pdmphoto wrote:
There would not be any "jaggies" on this picture without an AA filter. There is nothing that approaches the nyquist frequency of the sensor (which can produce moire) . Take the same pic with a Kodak SLR/c and you will see a big difference in edge accutance. Even the Canon 5DII doesn't have the same ability (I own both).
I have used both cameras but sold my SLR/c a while ago. The same pic taken with each camera and the same lens would result in only a small (but often noticeable) difference in edge acutance.
However, when the images from each camera are appropriately processed, that small difference ... or even a big difference when viewed on-screen ... is almost entirely wiped out when making prints. I've compared, tested, printed, compared, tested, printed til I'm blue in the face, and I can tell you that the lack of AA filter — for all of its seeming virtues — just doesn't make much difference when images are printed either on an ink jet or in magazines ... especially when printed in magazines.
Believe me, if the SLR/c were all that superior I would have kept it. And even if it can be proven to be superior with its sans-AA-filter design, that superiority goes out the window at any ISO over 640, where the camera's color shifts, noise and reduced D/R pretty much negate the value, if any, of its naked sensor.
- Steve