fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2010 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2010Sigma SD1

  
 
Jorgen Udvang
Offline
Details
p.4 #1Sigma SD1
Ian.Dobinson wrote:
Don't get me wrong, i'm not knocking them. I'm just asking if when you view the image if your going to see image dimensions of 14mp or 40+ mp? i actually think 14 is enough.
Also what size in mb are we talking for each file?

also its a bit of a shame that sigma or foveon dont do what fuji did and take a good body and shove their sensoe in that.


It seems to me this new body is miles ahead of the old ones, with a much larger viewfinder and solid construction.
Sep 21, 2010 at 05:56 PM
Lotusm50
Offline
Details
p.4 #2Sigma SD1
Jorgen Udvang wrote:
It seems to me this new body is miles ahead of the old ones, with a much larger viewfinder and solid construction.



I think that remains to be seen when the SD1 finally becomes available -- whenever that might be. According to the specs, it really hard to describe the viewfinder as "much larger" and its still tiny compared to the camera it probably sees as competitors.

Sep 21, 2010 at 07:19 PM
curious80
Offline
Details
p.4 #3Sigma SD1
Lotusm50 wrote:
According to the specs, it really hard to describe the viewfinder as "much larger" and its still tiny compared to the camera it probably sees as competitors.




The SD1 viewfinder is about the same size as 7D / D300s which are pretty much the largest APS-C viewfinders. It is about 20% larger than the SD14/SD15 which is pretty significant. As a reference the D3X viewfinder is about 13% larger than the SD1 viewfinder.
Sep 21, 2010 at 07:54 PM
Lotusm50
Offline
Details
p.4 #4Sigma SD1
curious80 wrote:
The SD1 viewfinder is about the same size as 7D / D300s which are pretty much the largest APS-C viewfinders. It is about 20% larger than the SD14/SD15 which is pretty significant. As a reference the D3X viewfinder is about 13% larger than the SD1 viewfinder.



7D viewfinder is bigger. 7D: 100% coverage at 1.0 magification. SD1: 98% coverage at .98 magnification. Viewfinder of camera it presumes to compete with, the D3x, a900 and 1Dslll viewfinders are all significantly larger.

Sep 21, 2010 at 08:09 PM
Geert Koning
Offline
Details
p.4 #5Sigma SD1
Lotusm50 wrote:
curious80 wroteThe SD1 viewfinder is about the same size as 7D / D300s which are pretty much the largest APS-C viewfinders. It is about 20% larger than the SD14/SD15 which is pretty significant. As a reference the D3X viewfinder is about 13% larger than the SD1 viewfinder.
7D viewfinder is bigger. 7D: 100% coverage at 1.0 magification. SD1: 98% coverage at .98 magnification. Viewfinder of camera it presumes to compete with, the D3x, a900 and 1Dslll viewfinders are all significantly larger.



7D 1.0 magnification and 100% coverage of 14.9x22.3 = 14.9x22.3
SD1 .98 magnification and 98% coverage of 16 x 24 = 15.4x23

I made a mistake:

SD1 .95 magnification and 98% coverage of 16 x 24 = 14.9x22.3
exactly the size of the 7D



Edited on Sep 22, 2010 at 05:56 AM · View previous versions
Sep 21, 2010 at 11:38 PM
---XR---
Offline
Details
p.4 #6Sigma SD1
price?
Sep 21, 2010 at 11:42 PM
curious80
Offline
Details
p.4 #7Sigma SD1
Lotusm50 wrote:
7D viewfinder is bigger. 7D: 100% coverage at 1.0 magification. SD1: 98% coverage at .98 magnification. Viewfinder of camera it presumes to compete with, the D3x, a900 and 1Dslll viewfinders are all significantly larger.



When you compare viewfinder sizes, you need to incorporate the sensor size as well - otherwise you will think that the 1Ds III with "only" 0.76 magnification will have a smaller viewfinder than the 7D with 1.0 magnification.

7D has a 1.0 magnification but its sensor size is slightly smaller than the SD1 or D300s sensors.

Lets say we have a 35mm camera with a 1.0x , 100% viewfinder. Using that as a reference, following will be the sensor sizes for some of the cameras being discussed here:

1DSIII = 0.76 * 100% = 0.76
D3x = 0.7 * 100% = 0.7
7D = 1.0 * 100% * 1/1.6 = 0.62
D300s = 0.94 * 100% * 1/1.5 = 0.63
SD1 = 0.95 * 98% * 1/1.5 = 0.62
SD14 = 0.9 * 98% * 1/1.7 = 0.52
T1i = 0.52

So as I mentioned before:

1. SD1 viewfinder is pretty much the same size as 7D and D300s
2. SD1 viewfinder is about 20% larger than SD14 viewfinder
3. D3X viewfinder is about 13% larger than SD1 viewfinder

and just for fun:

4. 1dsIII viewfinder is about 8% larger than D3x

Alright. These were lots of numbers But hope that clarifies the situation a bit

Plus I don't think Sigma has indicated that SD1 intends to compete with 1DsIII/D3X etc - its not a full-frame camera.
Sep 22, 2010 at 12:19 AM
Pixel Perfect
Offline
Details
p.4 #8Sigma SD1
Lotusm50 wrote:
garydavidjones wroteWith 46 MP crammed into APS-C
and

j.liam wroteNo knock on Sigma lenses because some of them are fine optics, but at a stated 46MP very few, if any can deliver quality optical information to do the sensor justice.
OK. Let's be clear on this, as it appears that Sigma marketing is marking some headway in perceptions. They are no cramming 46 mp in to APS-c. They are cramming 16mp on to APS-c. (each of these 16mp has a stack of 3 color receptors). So rather than having to resolve 46mp in an APS-c space, lenses really only have to resolve 16mp on an APS-c space.



Yes, and the fact they don't use AA filter and don't need demosaicing means the X3 sensors resolve more than expected. I know noise has been a problem, but detail can be superb. Let's hope noise has improved so it can at least offer good IQ up to at least ISO 800.
Sep 22, 2010 at 03:30 AM
Spyro P.
Offline
Details
p.4 #9Sigma SD1
curious80 wrote:
Lets say we have a 35mm camera with a 1.0x , 100% viewfinder. Using that as a reference, following will be the sensor sizes for some of the cameras being discussed here:

1DSIII = 0.76 * 100% = 0.76
D3x = 0.7 * 100% = 0.7
7D = 1.0 * 100% * 1/1.6 = 0.62
D300s = 0.94 * 100% * 1/1.5 = 0.63
SD1 = 0.95 * 98% * 1/1.5 = 0.62
SD14 = 0.9 * 98% * 1/1.7 = 0.52
T1i = 0.52

So as I mentioned before:

1. SD1 viewfinder is pretty much the same size as 7D and D300s
2. SD1 viewfinder is
...Show more →

And my OM1 still shits on them all
Sep 22, 2010 at 04:34 AM
carstenw
Offline
Details
p.4 #10Sigma SD1
I am very happy to see Sigma release this. The older Sigmas had great image quality at low ISO, and the more competition at high image quality, the more Nikon and especially Canon might be motivated to cut back on their AA filters and pay more attention to colour.

I have to say that I am really disappointed at this old 3x lie being pushed yet again. There are only 16MP unique pixel locations on that sensor. The 3 receptors per pixel account for the higher image quality, which makes this a true 16MP full-colour camera. I suppose they feel pressured to do this by other manufacturers who advertise their Bayer cameras as having xMP, while "forgetting" to say that only one colour is measured at each pixel. The end effect of a Bayer sensor: xMP resolution, but x/2 MP green resolution, and x/4 MP blue and red resolution. Still, one lie doesn't justify another, and the 46MP is incredibly misleading. What you get is the sharpest 16MP you ever saw, but still only 16MP.

Don't the old Foveon cameras have a special mode which upscales x3 to reach the overstated resolution figures?

IIRC, the last time Foveon sensors were discussed around here, it was pretty much agreed that the images could be upscaled by about 2x before starting to look worse than Bayer sensors, i.e. the more realistic multiplier for comparing resolution was 2x, which makes sense when you know that the green channel gives an image its apparent sharpness, and there are half as many green sites on a Bayer sensor as on a Foveon sensor.
Sep 22, 2010 at 01:24 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.4 #11Sigma SD1
carstenw wrote:
IIRC, the last time Foveon sensors were discussed around here, it was pretty much agreed that the images could be upscaled by about 2x before starting to look worse than Bayer sensors, i.e. the more realistic multiplier for comparing resolution was 2x, which makes sense when you know that the green channel gives an image its apparent sharpness, and there are half as many green sites on a Bayer sensor as on a Foveon sensor.


This is roughly my experience with the DP1 images I shot and processed. Slightly more then 2x enlargement before seeing what I'm used to seeing (on screen and in print) from a good bayer sensor. Part of the advantage with that model I attribute to the superior 28mm equivalent lens.

So, if this new Sigma SD1 is capable of giving the IQ one would expect from a FF 30MP bayer sensored camera, even at just low ISO's, I think the camera will have a solid following (as long as it's priced reasonably).
Sep 22, 2010 at 02:47 PM
carstenw
Offline
Details
p.4 #12Sigma SD1
Agreed, although looking through reviews of previous Sigma DSLRs, there may also be body issues, so I guess it pays to be cautious. One can forgive a lot for great IQ, but not everything. And unless the world has been flipped upside down, the high ISO performance will be awful, starting very low, so it will really be a great-light or studio camera, or if long exposure times don't introduce noise, a tripod camera.

The thing that bugs me the most about the Sigma DSLRs is the Sigma lenses. They have a few good ones, but a lot of very mediocre ones too.
Sep 22, 2010 at 03:23 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.4 #13Sigma SD1
carstenw wrote:
The thing that bugs me the most about the Sigma DSLRs is the Sigma lenses. They have a few good ones, but a lot of very mediocre ones too.


If I went this route, I would seriously consider sticking a Canon EF mount onto the SD1. Then you have endless options for glass, including Zeiss ZE. Zeiss plus Foveon might be a really nice combination.
Sep 22, 2010 at 03:59 PM
Ian.Dobinson
Offline
Details
p.4 #14Sigma SD1
Tariq Gibran wrote:
carstenw wroteThe thing that bugs me the most about the Sigma DSLRs is the Sigma lenses. They have a few good ones, but a lot of very mediocre ones too.
If I went this route, I would seriously consider sticking a Canon EF mount onto the SD1. Then you have endless options for glass, including Zeiss ZE. Zeiss plus Foveon might be a really nice combination.


well yes , but it does look quite major surgery to do it (although if its possible someone will do it) but if you want to mod for anything other than EF lenses (and keep AF) then the other mount converters look a great way. still get the Zeiss option if you go Nikon.

But then a true Manual Focus cam better have a nice VF with a good screen etc, and if they could have Liveview for tripod work then alls the better
Sep 22, 2010 at 04:31 PM
Daniel Heineck
Offline
Details
p.4 #15Sigma SD1
This sensor has the possibility of being really, really cool if it implemented correctly. There are certainly manufacturing challenges involved with a foveon-style sensor that adds compromises. Theoretically speaking, a AA filter is still necessary, but practically--I don't know.

To make sure we're clear on this--from a spatial resolution standpoint, this camera should behave like a 16 mpixel. That's what you care about when thinking from a lens standpoint. The smaller the pixels get, the less attractive foveon looks, as well. The proof is in the pudding.

It's a huge jump between the prior generation and this guy. I don't want to be a wet blanket but I'm cautious for the moment. We could have a gem, but lets keep our fingers crossed and not get ahead of ourselves.
Sep 22, 2010 at 04:33 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.4 #16Sigma SD1
Ian.Dobinson wrote:
Tariq Gibran wrote
carstenw wroteThe thing that bugs me the most about the Sigma DSLRs is the Sigma lenses. They have a few good ones, but a lot of very mediocre ones too.
If I went this route, I would seriously consider sticking a Canon EF mount onto the SD1. Then you have endless options for glass, including Zeiss ZE. Zeiss plus Foveon might be a really nice combination.
well yes , but it does look quite major surgery to do it (although if its possible someone will do it) but if you want to mod for anything other than EF lenses (and keep AF) then the other mount converters look a great way. still get the Zeiss option if you go Nikon.

But then a true Manual Focus cam better have a nice VF with a good screen etc, and if they could have Liveview for tripod work then alls the better


Here is a link for various mount conversion kits for Sigma. Looks like they also offer converted EF Sigma bodies but I don't know if their conversion maintains AF. This has already been done though by others.

http://www.sigmacumlaude.com/products.html

This also looks to be a good resource for Alt lenses on Sigma:

http://foto.nordjylland.biz/SD14/SD14-NonSigmaLenses.htm
Sep 22, 2010 at 04:54 PM
Ian.Dobinson
Offline
Details
p.4 #17Sigma SD1
I posted this liknk a couple of pages back
https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/675852
the OP of that thread had moded a SD14 to full EF mount , including AF . that was a couple of years ago but he has posted within the last 3 months so it may be worth a PM to see if he's still around.
Sep 22, 2010 at 05:19 PM
Yakim Peled
Offline
Details
p.4 #18Sigma SD1
Just had a thought. What if you convert the mount to F or EF and then stick 21/2.8, 50/2 and 100/2 Zeiss lenses on it? Results should be incredible.

Happy shooting,
Yakim.
Sep 22, 2010 at 05:44 PM
phidong
Offline
Details
p.4 #19Sigma SD1
Mike Chaney says that foveon images look more 3d because of uniform resolving power across different colors. Can anyone who has shot with the DP cameras or the SD cameras chime in on this? I looked around for some samples from foveon sensors but nothing really stands out. If true, the combination of foveon + zeiss lenses must be amazing, no?
Sep 22, 2010 at 05:48 PM
veroman
Offline
Details
p.4 #20Sigma SD1
phidong wrote:
Mike Chaney says that foveon images look more 3d because of uniform resolving power across different colors. Can anyone who has shot with the DP cameras or the SD cameras chime in on this? I looked around for some samples from foveon sensors but nothing really stands out. If true, the combination of foveon + zeiss lenses must be amazing, no?


I was hesitant to post about the latest Sigma, but since you asked ....

I've owned and used the SD9, SD10, DP1 and SD14. The SD9 was my second "serious" DSLR (the first was a 2MP Kodak 520). I have always given the latest Sigma models the benefit of the doubt, but that's proven to be a generous decision in favor of Sigma rather than myself. These cameras (sensors) have consistently and repeatedly suffered from problems that appear to be problems associated with the Foveon sensor design itself ... but don't quite me on that. I'm only guessing.

The consistent problems are:
1) Color shifts and color casts even in good light, reminiscent of early Kodak DCS SLRs like the SLR/n.
2) Dramatic color shifts as ISO goes up ... beginning at ISO 400.
3) Dramatic loss of dynamic range as ISO goes up .... beginning at ISO 400.
4) Serious and unforgiveable (in this day and age) noise levels at ISO 800 and up (the Olympus E-3 noise at ISO 3200 seems like a miracle of cleanliness compared to the Sigma at ISO 800). The noise is far from fine-grained. It's that old big, blotchy color noise that cannot be corrected without losing the whole essence of the picture.

The Sigma/Foveons do get a little ... and I really mean a little ... better with each iteration. But compared to what else is out there, the gains from the Foveon sensor are, in my view, practically obliterated by the inherent problems that have been associated with these cameras.

About the 3-D business: well, take the AA filter off a Canon 5D or 5D II and you'll see the same 3-D. A lot if not most of that 3-D-ness has to do with the lack of AA filter, and some of it has to do with the Foveon's color response, which is really good. But the 3-D, if you can call it that, is more apparent on a computer monitor than it is in a print, which is the level playing field for comparing any two cameras. I would suggest anyone considering the SD1 vs another camera judge the output in large prints.

Finally ... if the SD1 is the camera everyone thinks it is, if Sigma has finally resolved all of the problems that have plagued these cameras since Day One, if the price is right and if Sigma's quality control in lens manufacturing has improved, I'd be the first on line to order their new mega-mega pixel camera. But I've been down their road several times before. I'm not confident ....

- Steve
Sep 22, 2010 at 06:14 PM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister