AdaptedLenses wrote:
... Things like bokeh, sharpness, spherical aberrations and contrast are just a few of the very visible differences.
All that said, the optical characteristics of the glass are secondary to the light and composition....
I have a variety of sample, I used to enjoy comparing. I’ll dig some up if I have time.
I would love to see some direct comparisons. If you don't want to post them publicly or they aren't MFNG, send me a message offline. (jimmuller @ rcn . com)
---------------------------------------------
leighton w wrote:
I agree with Matt's assessment. For me, I only have 5 lenses in my bag and I know the capabilities of each one so much that I don't give any thought to the capturing process other than light and composition.
Thank you both for replying. Technical details like "... bokeh, sharpness, spherical aberrations and contrast..." are real of course but only if visible. Purple fringe on a white object isn't good. A family portrait in which the people in the center are in focus but those on the edges aren't is just an amateur picture. I'm not sure I'd recognize spherical aberration unless the image content.made it obvious. Those technical details don't jump out at me unless botched (which I do often enough). Maybe the ability to use f/1.4 or even f/1.2 instead of f/8 is great if those wide apertures work okay. In the old days that was all about getting enough light.
The aesthetic effect of an image is a different matter. DOF, yes by intent. Bokeh balls with 6 edges or 7 or 9 or none? If the image is composed well that won't matter except to another photographer who looks for details like that.
I asked because I'm always musing about whether to spring for a Z-mount AF lens. Other than the luxury of AF, would a new (expensive!) 50mm f/1.2 S (for example) be that much better than my faithful MF 50mm f/1.4 for most of the pics I take? Maybe wide open or facing the sun. At f/2.8 would the color rendition or contrast be noticeably better with a new lens? Probably not that I could see, or not enough that a finished image would be aesthetically preferable.
When I read reviews of modern lenses my reaction is usually "Really?" That's why I'm curious about what contributors to this thread have to say. The great images tell me y'all know what you are doing. If you had two 50's for a particular shot, would you have reason choose one over the other except to post in this MF thread? I wouldn't, but then, I don't have those choices. Like Leighton I have 5 lenses, 3 of which I've used for half a century so I know what they can do and I have to live within their limitations. None are redundant because they cover different lengths. I choose one for the image I'm trying to get, not because I think one will provide better color rendition or less spherical aberration or better bokeh. Composition takes more thought which point-AF-click would discourage, a win for MF. If I can't see any improvements with a new lens, then it's not a win. But I might just be deluding myself.
Sorry about the length. This is a fun subject for me and pertinent to a MF thread. I haven't been able to get out with my camera for some days so this is a substitute for it.