Tariq Gibran wrote:
If the material has a known response that Sigma has engineered for, then they could also theoretically "tune" said response however they so need to.
No, they can't, and that is the point. Foveon uses photon diffusion in the semiconductor itself to separate colors between the three photodiodes. While you can control where the colors cross-over you can not, in anyway, change the extremely broad spectral response of each channel. This is the very nature of diffusion, the physics always works out this way and no material "tuning" will narrow the response. Thus they are "stuck" with the more broad than desired responses of the three layers and this is where some of the color conversion issues can appear (again, emphasis on can, the process clearly works quite well but it has different benefits and issues than the CFA approach).
For a CFA the filtering process is not diffusion, but absorption from chromogenic dyes. In these cases changing the chemistry of the dyes allows one to tune the spectral response and narrow it as much as desired (specifically to better match human spectral responses to prevent metamerism). By choosing different dye chemistries one can on a very sharp spectral scale select which energy (color) photons are absorbed and which pass on to the photodiode for detection. Since this process is absorption, not diffusion, there are many, many, many degrees of freedom in choosing each channels spectral response. Not so with diffusion, there is really nothing to adjust that has any impact on the narrowness or broadness of the spectral response.
And please keep in mind, all photodiodes are "black and white". Nothing about the Foveon sensor makes it "color" any more than a Bayer sensor. Foveon has three monochrome sensors stacked on top of each other, the stacking performing the color filtering via diffusion. The Bayer has four monochrome sensors sitting next to each other with chromogenic filters on top of them. Just different physical arrangements of the same monochromatic elements with color filters in front of them. In the Foveon case the upper sensors actually act as the filters for the lower sensors, but they are still just monochromatic sensors with filters in front of them.
So Foveon gets to measure three colors at each location (good) but they are restricted in the choice of the color channel response (not so good).
How "bad" are the broad Foveon responses? That is really hard to say. Like everything else about Sigma/Foveon we see relatively slow development. Is a particular case of weird color a limitation of the broad spectral response or is just because they "aren't doing it right" just yet? Can't really say, but by many accounts color has been getting better over time with the same sensors and just newer RAW converters - so it would seem they have still been learning and improving how they work around the broad spectral responses. We can speculate all we want about the impacts. The reality though is Foveon has very little choice over the spectral response of their channels, they just have to deal with what they get to a large degree and handle any challenges in the RAW converter. CFA can't benefit from "full color" pixels and must demosaic but it can optimize the spectral responses to make the color job easier in the RAW converter. Which is better? I don't know, but they are definitely different.