sebboh wrote:
i would try to find an FE 35/1.4 that you can test or somebody else has tested. it definitely seems to match the look of the GM 85 better than the sigma, which has less emphasis on smoothness and very different color.
Thanks - I forgot color, it's long time since I shoot with Sigma, and I already forgot those muddy colors (thou I would assume they have better colors in Art-series than they had in EX-series). I found one 2nd hand FE 1.4/35, but it's 2h drive and price is 1299EUR.
sebboh wrote:
i don't have your usual subjects with the FE, but here's a few with it (all wide open probably):
Good examples, I can see rendering style similarities to GM85.
philber wrote:
Samuli, I agree entirely with your findings on the 85 GM, but would like to add 2 things. Compared to some of your lenses, like Contax G, the Sony 85 has rather weak contrast, and I find that I need to boost it in post (not talking specifically of wide open shots). Then you tend to get more "character" IMHO.
Philippe, I agree on contrast - I haven't earlier needed the slider "Contrast" in ACR, but GM85 needs from +10 to +25 to reach "normal" levels of contrast. Also I found the "new" slider "Dehaze" useful on most of the GM85 photos. Zeiss is so easy, Profile, WB & blackpoint = done. Also GM85 does not work with profile I have shoot with ZE135, contrast and colors were too weak - I had to created own profile for GM85. All other lenses I use profile created for ZE135 or ZM35, it's good even for Leica lenses which don't have as strong contrast as Zeiss lenses. With the GM85 profile I was able to drop the need to add so much contrast.
philber wrote:
Second comment, there is one configuration when the GM 85 delivers a slightly strange image. If you shoot close to-mid-distance foreground with background not far behind, with aperture of f:1.4 to f:2.4, you get a very blurred background which "doesn't look natural" because it is too close to foreground for so much blur to feel natural. Just my $0.02.
I had not found this yet - maybe I was too concentrated to background boke as initial shoot was huge disappointment (I had gigantic expectations) due to lots of issues with large distance shots backgrounds. I also have always felt that I don't use foreground boke enough in my shots, and that is definitely area where I want to improve, but when I'm shooting I go back to old habits and forgot this kind of things.
Samuli