James Markus wrote:
This will set you back $85 (includes shipping), and it is good for 9 inches to infinity. Late model ai...
Thanks for the link. I googled for reviews of that lens and what I found made it seem quite impressive!
The first title that popped up was by Josh Solomon, Feb 2020 (Casual Photophile) for a non-AI version. He raved about it. Then a few pages into the history of Nikon's 50mm he had a link to his review of the 50mm f/1.4 S, Dec, 2017. That's the 50mm I have, except that my SN is almost double his, it was made in the early 70's, is multi-coated, and had a name change to S-C Auto. For comparison I read that review too.
In both the title and the second paragraph he called the 50m f/1.4 S his favorite lens. Granted it was 8 years ago and things change. Still, there must have been a reason at that time. By his description it has some great qualities and a few flaws. Multi-coating partially negates his complaint about flare. The rest of his description, the images, and the video all looked like what I'm familiar with, wonderfully smooth, seemingly in focus even if not digital-camera razor sharp. I rarely used it at f/1.4 except in low-light, not so much a limitation with the Z5-II like it was with film. So the limitations when wide open aren't so significant. It worked for me as a go-to lens for 50 years.
So I ask myself, do I need a possibly sharper but still MF 55mm when I'm happy with my 50? For length between 50 and 200 I have a Tamron 90mm macro, so neither length nor macro-ness is an attraction. As awesome as that 55 seems I can't convince myself to jump at it.
After all that, the real reason I'm saying no is that it is MF. If I'm going to acquire a Z-mount lens it should be AF. And for general use it should probably be a zoom like the 24-70 f/4 S, even though it's not cheap. One lens to rule them all, or at least be useful for them all.
This has been very educational. Thank you, James Markus and everyone else!