fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2011 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2011NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff

  
 
Jeff Kott
Offline
Details
p.6 #1NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
Sorry, I don't know why my previous response came out in bold type. I didn't mean it.
Oct 24, 2011 at 03:11 PM
wfrank
Offline
Details
p.6 #2NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
denoir wrote:
wfrank wroteThere's nothing soft about the 5D2 sensor I've seen no such thing. It depends on glass and handling not the sensor.
Not soft compared to what? The 5D2 has a fairly strong AA filter which makes the image much softer than you get from an M9 (no AA) or a camera with a weaker AA filter. The 18 megapixel M9 resolves a bit more than the 21 megapixel 5DII. To match the per pixel quality of the M9 you'd have to reduce the 5DII files to I'd say about 16 megapixels.

As for the NEX-7, from the full samples I've seen, I'd say you have to reduce it to around 12-16 megapixel to match the M9 per pixel quality. For the
...Show more →

Well I am not comparing to the M9 (who does?) but rather to what I can see on the pixellevel and comparing to any other cameras I've used. If I compare to anything related it would be to another widespread FF camera such as the D700 which has a significant resolution disadvantage vs the 5D2. For the Sony FF's I dont know. Within Canon the 7D is not a match for the 5D2. I am not talking about MTF curves and/or studio or tripod environments, I am talking images I do myself where I find the 5D2 is fully capable of taking pixelsharp images with a good lens well handled.

All said with appropriate respect of your detailed knowledge beyond most of us active here.
Oct 24, 2011 at 03:26 PM
philber
Offline
Details
p.6 #3NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
Well, Luka, if the 7 is in the 12-16 Mp region, it indicates, if I read between the lines, that it is the best crop camera in the business, and close to M9 or 5D II, or A 900 territory, at a lower price point. So you are actually confirming the many hopes people have in this new design.
Oct 24, 2011 at 03:30 PM
abam
Offline
Details
p.6 #4NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
"The shots I have seen from the 24MP APS sensor thus far (both from the a77 and NEX 7) have more of a harsh, thin, digital look."

"thus far", i'm of a similar opinion; though i'm reserving final judgement on the NEX-7 until i can get a hold of some technically-excellent RAWs.
Oct 24, 2011 at 04:11 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.6 #5NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
Jeff Kott wrote:
Earlier quoteTariq Gibran wrote

People seem to make a big deal about the Sony jpeg engine but at least in my a900 at low ISO's, it gives really great results by the way. I think some are expecting miracles with NEX-7 raw images.
My experience is different than yours. With my 5N, my raw files converted in Capture One 6 look a lot better than the jpegs.


That could be down to a 5n vs a900 jpeg engine difference so perhaps the NEX series does cut corners in this area.

Mine is in bold also. Don't know why.
Oct 24, 2011 at 04:18 PM
carstenw
Offline
Details
p.6 #6NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
Because the end-bold tag of your quoted mail got lost somehow

wfrank, I am not saying that the 5DII is a bad camera, nor that you can't make sharp photos with it, but compared to a good AA-filter-less sensor (which is exactly what you want to compare to, in order to get a good idea of its effectiveness), it has surprisingly little resolution for its specs. The NEX cameras appear to be similar in that respect. The D700/D3 have a lot less resolution than the 5DII, but not as much less as the numbers would indicate.

Philippe, getting 12-16MP out of a 24MP file is not impressive in my eyes, best APS-C sensor camera or not. The NEX-7 looks very nice, but why put such a sensor in it if you can't extract the results? A strong 16-18MP sensor would have made more sense and given better high ISO.
Oct 24, 2011 at 04:31 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.6 #7NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
Looks like Steve Huff is planning an extensive comparison of the NEX 7 to the 5n using some wide angle rangefinder lenses which should definitely show how both cameras deal with any issues...that is, if he does infinity, landscape type shots.

Here is what he will be using:

"These tests will include the Voigtlander 15mm, Leica 21 Elmarit, 24 Summilux as well as the 35 Summilux."

Oct 24, 2011 at 04:40 PM
sebboh
Offline
Details
p.6 #8NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
carstenw wrote:
Because the end-bold tag of your quoted mail got lost somehow

wfrank, I am not saying that the 5DII is a bad camera, nor that you can't make sharp photos with it, but compared to a good AA-filter-less sensor (which is exactly what you want to compare to, in order to get a good idea of its effectiveness), it has surprisingly little resolution for its specs. The NEX cameras appear to be similar in that respect. The D700/D3 have a lot less resolution than the 5DII, but not as much less as the numbers would indicate.


really? everything i've seen indicate that the D700/D3 actually have less per pixel sharpness than both the 5DII and the NEX while the D3x has better per pixel sharpness.

carstenw wrote:
Philippe, getting 12-16MP out of a 24MP file is not impressive in my eyes, best APS-C sensor camera or not. The NEX-7 looks very nice, but why put such a sensor in it if you can't extract the results? A strong 16-18MP sensor would have made more sense and given better high ISO.


you can ask the same question of any camera: why not put a 15MP sensor in the 5DII, an 8MP sensor in a D3, or a 10MP sensor in the 7D and get better high iso?
Oct 24, 2011 at 04:47 PM
ken.vs.ryu
Offline
Details
p.6 #9NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
if you want a nex-7 with a 5n sensor, get a 5n and the evf.
Oct 24, 2011 at 05:22 PM
uhoh7
Offline
Details
p.6 #10NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
So, who's biting the bullet and buying the Rock Huffwell domain?

I would but I just sent my little pre-war sonnar off to Henry Scherer.....

Now, that is a man with opinions

http://www.zeisscamera.com/services_lens.shtml
Oct 24, 2011 at 08:15 PM
kahren
Offline
Details
p.6 #11NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
sebboh wrote:
carstenw wroteBecause the end-bold tag of your quoted mail got lost somehow

wfrank, I am not saying that the 5DII is a bad camera, nor that you can't make sharp photos with it, but compared to a good AA-filter-less sensor (which is exactly what you want to compare to, in order to get a good idea of its effectiveness), it has surprisingly little resolution for its specs. The NEX cameras appear to be similar in that respect. The D700/D3 have a lot less resolution than the 5DII, but not as much less as the numbers would indicate.
really? everything i've seen indicate that the D700/D3 actually have less per pixel sharpness than both the 5DII and the NEX while the D3x has better per pixel sharpness.

carstenw wrotePhilippe, getting 12-16MP out of a 24MP file is not impressive in my eyes, best APS-C sensor camera or not. The NEX-7 looks very nice, but why put such a sensor in it if you can't extract the results? A strong 16-18MP sensor would have made more sense and given better high ISO.
you can ask the same question of any camera: why not put a 15MP sensor in the 5DII, an 8MP sensor in a D3, or a 10MP sensor in the 7D and get better high iso?


I am afraid more megapixels does not equal more noise, in fact the opposite. IF the light gathering amount of both sensors is the same then the higher megapixel camera will get less noise, because you can interpolate better with the extra information you are getting from the higher pixel count. If the nex7 is more noisy then the 5n, then i am afraid all that means is that either the light gathering amount on the nex7 is less then then 5n sensor or simply sony is not good at processing their data they get from the extra pixels. IMO its the latter IF its actually more noisy.
Oct 24, 2011 at 10:40 PM
douglasf13
Offline
Details
p.6 #12NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
carstenw wrote:
As the pixels get smaller, more of the area is used by electronics, so we are throwing away ISO performance. There is a reason to keep the megapixel count down, as evidenced by the 1D-X. Let's see if the NEX-7 shots even have 24MP of effective resolution. From the test shots I have seen so far, they do not. There is no point unless megapixels translate to resolution.


The megapixel count of the 1DX was kept down in order to facilitate faster data throughput and more fps, and I think it's unfortunate that Canon merged the two lines together.
Oct 24, 2011 at 11:03 PM
carstenw
Offline
Details
p.6 #13NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
sebboh wrote:
really? everything i've seen indicate that the D700/D3 actually have less per pixel sharpness than both the 5DII and the NEX while the D3x has better per pixel sharpness.


I have owned 5D and D3, and have shot 5DII as well, and the first two are close, but the 5DII is less sharp, and I think the colours are also weirder somehow. I have read about a weak CFA, built in to increase high ISO performance, but which also reduces colour performance. Although the reds and greens are not quite right with the D3, before PP, the 5DII sometimes has ballistic red performance. I once took a shot of my daughter's fire engine red pushbike, and it came out almost fluorescent orange! The weirdest thing I have seen. Combine this with noise in the shadows at base ISO, and the 5DII is a very difficult camera to get good results from, w.r.t. colour and sharpness. Clearly people manage, but I was never attracted personally to this camera. The D3 is much easier to tame, meaning more time with photography, less with PP.

Anyway, my D3 is good enough for sharpness, but I am really looking forward to a switch to either D4 or D3x for some more resolution, and hopefully better colour too.
Oct 25, 2011 at 01:17 AM
you2
Offline
Details
p.6 #14NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
ken.vs.ryu wrote:
if you want a nex-7 with a 5n sensor, get a 5n and the evf.

-
But I'm not sure this is true. It sounds like the nex-7 has a few extra useful bells and whistles such as electronic level (which would be really nice if shows up in the evf)
-
Price wise it sounds like there is not a huge difference if you buy the evf; so then it becomes a matter of form factor and image quality.
-
I'm in no hurry to purchase but (for example) if dynamic range is significantly reduced on the 7 then I would definitely go with the 5n; but if image quality is very similar then I think the 7n might be worth the extra features (I would want to feel both bodies before deciding if all else is equal).

(I mostly plan on using my old c/y lenses; but might pick up one or two cv lenses; if auto focus was the target I think the ep-3 might be a better camera)
Oct 25, 2011 at 07:30 AM
carstenw
Offline
Details
p.6 #15NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
One thing which I find *really* attractive about the NEX-7 is the degree of customization possible with the two thumbwheels and the normal wheel. I also find the 5N too small and light, and a bit flimsy. I am expecting the 7 to resolve all this. I just find it very silly to stuff a 24MP sensor in a camera when it only delivers maybe 16MP of information. That 24MP will slow down my computer and fill up my hard drive.
Oct 25, 2011 at 08:02 AM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.6 #16NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
you2 wrote:
ken.vs.ryu wroteif you want a nex-7 with a 5n sensor, get a 5n and the evf.
-
But I'm not sure this is true. It sounds like the nex-7 has a few extra useful bells and whistles such as electronic level (which would be really nice if shows up in the evf)
-
Price wise it sounds like there is not a huge difference if you buy the evf; so then it becomes a matter of form factor and image quality.
-
I'm in no hurry to purchase but (for example) if dynamic range is significantly reduced on the 7 then I would definitely go with the 5n; but if image quality is very similar then I think the 7n might
...Show more →

Of course it's not true. Beyond any additional features, just the difference in the vastly superior control layout and ergonomics due to the larger grip and built in EVF of the NEX-7 means that the camera will be much different (better for most) to use.
Oct 25, 2011 at 08:06 AM
FlyPenFly
Offline
Details
p.6 #17NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
As far as flimsy, the 5N feels far more solid and well constructed than my previous cameras like the EPL2 or EP2. It is Miles above the build quality of most Panasonic MFT cameras like the G series which feel especially very flimsy, moreso than compact consumer cameras. It felt like paper mache with soft touch rubber coating. The only Panasonic MFT camera that I thought was very well made was the GF-1.
Oct 25, 2011 at 08:10 AM
douglasf13
Offline
Details
p.6 #18NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
carstenw wrote:
One thing which I find *really* attractive about the NEX-7 is the degree of customization possible with the two thumbwheels and the normal wheel. I also find the 5N too small and light, and a bit flimsy. I am expecting the 7 to resolve all this. I just find it very silly to stuff a 24MP sensor in a camera when it only delivers maybe 16MP of information. That 24MP will slow down my computer and fill up my hard drive.


What do you mean by "16mp of information?" If using a tripod or higher shutter speeds, there will be a resolution improvement over the 5n.
Oct 25, 2011 at 10:12 AM
Lotusm50
Offline
Details
p.6 #19NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
carstenw wrote:
I just find it very silly to stuff a 24MP sensor in a camera when it only delivers maybe 16MP of information.



Don't all existing 24mp cameras supply roughly 16MP of information (give or take some)? I'm not sure what your measuring benchmark is for a MP of information, but is there a camera available anywhere that provides MP's of information equal to the number of MP's on the sensor? Does the Canon 5Dll supply 21MP of information? Does the Nikon D3x supply 24MP of information? Does the Sony a900? The issue you imply about the NEX-7 is far from exclusive to the NEX-7. You can make a similar assertion about most (if not all) digital cameras.

Clearly any camera that uses an AA filter to control moire sacrifices some MP. I don't think the NEX-7 is really any different in this regard than any other AA filter-equipped camera. Do I expect 24mp sensor in the NEX-7 to produce more information than other AA filter-equipped 16-18mp cameras(such as the NEX-5N, for just one example)? Yes I do. That's why they stuff a 24MP sensor into the NEX-7.

Oct 25, 2011 at 10:25 AM
douglasf13
Offline
Details
p.6 #20NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
+1, Lotusm50. On a side note, not all raw converters are created equal. When I export raws out of LR3 to be converted in RPP, the difference in detail is stunning, so a raw converter upgrade may help you as much as removing an AA filter.
Oct 25, 2011 at 10:38 AM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell