fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2010 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2010Sigma SD1

  
 
rhameed
Offline
Details
p.6 #1Sigma SD1
With the bayer pattern the quality of the reconstruction will also vary depending on the statistics of the underlying image. As an extreme hypothetical example if you have a scene which only has shades of blue with no red or green then a 16MP bayer sensor will essentially become close to a 4MP sensor from a resolution perspective. The red and green dots will not add too much information in that case. It should similarly be possible to construct hypothetical scenarios where the interpolation scheme will be able to do a near perfect reconstruction getting close to true 16MP resolution.

And I am sure the reconstruction quality from foveon sensors must also depend on some image characteristics in its own way.

Off course real-world images are typically not going to be extreme cases like the shades-of-blue example and it is likely that the interpolation can do a great job for most "average" real world scenes. But the point is that it might be hard to concretely define the resolution available from bayer versus X3 sensors.
Sep 23, 2010 at 05:04 PM
kwalsh
Offline
Details
p.6 #2Sigma SD1
theSuede wrote:
This means that you triple the amount of electrical noise per pixel, and loose about 1Ev efficiency compared to a normal Bayer sensor (which explains the poor high ISO performance and to use as kind words as possible - special - colour rendition)


Not triple. Noise adds in quadrature.

But yes, the off axis terms in the color transform essentially have a noise amplification effect. This is the same effect that happens in CMY Bayer arrays. A few of these were made about a decade ago with the idea that you'd have better noise performance than RGB because you'd be filtering fewer photons out. Of course it didn't actually help much at all in the end because of the color transform issues.

A number of the Foveon boosters make a big deal about how the imager should have a noise advantage over Bayer because of the lack of filters. While this is certainly true to a degree it ignores the details of the stack pixel sensor itself and what other negative impacts there may be in a stacked pixel versus flat pixel design. The reality is theory needs to take a back seat to what the results in the camera actually are.

Bayer interpolation, especially in some RAW converters, is getting quite impressive as far as luminance recovery goes. Resolving up to 80% of Nyquist is achievable if the sensor's AA filter will allow it. That still gives the Foveon imager about a 1.5 multiplier in effective MP as far as luminance resolving power compared to a Bayer imager, not earth shattering but worth keeping track of. A Foveon fan would break out a resolution chart made of red lines on a blue background at this point in the discussion .

Anyway, like everyone else I'll be really curious to see the results from the SD1 when it hits the market.

Ken
Sep 23, 2010 at 10:09 PM
Mike V
Offline
Details
p.6 #3Sigma SD1
Sigma would have a lot more credibility if they stopped saying this camera was 46 Mega pixel.
Sep 24, 2010 at 06:28 AM
veroman
Offline
Details
p.6 #4Sigma SD1
kwalsh wrote:
..... A Foveon fan would break out a resolution chart made of red lines on a blue background at this point in the discussion
Ken


!!!
Sep 24, 2010 at 06:30 AM
veroman
Offline
Details
p.6 #5Sigma SD1
Mike V wrote:
Sigma would have a lot more credibility if they stopped saying this camera was 46 Mega pixel.


They have consistently used the 3X multiplier to establish their "MP count" due to the 3-layer design. The SD9, their first DSLR, was released as a 10MP camera. It wasn't.

- Steve
Sep 24, 2010 at 06:33 AM
Pavel
Offline
Details
p.6 #6Sigma SD1
Mike V wrote:
Sigma would have a lot more credibility if they stopped saying this camera was 46 Mega pixel.



No, no they would not. For most detractors it would have to have Nikon or Canon on the front. Instant credibility then -even before the first picture. Much like the belief that the D300 is better than the D200 and that the D800 will be better than the D700.

Tape Nikon or Canon on the front for instant success.
Then the majority of the insecure would trumpet 46 megapixels or whatever without prompting, without doubt. It would be taken at face value - just as the bayer is, but of course it would be better because it is new.
Sep 24, 2010 at 07:33 AM
Pavel
Offline
Details
p.6 #7Sigma SD1
I suppose Steve you had a SD14 or SD15 - or both ... right? Right!

Why are some wrapped up in megapixels? There are 46 light capturing photosites on the sensor. Do you dispute that?

So why not leave it alone. You don't seem to pixel peep the theory behind the bayer, which makes laughable claims in the same vein though the details are different.

Do you pause to think that some of you are seeming to find a bone of contention about 15 versus 45 megapixels as if it had some taint on the camera's performance due to the moniker Sigma chose.
Hey ... lets just call it a 15 megapixel sensor ok? I wonder how that will deliver compared to your Canon or panasonic 12 or so megapixel green, blue and red guestimator?

The issue here is a new technology still viable after some doubt. Kind of like Nikon finally giving us a new 85 f/1.4 (some of us doubted that it would EVER come )

This camera could suck, or it could deliver some, who are not content with the current state of low iso performance, out of anti-alias hell. Don't know which it will be. But I do know that the naming scheme, and whether they are "True" 46 megapixel bodies - won't matter squat.
Sep 24, 2010 at 07:42 AM
veroman
Offline
Details
p.6 #8Sigma SD1
Pavel wrote:
I suppose Steve you had a SD14 or SD15 - or both ... right? Right! Why are some wrapped up in megapixels? There are 46 light capturing photosites on the sensor. Do you dispute that? So why not leave it alone. You don't seem to pixel peep the theory behind the bayer, which makes laughable claims in the same vein though the details are different. Do you pause to think that some of you are seeming to find a bone of contention about 15 versus 45 megapixels as if it had some taint on the camera's performance due to the
...Show more →

I had the SD14 ... for a time. I gave up on it after a couple of weeks.

As far as MP count goes, I agree with you to a point. My first Sigma ... the SD9 ... easily out-resolved most other cameras of the day, and I could print huge without much noticeable deterioration. Whether or not it was a 10.2MP camera or a 3.4 almost seemed irrelevant when I considered the quality of the images.

But the SD14 ... a 14MP camera according to Sigma ... didn't seem to offer a significant increase in resolution compared to its 10MP predecessors; hardly noticeable at all, in fact ... while an increase from 10MP to 15MP with a Canon or Nikon is definitely noticeable and usually beneficial. I don't know why this is so 'cause I'm not really all that technical. I'm a photographer. All I care about is image quality and the ergonomics of the thing. I just didn't see the 14MP of the SD14 as an improvement over the 10.2 of the earlier models.

So when Sigma now says 46MP, I can't help but wonder if we'll see the same kind of quantum leap in resolution if we were going by our experience with Bayer increases ... ie, if and when Canon or Nikon come out with a 46MP camera, you can be damned sure we'll see the increased resolution in the images. Not so sure with the Sigma ... based on what I experienced (or didn't experience) with the SD14. I mean, my 5D II is 21MP, and I can really see the benefit of those 21MP over the 12MP of my 5D Classic. Will we see the same from the Sigma? Time will tell.

And, by the way, we're "wrapped up" in megapixels 'cause it's an important spec, no matter how it's determined. It's a pretty standard guideline when we're trying to come to terms with things like cropping room, file size, print size, resolution of fine detail (although we can't always correlate MP count with resolving detail), etc. I didn't buy a 5D II just because it was 21MP. I bought it because it provided files that my clients could crop with ease and still have a high quality image.

Besides, if anybody's wrapped up in megapixels, it's Sigma! 46MP? Wow. And why? Who needs it? Do they think pros are going to move over from their high MP medium format Hassies and Mamiyas for a Sigma? Not on your life. I'd say that, among camera makers, Sigma is more caught up in MP count than any of them. Why didn't they just call the SD1 a 16MP camera and be done with it? What's wrong with offering a 16MP camera? Look at what Nikon's 12MP cameras can do!

- Steve
Sep 24, 2010 at 08:16 AM
Lotusm50
Offline
Details
p.6 #9Sigma SD1
Pavel wrote:
No, no they would not. For most detractors it would have to have Nikon or Canon on the front. Instant credibility then -even before the first picture. Much like the belief that the D300 is better than the D200 and that the D800 will be better than the D700.

Tape Nikon or Canon on the front for instant success.
Then the majority of the insecure would trumpet 46 megapixels or whatever without prompting, without doubt. It would be taken at face value - just as the bayer is, but of course it would be better because it is new.



That seems a bit jaded. I also don't think it is fair or accurate and your model-number analogy flawed.

I do agree that Sigma would have it more credibility if they promoted this as a 16mp in line with the way most people think of a "pixel", rather than what is pretty clearly deceptive marketing. It gives one the impression that they are not earnest and seek to exploit the uniformed and gullible. I would get the same impression if Canon or Nikon engaged in the same tactics.

To be sure, this could be a very impressive 16mp in some situations, but a very disappointing 46mp in all situations.

Sep 24, 2010 at 08:27 AM
dcjs
Offline
Details
p.6 #10Sigma SD1
Not to defend them, but this is just Sigma adapting to the misleading marketing expressions that are widely used (and the more widely used the more accepted) in the industry.
A Bayer sensor just doesn't produce as much original information as the pixel count implies, some of it is interpolated. Yet everyone is happy with the pixel count denomination because they are used to it.

As a side note, did anyone ever find it strange that the pixel count number is a square function of the linear resolution (so that double the pixel count only equals ~1.4x more linear resolution, but crop factor (for example 1.5x) is always given as a linear number because it sounds better to tell the customer "Your lenses will seem 50% longer!" than "You only get half of the sensor area compared to FF."?

If a small company was the only one to use these definitions, they would get hammered because of misleading marketing statements, but since everybody does it, it's okay and nobody even takes notice.

That said, from my personal experience with the DP1 (which produces results that severely limit it's use in some situations) I would say that you can upscale the images to about twice the pixel count (~140% linear)to end up with a result that looks like a Bayer sensor image at 100%, so I would expect results from the SD1 that are comparable to a 30MP Bayer sensor.

Sep 24, 2010 at 09:06 AM
Yakim Peled
Offline
Details
p.6 #11Sigma SD1
I wonder if anyone ever made a comparison between a Sigma camera and a regular bayer camera without the AA filter. I mean, if all or most of the difference stem from this why not just take a regular bayer camera and remove its AA filter.

Happy shooting,
Yakim.
Sep 24, 2010 at 11:30 AM
trdonja
Offline
Details
p.6 #12Sigma SD1
Yakim Peled wrote:
I wonder if anyone ever made a comparison between a Sigma camera and a regular bayer camera without the AA filter. I mean, if all or most of the difference stem from this why not just take a regular bayer camera and remove its AA filter.

Happy shooting,
Yakim.

Because Bayer filter is there for a reason. It is needed there, or else some pretty nasty artifacts appear. Google it, you will find plenty of photos with filter removed.
Sep 24, 2010 at 12:01 PM
Lotusm50
Offline
Details
p.6 #13Sigma SD1
trdonja wrote:
Yakim Peled wroteI wonder if anyone ever made a comparison between a Sigma camera and a regular bayer camera without the AA filter. I mean, if all or most of the difference stem from this why not just take a regular bayer camera and remove its AA filter.

Happy shooting,
Yakim.
Because Bayer filter is there for a reason. It is needed there, or else some pretty nasty artifacts appear. Google it, you will find plenty of photos with filter removed.



The 'artifacts" or moire occur only rarely and can be handled with software. Ask any Leica M9 or Kodak SLR/n user or any user of medium format digital back. I have a Kodak SLR/n which doesn't have an AA filer, and so far I've never had a problem with moire.

Sep 24, 2010 at 12:13 PM
trdonja
Offline
Details
p.6 #14Sigma SD1
Lotusm50 wrote:
trdonja wrote
Yakim Peled wroteI wonder if anyone ever made a comparison between a Sigma camera and a regular bayer camera without the AA filter. I mean, if all or most of the difference stem from this why not just take a regular bayer camera and remove its AA filter.

Happy shooting,
Yakim.
Because Bayer filter is there for a reason. It is needed there, or else some pretty nasty artifacts appear. Google it, you will find plenty of photos with filter removed.
The 'artifacts" or moire occur only rarely and can be handled with software. Ask any Leica M9 or Kodak SLR/n user or any user of medium format digital back. I have a Kodak SLR/n which doesn't have an AA filer, and so far I've never had a problem with moire.


I'm glad it works for you. I wouldn't remove Bayer filter from my DSLR. I don't want to have one more variable on my mind when it comes to "Keeper or trash" question. Some people don't mind those extra variables, I accept that.

EDIT: Moire can be handled with software? You mean by blurring it? I don't really like that, but again - if some people don't mind blurring part of their photos which turn out bad, I am fine with that.
Sep 24, 2010 at 12:16 PM
carstenw
Offline
Details
p.6 #15Sigma SD1
You don't like blurring a part of your photo, but have no problem blurring *all* of your photo? You do know what an AA filter is, right?
Sep 24, 2010 at 12:27 PM
trdonja
Offline
Details
p.6 #16Sigma SD1
carstenw wrote:
You don't like blurring a part of your photo, but have no problem blurring *all* of your photo? You do know what an AA filter is, right?

Hehe, good question, but I think it is one of those "don't take it too literally" things. We could make a case, that WHOLE photo is blurred even without AA filter. Any photo can appear blurred under certain conditions. What is blurred and what is not blurred is relative and even subjective. So let's not go down that road. I think you do know what I talked about, and there is no reason to misunderstand me on purpose.
Sep 24, 2010 at 12:40 PM
carstenw
Offline
Details
p.6 #17Sigma SD1
I am not misunderstanding you on purpose. I don't like AA filters, and what they do to photos, and love the look you get without, such as with my Leica M8, the Leica M9 or a medium format back. There is nothing really like it, and artificially sharpened photos often look fragile to me, like frozen plants.

There is software out there which handles the gentle blurring of moire admirably, and lots of high-end pros use it every day, for example Phocus for Hasselblad cameras, or Capture One for Phase One cameras.
Sep 24, 2010 at 12:43 PM
Lotusm50
Offline
Details
p.6 #18Sigma SD1
trdonja wrote:
carstenw wroteYou don't like blurring a part of your photo, but have no problem blurring *all* of your photo? You do know what an AA filter is, right?
Hehe, good question, but I think it is one of those "don't take it too literally" things. We could make a case, that WHOLE photo is blurred even without AA filter. Any photo can appear blurred under certain conditions. What is blurred and what is not blurred is relative and even subjective. So let's not go down that road. I think you do know what I talked about, and there is no reason to misunderstand me on purpose.



I think he understood you just fine. The choice, as Carsten put it is, 1) blur the entire image with the AA filter, or 2) blur only part of the image and only when you need to which is potentially rarely. To me, the choice is a no brainer, especially after my experience with a non-AA camera.

Sep 24, 2010 at 12:46 PM
AhamB
Offline
Details
p.6 #19Sigma SD1
Lotusm50 wrote:
The 'artifacts" or moire occur only rarely and can be handled with software. Ask any Leica M9 or Kodak SLR/n user or any user of medium format digital back. I have a Kodak SLR/n which doesn't have an AA filer, and so far I've never had a problem with moire.


Whether you'll see moiré depends entirely on the subject you're shooting. I saw some pictures here on FM, made with the SLR/c, showing a man with a jacket with some fine pattern on it and the false color was quite ugly (I don't recall that it really had a moire pattern).
Sep 24, 2010 at 12:47 PM
trdonja
Offline
Details
p.6 #20Sigma SD1
carstenw wrote:
I am not misunderstanding you on purpose. I don't like AA filters, and what they do to photos, and love the look you get without, such as with my Leica M8, the Leica M9 or a medium format back. There is nothing really like it, and artificially sharpened photos often look fragile to me, like frozen plants.

There is software out there which handles the gentle blurring of moire admirably, and lots of high-end pros use it every day, for example Phocus for Hasselblad cameras, or Capture One for Phase One cameras.

I understand what you are saying and I concede the point that I could be overrating moire problem, simply because I don't use cameras without it. I would like AA filter to be as weak as possible in my cameras. As for sharpening later, I think oversharpening is a common problem, but it is like with every other technique - some people do it, others don't. I am guessing that working with "noAA filter" files is much easier (if no moire present) because of that. I am guessing also that you part of your dislike for AA filter has much to do with those, who oversharpen when it is not appropriate. Nicely sharpened photos don't look that fragile.
Sep 24, 2010 at 12:57 PM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister