chez wrote:
mudlake wrote
gdanmitchell wrote
philip_pj wrote
So, was (is) lead important to image depth, a.k.a. dimensionality? Photography is no more about lenses than cooking is about spoons. Cooking is about INGREDIENTS and PREPARATION. Subpar ingredients with great preparation can still be good, but not close to what it would be with the best ingredients. Philip is talking about the ingredients of the lens leading to better output. I get what you’ve been saying, but a great lens AND great vision will always give better photographs. You’re discounting the lens too much. Yes, his analogy is totally garbage. A spoon has zero affect on the taste of the meal. A lens has a great affect on the aesthetics of an image. To think otherwise is just ignorance.
+1
Incident Light > Subject > Reflected Light > Lens > Film Plane
The lens is an integral part of the image path.
I mean, the decisions of whether to use Spherical elements vs. Aspheric or (extreme) Anamorphic (et al) lenses can provide significantly differentiated images projected on the film plane. Sometimes those differences present a radically different (anamorphic) projection, sometimes they are matters of correction vs. aberration (SA / Glow ... thinking Mandler vs. Karbe), while yet other aspects are more nuanced to taste (bokeh, transition rates, flare, contrast / acutance, color, micro-contrast, etc.) ... BUT, yes the differences in glass / lens design are inescapably an intentionally, inherent, contributing PART of the aesthetic.
For some, the differences don't make a hill of beans to them. For others, their palette is differently considered. If folks want to ignore the fact that some folks have preferential palettes that are different from their "I don't care, it's all the same." perspective ... then they should REALLY ignore the conversation, entirely ... rather than interloping for the sake of interloping.
I am quite certain that my 40/2 Summicron-C renders differently than a Voigt 40/1.2 in this regard ... both shot at equal aperture, e.g. f/2 (i.e. not referring to the larger aperture difference, itself).
I'd gladly put up comps to present for the naysayers, but I don't own the VM (yet). Similarly, that goes for things like the Vintage Line of Voigts vs. the APO Lanthar's, where the Vintage line retains more SA (by intentional design).