fredmiranda.com Login

which lens has the most 3D POP?

  
 
Daran
Offline
Details
p.152 #1which lens has the most 3D POP?
carstenw wrote:
I am not sure what you mean about my inability to show the 3D effect, due to my lenses with a shared focal length and something about the intensity? That sentence is too complex for me.

The question was whether certain lenses show the 3D in a manner that is unlike other lenses. If this is true, it should be possible to take one lens of each flavor and shoot a scene. Then we could all admire how the "3D" lens shows more depth effect than the "flat" lens and in the future buy those. Instead all we get here are scenes that are shot with only one lens. So even if a 3D effect is observed, it remains unclear how much of that effect is due to the lens. My guess is that only very little of the effect is due to the lens used. So if you see a 3D effect in a scene and shoot it with a different good lens, you would still see it.
Aug 25, 2026 at 06:34 AM
Ripolini
Offline
Details
p.152 #2which lens has the most 3D POP?
Daran wrote:
The question was whether certain lenses show the 3D in a manner that is unlike other lenses. If this is true, it should be possible to take one lens of each flavor and shoot a scene. Then we could all admire how the "3D" lens shows more depth effect than the "flat" lens and in the future buy those. Instead all we get here are scenes that are shot with only one lens. So even if a 3D effect is observed, it remains unclear how much of that effect is due to the lens. My guess is that only very
...Show more →

carstenw wrote:
Nonsense, to determine if a lens has 3D you just look at a photo which demonstrates the 3D, and decide if you agree or disagree.


@Daran@, don't waste your time...
Aug 25, 2026 at 06:47 AM
j4nu
Offline
Details
p.152 #3which lens has the most 3D POP?
Daran wrote:
carstenw wroteI am not sure what you mean about my inability to show the 3D effect, due to my lenses with a shared focal length and something about the intensity? That sentence is too complex for me.
The question was whether certain lenses show the 3D in a manner that is unlike other lenses. If this is true, it should be possible to take one lens of each flavor and shoot a scene. Then we could all admire how the "3D" lens shows more depth effect than the "flat" lens and in the future buy those. Instead all we get here are scenes that are shot with only one lens. So even if a 3D effect is observed, it remains unclear how much of that effect is due to the lens. My guess is that only very
...Show more →

I'm afraid you missed at least Fred's comparison that was linked recently...
Aug 25, 2026 at 07:34 AM
Jack Flesher
Offline
Details
p.152 #4which lens has the most 3D POP?
There is a secret sauce to 3D pop. I use it pretty regularly, but I’m not going to share it. I will give some hints. It can be added to most images. It occurs regularly in many lenses that are regaled as having “3D” or “character.” Look at a few old school paintings from the Dutch masters and you can see that they used it too.
Aug 25, 2026 at 09:28 AM
carstenw
Offline
Details
p.152 #5which lens has the most 3D POP?
Jack Flesher wrote:
There is a secret sauce to 3D pop. I use it pretty regularly, but I’m not going to share it. I will give some hints. It can be added to most images. It occurs regularly in many lenses that are regaled as having “3D” or “character.” Look at a few old school paintings from the Dutch masters and you can see that they used it too.


Would you post one such shot?
Aug 25, 2026 at 11:11 AM
Daran
Offline
Details
p.152 #6which lens has the most 3D POP?
j4nu wrote:
Daran wrote
carstenw wroteI am not sure what you mean about my inability to show the 3D effect, due to my lenses with a shared focal length and something about the intensity? That sentence is too complex for me.
The question was whether certain lenses show the 3D in a manner that is unlike other lenses. If this is true, it should be possible to take one lens of each flavor and shoot a scene. Then we could all admire how the "3D" lens shows more depth effect than the "flat" lens and in the future buy those. Instead all we get here are scenes that are shot with only one lens. So even if a 3D effect is observed, it remains unclear how much of that effect is due to the lens. My guess is that only very little of the effect is due to the lens used. So if you see a 3D effect in a scene and shoot it with a different good lens, you would still see it.
I'm afraid you missed at least Fred's comparison that was linked recently...

Have I? https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1719880/2#15721794 isn't claiming a particular 3D effect to the exclusion of other lenses. Only one looks actually sharp to me, the first of the four looks *very* soft. To my taste all four show a distracting amount of character (aka lens flaws). I guess they would require some stopping down to sharpen up (not the topic here, but may be relevant for the effect). I can see some 3D-ish effect in all but the soft image. Maybe that effect is a tad stronger in what I think the sharpest (second) image, but I would mark that down to that image being less distracting. Is this the special 3D sauce you think I missed?
Aug 25, 2026 at 01:11 PM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.152 #7which lens has the most 3D POP?
The conventional view in this YT video - take compositions that give you 3D, instead of using a suitable lens you actually prefer for your chosen compositions.
..



But at least he acknowledges it exists.
Aug 25, 2026 at 05:51 PM
ruthenium
Offline
Details
p.152 #8which lens has the most 3D POP?
another desperate attempt at 3D...




  GFX100S II    GF55mmF1.7 R WR lens    55mm    f/8.0    1/5s    500 ISO    0.0 EV  

Aug 25, 2026 at 07:11 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.152 #9which lens has the most 3D POP?
Daran wrote:
j4nu wrote
Daran wrote
carstenw wroteI am not sure what you mean about my inability to show the 3D effect, due to my lenses with a shared focal length and something about the intensity? That sentence is too complex for me.
The question was whether certain lenses show the 3D in a manner that is unlike other lenses. If this is true, it should be possible to take one lens of each flavor and shoot a scene. Then we could all admire how the "3D" lens shows more depth effect than the "flat" lens and in the future buy those. Instead all we get here are scenes that are shot with only one lens. So even if a 3D effect is observed, it remains unclear how much of that effect is due to the lens. My guess is that only very little of the effect is due to the lens used. So if you see a 3D effect in a scene and shoot it with a different good lens, you would still see it.
I'm afraid you missed at least Fred's comparison that was linked recently...
Have I? https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1719880/2#15721794 isn't claiming a particular 3D effect to the exclusion of other lenses. Only one looks actually sharp to me, the first of the four looks *very* soft. To my taste all four show a distracting amount of character (aka lens flaws). I guess they would require some stopping down to sharpen up (not the topic here, but may be relevant for the effect). I can see some 3D-ish effect in all but the soft image. Maybe that effect is a tad stronger in what I think the sharpest (second) image, but I would mark that down to
...Show more →

The point of the sharing it ... bearing in mind it wasn't Fred's mission to produce some kind of exceptional 3D shot when he shot those ... the point of me referencing them was to present that it is about as good an A:B comp with the primary diff being the lenses. And, as such ... the amount of diff (none of them super-monster 3D-ish, pop) is a factor of the lens variance used ... inducing the diff as it is presented. Bear in mind that such a difference can be "amplified" or "reduced" by soft vs. contrasty lighting. If these were taken in different lighting, the variance might be even greater ... so, you kinda need to use your noodle a bit when understanding the point of the diff's being a byproduct of the different optic. The point is that the difference IS visible, not that the AMOUNT is tremendous, as the "best" example.

I also linked a previous 50mm (iiirc) shootout (quite some time ago) that one could see some diff's too, but I thought Fred's were "easier" to see how a different lens can contribute to a different amount being realized (under same conditions).
Aug 25, 2026 at 07:29 PM
ZdevilH1
Offline
Details
p.152 #10which lens has the most 3D POP?
Adding another image to the thread, this one shot with the CV 35mm f1.5 on M11D




Aug 25, 2026 at 08:34 PM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

j4nu
Offline
Details
p.152 #11which lens has the most 3D POP?
Daran wrote:
j4nu wrote
Daran wrote
carstenw wroteI am not sure what you mean about my inability to show the 3D effect, due to my lenses with a shared focal length and something about the intensity? That sentence is too complex for me.
The question was whether certain lenses show the 3D in a manner that is unlike other lenses. If this is true, it should be possible to take one lens of each flavor and shoot a scene. Then we could all admire how the "3D" lens shows more depth effect than the "flat" lens and in the future buy those. Instead all we get here are scenes that are shot with only one lens. So even if a 3D effect is observed, it remains unclear how much of that effect is due to the lens. My guess is that only very little of the effect is due to the lens used. So if you see a 3D effect in a scene and shoot it with a different good lens, you would still see it.
I'm afraid you missed at least Fred's comparison that was linked recently...
Have I? https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1719880/2#15721794 isn't claiming a particular 3D effect to the exclusion of other lenses. Only one looks actually sharp to me, the first of the four looks *very* soft. To my taste all four show a distracting amount of character (aka lens flaws). I guess they would require some stopping down to sharpen up (not the topic here, but may be relevant for the effect). I can see some 3D-ish effect in all but the soft image. Maybe that effect is a tad stronger in what I think the sharpest (second) image, but I would mark that down to
...Show more →

Yes, I already said it's not the best "3D pop" example, but it shows differences between various lenses.
So, there actually are some rare comparisons between lenses posted in this thread ...
Aug 26, 2026 at 03:09 AM
Jonas B
Offline
Details
p.152 #12which lens has the most 3D POP?
I suspect that whatever anyone posts in the way of comparisons between a couple lenses will be condemned as useless. There will for sure be something wrong about the light, the target(s), the distances between everything in the image. There may also be something wrong with the location, the time of the year, the cardinal directions or some never heard of magnetic field.

If nothing of that fails we'll see a period of general confusion until a lens costing not less than [currency or grams] 1.800 is mentioned as the best one in general but unfortunately limited when it comes to 3D rendering.
Aug 26, 2026 at 03:18 AM
Nifty Fifty
Offline
Details
p.152 #13which lens has the most 3D POP?
Well, to be honest, even a direct 1:1 comparison would merely prove that Lens A performs "better" than Lens B for that specific subject setup. If one were to change nothing but the distance to the subject for a second comparison, the result could well differ—or even be reversed. This point has already been made here, and I fully agree with it. For this reason, I personally consider the current discussion completely pointless. You can show images and discuss whether the chosen lens suggests more spatial depth than another in that specific scene and under those exact conditions—but that is really all there is to it.
Aug 26, 2026 at 03:30 AM
Jonas B
Offline
Details
p.152 #14which lens has the most 3D POP?
Nifty Fifty wrote:
Well, to be honest, even a direct 1:1 comparison would merely prove that Lens A performs "better" than Lens B for that specific subject setup. If one were to change nothing but the distance to the subject for a second comparison, the result could well differ—or even be reversed. This point has already been made here, and I fully agree with it. For this reason, I personally consider the current discussion completely pointless. You can show images and discuss whether the chosen lens suggests more spatial depth than another in that specific scene and under those exact conditions—but that
...Show more →

That is all true.
It is also true that we'll see differences between lenses.

My favorite lenses are all chosen for one reason or another, for example be it lack of CA or good ergonomics. Any special consideration of ability to render 3D has never been on the table.
Aug 26, 2026 at 03:35 AM
Daran
Offline
Details
p.152 #15which lens has the most 3D POP?
RustyBug wrote:
[The point of the sharing it ... bearing in mind it wasn't Fred's mission to produce some kind of exceptional 3D shot when he shot those ... the point of me referencing them was to present that it is about as good an A:B comp with the primary diff being the lenses. And, as such ... the amount of diff (none of them super-monster 3D-ish, pop) is a factor of the lens variance used ... inducing the diff as it is presented.

Well, on an abstract level, sure. What I'm seeing in this example though is merely that if a lens performs so bad in a scene, that I would consider it unusable (at least with the given settings), it can also destroy a 3D effect otherwise present in the scene. This is not a comparison with a decent modern lens. If we exclude the first, than there is still some difference in 3D, but this still seems to correspond merely to two of them being soft (by modern standards). I have no doubt that some old school piece of window glass may not show what decent lenses can.

Bear in mind that such a difference can be "amplified" or "reduced" by soft vs. contrasty lighting. If these were taken in different lighting, the variance might be even greater ... so, you kinda need to use your noodle a bit when understanding the point of the diff's being a byproduct of the different optic. The point is that the difference IS visible, not that the AMOUNT is tremendous, as the "best" example.
Show a better comparison then. One where all lenses involved manage to be reasonably sharp on the subject. You think this too big of an ask?

I also linked a previous 50mm (iiirc) shootout (quite some time ago) that one could see some diff's too, but I thought Fred's were "easier" to see how a different lens can contribute to a different amount being realized (under same conditions).
For other lens criteria folks come up with some type of comparison that will highlight the difference. Works for reflections, LACA, LOCA, sharpness, Bokeh, etc. Not for 3D pop. Does that not make you pause?

PS: no idea why you think my "noodle" needs mentioning here.
Aug 26, 2026 at 06:27 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.152 #16which lens has the most 3D POP?
Nifty Fifty wrote:
Well, to be honest, even a direct 1:1 comparison would merely prove that Lens A performs "better" than Lens B for that specific subject setup. If one were to change nothing but the distance to the subject for a second comparison, the result could well differ—or even be reversed. This point has already been made here, and I fully agree with it. For this reason, I personally consider the current discussion completely pointless. You can show images and discuss whether the chosen lens suggests more spatial depth than another in that specific scene and under those exact conditions—but that
...Show more →


I do think there is some degree of merit point here ... that finding the "sweet" spot of a given lens ... lenses can have different sweet spots for which they are optimized. Where one lens may be optimized for portrait distances, another may be optimized for landscape (macro being, yet another). How the lens performs ... relative to its design choices ... in context of application. Yes, another variable in play.

I recall having a few different lenses over the years that I came to understand that their "sweet spots" were indeed different ... in general, but also as the matter of micro-contrast, field curvature, SA, etc. changed, the influence on rate of change can shift, as well. We'll never come to a consensus, but I still find that lens design has a contributing factor, even if it may be variable or the "last" leg of impact.

From a process perspective, it goes crudely like this:

Light > subject > composition > lens > processing.

The culmination of their contributions has impact on the varying rates of change that become the final image. Keep everything the same, except change one variable ... i.e. change the lighting from diffuse / overcast to specular, sunny or dim, blue hour ... and the levels of contrast in the final image change, as you changed the contrast levels reaching the lens, then the lens passing it onward, with its level of contribution. So, for those who do advocate that there are other factors ... indeed, there are.

My point of the A:B was that the non-lens contributions were largely unchanged, thus the diff's being attributed to the optic.

Now, finding a pair of lenses that someone owns that will be used for an A:B that offers such a clear differentiation ... elusive to a degree. Personally, I don't think it is a matter of non-existence, but a matter of (1) ownership, and (2) mitigation of factors that convolute other folks perceptions. Case in point, the softer light of Fred's car has folks thinking the lens is soft. When, if you shot those same lenses in more specular (higher contrast) lighting, the resultant being perceptually attributed to the lens (insert noodle) would likely be different from dismissive of them being "soft".

So, yeah ... we've gone a long way, and still don't have consensus. I get that. But, I also get that there are a litany of images that we see as "repeaters" that folks like to use, in the matter. And, certainly, there are a corresponding litany of folks who couldn't give a rat's backside about it. To that end, consensus will never be reached. But, even so ... I still regard the lens as part of the optical chain, with its contributing factors in play. Isolating those factors for decisive clarity of causation has been a challenge, and may be one that is never fully achieved.

But, folks still are keen to the physiological response, so as we aspire to develop an increased understanding of optical influence ... I see this as more of an "how much more can we learn" about it, vs. the "no it doesn't, yes it does, this is pointless" perspective. I mean, optical engineers / designers have worked on this for decades, and the nuances and combinations of today's soup-mix are vast. Except for the ardent naysayers, some folks find it an interesting topic of discussion, trying to advance their understanding of the optical contribution.

So, yeah the point about application of the optic does factor in along with (aligning to vs. against) optimization of a given optic design. In part, I think that is where we get certain folks, with certain lenses that are regular producers of the perception. To that point, I can go WAY BACK to Paul Yi ... he had it dialed in with his glass.

So, if we desire to ascribe that "all can" (not fully there, but I'll run with it), then maybe the discussion shifts to finding the "where" do they, vs. which ones can. Still, keeping the point of the discussion to advance understanding, vs. intent to dismiss or retard development of understanding of optical influence.

Aug 26, 2026 at 07:17 AM
Daran
Offline
Details
p.152 #17which lens has the most 3D POP?
RustyBug wrote:
Now, finding a pair of lenses that someone owns that will be used for an A:B that offers such a clear differentiation ... elusive to a degree. Personally, I don't think it is a matter of non-existence, but a matter of (1) ownership, and (2) mitigation of factors that convolute other folks perceptions.

I understand how many happen to have only a single good lens and hence no equipment to compare to. What I do not understand is how this is apparently all of those claiming to own 3D popping lenses and how they think they would even know their single lens is doing something particular.

Case in point, the softer light of Fred's car has folks thinking the lens is soft. When, if you shot those same lenses in more specular (higher contrast) lighting, the resultant being perceptually attributed to the lens (insert noodle) would likely be different from dismissive of them being "soft".
I rather doubt that. While there are indeed all sorts of effects that can influence the perception of sharpness (like your soft light), closer inspection can still reveal actual sharpness or lack thereof. Like with these images.
Aug 26, 2026 at 08:04 AM
carstenw
Offline
Details
p.152 #18which lens has the most 3D POP?
Nifty Fifty wrote:
Well, to be honest, even a direct 1:1 comparison would merely prove that Lens A performs "better" than Lens B for that specific subject setup. If one were to change nothing but the distance to the subject for a second comparison, the result could well differ—or even be reversed. This point has already been made here, and I fully agree with it. For this reason, I personally consider the current discussion completely pointless. You can show images and discuss whether the chosen lens suggests more spatial depth than another in that specific scene and under those exact conditions—but that
...Show more →

Well... we can show images! Lots of them.
Aug 26, 2026 at 11:13 AM
macwest
Offline
Details
p.152 #19which lens has the most 3D POP?
You want 3d pop shoot with flash.
Aug 26, 2026 at 11:16 AM
carstenw
Offline
Details
p.152 #20which lens has the most 3D POP?
Daran wrote:
I understand how many happen to have only a single good lens and hence no equipment to compare to. What I do not understand is how this is apparently all of those claiming to own 3D popping lenses and how they think they would even know their single lens is doing something particular.


I almost never walk out just to test equipment, life is too short for that, and thus I don't carry two identical lenses (for example 35mm f/1,4) basically ever.

However, I do go out with my Voigtländer 35mm f/1,4 Classic from time to time, and I never see 3D from it, whereas I will definitely see it with my Contax 35mm f/1,4.

That is how.
Aug 26, 2026 at 11:19 AM


FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister