carstenw wrote:
Jojib, in these shots (very nice btw) I see lots of subject separation via depth of field and boke, but not much 3D look in the sense that I, and some others, mean it. When I speak of 3D, I mean that the photo looks almost exactly as it would if it was right in front of me, a kind of mind trick, and I get the feel that I am not looking at a photograph, but a real 3-dimensional object right in front of me, as if the photo was a glass-less window.
That’s right; some people—including quite a few professional photographers—confuse the three-dimensionality of an image (or the 3D pop of a camera lens) with the separation of the subject from a background that remains fairly distinct.
As I wrote a few hundred posts ago, there are lenses that produce a 3D pop/rendering even at f/11... while others, which should be thrown away, have abrupt transitions between the in-focus plane and the progressively out-of-focus planes.
This does not mean that photographing a model with a fast lens, using a wide aperture, is not worthwhile or does not produce pleasing images that show us the scene in a way different from how we are accustomed to observing reality.
3D pop and subject isolation from the background are different aspects of photography.
It also happens that images in which the subject is clearly separated from the background tend to look flat.
carstenw wrote:
... I remember doing this in the old days, like with this Citroën, photographed with the 50 Planar and the 50 Makro-Planar, I think both at f/2:
They don't appear to have been taken with the same aperture. The depth of field is quite different (it's much greater in the second image).