low325 wrote:
IME keep in mind this isn't much of a landscape, architecture, commercial lens. I think it's a fantastic people, nighttime and artistic lens however.
You said your 50 1.4 does what you need so you have to ask yourself if your photography will need something with this type of character in your kit. To me the 58G can tell stories better than any standard FL lens in nikon's current lineup and even, dare I say it, an otus.
Not landscape? I don't see why not. I use the 50mm and the 85mm frequently for landscapes, of course there is no major foreground DOF like you would get from a 24mm, for example... I think it would do well in that area as well as with people, as you mentioned. I guess I just want a really nice 50~ish mm lens and I suppose the 58 is the one. I just find it hard to believe that it costs so much. It, like the 50mm, is not a hard lens to make. I guess it is the quality of the glass....who knows. Either way I think it is grossly over priced.
I bet I may use this 58mm more once I have it. So far I haven't enjoyed the 50mm Nikon or the sigma 50mm. They just were not sharp enough wide open. So, because of that, I did not use them much. I'll be in touch... thanks for the help.
Todd