Lotusm50 wrote:
garydavidjones wrote
With 46 MP crammed into APS-C and
j.liam wrote
No knock on Sigma lenses because some of them are fine optics, but at a stated 46MP very few, if any can deliver quality optical information to do the sensor justice. OK. Let's be clear on this, as it appears that Sigma marketing is marking some headway in perceptions. They are no cramming 46 mp in to APS-c. They are cramming 16mp on to APS-c. (each of these 16mp has a stack of 3 color receptors). So rather than having to resolve 46mp in an APS-c space, lenses really only have to resolve 16mp on an APS-c space.
I dont understand why this keeps cropping up because the way Foveon X3 sensor pixels are counted is actually exactly the same as Bayer sensor pixels are counted, ie, they count the total number of photodiodes on the sensor.
Sigma are not being inacurate in saying the SD1 has 46mp, because it does actually have 46 million pixels, being equal amounts of Red, Green and Blue over three layers.
However, Bayer sensors do not have equal amounts of red, green and blue pixels..50% are green, 25% are red and 25% are blue.
A fictional 46mp Bayer sensor would share the same percentages and so that translates as 23mp green, 11.5mp red and 11.5mp blue.
This fictional Bayer sensor only has higher resolution than the SD1 in the green channel but its has somewhat lower resolution than the SD1 in the red and blue channels...This gives a colour resolution advantage to the SD1.
The consumer is'nt told this fact when they buy a camera using a Bayer sensor so if anyones being inacurate...It is'nt Sigma/Foveon.