carstenw wrote:
ntotrr wrote
Sigma has far more than a "couple" of interesting lenses, far more like the 50mm EX DG, 70mm EX DG, 105mm EX DG, 17-50mm EX DG, 50-500mm, etc., etc. Are you trying to "correct" Lotus' opinion? IMO Sigma has exactly two interesting lenses: the 50/1.4 and the 150 Macro.
Carsten,
I think you forget a few zooms (if you're into that sort of thing) that are partly unique, and in some cases of stellar quality:
12-24mm f/4.5-5.6, the widest FF zoom available and surprisingly good.
100-300mm f/4, a very versatile and very sharp lens. Up there with the best.
120-300mm f/2.8, just relaunched with OS. It's a big, heavy beast, but there's nothing like it around, and it's often enough compared to 300mm primes.
50-500mm f/3.5-6.3, the Bigma. Easy to write off as a 10x toy lens, but it's not. Stopped down to f/8, it's as sharp as anything around, and when you need that range, there aren't really any alternatives around.
I haven't seen anything about the 85mm f/1.4 yet, but if it's as good as the 50, there's nothing to fear. Where they have failed to deliver recently, is with the new 24-70mm f/2.8. Looks stellar on paper, but not in photos unfortunately.
But since Sigma doesn't make a full frame camera, Sigma body users don't need to worry about the 24-70. The old 10-20mm f/4.0-5.6 is a very decent performer, the new 17-50mm f/2.8 OS can easily compete with the best (the only weak point seems to be corner sharpness at f/2.8, particularly at short focal lengths) and then there's the new 8-16mm f/4.5-5.6 which has no competition when it comes to focal length, and little to fear with regards to optical quality. For an extreme WA zoom, the 8-16 is up there with the best, with the exception of the Nikon 14-24 f/2.8, but the Nikon is three times as expensive, two times the weight and not nearly as wide (the Sigma being a 12mm equivalent on a Nikon DX body or on the SD1).
Sample variation would be my main (and possibly only) worry if I was limiting myself to Sigma, but I do think I would take the chance on making a living with Sigma lenses if that was the easiest choice, or if the SD1 keeps its promises. One can always have a Nikon or Canon body on the side for use with Zeiss and Leica primes.