fredmiranda.com Login

which lens has the most 3D POP?

  
 
rodenmg
Online
Details
p.170 #1which lens has the most 3D POP?
chiron wrote:
rodenmg wrote
chiron wrote
rodenmg wroteHere's a Fast Fifty comparison of a different type. The Sony GM 50 f1.2 and the Leica Noctilux 50 f0.95 both shot at f1.2 and processed as close to the same as possible using Abobe Standard profile with all effects turned off. Adobe lens correction profiles were used for both. These were shot back to back on a tripod from the same location. Simply swapping one camera for the other.

If you can, put your media view in a constant loop to make things easier.

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1B4mucpDtaPEBmS5W0LYO9_JivcRFf9By/view?usp=sharing

If you want to look at the individual photos they are here in 4K width.
Nice comparison. If you are willing, I would be interested to know how you, as the photographer who is familiar with the lenses and the scene, see the images as different and which image you prefer and for what reasons.
When I have time to focus carefully at closer distances, like portraits and such, I love the rendering of the Leica. I think the difference is obvious here. The smooth and soft but still detailed look and the creamy oof areas can be magic. By comparison the Sony looks to have a bit of pincushion distortion and the Leica a mild barrel effect. I don’t know which is more accurate but the Leica image seems to have more depth. I prefer the Leica.

But when I need to take photos/portraits of kids or impatient adults. I’ll grab the Sony every time because of the autofocus.
Thank you for your reading. I appreciate how you see it. My initial and continuing reaction is to prefer the Sony image, I think because the forms appear more cohesive with the body and less softened by blur so that the body appears consistent with the head.

But I in general also tend to prefer a bit more form and less blur in my bokeh, so personal preferences play a large role here. I also like the figures in my images to appear situated in their physical context.

I'll not in passing that I very much dislike the pasted cut-out
...Show more →
I value your opinion. The Sony 50 1.2 is one of my favorites. When processing images made with it I tend to soften them a bit using negative clarity and texture marking them more “Leica like”.

Good luck with the puppy. They are so sweet but can eat your house.
Nov 16, 2026 at 07:41 AM


FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister