fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2011 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2011NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff

  
 
h00ligan
Offline
Details
p.2 #1NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
Millsart you've just hit on another great unknown. By the time that lens lineup fills out for Sony or Fiji etc, will mft have that major sensor leap. Will we soon have a gf3x or similar with better high ISP than the gh3. With mft I feel like for a carry camera it's a good option except the sensor.

I would love to see better high ISO with mft and 16 mp. I think the oly 12, 45 panny Leica 25 covers most of what I'd need. But I shoot in low light at parties etc. and if you price that kit you're at what $3000? Including vf.

You're not shooting action with it, video is so so, high isoisn't great.

Sony has a chance to get there..I don't think that will happen charging $1000 for a lens that is good not great, in this segment.

If you want wide on nex, you have to use a subpar 24 equiv, kit zoom, or legacy glass.

All that said I was going to go to the state fair today (decided against it anyway) but in looking at what bag I would take for my 5d2 I decided tht frankly, it wasn't worth taking. So clearly I want something smaller. I just sold my gf1 and 20mm, which to me was starting to show its age (in quality)
Oct 23, 2011 at 12:04 PM
bluetsunami
Offline
Details
p.2 #2NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
millsart wrote:
For me, legacy glass was always a means to an end. It was a way to get focal lengths not offered, but at least with m4/3, when native glass like the 45mm f1.8 came along, that was great optically, affordable, could AF, smaller/lighter and didn't require messing about with an adapter or having to zoom in to focus etc, I saw no reason to use to legacy glass on it.


I definitely agree that if the native lenses are great that the need for alt lenses becomes less important. But I think Fuji would need to come out with a comprehensive set of lenses at first to reach this point. I think a smart move would to have the mount open so people can adapt and you can fill in the native lens gaps as Sony is doing now.

Even then I think I'd still like to adapt my favorite Zeiss lenses no matter what

On another note It'll be interesting to see how much weight Leica throws into this sector next year. So we'll have 3 behemoths in the NEX-7, X200 and Leica's mirrorless non-rangefinder offering. I'm sure it'll be at a premium though.
Oct 23, 2011 at 12:16 PM
mawz
Offline
Details
p.2 #3NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
Tariq Gibran wrote:
In Steve's review, we have him writing about the Zeiss 24 1.7 as such:

"While it is not clinically sharp, it has character… and to me, that is way more important that hyper sharpness."

Now, I certainly would expect a $1000 APS Zeiss lens to have character but is having character an excuse for not also being sharp? From my experience with Zeiss lenses, one thing most of them actually have in common is a lens "fingerprint" which gives the impression of overwhelming sharpness (usually through a combination of high micro-contrast and actual resolution). His statement creates enough suspicion that the
...Show more →

I'm getting the impression (from both reviews and samples) that the 24/1.8 strays a little too close to the classic 50 Sonnar in terms of performance to satisfy most people. Note the C Sonnar 50/1.5 is almost exactly the same price as the 24/1.8 Sonnar and could be described exactly the same way, ie 'not clinically sharp, it has character'. Unfortunately for Sony that's not really an ideal choice for the key prime in their lineup even if it does make me more interested in it (I do love the classic Sonnar look).
Oct 23, 2011 at 12:35 PM
najibs
Offline
Details
p.2 #4NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
And, for those interested, Luminous Landscape posted their NEX-5n review here:

http://www.luminous-landscape.com/reviews/cameras/sony_nex_5n_field_review.shtml
Oct 23, 2011 at 12:37 PM
michaelwatkins
Offline
Details
p.2 #5NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
Tariq Gibran wrote:
In Steve's review, we have him writing about the Zeiss 24 1.7 as such:

"While it is not clinically sharp, it has character… and to me, that is way more important that hyper sharpness."

Now, I certainly would expect a $1000 APS Zeiss lens to have character but is having character an excuse for not also being sharp? From my experience with Zeiss lenses, one thing most of them actually have in common is a lens "fingerprint" which gives the impression of overwhelming sharpness (usually through a combination of high micro-contrast and actual resolution). His statement creates enough suspicion that the
...Show more →

I keep wondering why Sony/Zeiss chose the Sonnar design for the E ZA 24mm f/1.8 instead of opting for a Biogon design such as was done for the Contax G or adapted the ZM 25. Was it purely a cost decision?

Or did they decide to infect the E ZA 24mm with some of the character of a lens like the ZM 50mm Sonnar 1.5 which some feel is a lens with two operating modes - usefully softer with character open, more traditionally Zeiss sharp stopped down (but not as sharp as say the ZM Planar 50mm).

Being a nearly silent relatively fast AF Zeiss lens with "character" I'm prepared to cut it some slack at least until I see some useful comparisons between it and the kit zoom at 24mm and maybe a ZM 25mm - shooting subjects and lighting that are more interesting to me. Actually I'd like to see a really thorough comparison between the NEX-7 (or also NEX-5) with the E ZA 24mm and the X100.

Huff's review of the lens and camera didn't offer me anything new that couldn't be gathered from prior reviews other than to add another vote of confidence for the EVF and focus peaking in support of using manual focus lenses. That's a really important feature for me personally so I'll continue to wait for the NEX-7 release unless someone else happens along to steal the show. At present there don't seem to be any other contenders waiting in the wings with clearly defined, announced, product, that isn't a Leica.
Oct 23, 2011 at 12:37 PM
kosmoskatten
Offline
Details
p.2 #6NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
MW: I find it strange that the 24/2 is not a Distagon or a Biogon. It seems like a nice lens whatever the designated name is.

The 50mm does not look so hot, in the shot of that old cottage/house in the forest the left side is quite blurry in a way that seems to indicate a decentered lens or plain poor performance. Sony lens QC seems iffy.

I would not call Steve Huffs presentation of the NEX7 a review. More like a presentation. The face value of his statements in this presentation is dubious, he seems very determined not to ruffle any feathers which makes for a really bland article. He seems quite enthusiastic about it but also plays down a comparison to the Leica M9 in a way that I find very vague as if he would be afraid of catching flak from... ...who I don't really know.

Steve Huff seems like a nice enough guy. With this review he lost a lot of credibility in my eyes though.
Oct 23, 2011 at 12:51 PM
michaelwatkins
Offline
Details
p.2 #7NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
mawz wrote:
Unfortunately for Sony that's not really an ideal choice for the key prime in their lineup even if it does make me more interested in it (I do love the classic Sonnar look).


Exactly. I have a Sonnar 50mm on order in fact for this very reason.

But selling a lens like that, mass market, may be too difficult given the tendencies of mass market reviewers to comment primarily on edge to edge sharpness and spotting the split end of a hair from 20 meters.

If Sony/Zeiss (Zony?) decided to "do photographers a favour" and intentionally incorporate the two-speed nature of the ZM 50mm Sonnar, they may have given reviewers and consumers too much credit and assumed they could make an informed decision as to purpose. If that is indeed the case it may backfire particularly when pros review a ZM 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar and not realize what type of lens they were reviewing and thus comment critically upon it for that reason. I'm referring to a review I once read in LL. Had LL initially reviewed the f/2.0 Planar 50mm it likely would have met their expectations for a sharp Zeiss lens and they'd have gushed about it.

Maybe a Planar or Biogon design would have been a better choice while the line up is still relatively immature. Or perhaps they could only commit to doing a few Zeiss E mount lenses and rationalized this was the best approach even if it took a bit of education. Or maybe they figured reviewers be damned, enthusiasts would like a 24mm AF Zeiss on this new camera.

If an advanced consumer does care, they have choices. A $1,000 dollar or more Zeiss lens buyer ought to be willing to consider the design and suitability for purpose before plunking down the cash. If they don't like the look, they could opt for a ZM 25mm f/2.8 and adapter and use the kit zoom for autofocus when needed. Or adapt an existing SLR 28mm in their gear bag for the past 20 years.
Oct 23, 2011 at 12:53 PM
douglasf13
Offline
Details
p.2 #8NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
Color shift at the corners is more than likely the reason for Zeiss avoiding a Biogon design for the 24/1.8. Even Biogon designs for 135 sensors have issues on Nex, although the newer cameras seem better.
Oct 23, 2011 at 12:53 PM
philber
Offline
Details
p.2 #9NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
Most of Steve Huff's review is JPEG based. He states that he converted some RAWs with the (slow and bad) Sony software, and just a few in Capture One. Judging IQ against that of other cameras at the TPEG level is largely influebced by the respective in-camera JPEG engines. Not hugely relevant to most of us here, unless I am mistaken. This is probably why the review is much more about ergonomics than IQ. He also does nto state whether he got a production camera, or, like everybody else so far, a pre-production one.
Oct 23, 2011 at 01:12 PM
h00ligan
Offline
Details
p.2 #10NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
It's a final version. He stated it previously iirc.
Oct 23, 2011 at 01:14 PM
millsart
Offline
Details
p.2 #11NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
Is poor JPEG quality really acceptable anymore ? Granted I typically shoot RAW myself still, and with many earlier cameras I've owned, M9 especially, you really had to shoot RAW as the JPEGS were just so poor.

However, these days we have seen a number of cameras with very good JPEG output, Olympus's m4/3 line, and the Fuji X100 for example. Having owned both of those, and experimenting a bit with jpeg vs raw, the JPEG output really stands up quite well in terms of detail and also color. There just isn't that much gained from shooting RAW imho, though I do still do it.

That said, and even if one may not shoot much JPEG, does anything else think that going into the year 2012 and with flagship cameras in their segments, that poor JPEG quality really shouldn't be acceptable anymore ?

I mean really, why can Fuji and Olympus produce really nice OOC files in terms of color, WB, detail and sharpening, even in their lower end models like the $599 EMP1 or the X10, and yet other brands, with just as much if not more resources still produce inferior JPEGs ?

Again, this isn't a RAW vs JPEG debate, but just that any $1000+ camera should really be able to deliver pretty good OOC files these days if you ask me.


philber wrote:
Most of Steve Huff's review is JPEG based. He states that he converted some RAWs with the (slow and bad) Sony software, and just a few in Capture One. Judging IQ against that of other cameras at the TPEG level is largely influebced by the respective in-camera JPEG engines. Not hugely relevant to most of us here, unless I am mistaken. This is probably why the review is much more about ergonomics than IQ. He also does nto state whether he got a production camera, or, like everybody else so far, a pre-production one.

Oct 23, 2011 at 01:39 PM
philber
Offline
Details
p.2 #12NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
Who says that the JPEGs are "bad"? I just said that they weren't as relevant to most of us as RAW, and not necessarily correlated quality-wise.
Oct 23, 2011 at 01:48 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.2 #13NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
douglasf13 wrote:
Color shift at the corners is more than likely the reason for Zeiss avoiding a Biogon design for the 24/1.8. Even Biogon designs for 135 sensors have issues on Nex, although the newer cameras seem better.


+1 This is the reason. Sony as much has said so with their remark about not being able to make tiny lenses for the larger sensor.
Oct 23, 2011 at 01:57 PM
sebboh
Offline
Details
p.2 #14NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
millsart wrote:
Interesting question for those that have a good number of current MF glass.

If (and I know it a big if) Fuji can introduce a line of lens that is optically good, of a compact size, and in the typical focal ranges/speeds that are popular, along with the ability to not only AF, but also with a direct MF ring (sort of like the Olympus 12mm f2.0) would you still prefer to mess with adapters ??

To some degree I guess this question applies to the NEX w/ Zeiss 24 as well. How many would prefer a $1200 ZM25, with the
...Show more →

for me this depends on whether the OEM lenses offer something other than autofocus and exif info, specifically performance, size, speed, or character. i realize i'm in a tiny minority, but autofocus doesn't add anything for me (and in many cases increases the size) and adapters aren't an issue (just stick them on the lens and forget them) except for the contax g ones. in the case of the new zeiss, it offers speed and possibly performance compared to a bunch of lenses that aren't functionally much smaller (zm 25/2.8, OM 24/2.8, rokkor 24/2.8), so i'm very interested in it. even if it is sharper across the frame at all apertures than my current 24mm (the rokkor), i'll still use the rokkor from time to time as it's one of my favorite lenses. most of my lenses i'd be willing to replace though with something faster, sharper, and smaller.
Oct 23, 2011 at 02:07 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.2 #15NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
I noticed earlier in the week, Steve had mentioned that full size images would be available for download when the review is posted:

"The review will feature many more samples as well as full size image downloads, high ISO samples and crops up to 16,000 ISO at night, my thoughts on the usability, the features and the lenses and much much more including a video with all of the features and menu system."

http://www.stevehuffphoto.com/2011/10/18/sony-nex-7-review-coming-this-weekend-more-image-samples-while-you-wait/

Did I miss the full size downloads somewhere in the review?

Of course, he also said earlier he would be testing some wide angle Leica lenses as well:

http://www.stevehuffphoto.com/2011/10/13/the-tease-the-first-sony-nex-7-samples-with-the-zeiss-24-1-8-and-50-1-8/

"I do not own any wide angle Leica lenses or 90mm Leica lenses so I can not test the wide angles from Leica on this camera just yet, but will do so in the future when I can gather a few wide angle Leica lenses."

Hopefully, he adds both over the next week or so.
Oct 23, 2011 at 02:11 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.2 #16NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
kosmoskatten wrote:
I would not call Steve Huffs presentation of the NEX7 a review. More like a presentation. The face value of his statements in this presentation is dubious, he seems very determined not to ruffle any feathers which makes for a really bland article. He seems quite enthusiastic about it but also plays down a comparison to the Leica M9 in a way that I find very vague as if he would be afraid of catching flak from... ...who I don't really know.

Steve Huff seems like a nice enough guy. With this review he lost a lot of credibility in
...Show more →

I agree with this observation. It is ironic that in the review, he mentions his post entitled "Sony Grew Some Balls!" in reference to the NEX-7.

Let's see how "ballsy" Steve Huff is in posting what everyone wants to see over the coming week or so.
Oct 23, 2011 at 02:59 PM
michaelwatkins
Offline
Details
p.2 #17NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
Hey, kk, didn't see your note until after I wrote my second. I think you nail it with this:

kosmoskatten wrote:
MW: I find it strange that the 24/2 is not a Distagon or a Biogon. It seems like a nice lens whatever the designated name is.


Agreed. If asked to pick just one AF lens, today, I'd prefer to have an AF lens in the 24mm focal length for APS-C so that lens should naturally be a prime (pun intended) choice for me... although I did an EXIF query recently and discovered I'm not as centered on moderate wide focal lengths as I imagined, if I exclude recent history with the X100. Still there is enough of a preferences coming through, which mirrors my pre-EXIF days recollection, that I should be a buyer of this lens.

But instead of the logical AF choice instead I bought a ZM25, not because I thought it would perform better or worse or due to construction or utility on other cameras but largely because the Zeiss E mount 24 aren't expected to be available in Canada until January 2012. The plan was to evaluate it and make a decision as to whether I am missing AF in a prime of that focal length or not. Of course I made this plan before it was clear that shipments of cameras would be delayed, perhaps for a long time.

I would not call Steve Huffs presentation of the NEX7 a review. More like a presentation.

His writing style seems designed to mirror his on camera speaking style. Sometimes it works for him but in this review maybe not so much.

The face value of his statements in this presentation is dubious, he seems very determined not to ruffle any feathers which makes for a really bland article. He seems quite enthusiastic about it but also plays down a comparison to the Leica M9 in a way that I find very vague as if he would be afraid of catching flak from... ...who I don't really know.

You used the word "iffy" in another context but the term certainly applies to the tone of the review / user report. He seemed too non-committal to be merely bland!

Visually I'm underwhelmed by quite a few of the images in the review but can't tell if that is Huff's shooting style coming through, or if images are impacted by his choice of settings on the camera (JPEG processing) or the nature of the in-camera raw to JPEG processing or the lenses or what.

The one comparison I was most interested in was the GXR/NEX image pair; not that anyone could make a decision based on just one image but if you could the takeaway would be there isn't enough difference between the two to make a choice based on image output alone, which means the NEX gets the nod (for me) for many other reasons even if I want to love the Ricoh (and presumably can still order it!).

A closing thought: Steve probably oversold his "review" and raised expectations for his review higher than he could deliver this weekend. Had he just sprung it on us without fanfare and to-do, maybe it would have been less critically viewed.
Oct 23, 2011 at 03:00 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.2 #18NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
mawz wrote:
Tariq Gibran wroteIn Steve's review, we have him writing about the Zeiss 24 1.7 as such:

"While it is not clinically sharp, it has character… and to me, that is way more important that hyper sharpness."

Now, I certainly would expect a $1000 APS Zeiss lens to have character but is having character an excuse for not also being sharp? From my experience with Zeiss lenses, one thing most of them actually have in common is a lens "fingerprint" which gives the impression of overwhelming sharpness (usually through a combination of high micro-contrast and actual resolution). His statement creates enough suspicion that the lens may be lacking.
I'm getting the impression (from both reviews and samples) that the 24/1.8 strays a little too close to the classic 50 Sonnar in terms of performance to satisfy most people. Note the C Sonnar 50/1.5 is almost exactly the same price as the 24/1.8 Sonnar and could be described exactly the same way, ie 'not clinically sharp, it has character'. Unfortunately for Sony that's not really an ideal choice for the key prime in their lineup even if it does make me more interested in it (I do love the classic Sonnar look).


The other issue I see with this comparison for Sony is that it's one thing to accept/ expect a fast FF lens to offer this sort of behavior but when your talking about a lens that covers a smaller format, is limited to only working in one system and is not as fast, the equation might not make as much sense for a potential buyer. Had the Sony Zeiss E 24 1.8 been a 1.4, no one would have thought twice if the lens behaved as above. In exchange for the speed discrepancy vs DOF of the smaller format lens, as well as the loss of mount versatility, a potential buyer might expect a smaller lens, a cheaper price and or better performance. I see this as the marketing problem Sony may face with the Zeiss E 24 1.8.
Oct 23, 2011 at 03:20 PM
FlyPenFly
Offline
Details
p.2 #19NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
As much as I hate to say it. If I end up loving the Nex 7, I can see myself buying the Zeiss 24mm F1.8. The Nex-5N was absolutely wonderful to have with some Contax G lenses on for focal lengths not covered by my full frame camera in my photo trips.

To me the beauty of the NEX system has been that I can shoot my main ZF 21mm on the big camera while still having longer or normal focal lengths available with excellent Contax G lenses. Sometimes I miss a shot because I don't have AF and that's where I see the 24mm Zeiss coming in..
Oct 23, 2011 at 03:26 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.2 #20NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
michaelwatkins wrote:
But instead of the logical AF choice instead I bought a ZM25, not because I thought it would perform better or worse or due to construction or utility on other cameras but largely because the Zeiss E mount 24 aren't expected to be available in Canada until January 2012. The plan was to evaluate it and make a decision as to whether I am missing AF in a prime of that focal length or not. Of course I made this plan before it was clear that shipments of cameras would be delayed, perhaps for a long time.


This route also gives you greater flexibility with future bodies/ systems (up to FF even) as your not locked only into the APS NEX system. This really didn't enter your decision process?


Edited on Oct 23, 2011 at 03:31 PM · View previous versions
Oct 23, 2011 at 03:28 PM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister