supermario343 wrote:
Todd wrote
Question everyone? Should I buy this lens? The reason I am asking this is because I have a dilemma. I already have a 50 mm f 1.4 G and it suits my needs fine. However I'm not sure if I should spend that kind of money just for this lens in general. The other half of my dilemma is that I have a Sigma 85 mm F1 .4 and I would like to sell it and go back to the Nikon 85 mm F1 .4. Since these two lenses are priced about the same, I'm trying to decide on which one I really want. I use the 85 mm probably 90% of the time. To be honest, I really don't use a 50 mm that much, nor do I use my 35mm that much.
It seems that I always only use the 85mm when I am out with my camera doing general shooting. But I guess it's good to have some variety and I could get rid of my 50 mm and use this 58 mm in place of it with higher-quality optics.... I tried another one of these 58 mm lenses at the camera store yesterday, and it was impressively sharp wide open and the corners were nice and sharp wide open as well. This is just a dilemma that I wish I did not have. Because I like both lenses I'm torn between which one to buy. I know I already have the 85 Sigma, but I think that I am missing the 85 quality of the Nikon better and I want to go back. I only have enough money to purchase one of those lenses at the moment. It seems like you guys are all happy about the quality of the 58, I guess it really just depends on your shooting style and what Lens you use the most. I guess I'm just looking for constructive criticism here, maybe some good positive reinforcement comments from you folks as to which I should get.
I really like shooting landscapes and people portraits etc. this 58mm would be good for both, especially night shooting when the lighting is low and you can she wide-open and still be pretty sharp. I guess it really sounds like I've answered my own question doesn't it? I guess I will report back and let you know what I decide,. I'm sure it doesn't matter to any of you which when I get it I just figured I would ask and get some opinions. Thanks
T I myself was in the same kind of dilemma. I had the 50mm 1.8g lens and sold it. I also have the sigma 85mm 1.4 and tamron 70-200mm VC. I wanted the 58mm 1.4 bc of the character everyone was talking about. Its unique and the nikon 85 didnt have it. Theres just something about this lens that makes me like it. I could never go back to the 50mm 1.4 or 1.8 lens after using this one. Hope that helps and best of luck with your decision.
Mario
Thanks Mario, I appreciate your opinion and personal experience you've had with the lens... It will help with my decision.
Todd