fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2010 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2010Sigma SD1

  
 
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.5 #1Sigma SD1
In my limited foveon experience (DP-1only), the 3D quality seemed to be due to the combination of processing (the same image processed in ACR did not have as much 3D quality as compared to Sigma's software), the lens and the extreme sharpness and color detail when viewed at native 100% on screen (Foveon sensor technology). In some instances, the resulting images were the closest thing I have seen to the look of a color transparency when viewed on a light table. Simply removing the AA filter from a bayer sensor will not give the same result, particularly if the camera was not designed to do so. You simply can't get away from the fact that a bayer sensor is interpolating (guessing) the color using a color filter array and will result in image artifacts and decreased color detail as a result of that interpolation.

I did have other issues with that camera but when the conditions were right, the image quality at low ISO was superb. Sigma certainly doe not have the best reputation for quality control (I had to return my first DP1) or even design so early adopters would do well to be hesitant.

Sep 22, 2010 at 07:37 PM
trdonja
Offline
Details
p.5 #2Sigma SD1
veroman wrote:
These cameras (sensors) have consistently and repeatedly suffered from problems that appear to be problems associated with the Foveon sensor design itself ... but don't quite me on that. I'm only guessing.

By that, do you mean that the reason for the problem you describe is the Foveon technology or badly produced sensor? Because frankly, I don't see logical explanation for Foveon technology being responsible for most of the problems you listed. My point is that surely it is theoretically possible to make a Foveon sensor of superior quality?
Sep 22, 2010 at 08:57 PM
Lotusm50
Offline
Details
p.5 #3Sigma SD1
Foveon sensors are not a magic bullet. They are not without issues. They are just different ones. I'll have to see if I can dig out some of the tech papers on this.

Sep 22, 2010 at 09:51 PM
tc95
Offline
Details
p.5 #4Sigma SD1
phidong wrote:
Mike Chaney If true, the combination of foveon + zeiss lenses must be amazing, no?



I use an SD14 with a Nikon F mount conversion...I shoot with the Zeiss ZF mounts...yes...the combination is killer...also the combination with Leica R lenses also has a very clean look...

3D yes...but you can achieve this with any camera...what stands out is the DOF when done correctly...everyone can argue all day long about the MP and the way to interpret the numbers...but in a nut shell...

You have one chip that has three layers...each site process 3 colors instead of one...is it better than the Bayer...yes and no...is it different yes...is Sigma up to par with the flag ship Nikon/Sony/Canon models...NO...but heck...are they gaining ground...I think yes....they took a huge leap forward with this chip....and I bet they are working on bigger and better things...

Just remember don't knock-it unless you have used it...!!!
Sep 22, 2010 at 10:47 PM
kwalsh
Offline
Details
p.5 #5Sigma SD1
Daniel Heineck wrote:
To make sure we're clear on this--from a spatial resolution standpoint, this camera should behave like a 16 mpixel. That's what you care about when thinking from a lens standpoint.


No, actually if you are comparing to Bayer cameras its resolving power will be more akin to about 25 to 30MP - see the earlier link posted regarding the resolving power of the older 4.5MP sensor compared to a Bayer.

So yes, this sensor will likely out resolve most glass.

Ken
Sep 22, 2010 at 11:01 PM
carstenw
Offline
Details
p.5 #6Sigma SD1
Outresolving most glass is an interesting point. Sigma glass is largely budget glass, so I guess they might outresolve most of their own lenses, apart from the stars in the lineup. I wonder how many people use Sigma glass on the D3x?

Still, there are only 16MP locations where the light is being measured (albeit three times), so for the purposes of outresolving glass, it should still be 16MP, not 30MP or any other number.
Sep 23, 2010 at 01:04 AM
ntotrr
Offline
Details
p.5 #7Sigma SD1
Yakim Peled wrote:
Jman13 wroteSigma pulled out the stops today, eh? I'll actually be looking forward to reviews of this one. While one is limited to Sigma lenses, they've got some really good glass now, and one could totally make a great kit with the current glass: 10mm fisheye, 8-16mm, 17-50 OS, 70-200/2.8 OS or 50-150 OS, 100-300/2.8 OS, 30/1.4 and 85/1.4.
I agree but one can get all these fine lenses in all mounts. If you get them in a Sigma mount and later change your mind, it is logical to assume that the depreciation will be a lot steeper. Thus one has to be extra sure that this camera is indeed for him/her before purchasing any Sigma camera. It is my understanding that the rarity of Sigma camera in the market is exactly due to this fact.

However, one may wonder why don't they manufacture cameras with Canon and Nikon mounts. It's not that they can't. If they have
...Show more →

Sigma is interested in a Sigma system, not selling cameras for another company's mount. There will not be any SD cameras inanything but Sigma mount.
Sep 23, 2010 at 06:01 AM
Jochenb
Offline
Details
p.5 #8Sigma SD1
I've had a sigma DP2. Image quality was great. I think the foveon sensor is awesome (at low iso).
Sep 23, 2010 at 06:53 AM
kwalsh
Offline
Details
p.5 #9Sigma SD1
carstenw wrote:
Still, there are only 16MP locations where the light is being measured (albeit three times), so for the purposes of outresolving glass, it should still be 16MP, not 30MP or any other number.


Well, no actually, if you are comparing to Bayer - that was the point of my post. A 16MP Bayer imager does not spatially resolve at the Nyquist spatial frequency you'd expect for its pixel count because of the anti-alias filter and the demosaicing process which softens the image. The Foveon sensors do resolve all the way up to Nyquist since they don't have an anti-alias filter or have to demosaic. Again, check out the link to the Sigma/Canon resolution tests earlier, or the DPR tests of the earlier Sigma cameras.

So a 16MP Bayer sensor will be significantly softer than a 16MP stacked pixel sensor and the Bayer sensor will mask lens softness that the stacked pixel sensor can detect. As far as lens resolution limitation goes you either need to consider a Bayer sensor to have fewer MP than stated when compared to a stacked pixel sensor or alternatively the stacked pixel sensor to have more.

I do suspect the relative resolving power differences between the Foveon imager and the Bayer imagers has moved a bit in the past few years - I believe more and more Bayer cameras have been using weaker anti-alias filters and improved demosaic algorithms. So the gap is probably a bit narrower than way back when.

Ken
Sep 23, 2010 at 07:32 AM
asbalyan
Offline
Details
p.5 #10Sigma SD1
As earlier members commented, (me too) after using DP-1s.. cant go wrong with this camera.

Lets see, what will be the price range + converting to Canon EOS mount...
Sep 23, 2010 at 08:42 AM
Pavel
Offline
Details
p.5 #11Sigma SD1
I had the sigma sd14 although I got it at with bad timing. Those days I was shooting stuff where I wanted decent iso 400 and even better if I could have more speed. I did not like the siggi ergonomics much neither, but the files had a look to them, that though I could not appreciate it due to what I was shooting at the time, that was really both stellar and one of a kind.

Now that I shoot things that don't move and now that I want texture in my shots I am seriously wondering if this new choice in systems may not be the thing for me. This is the second most exciting announcement this year for me, right after the Fuji FX100. (I'm a sucker for retro, simple and rangerfinder)
Sep 23, 2010 at 08:44 AM
Pavel
Offline
Details
p.5 #12Sigma SD1
I suspect that the issue of perhaps out-resolving glass is mostly smoke. May be true - but who cares.
When it is all quiet and still in the middle of the night, and the bluster has subsided - do may of you not wonder if the sensor out-resolves us - never mind what else?
Sep 23, 2010 at 08:47 AM
veroman
Offline
Details
p.5 #13Sigma SD1
kwalsh wrote:
.... I do suspect the relative resolving power differences between the Foveon imager and the Bayer imagers has moved a bit in the past few years - I believe more and more Bayer cameras have been using weaker anti-alias filters and improved demosaic algorithms. So the gap is probably a bit narrower than way back when.
Ken


It is. I remember going from my SD9 to a Canon 10D and missing the Sigma's resolution, detail and "transparency" compared to the 10D. But the 10D was a way better camera overall and far more adaptable to a wider range of environments and situations.

Today, cameras like the original 5D and the newer 5D II and the 7D ... not to mention oldies but goodies like the Nikon D2x ... are much closer to Foveon resolution of detail than most of the earlier models.

It will certainly be interesting to see what this new Sigma is really like come a year or so.

- Steve
Sep 23, 2010 at 08:50 AM
Daniel Heineck
Offline
Details
p.5 #14Sigma SD1
kwalsh wrote:
carstenw wroteStill, there are only 16MP locations where the light is being measured (albeit three times), so for the purposes of outresolving glass, it should still be 16MP, not 30MP or any other number.
Well, no actually, if you are comparing to Bayer - that was the point of my post. A 16MP Bayer imager does not spatially resolve at the Nyquist spatial frequency you'd expect for its pixel count because of the anti-alias filter and the demosaicing process which softens the image. The Foveon sensors do resolve all the way up to Nyquist since they don't have an anti-alias filter or have to demosaic. Again, check out the link to the Sigma/Canon resolution tests earlier, or the DPR tests of the earlier Sigma cameras.

So a 16MP Bayer sensor will be significantly softer than
...Show more →

Ken,

I'm going to have to disagree a bit. The sampling mathematics get ugly for a bayer sensor, but it does a darn good job of maintaining luminance resolution. As we push to higher and higher nyquist frequencies, the difference between a foveon and a bayer get smaller and smaller. Then we have to deal with efficacy of microlenses and inter-sensel leakage problems that are higher intrinsically in a foveon design (but still very present in a bayer). And, yes, a Foveon design *should* have an AA filter, albeit weaker than a bayer design. Whether they put one on or not, is a different question. From a first-order rule of thumb, I'm going to say that from a lens' perspective, a 16 mpix camera (actually whatever the pixel pitch is) of each type is the same.

And, as you say, the gap is narrower now than it was before. I'd argue quite a bit narrower. Again, not knocking the technology, but let's not get ahead of ourselves.
Sep 23, 2010 at 01:31 PM
Pavel
Offline
Details
p.5 #15Sigma SD1
Not get ahead of ourselves? .... ummm ..... but I thought that is what this forum is all about! What then ARE we going to do? Go shoot pictures? Sheesh.
Sep 23, 2010 at 03:26 PM
theSuede
Offline
Details
p.5 #16Sigma SD1
Since I've been talking to one of the persons developing those sensors, I have to agree that they aren't exactly "optimal". The 16MP of the DP1 will not be noticeably sharper than 16MP on a Bayer-based sensor. As Daniel mentioned, Bayer-interpolation these days is fairly good, and loose very little luminance resolution compared to a "perfect" sensor.

And a much misunderstood fact about the Foveons is that they do NOT measure the "R", "G" and "B" signals in every photosite. They measure "rGB", "rG" and "R" in each subsequent layer, meaning that to get full colour output you actually matrix transform the signal, just like with a "normal" - but with VERY large negative coefficients.
R = R - rG - rGB
G = rG - R - rGB
B = rGB - R - rG

This means that you triple the amount of electrical noise per pixel, and loose about 1Ev efficiency compared to a normal Bayer sensor (which explains the poor high ISO performance and to use as kind words as possible - special - colour rendition)
Sep 23, 2010 at 03:34 PM
mawz
Offline
Details
p.5 #17Sigma SD1
The biggest problem with the SD1 is that if it's released on the same schedule as the SD15 we won't see it on the market until late 2012. Sigma's delays in bringing announced cameras to market make Sony look good.

Sep 23, 2010 at 03:38 PM
Daniel Heineck
Offline
Details
p.5 #18Sigma SD1
Pavel wrote:
Not get ahead of ourselves? .... ummm ..... but I thought that is what this forum is all about! What then ARE we going to do? Go shoot pictures? Sheesh.


Sorry about that. You see, I only indulge in getting ahead of myself when it comes to my own work. :P
Sep 23, 2010 at 04:06 PM
phidong
Offline
Details
p.5 #19Sigma SD1
mawz wrote:
The biggest problem with the SD1 is that if it's released on the same schedule as the SD15 we won't see it on the market until late 2012. Sigma's delays in bringing announced cameras to market make Sony look good.


This is one of the first times I can remember Sigma actually giving a release date though. Usually we just hear estimated arrival dates from vendors that keep getting pushed back so there could be a little hope.. or not
Sep 23, 2010 at 04:14 PM
veroman
Offline
Details
p.5 #20Sigma SD1
theSuede wrote:
Since I've been talking to one of the persons developing those sensors, I have to agree that they aren't exactly "optimal". The 16MP of the DP1 will not be noticeably sharper than 16MP on a Bayer-based sensor. As Daniel mentioned, Bayer-interpolation these days is fairly good, and loose very little luminance resolution compared to a "perfect" sensor. And a much misunderstood fact about the Foveons is that they do NOT measure the "R", "G" and "B" signals in every photosite. They measure "rGB", "rG" and "R" in each subsequent layer, meaning that to get full colour output you actually matrix
...Show more →

Thanks for this information. I wasn't aware of any of it. It gives me a reasonable understanding of why the Sigmas do what they do, for better or for worse.

With Bayer closing the gap on Foveon clarity ... not that the really great cameras were ever that far off ... I can't help but wonder if the SD1 is supposed to be one last, grand shot at making a camera that's not only competitive to the Bayer bunch but also deliciously better all around.

And if it's not? What then? Perhaps Sigma has such a loyal following that they keep on making the Foveon cameras even at a loss. Who knows?

- Steve
Sep 23, 2010 at 04:33 PM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister