fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2011 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2011NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff

  
 
philber
Offline
Details
p.5 #1NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
You2, it is an oversimplification to conclude that the NEX 7 is worse than the 5N in high ISOs. The sensor is not the same, nor the electronics, so we just don't know. Only further full-scale tests will tell...
Oct 24, 2011 at 12:14 PM
thedigitalbean
Offline
Details
p.5 #2NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
I wouldn't make any conclusions or assumptions until we see RAW files from both cameras processed through the same RAW converter.

I recently jumped on the 5n + viewfinder mostly because with the floods in Thailand I wasn't sure I'd be able to get a 7 until well into next year. I may move to a 7 eventually, we'll see but so far I am pretty thrilled with the image quality of the 5n (both high and low ISO).
Oct 24, 2011 at 12:20 PM
Jeff Kott
Offline
Details
p.5 #3NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
you2 wrote:
I realize there is a lot of focus on noise at higher ISO; but I think it is a given the 5n is 1 or 2 stops better than the 7; .......


It is not a given, but I don't blame you for thinking that it is.

This is an example of sloppy unsubstantiated comments in "Reviews" by people like Steve Huff confusing people.

5N may or may not perform better than the 7 as far as high ISO noise when image size is adjusted to the same viewing size, but I have not seen any comprehensive testing that settles this.

Your other point on how both cameras probably perform really well up to ISO 800 ( I would guess 1600) is a good one and if someone is buying one camera over another for that reason, they're probably barking up the wrong tree.
Oct 24, 2011 at 12:29 PM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.5 #4NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
MCLMM wrote:
corposant wroteBased on this:

http://i1214.photobucket.com/albums/cc498/43rumors/sony_thai_water.jpg

The 5N has been ordered!
^ Yes, same here.


Yeah, after having played with a friend of a friend's (with the EVF) and having heard about the flood, I ordered one from Amazon last week. Got it Friday- it's fantastic. Hopefully the wait for the EVF won't be long. Still excited about the 7, but happily tided over until then.
Oct 24, 2011 at 12:33 PM
douglasf13
Offline
Details
p.5 #5NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
Visuals wrote:
So what now?

The 5N has better iso
the Nex 7 has better controls

so which are we getting?


Assuming you'd output files from either camera at the same size, the high ISO advantage of the 5n should be negligible.
Oct 24, 2011 at 01:02 PM
philber
Offline
Details
p.5 #6NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
Congrats on your new cameras, guys!
Oct 24, 2011 at 01:24 PM
wfrank
Offline
Details
p.5 #7NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
Any thoughts about the higher pixel density vs possible limits in lens resolution/handling etc?

I found (non scientificly) that some of my lenses that I found "ok" became pixelsharp when switching from 7D (APS-C 18MP) to 5DMkII (FF 21MP). The 5D have less than half pixeldensity compared to the 7D. Also, looking from that angle, the more than doubled pixel density of the 7D demanded more effort from the photographer - since minute micro movements or trembles are magnified with higher pixel density. One of my - personal and still non-scientific - observations is that this must be one reason IS (image stabilzation) is almost mandatory with new APS-C lenses (main stream lenses that is). Wheras the FF still do good without, at least on lesser focales.

Now, this may be a non-issue since the 5N and 7 share the same sensor size. But still the pixel density is higher, and if this is a hindrance to use the higher resolution in e.g. all (or most) handheld shots, the potential sensor advantage is almost gone. Just a thought.

(again, apart from built-in EVF, better mechanical interface etc )
Oct 24, 2011 at 01:32 PM
edwardkaraa
Offline
Details
p.5 #8NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
wfrank wrote:
Any thoughts about the higher pixel density vs possible limits in lens resolution/handling etc?



Only when viewing the photos at 100%. if you print, it depends on the output size anyway. If your lens has enough resolution to print say at 18x24 with a certain sensor, a higher resolution sensor will not make it any worse. If anything, the new sensor would allow you to print even larger. Printing large requires certain discipline, tripod, MLU, optimum aperture, regardless of the format.
Oct 24, 2011 at 01:45 PM
wfrank
Offline
Details
p.5 #9NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
edwardkaraa wrote:
wfrank wroteAny thoughts about the higher pixel density vs possible limits in lens resolution/handling etc?
Only when viewing the photos at 100%. if you print, it depends on the output size anyway. If your lens has enough resolution to print say at 18x24 with a certain sensor, a higher resolution sensor will not make it any worse. If anything, the new sensor would allow you to print even larger. Printing large requires certain discipline, tripod, MLU, optimum aperture, regardless of the format.


You're absolutely right, it wont make anything worse. But if the reasons I tried to elaborate are valid, then it would actually be a hindrance to use the resolution advantage in some/many/most circumstances depending how you shoot.
Oct 24, 2011 at 01:59 PM
edwardkaraa
Offline
Details
p.5 #10NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
wfrank wrote:
edwardkaraa wrote
wfrank wroteAny thoughts about the higher pixel density vs possible limits in lens resolution/handling etc?
Only when viewing the photos at 100%. if you print, it depends on the output size anyway. If your lens has enough resolution to print say at 18x24 with a certain sensor, a higher resolution sensor will not make it any worse. If anything, the new sensor would allow you to print even larger. Printing large requires certain discipline, tripod, MLU, optimum aperture, regardless of the format.
You're absolutely right, it wont make anything worse. But if the reasons I tried to elaborate are valid, then it would actually be a hindrance to use the resolution advantage in some/many/most circumstances depending how you shoot.


I think so too. This extra resolution will be more difficult to fully exploit. But on the other hand, it doesn't seem to cost us more, as sensor manufacturing gets more advanced, and it doesn't affect IQ at previous printing sizes. It does play another useful role though, the higher the pixel density, the less AA filters are needed. In fact the lens itself becomes the AA filter as it is unable to out resolve the sensor.
Oct 24, 2011 at 02:15 PM
douglasf13
Offline
Details
p.5 #11NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
Yep, you really only gain a resolution advantage from the 24mp sensor over the 16mp sensor if you use a great tripod, or maybe if you use fast shutter speeds. Even in an optimum scenario, the actual resolution advantage isn't all that great. That being said, outside of storage or data throughput concerns, there isn't much of a disadvantage to have more megapixels, even if you don't always eek out the resolution gains.

I do notice a little bit of difference in resolution when printing 12x18 with my NEX-5 and A900, and I'm hoping the NEX-7 bridges that gap, for the most part. I've found that going from LR3 to RPP for my raw conversions probably makes as much of a difference as increasing the pixel count in my cameras. Boy, there are a lot of variables in all of this!
Oct 24, 2011 at 02:18 PM
carstenw
Offline
Details
p.5 #12NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
As the pixels get smaller, more of the area is used by electronics, so we are throwing away ISO performance. There is a reason to keep the megapixel count down, as evidenced by the 1D-X. Let's see if the NEX-7 shots even have 24MP of effective resolution. From the test shots I have seen so far, they do not. There is no point unless megapixels translate to resolution.
Oct 24, 2011 at 02:22 PM
Lotusm50
Offline
Details
p.5 #13NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
carstenw wrote:
As the pixels get smaller, more of the area is used by electronics, so we are throwing away ISO performance. There is a reason to keep the megapixel count down, as evidenced by the 1D-X. Let's see if the NEX-7 shots even have 24MP of effective resolution.



Concerning "effective resolution", in your use of this, does the 5Dll have 21mp of effective resolution? Does the NEX-5N have 16mp of effective resolution? Does the D3x have 24 mp of it? Will the NEX-7 have the same effective resolution as an a900 at ISO 100? Will the NEX-7 have more resolution than the NEX- 5N? I suspect it will. Will it have it at all ISO's? I suspect its resolution advantage over the 5N will diminish with increasing ISO.

Oct 24, 2011 at 02:29 PM
carstenw
Offline
Details
p.5 #14NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
The 5DII certainly does not have 21MP of effective resolution, it is rather soft. Maybe 16? Some of Luka's comparison shots show that the M9 is at least as capable of capturing detail. I don't know the NEX-5N well enough, nor the D3x, although from the many detailed reviews I have read of the D3x, I would guess that its effectiveness-coefficient is rather high Not as high as the M9, but up there.

The NEX-7 will almost certainly have more effective resolution than the 5N, since they were built with similar trade-offs. Will it have more effective resolution than an M9? Interesting question.

Personally, I think it would have made more sense to make fewer pixels, but aim for better IQ at higher ISOs, but maybe that's just me. I am sure you are right about the ISO/resolution trade-off with the NEX-7 compared to 5N.
Oct 24, 2011 at 02:34 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.5 #15NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
carstenw wrote:
As the pixels get smaller, more of the area is used by electronics, so we are throwing away ISO performance. There is a reason to keep the megapixel count down, as evidenced by the 1D-X. Let's see if the NEX-7 shots even have 24MP of effective resolution. From the test shots I have seen so far, they do not. There is no point unless megapixels translate to resolution.


The shots I have seen from the 24MP APS sensor thus far (both from the a77 and NEX 7) have more of a harsh, thin, digital look than those from my a900. The rendering difference is almost like that between viewing large format film mages vs small format images and goes beyond just resolution.
Oct 24, 2011 at 02:35 PM
Jeff Kott
Offline
Details
p.5 #16NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
Tariq Gibran wrote:
The shots I have seen from the 24MP APS sensor thus far (both from the a77 and NEX 7) have more of a harsh, thin, digital look than those from my a900. The rendering difference is almost like that between viewing large format film mages vs small format images and goes beyond just resolution.


Were all of those shots from the different cameras taken in raw and converted in the same raw converter?
Oct 24, 2011 at 02:39 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.5 #17NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
Jeff Kott wrote:
Tariq Gibran wroteThe shots I have seen from the 24MP APS sensor thus far (both from the a77 and NEX 7) have more of a harsh, thin, digital look than those from my a900. The rendering difference is almost like that between viewing large format film mages vs small format images and goes beyond just resolution.
Were all of those shots from the different cameras taken in raw and converted in the same raw converter?


Certainly not the NEX-7 shots- and I need to see more from it - but yes on the A77 shots. I downloaded the raws and converted them with raw photo processor.

People seem to make a big deal about the Sony jpeg engine but at least in my a900 at low ISO's, it gives really great results by the way. I think some are expecting miracles with NEX-7 raw images.
Oct 24, 2011 at 02:43 PM
wfrank
Offline
Details
p.5 #18NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
carstenw wrote:
The 5DII certainly does not have 21MP of effective resolution, it is rather soft. Maybe 16?


There's nothing soft about the 5D2 sensor I've seen no such thing. It depends on glass and handling not the sensor.
Oct 24, 2011 at 03:00 PM
Jeff Kott
Offline
Details
p.5 #19NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
Tariq Gibran wrote

People seem to make a big deal about the Sony jpeg engine but at least in my a900 at low ISO's, it gives really great results by the way. I think some are expecting miracles with NEX-7 raw images.


My experience is different than yours. With my 5N, my raw files converted in Capture One 6 look a lot better than the jpegs.
Oct 24, 2011 at 03:10 PM
denoir
Offline
Details
p.5 #20NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
wfrank wrote:
There's nothing soft about the 5D2 sensor I've seen no such thing. It depends on glass and handling not the sensor.


Not soft compared to what? The 5D2 has a fairly strong AA filter which makes the image much softer than you get from an M9 (no AA) or a camera with a weaker AA filter. The 18 megapixel M9 resolves a bit more than the 21 megapixel 5DII. To match the per pixel quality of the M9 you'd have to reduce the 5DII files to I'd say about 16 megapixels.


As for the NEX-7, from the full samples I've seen, I'd say you have to reduce it to around 12-16 megapixel to match the M9 per pixel quality. For the NEX-C3, it's in the 8 megapixel region - there's a small test here: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1030741/2#9794524
Oct 24, 2011 at 03:11 PM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell