fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2010 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2010Sigma SD1

  
 
Lotusm50
Offline
Details
p.12 #1Sigma SD1
Dim.ka_ wrote:
Guys, please do not forget that Sigma camera could be converted to almost fully working EOS bayonet (will not work image stabilization with Canon lenses) camera with AF.



Yes, with effort and invalidation of the warranty. This really is only something that will attract a small number of people. They aren't basing their sales projections based on this.

Further, given the assumption that Sigma is using these cameras to sell their lenses, this ability to convert the camera to a different lens mount totally defeats that purpose and each camera bought to be converted represents a clear loss for Sigma. If Sigma is smart, they would do something to disable this conversion possibility for users.

Oct 05, 2010 at 06:41 AM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.12 #2Sigma SD1
Lotusm50 wrote:
Dim.ka_ wroteGuys, please do not forget that Sigma camera could be converted to almost fully working EOS bayonet (will not work image stabilization with Canon lenses) camera with AF.
Yes, with effort and invalidation of the warranty. This really is only something that will attract a small number of people. They aren't basing their sales projections based on this.

Further, given the assumption that Sigma is using these cameras to sell their lenses, this ability to convert the camera to a different lens mount totally defeats that purpose and each camera bought to be converted represents a clear loss for Sigma. If Sigma is smart, they would do something to disable this conversion possibility for users.



I'm not so sure as they would alienate the vital hard core group that helps promote the brand /technology the loudest by doing this. In the long run, getting a very good implementation of the Foveon technology (if this proves to be the case) in as many hands as possible might make the most sense if they truly believe they have something special. It will be interesting to see if Sigma does make modifications to the mount and/ or camera software that might prevent mount and lens conversions. Doing so would seriously disuade me from considering this camera.
Oct 05, 2010 at 07:12 AM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.12 #3Sigma SD1
AhamB wrote:
http://www.dpreview.com/news/1010/10100504Sigmainterview.asp

Interview with Sigma about the work they've been doing on the sensor the past two years.



Great explanation and the science seems to back up the 30MP bayer equivalent figure many have been discussing in this thread.
Oct 05, 2010 at 07:25 AM
Lotusm50
Offline
Details
p.12 #4Sigma SD1
Tariq Gibran wrote:
AhamB wrotehttp://www.dpreview.com/news/1010/10100504Sigmainterview.asp

Interview with Sigma about the work they've been doing on the sensor the past two years.
Great explanation and the science seems to back up the 30MP bayer equivalent figure many have been discussing in this thread.



Really? Sounds like pure marketing spin. Clearly tries to suggest the differences are greater than it is (hey, they show mathematics!), and ignore all the relevant points theSuede correctly brought up in this thread. Can't rely on the company's own BS for an accurate description of what is going on. We need an much more objective source to get the full story on these issues.

Oct 05, 2010 at 07:37 AM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.12 #5Sigma SD1
Lotusm50 wrote:
Tariq Gibran wrote
AhamB wrotehttp://www.dpreview.com/news/1010/10100504Sigmainterview.asp

Interview with Sigma about the work they've been doing on the sensor the past two years.
Great explanation and the science seems to back up the 30MP bayer equivalent figure many have been discussing in this thread.
Really? Sounds like pure marketing spin. Clearly tries to suggest the differences are greater than it is (hey, they show mathematics!), and ignore all the relevant points theSuede correctly brought up in this thread. Can't rely on the company's own BS for an accurate description of what is going on. We need an much more objective source to get the full story on these issues.



So which one of these statements from the link is spin?

"The spectral response of human visual system has its peak in green. The Bayer design takes advantage of that by having two green pixels in every four. With our X3 technology every darned pixel captures green."

or

"We responded by driving pixel size down to equivalent sizes,' says Guttosch: 'a sensor with an equivalent number of pixels has a √2 resolution advantage over Bayer for the green channel and about 2 times for other colors. Clever demosaicing reduces the gap but you still have an anti-aliasing filter with Bayer. And, if you look at the maximum resolution of most Bayer cameras, they give a figure that's around 70% (1/√2) of the potential maximum value (Nyquist), whereas we can get right up towards the Nyquist frequency."

If it is marketing BS, it seems to be well informed BS.


Oct 05, 2010 at 07:44 AM
kofron
Offline
Details
p.12 #6Sigma SD1
Lotus,

You won't get a more 'objective' source until the camera is released to the wild. But let's take a look at the 'relative points' theSuede brought up:

Positives for the Foveon:
-Much nicer noise pattern, chromatic noise is perfectly scaled to pixel size (until you start correcting for the abysmal colour hue resolution, then it's actually worse than Bayers).
-Less (but not totally removed) risk of colour moire.

Negatives for the Foveon:
-Low sensitivity - noise performance is pretty poor

As mentioned in the article, Foveon had been working hard on cell phone images for the last couple years before being bought by Sigma. Hard as defined by the majority of their resources. So they've been dealing with smaller pixels. One would expect that they have worked on noise performance. And in fact, one can read Foveon patents on reducing wiring on the chip to achieve exactly that. Coupled with the fact that they've gotten progressively better in noise performance from the SD14 to DPn's to the SD15---all using essentially the same chip---indicates that they're making progress in both the in camera imaging pipeline as well as their software.


-Low colour hue sensitivity
Again, colors are getting better (and easier) with every iteration of camera. My SD15 profiles very 'neutrally' when shooting a ColorChecker, even...


-VERY high metamerism errors (bad for difficult lights like fluorescents and such)
...under different spectral conditions. In general, a good set up lookup tables are probably responsible for Sigma getting the SD15 to be easier to work with. AutoWB is working well for a refresing change too.


-Very sensitive to light incident angles.


This is just a internet myth, put together by people who flunked trig and physics. In the dSLR, the registration distance is 44 mm on a chip that is 22 mm wide. That angle on the edge (not the corner---I'm too lazy) is 14 degrees from perpendicular. When light goes from a low refractive index medium to a high one (Si has an index of 4.5 if I remember correctly), it gets bent to the perpendicular. Strongly, in this case--to an angle of 2.6 degress from perpendicular. Angular incidence is not an issue.

For short registration distances (like a compact), there can be an angle of incidence problem, but I believe it's mainly a reflection issue (chips are shiny). Most antireflective coatings are wavelength dependent, so that causes complications.

I was very impressed with regards to the interview, and thought that the team gave pretty good, non marketing details.


Oct 05, 2010 at 08:05 AM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.12 #7Sigma SD1
kofron wrote:
Lotus,

You won't get a more 'objective' source until the camera is released to the wild.


+1

I think we are all just going to have to wait and see what the camera is capable of once it is released. In the end, all of the speculation about math, science, magic or whatever means nothing until we see the images. Many of those who have shot a Foveon equipped camera, particularly more recent ones, believe there is something to it while those who have not or have had poor experiences are rightly skeptical. The proof of the pudding is in the eating, right?
Oct 05, 2010 at 08:19 AM
ntotrr
Offline
Details
p.12 #8Sigma SD1
Tariq Gibran wrote:
kofron wroteLotus,

You won't get a more 'objective' source until the camera is released to the wild.
+1

I think we are all just going to have to wait and see what the camera is capable of once it is released. In the end, all of the speculation about math, science, magic or whatever means nothing until we see the images. Many of those who have shot a Foveon equipped camera, particularly more recent ones, believe there is something to it while those who have not or have had poor experiences are rightly skeptical. The proof of the pudding is in the eating, right?


There were images on display at Photokina from the new sensor and from those that have reportted on them, they look great. Yes, we all have to wait and see until the camera is released. Up to this point, the Sigma cameras released resolve as well as a typical Bayer sensor camera with twice the MPs and that is according to independent sources such as dpreview, not the "fanboys". Therefore, it's logical to expect that the SD1 will resolve as well as a 30 MP Bayer sensor camera. Now, let the "anti fanboys" whom we've heard from begin the attack on this post.
Oct 05, 2010 at 09:12 AM
Lotusm50
Offline
Details
p.12 #9Sigma SD1
Tariq Gibran wrote:
So which one of these statements from the link is spin?



Half stories and incomplete information. Errors of omission. Oversimpliying assumptions. They are only giving you part of the story, the part of the story they want you to hear.

Oct 05, 2010 at 09:18 AM
Lotusm50
Offline
Details
p.12 #10Sigma SD1
kofron wrote:
...



...and the Sigma support troops are back! It's been a while and how we missed you! I knew a new model would bring them back out of the woodwork to promote and defend the products. Here we go again.


As I mentioned before, we need "objective" analysis not promotional activity and spin from associated supporters. If we have to wait until the new model appears so be it. Until then, you're all just jerking around with incomplete, self-serving, and biased information (with only occasional does of sanity from independent informed sources). The statement, "We'll have to wait and see", was never more true.


Oct 05, 2010 at 09:20 AM
Rob Riley
Offline
Details
p.12 #11Sigma SD1
well after they are done 'waiting and seeing'
i hope they screw you to the wall
Oct 05, 2010 at 09:31 AM
kofron
Offline
Details
p.12 #12Sigma SD1
Lotusm50 wrote:
kofron wrote...
...and the Sigma support troops are back! It's been a while and how we missed you! I knew a new model would bring them back out of the woodwork to promote and defend the products. Here we go again.

As I mentioned before, we need "objective" analysis not promotional activity and spin from associated supporters. If we have to wait until the new model appears so be it. Until then, you're all just jerking around with incomplete, self-serving, and biased information (with only occasional does of sanity from independent informed sources). The statement, "We'll have to wait and see", was never
...Show more →

By 'support troops', I assume that you mean someone that has actually owned and used the product. So yup.

As opposed to 'jerking around with incomplete, self-serviing, and biased information', I suppose that you're referring to my reference of patents, of the company history, and of optics and physics?

I agree we need objective analysis. We don't need yet another Foveon basher to spread the hate prior to a release. I've got no problems with dissenting opinions, but you really should brush up on facts---which you seem to be playing pretty loose with. Of course, this is the internet...
Oct 05, 2010 at 09:31 AM
Lotusm50
Offline
Details
p.12 #13Sigma SD1
Like I said, "Here we go again.". Anyone who dares raise questions and who doesn't take Sigma's promotional material and that of obvious promoter as gospel gets attacked.

I haven't "bashed", just expressed healthy and warranted skepticism over obvious promotional statements, and agreed with the suggestion that we need to wait to see the actual product. I have not provided contrary facts, other than to say Sigma promotion leaves out many -- which should be obvious to anyone. Like I said, Sigma is only giving you the part of the story they want you to hear. How can that possibly be controversial? That is typical of EVERY manufacturer, not just Sigma. But in the eyes of the recently re-emerged (just in time!) Sigma support troops, anything less than total devotion and in faith in the Sigma product and message is heresy worthy of burning and attack. This is SO tiresome. Why don't you go back into the woodwork and take your blatant promotional activity elsewhere? These guerrilla marketing tactics are really some of the worst aspects of the internet.

Oct 05, 2010 at 10:01 AM
ntotrr
Offline
Details
p.12 #14Sigma SD1
Lotusm50 wrote:
kofron wrote...
...and the Sigma support troops are back! It's been a while and how we missed you! I knew a new model would bring them back out of the woodwork to promote and defend the products. Here we go again.

As I mentioned before, we need "objective" analysis not promotional activity and spin from associated supporters. If we have to wait until the new model appears so be it. Until then, you're all just jerking around with incomplete, self-serving, and biased information (with only occasional does of sanity from independent informed sources). The statement, "We'll have to wait and see", was never
...Show more →

You consider yourself objective? A read through your posts will show that you have a bias against Sigma products. If you want to consider those who use Sigma's cameras and lenses as not objective, go ahead but you sure can't hold yourself up as objective either.
Oct 05, 2010 at 10:04 AM
Lotusm50
Offline
Details
p.12 #15Sigma SD1
ntotrr wrote:
You consider yourself objective? A read through your posts will show that you have a bias against Sigma products. If you want to consider those who use Sigma's cameras and lenses as not objective, go ahead but you sure can't hold yourself up as objective either.



I'm just skeptical based on the past. Most of company and company-related rhetoric in the past wasn't borne out to my eyes when I examined it. To be clear, I have no "bias" against Sigma. I have no interest in any competing products or any alternative. But I do believe that performance in the past has not matched the rhetoric, and I am far from alone in that opinion. Quite clearly the nearly insignificant market performance of the product suggests that I am also not far from wrong. But as I said, I wait for the new product to appear along with real objective and critical examination before drawing conclusions on this product. All we have now is incomplete information, and only the information the company wants you to see, as well as hype and boosterism. While there are some positive things to it (and I have indicated that in the past) there are also some negative things, and these have lead on balance to disappointment in the past. We have to see if Sigma has been able to shift that balance more toward to the positive in the new product.

Oct 05, 2010 at 10:45 AM
nugeny
Offline
Details
p.12 #16Sigma SD1
Based on the review of SD10 (2004), SD1 should do very well and would be equivalent to 30MP of Cmos sensor
Oct 05, 2010 at 11:52 AM
ntotrr
Offline
Details
p.12 #17Sigma SD1
Lotusm50 wrote:
ntotrr wroteYou consider yourself objective? A read through your posts will show that you have a bias against Sigma products. If you want to consider those who use Sigma's cameras and lenses as not objective, go ahead but you sure can't hold yourself up as objective either.
I'm just skeptical based on the past. Most of company and company-related rhetoric in the past wasn't borne out to my eyes when I examined it. To be clear, I have no "bias" against Sigma. I have no interest in any competing products or any alternative. But I do believe that performance in the past has not matched the rhetoric, and I am far from alone in that opinion. Quite clearly the nearly insignificant market performance of the product suggests that I am also not far from wrong. But as I said, I wait for the new product to appear
...Show more →

Fair enough, my apologies if I've disparaged you.
Oct 05, 2010 at 12:01 PM
phidong
Offline
Details
p.12 #18Sigma SD1
Lotusm50 wrote:
Now, the final question when should we expect the Sigma promotion and defense crew to invade the forum to do their job for Sigma? We only see these 2 or 3 people when Sigma has a new product, and they fiercely, unrelentingly and even viciously support, defend and promote the product.

And I eagerly await the biased, stilted fan-boy comparisons that will purport to show how superior this is to a Nikon D3x or Sony a900, or Canon 1Dslll.


Well it looks like the Sigma promotion and defense crew you were talking about has finally invaded the forum. Now if we only had someone to fiercely, unrelentingly and even viciously attack and dismiss the product to even things out.
Oct 05, 2010 at 12:19 PM
Daniel Heineck
Offline
Details
p.12 #19Sigma SD1
phidong wrote:
Well it looks like the Sigma promotion and defense crew you were talking about has finally invaded the forum. Now if we only had someone to fiercely, unrelentingly and even viciously attack and dismiss the product to even things out.


Allow me?

Actually, no. There's absolutely nothing interesting in that press report. Here's an executive summary for those not wishing to waste their time with reading it:

"We've made a new sensor that's physically bigger, uses more modern fabrication techniques and has smaller pixel pitch. Oh yeah, and we're working on all the other stuff that makes a good imaging train, just like everyone else."

So basically, knock out the wikipedia-grade pro-foveon marketing speak it's a press release any camera manufacturer could have written without mentioning a single specific. We ignore those, so let's ignore this one too. Yawn.

I have no bone against Foveon architecture, even if I've knocked the product in the past (and probably still am in some folks eyes). What I won't stand here and watch is people foaming at the mouth with complete and utter misinformation about the strengths and weaknesses of the different architectures and making pie-in-the-sky conjectures. There are pluses and minuses to all designs.

The points Ken, Joakim, rhameed (don't know his name) and I have made are entirely valid. They're historically valid, and will be valid moving forward. I'm going to safely bet none of us failed trigonometry, physics, optics, or our signal & systems classes either.

Innocent questions--what's the penetration/absorption profile of blue light in silicon? How will this affect the noise and color reconstruction of an image captured on a foveon sensor versus a bayer sensor? How does it affect the incident angle sensitivity assuming a NA=0.95 microlens ?

So while I'm clearly incredulous and skeptical on a new foveon chip, I really do hope that sigma has made a lot of forward progress on leveling the field. I'd love to see a modern take at this architecture, since the last one was quite_a_long_time_ago.
Oct 05, 2010 at 01:22 PM
theSuede
Offline
Details
p.12 #20Sigma SD1
I have no doubt at all that a lot of images from the new SD1 will look great. I just expressed some concern about the usability/flexibility of the system. There are some inherent weaknesses in the Foveon based systems that needs to be resolved, and from the information we've gotten so far - NONE of them have been addressed.

Will the SD1 be able to make pictures with great colour? YES!
-But unfortunately only some of them, taken under certain circumstances - with certain subject matter. In certain other situations reality/photograph colour match might be a total catastrophy. And also impossible to correct.

Unfortunately colours don't work like kofron seems to think. You can't just "LUT" them into shape, you need some base premises covered before you even GET to that point. One of them is metamerism failure, something that the Foveons are REALLY bad at.
Oct 05, 2010 at 07:58 PM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister