fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2010 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2010Sigma SD1

  
 
trdonja
Offline
Details
p.7 #1Sigma SD1
Lotusm50 wrote:
trdonja wrote
carstenw wroteYou don't like blurring a part of your photo, but have no problem blurring *all* of your photo? You do know what an AA filter is, right?
Hehe, good question, but I think it is one of those "don't take it too literally" things. We could make a case, that WHOLE photo is blurred even without AA filter. Any photo can appear blurred under certain conditions. What is blurred and what is not blurred is relative and even subjective. So let's not go down that road. I think you do know what I talked about, and there is no reason to misunderstand me on purpose.
I think he understood you just fine. The choice, as Carsten put it is, 1) blur the entire image with the AA filter, or 2) blur only part of the image and only when you need to which is potentially rarely. To me, the choice is a no brainer, especially after my experience with a non-AA camera.

Ok and I still disagree and I think that to say that is rhetorical wizardry, which doesn't have much to do with the subject. Kind of like my philosophical response, that what is blurred and what not is relative in any case. Technically very true, but it doesn't bring much to a real life discussion.

Whether you'll see moiré depends entirely on the subject you're shooting. I saw some pictures here on FM, made with the SLR/c, showing a man with a jacket with some fine pattern on it and the false color was quite ugly (I don't recall that it really had a moire pattern).
I wanted to say the same, but I forgot earlier. My last trip definitely would not be very friendly to all cameras without AA filter.

Anyway, to me it says a lot that even companies that are offering DSLR's with AA filter removed are very clear about the moire problem and I saw some ugly examples on a site of such company. They don't try to hide it, simply to avoid clients feeling cheated. They show bad examples with a note: "It can happen". The only fair thing, then it is up to every person to decide if he wants that or not. I don't feel there is a "correct" or "wrong" decision here.
Sep 24, 2010 at 01:12 PM
Pavel
Offline
Details
p.7 #2Sigma SD1
The way Steve put his comment, I can see things from his perspective. Yeah, I guess 16 megapixels on the spec sheets would have been long term much smarter.

But now to get past that, I personally feel that the benefits of the Sigma may be worthwhile if it is similar to, and perhaps improved over the old models they offered. I used to like my canon mkii files for portraits but not for things with texture. That is just me, lets say - but I do feel that as time goes by we have cameras that are mostly all very capable as "all around" cameras. A bit of a difference here ... and there ... but mostly until one takes the finantial dive with Medium format, goes back to film or buys one of the camera bodies that march to a different set of beliefs such as the Leicas we have much the same advantages and disadvantages in 99 percent of our choices.

That is why I hope the Sigma is more than it likely will be. THey seem to perhaps have given us a trully stark difference if we buy into it. The body is relatively inexpensive (I'd guess less than two thousand) and a few lenses just for it opens up new vistas - perhaps.

So if it turns out that they have a very crisp per pixel rendition of the scene, I think we are missing the boat if we argue the merrits/liabilities of the AA filter. Lets consider the merrit of having a choice away from strong AA filters - for when that is worth the trouble.

Heck I'd even go so far as to say that I WANT lousy high iso performance. Sure ... if they leave micro lenses off the dang thing, who knows ... it may just be a nice gutsy way of concentrating on the last ounce of LOW iso performance.

I do hope however that they have made the ergonomics a wee bit better.

I wonder what the viewfinder will be like and the responsiveness. Battery life? All these details may be more important that what we have focused on so far. A D700 killer ... I don't think so. But perhaps a great D700 or 5D mkii alternate day body, alternate look sensor. The more different and niche the better. What could be wrong with that?
Sep 24, 2010 at 02:08 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.7 #3Sigma SD1
veroman wrote:
And, by the way, we're "wrapped up" in megapixels 'cause it's an important spec, no matter how it's determined. It's a pretty standard guideline when we're trying to come to terms with things like cropping room, file size, print size, resolution of fine detail (although we can't always correlate MP count with resolving detail), etc. I didn't buy a 5D II just because it was 21MP. I bought it because it provided files that my clients could crop with ease and still have a high quality image.

Besides, if anybody's wrapped up in megapixels, it's Sigma! 46MP? Wow. And why? Who
...Show more →

I would disagree concerning the use of MP as a yardstick for measuring a files ability to be printed at a specific size, particularly in the case of foveon vs bayer. The reason it has worked as a rough yardstick in your case is that you stuck with the exact same technology. Canon CMOS. That's much more an apples to apples comparison. Start comparing a Kodak 10MP ccd that has no aa filter to Canon Cmos and the difference in sensor technology and implementation begins to skew the one to one relationship. The same logic applies here. One simply can't make a direct comparison based solely upon MP when the underlying sensor technology and implementation is dramatically different.

I do think there is a large group of pro's and advanced amateurs who can't afford 10,000+ MF digital backs who now use the highest end DSLR's with the best glass in order to eek out as much quality possible from these systems for their landscape and studio work. If a camera came around that offered significantly better image quality then what they are currently using, I don't think it would matter who makes it as long as it proved reasonably reliable!

Sep 24, 2010 at 02:17 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.7 #4Sigma SD1
carstenw wrote:
There is software out there which handles the gentle blurring of moire admirably, and lots of high-end pros use it every day, for example Phocus for Hasselblad cameras, or Capture One for Phase One cameras.


In my experience, such software works most of the time but when it doesn't, man it really doesn't and the file will require some major time to fix (and of course, your not truly fixing things but hiding them).
Sep 24, 2010 at 02:27 PM
veroman
Offline
Details
p.7 #5Sigma SD1
Lotusm50 wrote:
The 'artifacts" or moire occur only rarely and can be handled with software. Ask any Leica M9 or Kodak SLR/n user or any user of medium format digital back. I have a Kodak SLR/n which doesn't have an AA filer, and so far I've never had a problem with moire.


Moire cannot be handled with software. The moire pattern can only be heavily blurred or obscured in some other way, leaving the affected area of the image looking nothing like the original and heavily retouched to boot. That's not a good solution.

I might add that moire existed long before digital and was a recurring problem when certain patterns criss-crossed with printer's screening.

Moire as a potential problem also isn't limited to cameras with no AA filter. I experienced many instances of moire with my Canon 5D ... most notably when photographing a room with sheer curtains or screen doors that had a particular construction pattern.

And I did own the Kodak SLR/c for a time ... the Canon-mount version of your SLR/n (a great camera up to ISO 640 but plagued with problems other than noise). I had quite a few instances of moire with that camera.

- Steve
Sep 24, 2010 at 02:29 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.7 #6Sigma SD1
Pavel wrote:
Heck I'd even go so far as to say that I WANT lousy high iso performance. Sure ... if they leave micro lenses off the dang thing, who knows ... it may just be a nice gutsy way of concentrating on the last ounce of LOW iso performance.



+1 Hey, I like how you think!
Sep 24, 2010 at 02:32 PM
Daniel Heineck
Offline
Details
p.7 #7Sigma SD1
Except good microlenses are the last thing I'd get rid of. Trust me, they're definitely not the problem. Foveon technology DEPENDS on them, desperately.

I appreciate the sentiment, but things that will make a foveon sensor better at low isos will also help a ton at high isos. There's no CFA to mess with here, folks.
Sep 24, 2010 at 02:38 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.7 #8Sigma SD1
Daniel Heineck wrote:
I appreciate the sentiment, but things that will make a foveon sensor better at low isos will also help a ton at high isos. There's no CFA to mess with here, folks.


That's a good point as it seems that with a bayer sensor, there is a trade off between a light CFA (5DII for instance which offers very good high ISO but not so good color and low iso quality) and a denser CFA (Sony FF which offers superb color and good low ISO but not so hot high ISO.) So, the CFA has to be optimized for one or the other it would seem. Or am I wrong?
Sep 24, 2010 at 02:45 PM
Daniel Heineck
Offline
Details
p.7 #9Sigma SD1
That's a good summary.
Sep 24, 2010 at 02:46 PM
pascal03
Offline
Details
p.7 #10Sigma SD1
Back end of the discussion here..... but I for one am impressed with Sigma's new 16MPx3 SLR. I am a big fan of the DP1 and DP2s compacts and own both. They both offer superb lenses.

With the release of this camera, I now can hope for a similar sensor on the compacts - which should kill just about any competition out there in this category.
Sep 24, 2010 at 02:47 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.7 #11Sigma SD1
pascal03 wrote:
With the release of this camera, I now can hope for a similar sensor on the compacts - which should kill just about any competition out there in this category.


Frankly, I would not hold my breath for that to happen. I would imagine the processing power/heat required might be too much for a compact DP at this point for Sigma. Think the DP's are slow...imagine what it might be with this new chip. Plus, we are talking Sigma here. Maybe five years from now?
Sep 24, 2010 at 02:54 PM
phidong
Offline
Details
p.7 #12Sigma SD1
Yeah the SD1 has two true processors. I'm not sure Sigma would put two into the DP series.. perhaps when the next version of TRUE comes out it could be feasible.. or leave the DP series at 1.7x crop for a more manageable ~11mp?
Sep 24, 2010 at 04:07 PM
Yakim Peled
Offline
Details
p.7 #13Sigma SD1
trdonja wrote:
Yakim Peled wroteI wonder if anyone ever made a comparison between a Sigma camera and a regular bayer camera without the AA filter. I mean, if all or most of the difference stem from this why not just take a regular bayer camera and remove its AA filter.

Happy shooting,
Yakim.
Because Bayer filter is there for a reason. It is needed there, or else some pretty nasty artifacts appear. Google it, you will find plenty of photos with filter removed.


Humble apologies if I am mistaken but have you read my question? I've seen plenty of such pictures but have yet to find a direct comparison.

Happy shooting,
Yakim.
Sep 25, 2010 at 07:02 PM
Pixel Perfect
Offline
Details
p.7 #14Sigma SD1
veroman wrote:
Lotusm50 wroteThe 'artifacts" or moire occur only rarely and can be handled with software. Ask any Leica M9 or Kodak SLR/n user or any user of medium format digital back. I have a Kodak SLR/n which doesn't have an AA filer, and so far I've never had a problem with moire.
Moire as a potential problem also isn't limited to cameras with no AA filter. I experienced many instances of moire with my Canon 5D ... most notably when photographing a room with sheer curtains or screen doors that had a particular construction pattern.

- Steve


If you do insect macros, moire in insect eyes can be a real pain and very hard if not impossible to remove.
Sep 26, 2010 at 09:36 PM
davidahn
Offline
Details
p.7 #15Sigma SD1
The Bayer "filter" is not only necessary, but with a single 1-layer sensor, removing the Bayer filter removes your color. Removing the Bayer filter would make a killer B&W camera, but not many people would buy such a one-trick pony. See the diagram of a Bayer sensor, maybe you'll better understand why it's necessary and why Foveon is so awesome with full resolution color at every pixel:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bayer_filter

Alternatives to the Bayer filter: 1) 3-CMOS sensors with light splitter; 2) take 3 images in rapid succession with R-G-B color filters; 3) Foveon. With full frame sensors, there's simply no space to split the beam and have 3 separate sensors in current camera bodies (not sure about APS-C sensors), and 3 images in rapid succession would only work for VERY still subjects.

The moire effect you see is created by the Bayer sensor, not by the antialiasing filter. The AA filter attempts to reduce it.

David
Sep 27, 2010 at 12:08 PM
kwalsh
Offline
Details
p.7 #16Sigma SD1
davidahn wrote:
The moire effect you see is created by the Bayer sensor, not by the antialiasing filter. The AA filter attempts to reduce it.


At the risk of being way too pedantic, moire exists in both the Foveon and Bayer imagers, and in fact in any spatial sampling imager without adequate anti-alias filtering. The Bayer imagers can produce chroma moire from monochromatic subjects, which when it happens can be very obvious and objectionable. The Foveon won't produce the chroma moire, but since the Sigma cameras use no AA filter they can produce luminance moire - which is usually less noticeable and not nearly so objectionable.

But, yes, the larger point is exactly correct. AA filters don't cause moire, they are in fact there to try to prevent it!

And sorry for being a nitpicker .

Ken
Sep 27, 2010 at 12:19 PM
phigment
Offline
Details
p.7 #17Sigma SD1
davidahn wrote:
The moire effect you see is created by the Bayer sensor, not by the antialiasing filter. The AA filter attempts to reduce it.

David


The moire effect is created by having discreet sampling points. It will be visible on the faveon sensor as well. Mind you, you will only see luminance moire, and not colour moire.

Paul

Edit: Haha Ken, you beat me to it... with a better explanation.

Edited on Sep 27, 2010 at 12:27 PM · View previous versions
Sep 27, 2010 at 12:25 PM
carstenw
Offline
Details
p.7 #18Sigma SD1
The moire effect you see is created by the Bayer sensor, not by the antialiasing filter. The AA filter attempts to reduce it.

Well, no. The Bayer sensor doesn't create the moire, the undersampling of the signal does, i.e. the pixel spacing relative to the frequency content of the world. You need to sample at above twice the frequency of the highest frequency part of the signal to have no aliasing, yet as the frequency content of a normal scene can contain frequencies of practically infinity, you can get moire. You can also get moire with a Foveon sensor, since the light-sensitive part doesn't cover the whole area that the pixel represents. An AA filter can in theory bring the frequency content down to below half the frequency of the pixel grid, but in practice they are not normally that strong, so some aliasing will still make it through. Even cameras like the Canon 5D can generate moire. I had some photos like that.

I replaced the Canon 5D with a Leica M8. I would rather have full-time sharpness and part-time moire than full-time softness and somewhat less moire. In practice, I have rarely seen moire in my M8 photos. It can be annoying, true, but I appreciate the sharpness on every shot. The 5D was just disappointing in that regard. I actually sent a concerned email to Canon about the lack of sharpness of my brand-new camera, and I never really recovered from the disappointment that this was normal.

[Edit: Bah, Ken and Paul got there before me ]
Sep 27, 2010 at 12:27 PM
davidahn
Offline
Details
p.7 #19Sigma SD1
I for one am SUPER excited by the SD1. For years, Foveon has failed to keep up in the megapixel race. Yes, they have more color resolution (chroma data), but lagged way behind in image resolution (luma data). With the 3x15.4MP sensor, the slight loss of luma data is EASILY outweighed by the HUGE jump in true, uninterpolated chroma data.

The 5D Mark II, for example, is a 5.3 MP Red-Blue, 10.7 MP Green, 21.3MP B&W camera. Sadly, because the 5D is full-frame, has awesome high-ISO performance, and does video, I can't get rid of it when the SD1 comes out.

The big questions for me are: 1) how is the quality of each pixel's red, blue, and green channels? 2) how is the high-ISO performance? and 3) what FPS and how good is the autofocus? I was seriously considering a 7D as my walkaround camera because of its high FPS and the Canon 15-55 f/2.8 IS, but the SD1 just might be calling my name.
Sep 27, 2010 at 12:35 PM
carstenw
Offline
Details
p.7 #20Sigma SD1
I share your excitement with the sensor to a large extent, but my excitement is severely tempered by Sigma's past attempts. If Nikon were to use this sensor for something, I would try to scrape together the cash to get one, but I guess I will sit the SD1 out on the sidelines.
Sep 27, 2010 at 12:51 PM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister