I've had two different copies of this lens in the past year. Both behaved differently, not bad, just different. I feel in our day and age, folks want incredible breath-taking images immediately. With my experience with this lens, it honestly took time. Time to figure out the auto focus fine tune. Time to explore the strengths and weaknesses. The sharpness and focus would change depending on your shooting distance to your subject. There were a ton of factors to consider with this lens. I felt it was an incredible piece of glass. But most 'younger' folks want tack sharp and magic fairy dust right out of the box. This lens will not bring that. Not in my experience. It is there, just takes some work.
My reason for changing up what's in my bag, focal length. For my wedding and portrait work, I was feeling confined with the 58mm. I really enjoy working an 85mm, and this was just too close. I can work all day with 35 and 85 at a wedding. Having the 58, I felt trapped at that distance.