 3 stop advantage to the 7S!! Many other people looking at his sample images saw less than 1 stop. Which is also what DxO said, etc,.
It could have been a good effort. After all of that work, even if they showed us samples of the output it would have put it all in context. Oh well ... One more limited data point.
p.1 #14So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
Sounds fishy.
Also: "Our print quality tests are conducted using straight-from-camera JPEGS at default noise reduction settings, in order to have a common standard on which to base these comparisons. "
sounds silly, how is using default in cam settings a way to produce a standard fair comparison when default settings can radically differ as to how much and what types of NR and sharpening to apply?
p.1 #18So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
EB-1 wrote: shutterbug guy wroteWhat is DxOmark?Imagemaster wroteGoogle it. shutterbug guy wroteNah, it'd just be a waste of time. Why, has your government taken Google and DXOMark off the web?
EBH
I lost faith in DxO when they put out that certain full frame DSLR's surpassed the medium format cameras in image quality. They are scoring image quality a whole lot different than the way I see it.
Anything that I read put out by DxO is a waste of time imho.